Menu
Subway
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Subway
Photos

Subway

Sandwich · Bay Shore

3.8 · 132 reviews Google
restaurants.subway.com

About Subway

At our Bay Shore location, we strive to provide a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel at home. Our friendly team, led by Anil and Falguni, will take great care of you, serving up fresh and healthy options made to your liking. From our signature dishes like the Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki to ou...

At our Bay Shore location, we strive to provide a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel at home. Our friendly team, led by Anil and Falguni, will take great care of you, serving up fresh and healthy options made to your liking. From our signature dishes like the Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki to our extensive selection of sandwiches and salads, there's something for everyone. We're proud of our organized and clean environment, ensuring a pleasant dining experience for all. With generous portions, quick service, and a commitment to making every customer feel valued, we're the perfect choice for a satisfying meal on-the-go or a relaxing lunch break.

What Customers Say About Subway

This Subway location receives high praise for its exceptional customer service, cleanliness, and generous portions. Many reviewers specifically call out friendly and helpful staff. Negative reviews mention issues with food quality, rude service, and coupon acceptance.

Popular Dishes

rib sandwich Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki footlong cookie Foot long black forest ham chopped veggie salad

Best For

Quick Bite Solo Dining Locals Casual

Tip: The customer service is great, especially when Anil and Falguni are working. Some customers have had issues with coupons not being accepted.

Features

🅿️ Parking Accessible 🌅 Breakfast 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner 🥗 Vegetarian 🌱 Vegan
🎯 Casual 👥 Groups

What to see nearby

First Congregational Church of Bay Shore
Heritage
A 354m

First Congregational Church of Bay Shore

iglesia

View details
Bay Shore Methodist Episcopal Church
Heritage
A 423m

Bay Shore Methodist Episcopal Church

iglesia

View details
Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Building, Bay Shore
A 480m

Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Building, Bay Shore

edificio

View details

Data from Wikidata

Explore the area around Subway

Subway is located in Bay Shore, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.

Historical Heritage

  • First Congregational Church of Bay Shore (A 354m) — church building in New York, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
  • Bay Shore Methodist Episcopal Church (A 423m) — church building in New York, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos

Other Points of Interest

  • Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Building, Bay Shore (A 480m)

Data from Wikidata

Frequently asked questions about Subway

Subway is located at 1735 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706, Bay Shore.
Near Subway you can find points of interest such as First Congregational Church of Bay Shore, Bay Shore Methodist Episcopal Church, Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Building, Bay Shore.
Subway offers sandwich cuisine.
Subway has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.
Subway offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway.
The most recommended dishes at Subway based on customer reviews are: rib sandwich, Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki, footlong cookie, Foot long black forest ham, chopped veggie salad.
Subway is ideal for quick bites, solo dining, locals, casual dining.
This Subway location receives high praise for its exceptional customer service, cleanliness, and generous portions. Many reviewers specifically call out friendly and helpful staff. Negative reviews mention issues with food quality, rude service, and coupon acceptance.
The customer service is great, especially when Anil and Falguni are working. Some customers have had issues with coupons not being accepted.
132
Reviews

Subway Bay Shore Reviews

3.8
132
5★
49%
4★
20%
3★
10%
2★
3%
1★
18%
Reviews (40)
T
T JR

Nice little Subway, worker was nice and friendly made my sandwich quickly, my experience just now was 5 stars! I would give 6 stars if I could.

J
Jason C

The food here is pretty good and the employees are kind. I assume this Subway is a family owned franchise. You gotta try the Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki and their footlong cookie.

L
Larue Raynaud

They have great customer service. Kerwyn is amazing!!!

B
Bridgette Gajadhar

Fire service, fire quality food, clean clean clean atmosphere. I always come here with no issues. I just left the subway on Main Street in bay shore because they were so rude and disgusting but here??!! I come here all the time and they never let me down. Always kind and sweet and get me in and out in no time. Highly recommend this location.

a
abu waqas

I had amazing experience at this location. Anil and Falguni were great they welcomed me in and were very knowledgeable about food they serve. Clean and friendly environment. Always a pleasure to be here, my wife and I make sure to come here every couple of weeks and always prefer when they are working because they are clean and very attentive towards everyone and everything.

