Sorento's
Pizza · Herkimer
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About Sorento's
Sorento's is a Pizza restaurant located in Herkimer, NY. Rated 4.5 out of 5 by guests. Known for: Fast service, Great dessert, Great wine list, Serves local specialty. Popular for lunch, dinner, solo dining. The menu features coffee, comfort food, healthy options, quick bite, small plates. Offers di...
Sorento's is a Pizza restaurant located in Herkimer, NY. Rated 4.5 out of 5 by guests. Known for: Fast service, Great dessert, Great wine list, Serves local specialty. Popular for lunch, dinner, solo dining. The menu features coffee, comfort food, healthy options, quick bite, small plates. Offers dine-in, delivery, takeout. Casual, cozy, quiet, trendy atmosphere.
What Customers Say About Sorento's
Sorento's is a local favorite known for its delicious Utica Greens, Riggies (especially Buffalo Chicken), and pizza. Many reviewers praise the fresh ingredients, flavorful sauce, and friendly service. Some have noted inconsistent food quality or slow service at times.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: The Utica greens and riggies are a must-try, and you can specify the heat level (mild, medium, or hot) for the riggies.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Sorento's
Sorento's Herkimer Reviews
I ordered medium heat chicken Riggis and it was outstanding not sure on how they're made correctly but theirs was on point ,chicken parm and the pizza are very good as well,hard to find a good dish around this area
First and foremost...OUTSTANDING FOOD! I came here with my buddy today! I had the lasagna special, 10 wings, and he ordered a small mushroom pizza!! Lasagna is my favorite food, and I know excellent lasagna when I taste it!! I had excellent, even outstanding, lasagna at Sorrento's!! In all seriousness, it was the best lasagna I've had in months!! The wings were perfectly cooked! My buddy loved his pizza!! Even better than the meal, was our very friendly, outgoing, and professional server named Dante!! On a scale from 1 to 10...this meal was easily a 10 (Outstanding)! Thanks Dante!! You were awesome!!
The service was outstanding and the food delicious! It was a family gathering and we never felt rushed. We will return!
Great, freshly made calzone’s. Staff was super friendly and just the right interactions to allow us to enjoy our food and conversations. Recommend this place if you’re looking for some real good quality food.
Fresh, tasty good food. Engaging waitress who knows her food. Came back a couple of years later during a shift change and construction. Waitress was kind but not overly attentive. Pasta salad was good but a little off seasoning wise. Calzone wasn’t soggy! Egglant sub was soggy and very little sauce or cheese. Flavor was good. The beef sub was really good. We’ll come back!
We stopped in for lunch after riding 30 miles from Rome on the Erie Canal Trail. Appetizer was a loaded tater tots dish, yowza! Delicious, just enough to whet the appetites of thred bicyclists. Next a full Caesar salad, very nice. Finally a half order of rigatoni (the "riggie"), delicious and plenty of food. I could not have eaten a full order. Did I say finally? We finished of with a slice of pumpkin cheesecake (a little 4" cheesecake all by itself) topped with nuts and whipped cream. Mmmm. Great food, friendly waitstaff, reasonable prices. Excellent value!
I always get Chicken Riggies when I'm at Sorrento for dinner. This time I tried the Buffalo Chicken Riggies and man oh man are they amazing. I've been coming here since I was a kid and the Magro family has kept the same sauce and recipes going all these years. They take care of the kids that come in for a slice and coke even after all these years. The pizza is unparalleled to anywhere else and is a must try. You won't be di as appointed.
Best restaurant in town! Whether you’re a local or visiting, you won’t find a better place to eat. I had their signature Utica Greens, and a grilled chicken spinach salad. Both were prepared to order, the service was excellent, and the restaurant was very clean and well maintained. The garlic bread was excellent as well. You’ll find all of your Italian favorites here.
Very consistent experience. It seemed like yesterday when they moved into their building and I had not eaten here in almost that amount of time. It was as good as I remembered. How they have been able to keep that same flavor and experience over such a long time is amazing. I was in town visiting some folks and we chose Sorrento's, good choice. I will suggest it the next time I'm in town.
This restaurant is a locals favorite, and even when it’s large enough, there could be a wait. Warmly decorated and clean. Our server was very sweet and efficient. They have an extensive menu. The Utica greens are a great starter, or a good side dish, and they are a favorite dish for the patrons. The eggplant Rollatini is very differenly prepared, as it is not breaded. The marinara sauce that comes over it is light, chunky and tasty.
Love their pizza and garlic nots, but their fish fry and coleslaw isn't good at all. Fish is thin and dry, coleslaw is gross. To much vinegar.
All I can say is that I haven’t ordered from here in awhile so decided to order some calzones and what a mistake they were all dough inside not properly cooked no flavor at all and I had yo recook them myself and the sauce was all watery with no taste. I hope they get back to better quality food and taste soon.
Ordered a margarita pizza pie under cooked cheese was not melted .. soggy never again .. crust was way to thin
We couldn’t finish our food because we were freezing. It wasn’t just us. Other customers complained too. I realize it’s hot in the kitchen but you paying customers were freezing. I think you need to figure out out to keep the kitchen cool without freezing your customers.
Good food, bad service. Came in for lunch not busy at all. Took over an hour and a half for food Tables came in after us same size, ate and left before we recieved our food.
Food was old. Had lasagna and noodles in quite a few places were hard. I noticed also a weird taste then I stopped trying to eat. Didn't even eat half. I was taken out for my birthday and didn't want people I was with to know how bad it was. People in that kitchen had to know that was not acceptable to give to someone. Food is expensive and felt that they just pawned it off on me. Thanks for such a terrible experience
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Railroad Street Tavern
Herrera Sabor Latinos
Asteroga Alehouse
Dunkin'
Babe's
Burger Cardeña
Black Rice Sushi & Thai
Wingstop
Yetty's Pizza
KFC
31 Photos
Explore Sorento's's photos
About Sorento's
How to get there
86 Central Ave, Ilion, NY 13357
Herkimer, NY 13357
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
park in the United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Sorento's and other restaurants
Earn Points at Sorento's!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Sorento's
🏆 Rewards at Sorento's
10% Discount
At Sorento's
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu