Melt Shop
Sandwich · Garden City
About Melt Shop
At Melt Shop in Garden City, we're dedicated to serving up delicious comfort food that brings people together. Our restaurant offers a welcoming ambiance where solo diners and groups alike can enjoy our signature dishes, including crispy chicken toasted sandwiches, decadent vanilla shakes, and addic...
At Melt Shop in Garden City, we're dedicated to serving up delicious comfort food that brings people together. Our restaurant offers a welcoming ambiance where solo diners and groups alike can enjoy our signature dishes, including crispy chicken toasted sandwiches, decadent vanilla shakes, and addictive tots. Our team is committed to providing exceptional service with a warm smile, from the friendly staff at the counter to the knowledgeable recommendations behind the scenes. With convenient options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, we're the perfect stop when you need a break or a quick bite. Whether you're meeting friends, grabbing lunch, or satisfying your cravings after a long day, Melt Shop is here to melt your heart with our cheesy goodness and warm hospitality.
What Customers Say About Melt Shop
Melt Shop in Garden City receives mixed reviews. Many customers praise the friendly and helpful staff (Mohan, Omar, Michelle, Genesis, Rabell, Josue) and the delicious food, especially the shakes, tots, and chicken sandwiches. However, some complain about greasy food, small portions, and slow service.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: The staff is very helpful with recommendations. Be aware that it can be hard to find a seat during peak hours.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Melt Shop
Melt Shop Garden City Reviews
The staff was excellent the guy with the glasses who took our order ( for Jose aka Josue lol)and double checked we were okay with all of the prices , thank you for your help!!!
Incredible experience tonight. Exceptional collaboration leadership from Genesis and Rabell. Magnificent location serving delicious tasty food. GENESIS, is truly a professional- so efficient, friendly with a admired calm demeanor. Proactive efficiency - with our order. Was sensational with modification to our dishes due to personal-dietary and religious preferences. She is a treasure! Truly grateful. A perfect place to dine with a outstanding staff. Thanks, Genesis !!
This place is a 100/10- the customer service from all, so lively and kind ! The girls were complimenting our outfits and sparking conversation and Mohan was so helpful and kind! The food 😫🤩 the Nutella milkshake 🤤 I will most very be driving an hour west specifically for this again very soon !!
My boyfriend ordered this meal. It was both our first time trying from this spot. This meal is so simple yet so delicious! It is more on the pricy side but it’s definitely very delicious! The tots were crispy and super good and the sandwich as well! I surprisingly enjoyed the tots without ketchup (: The chicken is so crispy and tender. With the Mayo sauce that it comes with!! SOOO delicious!! Would definitely come back.
Well, good take-away place inside the mall, the salads are definitely very nutritious but let's say not so much light & healthy, but absolutely tasty and abundant! Service a little "cold" maybe, sometimes a smile makes it better! But still, I had a good lunch, ordering was easy and service was quick.
The Meltshop is a part of the cafeteria area in Roosevelt Field Mall. The food is great and the service was fine. The only downside is if you are going to eat in because there are times during the day when it is hard to find a seat. Other than trying to find a seat, the experience was pretty good.
I asked the counter girl to please order me whatever is available to have me coming back every day for life. I didn’t care what it was except I want it cheesy. Of course, I’m at a Melt Shop. I also ordered cheesy tots which were fresh and, wait for it.... cheesy! 🙄🙄 They were actually great. Fresh, crispy and had quite a bit of cheese on them. My surprise order was the Nashville Hot sandwich... which has no cheese on it. Some sort of sauce, pickles (not enough) and a bun. The chicken was cooked perfectly but I really wanted cheese. Will I go back for that? No. But I will go back to try other things since what I did have today was very good. They are allowing people to sit and eat at tables right next to the store. Living on the edge 🙄🙄
Ordered a burger melt. Bread was not grilled at all.. burger part good, bread not so much. Also ordered side of Mac & cheese cost $6 had the smallest amount I have ever seen. Asked guy why so small, he said that what they tell us to give & said to leave a review… I gave it back and got refunded.. all in all , very disappointed
Melt Shop at Roosevelt Field Mall was a mixed bag for me. I opted for their classic grilled cheese, tomato soup, and fries—a quintessential comfort meal. The grilled cheese was decent. The bread was crisp and toasted well, and the cheese melted just right, but it wasn’t anything out of the ordinary. The fries were average—not particularly memorable but not bad either. The tomato soup, though, was underwhelming. It lacked the rich, creamy depth of flavor I was hoping for. I’ve had better elsewhere, and it felt like it could use a bit more seasoning or freshness to stand out. Overall, while the meal satisfied my hunger, it didn’t wow me. Melt Shop might be better explored for its other offerings, but as far as my experience went, it was just okay.
Original crispy chicken sandwich is very disappointing with two piece of small dry chicken with buns probably right out of a plastic bag, not toasted. Added $0.79 slaw, which is some soggy purple lettuce. In the ad, the sandwich has mayo in it, in reality, they give you a Kraft mayo pouch to squeeze yourself. The strawberry shake tastes loaded with artificial-sweetener. Fries are ok. Paid about $23 for this meal and waited for 20 minutes. We could be better off getting chick-fil-a across the hall.
This place traumatized me. I’ve been vegetarian for 10 years so I asked for the impossible burger. After taking a few bites of the burger they gave me I realized it was real meat. I was disgusted and distraught, I had a severe emotional response that I was not expecting. If you don’t care about someone’s dietary restrictions then take off the impossible burger option off the menu. This was the first time I had eaten meat in a while and it made me physically sick, diarrhea and nasea.
That picture of the lady holding the grilled cheese here in the google maps search is a horrible lie. At least my grilled cheese had a crispy outside as they should, though a sad amount of cheese. My partners, on the other hand, had all my negatives plus a soggy, soft, lack of a crust. The worse was what appeared to be a layer of the saltiest... I don't know what, spread across the outside of the bread. Which I can guess is what lent to the soggyness. Second time here and my last. The first with my daughter was quite satisfying. But these were inexcusable.
Disappointing. The amount of oil and presentation are simply disgusting. Tbh, the price and the wait times are not the best either (paid over $10 just for the sandwich and waited over 15 mins to order and pick up). The tots were also very dry, and not fresh tasting. The melt shop needs to step up their game or they’re going to continue to lose customers.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Grand Lux Cafe
The Capital Grille
Vincent's Clam Bar
Thomas's Diner
Youta Ramen
True Food Kitchen - Garden City - Roosevelt Field
Burger King
Mint
Bleecker Street Pizza
Nomiya
32 Photos
Explore Melt Shop's photos
About Melt Shop
How to get there
630 Old Country Road FB14, Space K101, Garden City, NY 11530
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
630 Old Country Road FB14, Space K101, Garden City, NY 11530
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Upcoming Events
Boise Hawks vs. Modesto Roadsters
29 May 2026, 19:05
Memorial Stadium - ID
Boise Hawks vs. Modesto Roadsters
30 May 2026, 19:05
Memorial Stadium - ID
Boise Hawks vs. Modesto Roadsters
31 May 2026, 13:05
Memorial Stadium - ID
Boise Hawks vs. Idaho Falls Chukars
09 Jun. 2026, 19:05
Memorial Stadium - ID
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Melt Shop and other restaurants
Earn Points at Melt Shop!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Melt Shop
🏆 Rewards at Melt Shop
10% Discount
At Melt Shop
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu