Mario & Salvo's Pizza
Pizza · DeWitt
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About Mario & Salvo's Pizza
At Mario & Salvo's Pizza, we're all about serving up a slice of DeWitt charm with every pie that leaves our oven. As a local favorite pizzeria, we've perfected the art of crafting both thin- and thick-crust pies that'll transport you to Italy. Our menu features hot subs, wings, and other classic far...
At Mario & Salvo's Pizza, we're all about serving up a slice of DeWitt charm with every pie that leaves our oven. As a local favorite pizzeria, we've perfected the art of crafting both thin- and thick-crust pies that'll transport you to Italy. Our menu features hot subs, wings, and other classic fare to satisfy any craving. Guests rave about our cozy atmosphere, where friends and family gather to enjoy a cold drink and a slice (or three). We're proud to be the go-to spot for a quick bite or a night out with friends. Come taste the difference at Mario & Salvo's Pizza!
What Customers Say About Mario & Salvo's Pizza
Mario & Salvo's Pizza is highly praised for its authentic NY-style pizza, with many calling it the best in Syracuse. Customers rave about the thin, foldable crust and flavorful sauce. Service is generally friendly and efficient, though some have noted inconsistencies.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: If it's your first time, ask for recommendations! The "grandma" style crust with ricotta, sausage, and red onion is a popular choice.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Mario & Salvo's Pizza
Mario & Salvo's Pizza is located in DeWitt, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Parks & Gardens
- Chappell Field (A 777m) — park in the United States of America
- Upper Athletic Fields (A 919m) — park in the United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Mario & Salvo's Pizza
Mario & Salvo's Pizza DeWitt Reviews
There is no better original Italian pizza in Syracuse. I've been coming here since the 90s. It's the best and special props to Grandma Pie.
love love love this place!! i’ve never been disappointed - the pizza is delicious every single time. it’s a small area, with three medium sized tables and one counter looking out the window… but honestly, i think it adds to the atmosphere!! i come here all the time, and i think you should too!!
I've been enjoying this iconic pizza for nearly 25 years. Shame on me for not reviewing until now. I know zip about NYC pizza, but I do know good food, and this is it! Friendly, informal vibe (Gus puts my buffalo chicken slice in to heat when I walk in the door), efficient service, and absolutely fabulous pizza! Chewy, crisp crust, bold flavors, all fresh and homemade. Calzone is made to order, sausage is outstanding with proper hint of fennel, whole milk mozzarella, not an off note to be found. We're fortunate to have a local business to support.
We ate here twice while in town and it was equally delicious both times. Pizza was authentic NY pizza, and the meatball parm sub was tasty. Service was top notch as well. Would definitely recommend.
Holy moly!! This is the only place to enjoy a real pizza in Syracuse. Ordered at the counter, told them it was my first time there—got the full rundown—she recommended the “grandma” style crust. Took the rec and added ricotta, sausage, and red onion!! Pops garnished with basil and we were good to go a quick 20 min later. While we sat and waited it seemed like the whole town of Syracuse made their way through, picking up, grabbing slices, dining in. Great lively atmosphere on a rainy Thursday night :) P.S. the pizza tastes INSANELY delicious. Fresh sauce, scrumptious cheese mix, great sausage, beautiful ricotta… we’ll be back
This is definitely an authentic NY style pizza here in Upstate NY. Pizza and calzones are delicious. Pizza has great sauce and cheese in the correct proportions. It's simply great pizza. Service is always friendly. When you enter the restaurant, they tell you hello, how are you? And they smile. That is genuine friendliness. So we will go back again and again. Thank you.
If you’re searching for an authentic New York-style pizza experience outside the five boroughs, look no further than Mario & Salvo’s. This place absolutely nails what makes a proper NYC pie—thin, foldable crust with just the right amount of crisp, a perfect balance of tangy-yet-slightly-sweet sauce, and a generous layer of high-quality cheese that bubbles and browns just the way it should. Every bite transports you straight to a classic New York pizzeria. The crust has that ideal chew with a slight char, proving they know how to handle their dough. The sauce isn’t overpowered by herbs or sugar—just a clean, fresh tomato flavor that complements the cheese beautifully. And speaking of cheese, they don’t skimp. It melts into the sauce with that signature stretch you expect from a legit slice. Beyond the pizza, the atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and no-frills—exactly how a great pizza joint should be. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or taking home a full pie, Mario & Salvo’s will have you questioning whether you ever need to trek to NYC for pizza again. A must-try for any pizza lover!
Excellent pizza and great customer service from the owner and staff! The best pizza in the City of Syracuse, no gimmicks just great ingredients. I ordered a pie on Slice for a specific time and that pie was at my front door fresh out of the oven 10 minutes earlier than the delivery time. Best pie on the Eastside, hands down the competition doesn't even come close!
They make the best heroes around. We got an eggplant Parmesan and a meatball Parmesan hero and couldn't have been happier. The bread was toasted and not soggy, the filling perfect. The place is a small box of a room, not a restaurant to sit down at, hence the low atmosphere rating. This was our second visit and we'll be returning.
The food was good and big portions. Their menu consists of burgers sandwiches chicken wings mac salad, and drinks and a cooler. The atmosphere is very clean and eclectic, had many wall coverings with pictures and a large fork and spoon.
Parking lot is a little bit of a tight and awkward space, but the pizza is pretty good! It’s the closest I could find to NY style thin crust pizza, but not as cheap sadly. The cheese just melts in your mouth 😋 They are always very busy though, and the atmosphere seems very fast paced, but it kind of adds to the Italian charm of it.
We waited a long time for a Neapolitan pizza. Let's just get that out of the way to start here. Eventually, the gentleman who took our order approached our table to explain: The first pie came out "a little too black." He said that because it was our first time at the pizzeria, he didn't want to serve us that. So they put another one in for us. It was nice that he came over to apologize, and he took care of refills. I like the pizza quite a bit. It's definitely the kind you need to fold. So, authentic Neapolitan. Nice and oily. Not a perfect first impression, but I would certainly eat there again.
The pizza was decent but we thought it was overpriced. It cost like $19 for a large pizza and we don’t think it tasted like a $19 pizza. We are from Pennsylvania where you can get a good local pizza for $11 or $12 or maybe even $13. We were going to possibly dine in but it was a little congested and busy in there from all the people waiting for carry out orders. Would be nice if there was a separate dining area from all the people hanging around waiting for carry out.
Stopped in passing bye, noticed tables not to clean and overall outdated vibe, plenty of workers to do things but a lot standing around.. overall got two slices chicken bacon ranch slice and cheese slice. CBR slice average chicken was dry, crust extremely chewy and little crisp to it 6.1 Cheese slice no stand out sauce taste cheese okay and chewy floppy crust 5.9
This recent Monday I ordered and paid for an order of chicken tenders with the intentions to share them as part of a meal with others. I paid almost $11 for 4 chicken tenders. When I’ve ordered this in the past I’ve received 7 (sometimes 8 if I’m lucky). Hence why I ordered it to share. I could’ve bought a bag of chicken tenders for the same price. I didn’t though since I prefer the taste and quality of yours better. Something to consider price wise if you’re only gonna serve 4 tenders for almost $11. ( I wish I had taken a picture but at that point it was the end of everyone’s day at dinner time and we all were very tired, hungry and annoyed.)
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Pavone's Pizza
Fortune Hawaii
Brad's Extra Innings Sports Bar
Twin Trees
Mitsuba
All Night Egg Plant
Sahara Mediterranean Cuisine
Empire Buffet
Mr. Noodle and Ms. Dumpling
Redwood Diner
31 Photos
Explore Mario & Salvo's Pizza's photos
About Mario & Salvo's Pizza
How to get there
4326 E Genesee St, Syracuse, NY 13214
DeWitt, NY 13214
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
park in the United States of America
park in the United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Mario & Salvo's Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at Mario & Salvo's Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Mario & Salvo's Pizza
🏆 Rewards at Mario & Salvo's Pizza
10% Discount
At Mario & Salvo's Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu