Master's Pizzeria
Pizza · Brooklyn
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About Master's Pizzeria
Located on Fifth Avenue in Sunset Park, Master's Pizzeria is a beloved family-owned spot offering classic comfort food with a warm Brooklyn charm. Guests consistently praise the fresh, well-seasoned pizza featuring a satisfyingly crispy crust, paired perfectly with an extensive selection of deliciou...
Located on Fifth Avenue in Sunset Park, Master's Pizzeria is a beloved family-owned spot offering classic comfort food with a warm Brooklyn charm. Guests consistently praise the fresh, well-seasoned pizza featuring a satisfyingly crispy crust, paired perfectly with an extensive selection of delicious ice cream and refreshing slushies. Beyond the menu, visitors appreciate the clean surroundings, friendly service, and spacious seating that accommodate solo diners and families alike. Whether enjoying a quick lunch or a relaxing dinner, this accessible establishment delivers high-quality meals at great prices, ensuring every visit feels like a special treat for the whole family.
What Customers Say About Master's Pizzeria
Master's Pizzeria is praised for its pizza and ice cream combo, with many considering it a local favorite. While some appreciate the fresh food and service, others have experienced issues with undercooked dough, inconsistent pasta quality, and payment issues.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Enjoy the pizza and ice cream combo, but be aware of potential inconsistencies in food preparation and payment processing. Check your order carefully.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Master's Pizzeria
Master's Pizzeria is located in Brooklyn, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- Sunset Park (A 198m) — barrio de Brooklyn, Nueva York, Estados Unidos Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
Religious Buildings
- basílica de Nuestra Señora del Perpetuo Socorro (A 582m) — church in Brooklyn, New York City
- St. Michael's Roman Catholic Church (A 862m) — building in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, New York, United States
Parks & Gardens
- Rainbow Playground (A 363m) — park in the United States of America
- Pena Herrera Playground (A 630m) — park in the United States of America
- Martin Luther Playground (A 732m) — park in the United States of America
- Sunset Park (parque de Brooklyn) (A 813m) — parque público en Brooklyn, Nueva York, EE.UU.
Other Points of Interest
- Sunset Park Courthouse (A 802m) — building in New York City, US
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Master's Pizzeria
Master's Pizzeria Brooklyn Reviews
THIS IS MY FAVORITE PIZZERIA IN SUNSET PARK, BROOKLYN!!! Master's Pizzeria is the only pizzeria on 5th avenue, you can get outstanding PIZZA and amazing ICE CREAM in one spot. You can't beat the quality of the food for the price, anywhere in sunset park. They have special promotions in store and on the online ordering apps. The people in this place are like family. Thank you - Master's Pizzeria and Ice Cream.
THIS IS MY FAVORITE PIZZERIA IN SUNSET PARK, BROOKLYN!!! Master's Pizzeria is the only pizzeria on 5th avenue, you can get outstanding PIZZA and amazing ICE CREAM in one spot. You can't beat the quality of the food for the price, anywhere in sunset park. They have special promotions in store and on the online ordering apps. The people in this place are like family. Thank you - Master's Pizzeria and Ice Cream.
My best pizza and ice cream shot ever 😃 🍕 🍦
Great family owned business. Love this place .
Overall this pizza place is very amazing. They keep the tables and other surroundings clean. The food is freshly made with awesome seasoning. I definitely recommend coming to this place as it’s a very calm place with great service.
Overall this pizza place is very amazing. They keep the tables and other surroundings clean. The food is freshly made with awesome seasoning. I definitely recommend coming to this place as it’s a very calm place with great service.
Great family owned business. Love this place .
My best pizza and ice cream shot ever 😃 🍕 🍦
Has pizza and ice cream. Lots of ice cream. Also has both slushys and slush puppies drinks as well. Prices are great. Pizza is crispy and there's plenty of seating.
Has pizza and ice cream. Lots of ice cream. Also has both slushys and slush puppies drinks as well. Prices are great. Pizza is crispy and there's plenty of seating.
Very delicious and yummy pizza I started eating since 1997 till today's ...of course under new management.
To put it in one word yummy to put it in two words very yummy.
The food is all right it’s kind of made but it has lotta flavor they sell ice cream. The service is pretty good. They sometimes bring you the food depends if you ask only part I don’t give it a five is because I found a hair in my food so watch out be safe.
The food is all right it’s kind of made but it has lotta flavor they sell ice cream. The service is pretty good. They sometimes bring you the food depends if you ask only part I don’t give it a five is because I found a hair in my food so watch out be safe.
Very delicious and yummy pizza I started eating since 1997 till today's ...of course under new management.
To put it in one word yummy to put it in two words very yummy.
Too much dough, and not enough pizza for $3. An average slice. Nothing notable at all. Medium thin crust. Can't taste the sauce. Basically a melted cheese slice.
Too much dough, and not enough pizza for $3. An average slice. Nothing notable at all. Medium thin crust. Can't taste the sauce. Basically a melted cheese slice.
What happened with the pasta today? I was super excited to order my favorite pasta from Masters pizzeria today but it was a disappointment. It is usually very delicious but today it was flavorless, no grated cheese and nearly had any chicken. Did the cook change?
Good Philly cheese greta staff. Haven't tried the pizza yet
Nice place and good ice cream...
I just received my order from this restaurant I ordered a pie half with pepperoni, sausages, mushrooms, onions, and peppers and half pepperoni. The pizza Dough was still soft and not cooked enough for all the ingredients on it. I would have preferred a harder crust
I just received my order from this restaurant I ordered a pie half with pepperoni, sausages, mushrooms, onions, and peppers and half pepperoni. The pizza Dough was still soft and not cooked enough for all the ingredients on it. I would have preferred a harder crust
Good Philly cheese greta staff. Haven't tried the pizza yet
What happened with the pasta today? I was super excited to order my favorite pasta from Masters pizzeria today but it was a disappointment. It is usually very delicious but today it was flavorless, no grated cheese and nearly had any chicken. Did the cook change?
Nice place and good ice cream...
Hey Michael stop talking sh!t. Kings pizza is way better pizza. Slices are big so are the slices. Out standing taste. For the same price. Food is way better than master can even imagine to be,with those skimpy a$$ pizzas
every time i go here their machine doesn’t accept tap payments, i went to another store right after and it worked. and when i told the lady she looked at me like i was crazy or something. they didn’t even take my order right, they gave me a whole other pizza size i didn’t ask for, i don’t know if they tryna make you pay more but im definitely not going back again
every time i go here their machine doesn’t accept tap payments, i went to another store right after and it worked. and when i told the lady she looked at me like i was crazy or something. they didn’t even take my order right, they gave me a whole other pizza size i didn’t ask for, i don’t know if they tryna make you pay more but im definitely not going back again
Hey Michael stop talking sh!t. Kings pizza is way better pizza. Slices are big so are the slices. Out standing taste. For the same price. Food is way better than master can even imagine to be,with those skimpy a$$ pizzas
15 minutes ago I asked for two gallons of water for hand washing at this place.... I am working in the street and touching dirty stuff... so I permanently keep water in my car... sometimes it happens and I am out of water... especially when it's damn hot in the streets these days...🙂 And I am asking to personell of nearest laundry or a cafeteria to fill out some water for me...and...God bless them... During 1.5 years nobody have refused for 1 or 2 gallons of water for cooling or washing hands etc... So, owner of this pizzeria was the first guy who asked me money...🙂... And that's OK...I know that he pays for water ...and for everything else.... But...he asked 5 $ per gallon...😁😄 (I thought he was kidding but... sorry...😁😁)... Even at the most expensive groceries in Manhattan that costs ...2.5$!!! per gallon of drinking water..but not technical from tap... So, this guy deserved title of MISER of the 2025...🥇..😁.....Congrats 👏 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
Thought we'd try a new pizza place. They sent a pizza that was already baked and added the pepperoni as an afterthought. See how the cuts don't go through the pepperoni? Cold, underbaked, doughy. Calamari was greasy and tasted like past it's prime fryer oil. Would not recommend.
15 minutes ago I asked for two gallons of water for hand washing at this place.... I am working in the street and touching dirty stuff... so I permanently keep water in my car... sometimes it happens and I am out of water... especially when it's damn hot in the streets these days...🙂 And I am asking to personell of nearest laundry or a cafeteria to fill out some water for me...and...God bless them... During 1.5 years nobody have refused for 1 or 2 gallons of water for cooling or washing hands etc... So, owner of this pizzeria was the first guy who asked me money...🙂... And that's OK...I know that he pays for water ...and for everything else.... But...he asked 5 $ per gallon...😁😄 (I thought he was kidding but... sorry...😁😁)... Even at the most expensive groceries in Manhattan that costs ...2.5$!!! per gallon of drinking water..but not technical from tap... So, this guy deserved title of MISER of the 2025...🥇..😁.....Congrats 👏 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
Just got scammed, yesterday we ordered a pizza and payed with it with a card and today ordered another one and they said we didn’t pay yesterday so he charged me for 2 today when there’s proof the transaction went through for yesterday 😂 been ordering here for years never ordering again
Served me a sorry excuse for a pizza. Had to put it in the trash where it belonged. Don’t recommend at all.
Thought we'd try a new pizza place. They sent a pizza that was already baked and added the pepperoni as an afterthought. See how the cuts don't go through the pepperoni? Cold, underbaked, doughy. Calamari was greasy and tasted like past it's prime fryer oil. Would not recommend.
Thought we'd try a new pizza place. They sent a pizza that was already baked and added the pepperoni as an afterthought. See how the cuts don't go through the pepperoni? Cold, underbaked, doughy. Calamari was greasy and tasted like past it's prime fryer oil. Would not recommend.
Just got scammed, yesterday we ordered a pizza and payed with it with a card and today ordered another one and they said we didn’t pay yesterday so he charged me for 2 today when there’s proof the transaction went through for yesterday 😂 been ordering here for years never ordering again
Served me a sorry excuse for a pizza. Had to put it in the trash where it belonged. Don’t recommend at all.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
Tulcingo
Restaurante Rancho Grande
El Salvador
My Coral
Eden Deli Grocery
Hawaiian Fried Wings
Generoso's
Sunset Bagels
Texas Chicken & Burgers
Tung Hing Chinese Kitchen
2 Photos
Explore Master's Pizzeria's photos
About Master's Pizzeria
How to get there
5201 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
5201 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Upcoming Events
barrio de Brooklyn, Nueva York, Estados Unidos
park in the United States of America
church in Brooklyn, New York City
park in the United States of America
park in the United States of America
building in New York City, US
parque público en Brooklyn, Nueva York, EE.UU.
building in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, New York, United States
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Master's Pizzeria and other restaurants
Earn Points at Master's Pizzeria!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Master's Pizzeria
🏆 Rewards at Master's Pizzeria
10% Discount
At Master's Pizzeria
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu