Isabel's Pizza

Name: Isabel's Pizza
Address: 142 Connetquot Ave, East Islip, NY 11730, East Islip, NY, 11730, US
Telephone: +16312242699
Price range: €€
Rating: 4.6

Pizza · East Islip

4.6 · 231 reviews Google

Deals available

Be flexible, save more

Isabel's Pizza

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

isabellas.pizza

About Isabel's Pizza

Isabel's Pizza, located in East Islip, is a local favorite known for serving up delicious comfort food in a clean and friendly atmosphere. While offering dine-in, takeout, and delivery, Isabel's provides a welcoming experience for everyone, including solo diners, with wheelchair accessibility. Customers rave about the exceptional pizza, especially the Brooklyn slice and Grandma pie, with many claiming it's the best around. Beyond pizza, the menu boasts a variety of well-priced and flavorful entrees, including outstanding buffalo chicken rolls, meatball parm heroes, and creative salads like the Beat Salad, showcasing fresh ingredients and satisfying portions. Whether it's a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner, Isabel's Pizza consistently delivers a delightful experience.

What Customers Say About Isabel's Pizza

Isabel's Pizza is highly praised for its delicious pizza, especially the grandma slice and buffalo chicken pizza. Customers also rave about the entrees and friendly service. The restaurant is small and can get warm in the summer, but the food is worth it.

Popular Dishes

grandma (3) Buffalo chicken pizza (4) meatball Parm hero chicken Rollantine garlic knots Buffalo chicken rolls insalata caprese salad penne pasta

Best For

Locals Casual Quick Bite

Tip: Try the grandma slice; the sauce is pretty much perfect. Also, be aware that the restaurant can get warm during the summer months.

Features

📶 WiFi 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery ♿ Accessible 🌅 Breakfast 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner

🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Frequently asked questions about Isabel's Pizza

Isabel's Pizza is located at 142 Connetquot Ave, East Islip, NY 11730, East Islip.

Isabel's Pizza offers pizza cuisine.

Isabel's Pizza has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.

Isabel's Pizza offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.

The most recommended dishes at Isabel's Pizza based on customer reviews are: grandma, Buffalo chicken pizza, meatball Parm hero, chicken Rollantine, garlic knots.

Isabel's Pizza is ideal for locals, casual dining, quick bites.

Try the grandma slice; the sauce is pretty much perfect. Also, be aware that the restaurant can get warm during the summer months.

231

Reviews

Isabel's Pizza East Islip Reviews

4.6

231

5★

79%

4★

14%

3★

2★

1★

Reviews (22)

Alison K-V

Excellent Italian food! I cater from here for all my business events. Everyone raves about it. Especially out of towers that want real NY Italian food and pizza. Fresh, delicious every time. They always go above and beyond. On time with delivery. My go to place for business and personal food.

Charles Cangi

Best pizzeria! Incredible pasta too. Great portions.

Justin Hansen

One of the best plain slices I've had in a while. The bottom crust is perfectly crispy and not doughy at all. The buffalo slice was very flavorful as well.

Hailey Cooke

Always love coming here. Never disappointed. Their food is absolutely delicious and the staff are very friendly. They have really good specials too. :D

patrick delaney

Food is always amazing! Tried the chicken Rollantine tonight, very very good. Highly recommend.

Samantha M.

THE BEAT SALAD (added shrimp & avocado) ! Holy HEAVENS! OH MY DAYS! I had to sit in the parking lot to chow down. Absolutely worth the wait. Super delicious. Honestly I forgot to use the salad dressing. That’s how yummy this is. Will be back! Thank you all!! #DELISH

Carlo Sibilla

Unbelievable I grew up in ozone Park and this is the best grandma I ever had and I’ve been to tons of pizzerias all over the island and Queens, New York by far the best I will not go anywhere else. Please try that grandma.

nikki dragone

Stopped in on our way out east - right before closing and they still had a variety of slices to choose from. Heated perfectly and great taste!! So glad we stopped!!

Elle Flizzy

I'm gonna start off by saying, we have a good selection of pizzerias in this area. But, Isabellas pizza is by far the best actual pizza around! And their entrées are just as good, and for a great price! Looking foward to trying more of it in the future!

Kathy Scalzo

Clean, comfortable, friendly, delicious! This was a great surprise for us in a new neighborhood after a baseball game. Wish I lived closer...The Brooklyn slice was perfect and my son loved the Buffalo. The crusts were perfect crusty chewy.

Vanessa Pean

The Buffalo chicken pizza was literally cooked to perfection. Even the salad dressing was delicious. The penne pasta was perfect! Nice and saucy!! I love you guys . Everything was literally delicious

Leo Abbate

This Pizza place is great! Prices are fantastic and the food is delicious. I come here often for lunch and am always satisfied. The environment is cute and quaint for a bite. Highly recommend to anyone!

Vashti Persad

I kept going for pizza alone and most recently started trying the various pasta dishes. There are so many other places in the surrounding area that are well known with a lot more space for indoor dining. I would hands down choose Isabella's for the amount of food you receive and the taste (small space to dine in, but we do take out). My son is a bit of an Italian food addict and we were trying different places to keep it interesting. I just can't believe how good the food is and the price at Isabella's. Why go out of my way to try other places when I have found our favorite? To be continued with more pics as I make my way through the menu....today we got 2 regular, 1 buffalo, chicken Florentine with spinach and kids chicken parm with spaghetti. The bread that comes with the pasta dishes is amazing! There is no need for garlic knots I'd you get this bread.

Tatiana Benenaula

Not only the best pizza but their soups and burgers are delicious! 🤤 Food always fresh too.

Claire Fitz

We have lived in Oakdale for 6+ years and have always complained that the only thing we didn't like was the lack of good pizza/italian takeout! We finally expanded our search a little bit and luckily found this place. I am really picky about the pizza - if you're going to splurge, it better be worth it! And this pizza is so worth it. Every topping you could want & all the basics were perfect. Everything was phenomenal, fresh, delivered really fast, priced great, and service was amazing (called to check on custom request via online app to make sure they understood 100% correctly - we all know this is not always the case!). Cannot recommend highly enough. Give them a try - you will be so happy.

Justin S

Grandma slice was amazing. The sauce is pretty much perfect. Lil sweet, lil tangy . The crust is super delic! Check em out if you're in the area.

Sean Keele

Great pizza. Best I've had in the area.

Jay Abra

I got the Buffalo chicken slice and my wife got the taco salad slice. Both were very good.

Brandon Billings

First time trying them. Everything was amazing. One of the best buffalo chicken rolls I've had. Wife got a insalata caprese salad which she loved. meatball Parm hero fantastic. Also got a personal specialty pie which was great. No complaints. (that was bbq chicken). Will get again.

FREDDYG_NY

Isabella's Pizza is a must in the Islip area. Great spot next to a pub. Love every slice, garlic knots and fried oreos. Excellent customer service.

John Doe

Came here during my stay at Heckscher Park. Pizza and the meatball hero was good, and had no issues otherwise. Noticed the lack of air conditioning during the summer. That’s got to suck for someone.

Michael Kaiser

Kind of small, but delicious chicken parm pizza. The garlic knots were okay, not enough garlic in my opinion. I will definitely be back to try more of there slices. I will most likely never have their Buffalo chicken slice because of the ranch dressing that is on tip. But that is my own opinion. But that is the normal slice i judge a good pizzeria off of.