Goodfellas Pizza

Gavin

I got a mini pizza with pepperoni and sausage, I would give it a 7.5/10. Overall it’s a decent pizza spot with fast service, only took about 10 minutes.

Dianna Veneziano

This was probably the BEST pizza I have ever had! I'm from Philadelphia, PA. Over there, Pizza Hut is bottom of the barrel. In Carson City, it's the best you can get. It's so refreshing to get hand made pizza for once. I paid $14 for a personal pizza, but I was not disappointed. Would highly recommend! #WhiteOut

Bill Geddes

For over 20 years we never come to town without coming to Goodfella's at least once. Crust and sauce can't be beat, vibe is great (even in the "new" location), and the food is a GREAT value. This non-Michelin reviewer gives 5 stars!

DjRC Detroit

Pizza was crispy and very good. Turkey sub was really really good. Wings were ok. Bread sticks were good too. They did forget our marinara sauce. But the taste of the food made up for it

999 X

The food at Goodfellas was excellent! I ordered the lasagna, garlic bread and salad bar while the rest of my group ordered Calzones. I'm very glad we stumbled upon this little gem after a long day. The portions are a good size and it really hit the spot! The decor was cute and Italian/sport themed. Also, they serve Pizza by the slice, sandwiches, Pasta, Beer and wings. Don't let the size of this place fool you, it gets busy real fast but these guys are on it! It's Great Italian food for a reasonable price!

Jeffery Hyde

Our pie was great...decent salad bar, and a good place to watch sports

Ok, best pizza I’ve had in years. Sadly they only have pizza by the slice from 11:30-2. And the owner is like that soup Nazi from Seinfeld.

We ordered 6 large (they have real large 18" pizza's btw) pies for our Tahoe-Douglas Rotary evening at the beach for 25 people. I asked for a 6:15p pickup. The pizza's were all ready at 6:15, with the plates, peppers and cheese that we'd asked for, and they were HOT. The staff member was helpful and smiling, and the experience was perfect. (we didn't eat inside, but it looks pretty tight in there for larger parties anyway). Many of our members asked where the pizzas came from as they were impressed with the quality. The White Out and the Hawaiian were big hits! Definitely recommend Goodfella's Pizza in South Lake Tahoe!

Was out biking for a while and wanted pizza, so stopped here because it was near my hotel. Ordered 2 personal pizzas. They tasted amazing! The pizza sauce is the major winner here. Will definitely go again when I'm in the area.

Excellent pizza. I got the Goodfella's special and it was gr8. . Too to bottom. Plenty of toppings and most excellent. The wings were baked but tender and flavorful. Definitely ordering again

The pizza was very good and the cheese and sauce went very well together. The crust was very crispy and tasty. The service was amazing and overall this is one of the best pizzas I have ever tasted.

Incredible pizza, and possibly the best wings in town! If you want good old classic home style pizza this is the place! Service is great, and the atmosphere is quiet and great small mountain town vibe. Pizza is equally great to order to go and eat from home! Our favorite pizza place in Tahoe!

Andrew “Swarley” Suarez

Incredible pizza, and possibly the best wings in town! If you want good old classic home style pizza this is the place! Service is great, and the atmosphere is quiet and great small mountain town vibe. Pizza is equally great to order to go and eat from home! Our favorite pizza place in Tahoe!

Andy Peterson

Ok, best pizza I’ve had in years. Sadly they only have pizza by the slice from 11:30-2. And the owner is like that soup Nazi from Seinfeld.

Tim Williams

We ordered 6 large (they have real large 18" pizza's btw) pies for our Tahoe-Douglas Rotary evening at the beach for 25 people. I asked for a 6:15p pickup. The pizza's were all ready at 6:15, with the plates, peppers and cheese that we'd asked for, and they were HOT. The staff member was helpful and smiling, and the experience was perfect. (we didn't eat inside, but it looks pretty tight in there for larger parties anyway). Many of our members asked where the pizzas came from as they were impressed with the quality. The White Out and the Hawaiian were big hits! Definitely recommend Goodfella's Pizza in South Lake Tahoe!

J. Tyler

Was out biking for a while and wanted pizza, so stopped here because it was near my hotel. Ordered 2 personal pizzas. They tasted amazing! The pizza sauce is the major winner here. Will definitely go again when I'm in the area.

Indumathi Madhavan

The pizza was very good and the cheese and sauce went very well together. The crust was very crispy and tasty. The service was amazing and overall this is one of the best pizzas I have ever tasted.

dona mcgowan

I've lived here since 1984 and have tried them all. Nothing has even come close to Goodfellas Special pizza. We get it in large as the left overs reheat awesome in the air fryer 😁😋The salad bar is awesome. For special occasions big parties or in need of really good comfort food this is number one on our list.🍕👍😋🤤 Five stars every time ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

My husband and I stopped in here on a whim after two long hikes. We got a small pizza (6-7 slices) and 2 draft beers for $35 which is pretty good for this area. Their tomato sauce on the pizza was so good and we loved their crust! Sometimes the toppings would slide off but every good pizza is a little messy. Would recommend!

Good pizza, clean atmosphere, and friendly service. Lrg pizza is the perfect size! Tried the BBQ pizza and regular pepperoni. Nice place to grab and go!

Ray

My husband and I stopped in here on a whim after two long hikes. We got a small pizza (6-7 slices) and 2 draft beers for $35 which is pretty good for this area. Their tomato sauce on the pizza was so good and we loved their crust! Sometimes the toppings would slide off but every good pizza is a little messy. Would recommend!

Aurora Meraz

Good pizza, clean atmosphere, and friendly service. Lrg pizza is the perfect size! Tried the BBQ pizza and regular pepperoni. Nice place to grab and go!

Really great place—try the meatballs that red sauce is fantastic, the spinach wings are also equally great. My partner and I split a pizza and really enjoyed our time here.

G Samuel

Really great place—try the meatballs that red sauce is fantastic, the spinach wings are also equally great. My partner and I split a pizza and really enjoyed our time here.

Small place, mainly takeout with a few tables. Had to wait a while for service and the pizza. We got home with it and the toppings slid off of every piece. The underside and crust was burnt. Skip this joint.

Wifey Merc

Small place, mainly takeout with a few tables. Had to wait a while for service and the pizza. We got home with it and the toppings slid off of every piece. The underside and crust was burnt. Skip this joint.

My gluten free pizza personal size had most of the bottom/edges of the crust was burnt making it too hard to eat. When I tried to bite into the crust due to the hardness the cheese, toppings just slid off. I will say the flavor was pretty good. I’m just not accustomed to eating my pizza in pieces like that, especially when it’s so expensive. I tried to call but the phone was not working and apparently I had to have an account to leave a message. Judy Domingo

Judy Domingo

My gluten free pizza personal size had most of the bottom/edges of the crust was burnt making it too hard to eat. When I tried to bite into the crust due to the hardness the cheese, toppings just slid off. I will say the flavor was pretty good. I’m just not accustomed to eating my pizza in pieces like that, especially when it’s so expensive. I tried to call but the phone was not working and apparently I had to have an account to leave a message. Judy Domingo

Came here while on vaction. The guy taking our order was rude, like we were inconveniencing him. The quality of the food was not great. The cheese had a weird taste and rubbery texture. We ordered two personal pepperoni pizzas and a half order of garlic chips and the bill was around $31. Not worth it considering the taste and quality of the food. Overall, not memorable, would not eat here again. There are way better pizza places out there.

Eric Rider

Came here while on vaction. The guy taking our order was rude, like we were inconveniencing him. The quality of the food was not great. The cheese had a weird taste and rubbery texture. We ordered two personal pepperoni pizzas and a half order of garlic chips and the bill was around $31. Not worth it considering the taste and quality of the food. Overall, not memorable, would not eat here again. There are way better pizza places out there.