S
Sierra Love

Great organized place to eat ive always loved coming here, the customer service is always top notch and they are always fully stocked of anything you may need, not that many people come here so there isnt much to worry about when it comes to the wait time and theres plenty of areas to take a seat, i recommended having the tuna on a spinach wrap with onions!

R
Ritesh Shrestha

This store has really good customer service. I've been coming here for couple of years and the workers always treat me well. And also the store is always clean.

h
henry kennedy jr.

Very nice and friendly people very clean and organized.The guy knows me now he already knows what I want the rib sandwich.Unfortanely they don't have rib sandwich anymore but they have a wide selection of other things I like.I can't wait to try De Lucas the pizza they also have a wide selection of toppings.Even with everything going on I make sure I stop at Subway's from time to time.Thank You for your very polite serviice.

J
Jorge Cobos

The guys here serve you a ton extra, great service clean and good environment. That's a good place in my book. Way better than other subways worth going out of your way.

J
Jed Rodriguez

I was just there getting lunch and I forgot my wallet and they said I could come back after work and pay for it. For being a newly diagnosed diabetic who has to eat lunch is was a blessing.

S
Ssuarlin Maldonado

I love this place I am here 3-4 times a week wonderful costumer service ! And the food so good

J
John Stockerl

Good clean restaurant!

T JR
T JR

Nice little Subway, worker was nice and friendly made my sandwich quickly, my experience just now was 5 stars! I would give 6 stars if I could.

Larue Raynaud
Larue Raynaud

They have great customer service. Kerwyn is amazing!!!

John Stockerl
John Stockerl

Good clean restaurant!

Jason C
Jason C

The food here is pretty good and the employees are kind. I assume this Subway is a family owned franchise. You gotta try the Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki and their footlong cookie.

Bridgette Gajadhar
Bridgette Gajadhar

Fire service, fire quality food, clean clean clean atmosphere. I always come here with no issues. I just left the subway on Main Street in bay shore because they were so rude and disgusting but here??!! I come here all the time and they never let me down. Always kind and sweet and get me in and out in no time. Highly recommend this location.

Sierra Love
Sierra Love

Great organized place to eat ive always loved coming here, the customer service is always top notch and they are always fully stocked of anything you may need, not that many people come here so there isnt much to worry about when it comes to the wait time and theres plenty of areas to take a seat, i recommended having the tuna on a spinach wrap with onions!

Jed Rodriguez
Jed Rodriguez

I was just there getting lunch and I forgot my wallet and they said I could come back after work and pay for it. For being a newly diagnosed diabetic who has to eat lunch is was a blessing.

henry kennedy jr.
henry kennedy jr.

Very nice and friendly people very clean and organized.The guy knows me now he already knows what I want the rib sandwich.Unfortanely they don't have rib sandwich anymore but they have a wide selection of other things I like.I can't wait to try De Lucas the pizza they also have a wide selection of toppings.Even with everything going on I make sure I stop at Subway's from time to time.Thank You for your very polite serviice.

Ssuarlin Maldonado
Ssuarlin Maldonado

I love this place I am here 3-4 times a week wonderful costumer service ! And the food so good

Ritesh Shrestha
Ritesh Shrestha

This store has really good customer service. I've been coming here for couple of years and the workers always treat me well. And also the store is always clean.

abu waqas
abu waqas

I had amazing experience at this location. Anil and Falguni were great they welcomed me in and were very knowledgeable about food they serve. Clean and friendly environment. Always a pleasure to be here, my wife and I make sure to come here every couple of weeks and always prefer when they are working because they are clean and very attentive towards everyone and everything.

Jorge Cobos
Jorge Cobos

The guys here serve you a ton extra, great service clean and good environment. That's a good place in my book. Way better than other subways worth going out of your way.

