Mattina's Pizzeria

Name: Mattina's Pizzeria
Address: 3744 Delaware Ave, Kenmore, NY 14217, Buffalo, NY, 14217, US
Telephone: +17168775949
Price range: €€
Rating: 4.2

Pizza · Buffalo

4.2 · 465 reviews Google

Mattina's Pizzeria

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

mattinaspizzeria.com

About Mattina's Pizzeria

Mattina's Pizzeria, located in Buffalo, offers a welcoming experience for lunch and dinner, whether you choose to dine in, take out, or have your meal delivered. We specialize in Buffalo-style pizza, with a square cut and a dough that strikes a perfect balance. Our sauce is savory, complementing generous toppings. Beyond pizza, our wings, especially the BBQ pit wings, are a customer favorite. We pride ourselves on friendly service and a relaxed atmosphere. Our accessible location features outdoor seating and a wheelchair-accessible entrance, parking, and restroom. We aim to provide a clean and comfortable setting to enjoy a delicious meal.

What Customers Say About Mattina's Pizzeria

Mattina's Pizzeria is a local favorite known for its Buffalo-style pizza and flavorful wings, especially the char honey BBQ. Customers praise the tasty sauce, light and fluffy dough, and generous portions. Some report inconsistent quality and occasional issues with undercooked pizza or skimpy toppings.

Popular Dishes

pizza (14) wings (6) char honey BBQ chicken fingers White pizza Broccoli Chicken pizza subs

Best For

Families Locals Casual Quick Bite

Tip: Order the pizza with the sauce perfectly seasoned and slightly set. Char honey BBQ wings are also highly recommended.

Features

🌳 Outdoor 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery ♿ Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner 🥗 Vegetarian

🎯 Casual 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Frequently asked questions about Mattina's Pizzeria

Mattina's Pizzeria is located at 3744 Delaware Ave, Kenmore, NY 14217, Buffalo.

Mattina's Pizzeria offers pizza cuisine.

Mattina's Pizzeria has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.

Mattina's Pizzeria offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.

The most recommended dishes at Mattina's Pizzeria based on customer reviews are: pizza, wings, char honey BBQ, chicken fingers, White pizza.

Mattina's Pizzeria is ideal for families, locals, casual dining, quick bites.

Order the pizza with the sauce perfectly seasoned and slightly set. Char honey BBQ wings are also highly recommended.

465

Reviews

Mattina's Pizzeria Buffalo Reviews

4.2

465

5★

64%

4★

16%

3★

2★

1★

Reviews (21)

Sue Jiang

Great pizza! Great service!

Ken Kopper

The food was great. The service was very friendly and the price for 4 large slices and 2 drinks was very reasonable. The only issue was the dining area was a little untidy but certainly not a deal breaker. In fact, I plan on returning ASAP

Aj Eade

Chicken fingers were amazing and f1 on the tv was an added bonus.

T P (Tominator 716)

Amazing take out pizza place - I picked up a half pizza for 2 ppl and it worked! 8 squares was perfect: $15. Highly recommended for the perfectly seasoned and slightly set sauce. It's a nice change from my other fav Franco's Pizza. You can't go wrong with either place. No seating/no tables, pick-up or delivery only for this location.

Crowned Alpha Barbershop

Great place to grab some pizza and relax…. Guys are really chill and relaxed. Came here and was going to take out decided to eat in. Clean place they gave you napkins unlike other places. Bathroom was spotless and smelled great!! Tables were also clean and eating area smelled good… I was able to just sit and unwind while I ate some BOMB PIZZA!!! Thanks guys I work right up the street so you will 100% see me again….

D K

Listen. If you don't like mushrooms that's okay! Don't believe the lies that fungus is food. It's not. It's big mushroom filling your brain with spores. Get the White pizza with NO mushrooms. Its the only sane choice.

Laketa C

This Broccoli Chicken pizza was THE BOMB. Crispy pizza with chunky, juicy chicken & broccoli, the cheese with the burnt edges...OMG. Adding Mattina's to my cheat day list LOL

Christa J.

Tonight, my family and I ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza and chicken wings. It was, hands down, the best pizza we have had in a very long time. The food was still hot when we got home, which hasn’t been our experience with other pizzerias where they just let your food sit out on the counter and get cold. You can tell that the food here is always freshly made, and there’s a lot of care that goes into it. Service is always fast and friendly as well! Five stars!!

Katie Nowadly Esq.

Too level service and a top level Buffalo style pie. Square pie, medium- large thickness. Non-sweet sauce. Reminds me of Bocce back when they cared about their product. That good good cheese burned and melted on the edges of the crust. Great cup and char pepperoni's and the pizza is always cooked perfectly- not undercooked and not well done. A great Buffalo pie. The staff are fantastic and friendly and I have literally never had any order that was wrong or screwed up in any way- literally perfect. Great job Mattinas!

Kyle Matesic

I’ve ordered mattinas before. Called order. No online option for Tonawanda yet. Pickup went well. $30 for 1/2 sheet pepperoni. Got the pizza home and it looked like it got thrown together in a rush. Light cheese in some spots. Overall a decent tasting pizza but it was under cooked Super soft.

Joe H

Great place for Buffalo style pizza that's similar pizza to Bocce. Wings are always big and cooked to perfection. They're BBQ wings on the pit are especially tangy and delicious. Great family friendly environment with a large sit down area.

amy edson

Whoever is making the pizza tonight deserves a raise. Martina’s is always the spot but tonight I had the best square of my life. I will never forget it.

Denise Duffy

Hey first time ordered here..Thank you very much very good, sauce tasty, dough light and fluffy great dough texture, anchovies excellent.

Honky Tonk Guy

This place was great. First time ever here. Loved the dough they use for the pizza, wow was this pizza perfect. Not too heavy like Franco’s, cardboardy like dominoes, thicker than mustachios, honestly very impressed…the char honey barbecue wings were fabulous as well. The small half of pizza was so filling we only ate two slices but are definitely excited for the leftovers. Highly recommend trying them out if in the mood for pizza and wings!

SP G

The sauce is amazing and the wings are freaking great!!! Especially char honey BBQ.. I wouldn't get the subs but that's due to one experience.. highly recommended!

P.J. Robert

ALWAYS great food. I've been coming her since day one. I'd be reaching to complain, but if I were to, it would be that the pizza needs a little more sauce on it. Nothing better than those burnt edges... So good!

Wilson Cortes

The pizza, wasn't to my personal liking. Some spots were dry. Not enough sauce, some had way too much sauce. Got sausage on the pie, I wouldn't get the sausage again. The wings were good.

Foad Khaleel

I ordered 2 pepperoni pizzas and it took the about a hour to make them. This is horrible place and i wouldn’t recommend it.

Jeffrey DiNatale

Pizza us good, but inconsistent and skimpy on ingredients. Last 3-4 times ordered cheese, pepperoni, hot cherry peppers. Parts of the pizza had 1 piece of pepperoni and 1 or 2 little peppers. When I ordered i let the girl know last few times ingredients were skimpy. She told me she would make sure it had enough ingredients. Got home and same shit again. Prices are high enough as it is and not complaining about the price, but put enough ingredients on the pizza. I won't be back again

Gerrit DenBeste

Horrible customer service, they messed up my order and almost had an attitude like it was my fault. This is the 4th time something happened here. Never again. Btw. Lose your attitude you know who I’m talking about.

frank amati

Id give it 0 stars if I could. Pizza is always undercooked, and prepared terribly. ABSOLUTE WORST wings I've ever had , the wing quality is poor and they're always cooked bad. Most plain skimpy subs also. I been fooled by this place for the last time. Living so close for so long is the only reason for ever ordering. People who say this food is good clearly are not from the city and probably have never tried just about any other pizza, which is better then this place. Don't be fooled by these good reviews. Do yourself a favor and order from somewhere else