Old Fashioned Sub Shop
Geneseo
About Old Fashioned Sub Shop
Located inside Wegman's in Geneseo, Old Fashioned Sub Shop is a beloved local destination for those seeking exceptional comfort food. Guests consistently praise the incredible quality of their signature subs, which are crafted with care to deliver top-notch flavor whether you need a quick bite or a...
Located inside Wegman's in Geneseo, Old Fashioned Sub Shop is a beloved local destination for those seeking exceptional comfort food. Guests consistently praise the incredible quality of their signature subs, which are crafted with care to deliver top-notch flavor whether you need a quick bite or a leisurely lunch. The friendly and attentive staff ensures every visit feels warm and welcoming, making solo dining or family gatherings equally enjoyable. While sometimes busy during peak hours, the casual atmosphere and accessible parking make it easy for everyone to stop in. Known for balancing great taste with fast service, this shop remains a premier choice for locals looking for delicious sandwiches in a convenient setting.
What Customers Say About Old Fashioned Sub Shop
Old Fashioned Sub Shop is known for its great subs, but can be inconsistent. Some customers find the subs delicious and the service fast, while others complain about high prices, repetitive flavors, and inconsistent quality and service.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Plan your visit accordingly as it can be very busy during traditional lunch and dinner times.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Old Fashioned Sub Shop
Old Fashioned Sub Shop Geneseo Reviews
Absolutely incredible subs. A little on the expensive side, but other than Aunt Cookies, this is the best subs you can get in Geneseo. The employees are very nice as well!
This is located inside Wegman's in Geneseo. The subs are great!!!! They are $15 which to me is a bit much, but everything is these days.
One of the best sub shops in Geneseo. Edit: can be very busy during traditional lunch and dinner times, so plan accordingly.
Wegmans sub shop. So of course the food and service are top notch!
Great subs when you're on the go.
Great subs
Best subs ever
Fast service
Great subs
Great subs when you're on the go.
Wegmans sub shop. So of course the food and service are top notch!
This is located inside Wegman's in Geneseo. The subs are great!!!! They are $15 which to me is a bit much, but everything is these days.
Absolutely incredible subs. A little on the expensive side, but other than Aunt Cookies, this is the best subs you can get in Geneseo. The employees are very nice as well!
One of the best sub shops in Geneseo. Edit: can be very busy during traditional lunch and dinner times, so plan accordingly.
Best subs ever
Fast service
Subs are delicious. I like them almost as much as those on Main Street. Aunt ... I forgot. Paid $12 for a medium sized and a soda.
Subs are delicious. I like them almost as much as those on Main Street. Aunt ... I forgot. Paid $12 for a medium sized and a soda.
It's usually pretty busy whenever I stop in for subs. Sometimes the employees are friendly and sometimes they aren't. Sometimes our food is right and sometimes it's not.
Delicious, but very repetitive.
Had a meatball sub. It was ok, not bad but not great. Tables really needed to be wiped. Staff did the bare minimum. Not what I'd expect from something associated with Wegmans but it served the purpose.
Had a meatball sub. It was ok, not bad but not great. Tables really needed to be wiped. Staff did the bare minimum. Not what I'd expect from something associated with Wegmans but it served the purpose.
It's usually pretty busy whenever I stop in for subs. Sometimes the employees are friendly and sometimes they aren't. Sometimes our food is right and sometimes it's not.
Delicious, but very repetitive.
This sub shop had gone downhill. There can be 5 people behind the counter yet the line of customers stretches into the next room. They were out of onions one day. ONIONS. They are a supermarket with an award winning produce section. They couldn't walk over to produce, grab a few onions, and slice them up? The most concerning thing however, is thier little gluten free area. It has separate sub papers and knives, but I've seen both used for regular sub rolls. If you gluten intolerant, be aware.
This sub shop had gone downhill. There can be 5 people behind the counter yet the line of customers stretches into the next room. They were out of onions one day. ONIONS. They are a supermarket with an award winning produce section. They couldn't walk over to produce, grab a few onions, and slice them up? The most concerning thing however, is thier little gluten free area. It has separate sub papers and knives, but I've seen both used for regular sub rolls. If you gluten intolerant, be aware.
15 dollars and they really didnt have any meat or cheese on my italian assorted sub. Will not waste my money here anymore
15 dollars and they really didnt have any meat or cheese on my italian assorted sub. Will not waste my money here anymore
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
Galene
KFC
Main Moon Chinese Restaurant
Ember Woodfire Grill
High Banks Tavern
Lakeville Family Restaurant
Vincenzo's
Wadsworth Grill
Applebee's
Mark's Pizzeria
Gallery
No photos available
Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places
About Old Fashioned Sub Shop
How to get there
Geneseo, NY 14454
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
Geneseo, NY 14454
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Old Fashioned Sub Shop and other restaurants
Earn Points at Old Fashioned Sub Shop!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Old Fashioned Sub Shop
🏆 Rewards at Old Fashioned Sub Shop
10% Discount
At Old Fashioned Sub Shop
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu