Toddy's
Caterer · Cedarhurst
About Toddy's
Situated in Cedarhurst, Toddy's offers a warm, inviting atmosphere under new ownership that prioritizes friendly service and cleanliness. Guests consistently praise the fresh, kosher homemade bagels and top-quality fillings, such as the signature #3 with melted cheese, mushrooms, tomatoes, and jalap...
Situated in Cedarhurst, Toddy's offers a warm, inviting atmosphere under new ownership that prioritizes friendly service and cleanliness. Guests consistently praise the fresh, kosher homemade bagels and top-quality fillings, such as the signature #3 with melted cheese, mushrooms, tomatoes, and jalapeños. The establishment is equally renowned for its amazing coffee and no-nonsense approach to crafting great food. While prices reflect premium quality, many visitors feel the value is worth the wait, often lining up early in the morning. With convenient takeout and delivery options, accessible parking, and a modern payment system, Toddy's delivers a consistent, delicious experience that appeals to locals seeking an authentic, high-quality breakfast or lunch spot.
What Customers Say About Toddy's
Toddy's is known for its delicious, fresh, kosher bagels and high-quality lox. Customers rave about the taste and quality, though some mention high prices and potential for long waits. Some customers have reported rude service, especially from the owner/manager.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Be prepared for a potential wait, especially during busy times. Some suggest the vanilla or German coffee.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Toddy's
Toddy's Cedarhurst Reviews
Huge fan of Toddy’s and very happy with new owners. Love the Cholov Yisroel options now available. Bagels are great. Food is great. Coffee is great. Baked good are great. Long lines but worth the wait. High prices, but that seems standard nowadays.
Delicious bagels and fillings for sandwiches! I had the #3 with a whole wheat bagel stuffed with melted cheese, cooked mushrooms, tomatoes and jalapeños. It was awesome! You’re not going to be disappointed. 😎
Best bagels! Crunchy on the outside. Soft on the inside. Perfect.
Delicious bagels and fillings for sandwiches! I had the #3 with a whole wheat bagel stuffed with melted cheese, cooked mushrooms, tomatoes and jalapeños. It was awesome! You’re not going to be disappointed. 😎
Best bagels! Crunchy on the outside. Soft on the inside. Perfect.
Absolutely delicious, fresh, kosher homemade bagels and top quality lox.
Great food and friendly no-nonsense service. Don't be scared off by the signs.
I really like the new ownership. The new owner is really sweet and has created a inviting and friendly atmosphere in the store. Besides for their bagels and appetizers, they have really good coffee that you can buy by the pound. I highly recommend trying the vanilla or German coffee.
Best bagel shop in town! I go almost everyday, and enjoy it every time!
Great bagels. only Wish they had later hours. very good food & service.
Great food. Always fresh. Tasty. Consistently delicious. Amazing coffee. Friendly staff. Clean environment. Batman approved
This place cares about one thing and only one thing and that’s making great food. If you can get with their program you’ll get along just fine, there’s a reason folks line up for 45 minutes.
Absolutely amazing food however the price may be out of some people's budget but I overall saw the value and enjoyed the amazing food
You get what you ask for , old school simple and good , top quality . Highly recommend for a quick sit down or to go.
Best bagel shop in town! I go almost everyday, and enjoy it every time!
Great bagels. only Wish they had later hours. very good food & service.
The only best bagels in town (kosher).
You get what you ask for , old school simple and good , top quality . Highly recommend for a quick sit down or to go.
Absolutely delicious, fresh, kosher homemade bagels and top quality lox.
I really like the new ownership. The new owner is really sweet and has created a inviting and friendly atmosphere in the store. Besides for their bagels and appetizers, they have really good coffee that you can buy by the pound. I highly recommend trying the vanilla or German coffee.
This place cares about one thing and only one thing and that’s making great food. If you can get with their program you’ll get along just fine, there’s a reason folks line up for 45 minutes.
Great food. Always fresh. Tasty. Consistently delicious. Amazing coffee. Friendly staff. Clean environment. Batman approved
Absolutely amazing food however the price may be out of some people's budget but I overall saw the value and enjoyed the amazing food
Great food and friendly no-nonsense service. Don't be scared off by the signs.
Great place for coffee and bagels. They have some unique options as well. It's usually crowded. It can be a long wait.
Great place for coffee and bagels. They have some unique options as well. It's usually crowded. It can be a long wait.
Food is good Extremely long wait time it's not ever a quick thing Prices very expensive
Food is good Extremely long wait time it's not ever a quick thing Prices very expensive
WORKERS ARE THE MOST RUDE PEOPLE I HAVE EVER SEEN IN MY LIFE. I ALSO SAW SO MANY FLIES ALL OVER THE MUFFINS AND CROISSANTS IT WAS SO NASTY!! DEFINITELY GONNA CALL THE HEALTH INSPECTOR.
So unfortunate that you took down a sign to support the community which single handedly supports your store. You should be ashamed of yourselves.
I am so disgusted with this man who says he is the manager at this bagel store I didn’t get his name he is a spanish rude man with a go-tee! He states he is the manager but I have never dealt with such superiorism and disrespect with someone who supposebly runs a shop! He made a huge scene over a damaged bagel tht was sold to me. I will never be returning to this bagel store.
The food was not great. Usually that can be propped up by good service, but the workers and especially the owner was extremely rude. We were a group of 10 people and after all of us got food, the owner asked us to PAY HIM EXTRA MONEY TO SIT as we were “taking us his space”. Tones of lost business from me and everyone I meet.
Rude customer service and basic bagels. I preordered on the phone and they told me it would take 45 mins. I walked in and they asked me if I didn’t know how to tell time? Why would it take so long to make a bagel?! Didn’t get what I asked for. No attention to detail. Terrible food and even more terrible attitude. Never again.
Mediocre bagel and AWFUL service. The owner was yelling at a customer who tried to give him her catering order (for absolutely no reason) and then walked over to our table and made unprompted and rude remarks after we’d spent LOTS of money at his store. Would NOT recommend.
I am so disgusted with this man who says he is the manager at this bagel store I didn’t get his name he is a spanish rude man with a go-tee! He states he is the manager but I have never dealt with such superiorism and disrespect with someone who supposebly runs a shop! He made a huge scene over a damaged bagel tht was sold to me. I will never be returning to this bagel store.
So unfortunate that you took down a sign to support the community which single handedly supports your store. You should be ashamed of yourselves.
Rude customer service and basic bagels. I preordered on the phone and they told me it would take 45 mins. I walked in and they asked me if I didn’t know how to tell time? Why would it take so long to make a bagel?! Didn’t get what I asked for. No attention to detail. Terrible food and even more terrible attitude. Never again.
Mediocre bagel and AWFUL service. The owner was yelling at a customer who tried to give him her catering order (for absolutely no reason) and then walked over to our table and made unprompted and rude remarks after we’d spent LOTS of money at his store. Would NOT recommend.
The food was not great. Usually that can be propped up by good service, but the workers and especially the owner was extremely rude. We were a group of 10 people and after all of us got food, the owner asked us to PAY HIM EXTRA MONEY TO SIT as we were “taking us his space”. Tones of lost business from me and everyone I meet.
WORKERS ARE THE MOST RUDE PEOPLE I HAVE EVER SEEN IN MY LIFE. I ALSO SAW SO MANY FLIES ALL OVER THE MUFFINS AND CROISSANTS IT WAS SO NASTY!! DEFINITELY GONNA CALL THE HEALTH INSPECTOR.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Da Nicola
Burger King
Pizza Le
Los Carnales
Beginnings Bar & Restaurant
MoCA
The Upper Crust
Marinara
Lolli bop Cafe & Play
Subway
Gallery
No photos available
Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places
About Toddy's
How to get there
436 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
436 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Toddy's and other restaurants
Earn Points at Toddy's!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Toddy's
🏆 Rewards at Toddy's
10% Discount
At Toddy's
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu