Victoria “Vee” Underwood

Was in for the first today 3/27/25. Everything was delicious! Can’t wait to go back. Service was great. It was a bit dark upstairs but not crazy. Cannoli cake was fantastic. If I need a cake I would order one from there I thought it was that good.

+1

Angela Sylvester-Sekuterski

My shower was absolutely perfect. The food was great and the space was perfect. We had 20-25 girls. The staff was super helpful and accommodating. 10/10 top to bottom. My only complaint is how dark it is upstairs. All of the lighting looked dark and off in pictures so I wish they had better lighting for day time events, instead of just night time dinner lighting. We made the most of it!

Leadwulf1

Had lunch with friends today, it was awesome ! Lobster rolls was today’s lunch special for $23.95 with 1 side was loaded with lobster claw meat ! My wife had the blueberry martini and it was the best around. Nice place to eat !

Chris Aldrich

Charming place with several beautiful eating spots: inside the tavern-like rooms, by the pub-like bar and outside on a large patio with either sun or shade. Great menu selection with food that is obviously well-planned by excellent chefs. I really enjoyed the chicken and vegetable soup and the flat bread pizza and the turkey club sandwich- delicious special mayonnaise. Will absolutely be back here soon!

+1

Gregg Szucs

First time here. Came with a group for our friend "Smeg's" birthday. Very nice atmosphere and decor. Friendly staff. Had samples of their crab cakes at Taste of East Aurora and are absolutely amazing, so had intentions of coming here at some point and was not disappointed. Food looked beautiful and tasted great! Prices weren't too bad, but it was only the lunch menu. Will definitely be coming back sooner rather then later to try dinner!

Fabulous lunch fare with succulent salads loaded with fresh fruit and vegetables and raspberry vinaigrette dressing drizzled overall. I enjoyed a tenderloin shaved steak sandwich complete with mozzarella and a mild jalapeño dressing. Finishing with a flourless, double chocolate torte accompanied by a dollop of fresh whipped cream.

Justin Epps

This restaurant is very cozy and intimate. Great for a special occasion. We didn’t have a reservation but were able to be seated immediately. People tend to dress nicely when coming here, i was meeting a friend after work so i wasn’t able to dress up but they didn’t seem to mind. However some of the locals in the dining room gave us some looks, i guess that’s just East Aurora for you. This place is very expensive and i must say i thought the food was quite average. The calamari is served in a pool of tomato sauce and it ended up being soggy rather than crispy. My friend ordered the cowboy steak which was cooked perfectly. The potato croquettes seemed to lack flavor. My seafood risotto also seemed to lack flavor, it was good, but not $52.95 good. We spent $200 here and i left unimpressed. I wouldn’t say that i don’t recommend this place, because it wasn’t bad, but for a $200 experience i think there might be some better places to go.

M. Klein

We have been in East Aurora quite a bit, as it's smaller town with cool restaurants, shops and more. We decided to stop in at Rick's on Main this trip, as we have never been. It has the best patio seating on Main St. We were greeted and seated promptly. Our server was pleasant and professional. We happed to stop in for lunch (on a week day) and we were able to get a prime location on the front patio. We ordered the chicken souvlaki salad and the roast beef. The chicken salad was a top five. The meat was grilled to perfection. The roast beef was marginal (in my opinion) as it seemed a little bland and was too well done for my liking. The indoor space is nice and the bar has a cozy feel. We will come back again for dinner next time!

+5

Carlos Hennings

Kim's service was exceptional. Her knowledge of the menu and attention to guest needs is hard to come by these days. Entree plating could use a little work. Would have liked to see the steak on the Gorganzola sliced on top and not mixed in. Dessert was amazing.

I made reservations for my bf birthday.. the service was great.. the food not so much I got the seafood risotto and it was sticky , clumpy and bland, not creamy like risotto should be I didn't eat it gross I spent 300 on this trip I won't go back Very disappointing

Mark Warren

We have been here a few times and things have been great! This last visit on 11-10 Monday night we ordered the Cowboy Ribeye and was way undercooked to the temperature we asked for… also it was cold in the middle so I was wondering if it was a frozen steak but with their reputation it wasn’t just not prepared correctly… to top it off may need to sharpen the steak knives… other than that everything was perfect drinks and Bartender…

Carlos Delgadillo

Most over rated spot in town. Aged steak tasted like an aged shoe. Good service & atmosphere, enjoyed the old fashion, but what for I paid, I won’t be coming back - at least for food.