W
William Coto

This subway is supposed to be 24 hours. They ain't. The guy even has the huge LED sign that says open, their google page says 24 hrs, but guess what, the guy will just lock the door and go in the back to probably watch youtube. As I was knocking on the door, I joke you not, he literally came from the back of the counter to wave his finger to me to say he wasn't opening for me. I don't know if maybe he is related to the owner (which wouldn't surprise me) to take this liberties of just closing the store down whenever he feels like it. If you're thinking of a late snack, or even worse yet, you're someone who is a worker at the hospital or a visitor for a patient at the hospital and looking for something to eat nearby because you can't have anything at the hospital, THIS PLACE WILL NOT BE OPEN BECAUSE THE GUY LOVES TO TAKE NAPS IN THE BACK. If you guys don't want to work after a certain time, WHY MAKE IT 24 HRS?????

L
Latosha Joynes

It’s always one employee to mess things up. I eat from here a lot and every time I leave a tip because they are extremely polite and make my sandwiches the way I like. But tonight this one employee who was rushing me along with the other guy helping him; and the entire time they were talking about me in their language, but as he’s handing me my change he rudely says “where’s my tip” like that is all the way out of line and I know subway does not train them to do so. I told him you don’t do that to anybody. I gave him a tip anyways although I shouldn’t have but I will be calling corporate in the morning. My entire experience there tonight was not good from the time I stepped in & I was extremely polite as I was raised to be. The regular guys that work there will say that about me.

T
Tutie Alicea

Definitely rude. I work in the area, I just tried ordering a chopped veggie salad and I asked for fresh green salad not the yellow salad they have out all day and she argued with me that it is fresh even though that is not what I wanted. I didint argue i just walked out and took my money else where. I will def not recommend this subway. Too bad the one on main st in the shopping center closed. They were really nice ppl.

J
Jeff Scott

This is quite a review to share so please some may have already had this experience. It seems that subway and the local owners has conspired with other local owners to not accept subway coupons. The company spends tens of millions of dollars on marketing and advertising and mails the coupons to my home with other weekly flyer discounts. This subway will not accept SUBWAY coupons and had the audacity to lie and say that the company POS machine will not accept the coupons. It is a lie! An OUTRIGHT LIE….The local owners are all complaining that they don’t get their kickbacks from corporate and will not honor of the coupons. I’m done with Subway I’m done with this owner, who is a cheapskate and A liar. As it is when I went in there other times, I had to fight with the woman proprietor when I asked for extra toppings. She would dabble on one or two more. I had to ask two more times for olives. This subway sucks as well as East Islip. Do not patronize the store. They have no right to refuse the coupons as this is a corporate entity. They are conspiring with other stores. Do not patronize Subway there are other options for sandwiches. I am extremely disappointed at a store in and around my hometown. Close up and move on. Jersey Mikes is more expensive, but they are NOT LIARS.

C
Caitlyn Chong

I got the Foot long black forest ham with cucumbers, tomato, jalapenos, green peppers, and honey mustard. It was very delicious, but after 30 minutes I started to get a really sick. AVOID THIS PLACE

M
Matt C

The guy had no clue what I was saying brought frozen eggs from the back toasted it still cold just not good

t
talisha elizabeth

Horrible customer service & did not want to remake or discount a sandwich that they drowned in the wrong sauce .

M
Martain Miller

Food was cold. Service was a 1. Only 1 person work at lunch time. The line was long n the lady had a attitude for kno reason

William Coto
William Coto

This subway is supposed to be 24 hours. They ain't. The guy even has the huge LED sign that says open, their google page says 24 hrs, but guess what, the guy will just lock the door and go in the back to probably watch youtube. As I was knocking on the door, I joke you not, he literally came from the back of the counter to wave his finger to me to say he wasn't opening for me. I don't know if maybe he is related to the owner (which wouldn't surprise me) to take this liberties of just closing the store down whenever he feels like it. If you're thinking of a late snack, or even worse yet, you're someone who is a worker at the hospital or a visitor for a patient at the hospital and looking for something to eat nearby because you can't have anything at the hospital, THIS PLACE WILL NOT BE OPEN BECAUSE THE GUY LOVES TO TAKE NAPS IN THE BACK. If you guys don't want to work after a certain time, WHY MAKE IT 24 HRS?????

Matt C
Matt C

The guy had no clue what I was saying brought frozen eggs from the back toasted it still cold just not good

Latosha Joynes
Latosha Joynes

It’s always one employee to mess things up. I eat from here a lot and every time I leave a tip because they are extremely polite and make my sandwiches the way I like. But tonight this one employee who was rushing me along with the other guy helping him; and the entire time they were talking about me in their language, but as he’s handing me my change he rudely says “where’s my tip” like that is all the way out of line and I know subway does not train them to do so. I told him you don’t do that to anybody. I gave him a tip anyways although I shouldn’t have but I will be calling corporate in the morning. My entire experience there tonight was not good from the time I stepped in & I was extremely polite as I was raised to be. The regular guys that work there will say that about me.

talisha elizabeth
talisha elizabeth

Horrible customer service & did not want to remake or discount a sandwich that they drowned in the wrong sauce .

Caitlyn Chong
Caitlyn Chong

I got the Foot long black forest ham with cucumbers, tomato, jalapenos, green peppers, and honey mustard. It was very delicious, but after 30 minutes I started to get a really sick. AVOID THIS PLACE

Jeff Scott
Jeff Scott

This is quite a review to share so please some may have already had this experience. It seems that subway and the local owners has conspired with other local owners to not accept subway coupons. The company spends tens of millions of dollars on marketing and advertising and mails the coupons to my home with other weekly flyer discounts. This subway will not accept SUBWAY coupons and had the audacity to lie and say that the company POS machine will not accept the coupons. It is a lie! An OUTRIGHT LIE….The local owners are all complaining that they don’t get their kickbacks from corporate and will not honor of the coupons. I’m done with Subway I’m done with this owner, who is a cheapskate and A liar. As it is when I went in there other times, I had to fight with the woman proprietor when I asked for extra toppings. She would dabble on one or two more. I had to ask two more times for olives. This subway sucks as well as East Islip. Do not patronize the store. They have no right to refuse the coupons as this is a corporate entity. They are conspiring with other stores. Do not patronize Subway there are other options for sandwiches. I am extremely disappointed at a store in and around my hometown. Close up and move on. Jersey Mikes is more expensive, but they are NOT LIARS.

Tutie Alicea
Tutie Alicea

Definitely rude. I work in the area, I just tried ordering a chopped veggie salad and I asked for fresh green salad not the yellow salad they have out all day and she argued with me that it is fresh even though that is not what I wanted. I didint argue i just walked out and took my money else where. I will def not recommend this subway. Too bad the one on main st in the shopping center closed. They were really nice ppl.

Martain Miller
Martain Miller

Food was cold. Service was a 1. Only 1 person work at lunch time. The line was long n the lady had a attitude for kno reason

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in Bay Shore →
📸

Gallery

📸

No photos available

Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places

📍

About Subway

How to get there

1735 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Loading map...
Subway
Tap for directions

Highlights

💬
Many Reviews
132 reviews
💰
Budget Friendly
Price level
👨‍🍳
sandwich
Cuisine type

Services

🥞 Breakfast
🍽️ Lunch
🍾 Dinner
🍰 Desserts
🥗 Vegetarian Options
🌱 Vegan Options
🥡 Takeout
🍴 Dine-in

Dining Options

🍽️ Dine In
🥡 Takeout

Restaurant Info

Status
Verified by owner
🕐 Hours Today
9AM-12AM
Rating
3.8/5
💬 Reviews
132
💰 Price Level
$
📞 Phone
+1 631-206-3800
🌐 Website
order.subway.com

Amenities

🅿️ Parking
Wheelchair Accessible
🚻 Restroom
💳 Credit Cards
📱 Mobile Payments
🏘️

The Neighborhood

Location

1735 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

📍 Explore the Neighborhood

Weather
23°
Weather updated hourly · Jobs and events refreshed daily
First Congregational Church of Bay Shore Heritage

church building in New York, United States of America

A 354m
Bay Shore Methodist Episcopal Church Heritage

church building in New York, United States of America

A 423m
Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Building, Bay Shore
A 480m
🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Subway and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Subway!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Subway

🏆 Rewards at Subway

💰

10% Discount

At Subway

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
Leave a Review on Google
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it