Marlo Pizzeria

Name: Marlo Pizzeria
Address: 1447 US-9W, Marlboro, NY 12542, Marlboro, NY, 12542, US
Telephone: +18452361500
Price range: €€
Rating: 4.6

Pizza · Marlboro

4.6 · 257 reviews Google

Marlo Pizzeria

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

About Marlo Pizzeria

Marlo Pizzeria, located in Marlboro, offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for lunch or dinner, whether dining in, taking out, or ordering delivery. We're known for our delicious pizzas, crafted with quality ingredients and a perfectly balanced crust that's both thin and crispy. Customers rave about the New York-style slices and the generous portions of our entrees. Beyond pizza, we offer a variety of comfort food options, including pasta dishes and wings. Our friendly and attentive service creates a welcoming experience for everyone, and we're proud to be a wheelchair accessible local spot.

What Customers Say About Marlo Pizzeria

Marlo Pizzeria in Marlboro is a local favorite known for its delicious pizza, especially the crust and sauce. Customers rave about the buffalo chicken wrap, fast delivery, and friendly service. Some reviewers mention issues with cleanliness and inconsistent food quality.

Popular Dishes

buffalo chicken wrap (3) pizza (14) wings garlic knots chicken parm wraps

Best For

Families Locals Casual Quick Bite

Tip: Great for takeout and delivery. Dinners come with pasta, salad, and bread, also good for catering.

Features

🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery ♿ Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner ☕ Coffee

🎯 Casual 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Frequently asked questions about Marlo Pizzeria

Marlo Pizzeria is located at 1447 US-9W, Marlboro, NY 12542, Marlboro.

Marlo Pizzeria offers pizza cuisine.

Marlo Pizzeria has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.

Marlo Pizzeria offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.

The most recommended dishes at Marlo Pizzeria based on customer reviews are: buffalo chicken wrap, pizza, wings, garlic knots, chicken parm wraps.

Marlo Pizzeria is ideal for families, locals, casual dining, quick bites.

Great for takeout and delivery. Dinners come with pasta, salad, and bread, also good for catering.

257

Reviews

Marlo Pizzeria Marlboro Reviews

4.6

257

5★

77%

4★

16%

3★

2★

1★

Reviews (21)

David Schloemer (Raymain)

This is my all-time favorite pizza place. Pizza that is crisp on the bottom and soft on top. The single slices are massive. Staff recognizes repeat customers and is very friendly.

O.G. Lawrence

I asked the cook is your pizza like New York City pizza? He said no, it's Upstate New York pizza🤣🤣🤣🤣 But the pizza was great. Will patronize this establishment the next time I'm in town.

Keep Smiling

Love Marlos. The Pizza is the perfect combination of thin and crispy and .... not. Their entrees have nice portion sizes too. They could use a little help in their subs, hot and cold always seem to be pretty light on the contents be it an Italian combo or meatball parm. They could definitely be more hearty.

John Dilemme

Just had our first dry of any pizza in Marlboro, not bad! fast & friendly family owned business, definitely be back for more.

Diane Stout

Hello Marlboro ny myself and husband are from new Windsor ny … We are retired now in our younger days we use to come to your resturant there we always had broccoli and pasta it was delicous do you mke or serve it anymore… We live in Las Vegas now we were just wondering if still making or seeing it still think of you always and I still mke broccoli and pasta …Thank you love LV

Ryan Cramer

Food is always great. Never a bad meal from here. Love the buffalo chicken wrap and pizza

Brittlynn M Hall

What a great local spot. This is a solid pie with some pretty delicious crust. They consistently deliver quality pizza with quality ingredients and sauce. It’s a family-owned business and you can tell there’s a lot of kindness there, between the proprietors and the staff. Super reliable, super delicious.

Lizzy Goodenough

Beautiful family restaurant. Delicious food & excellent service. Chicken parm wraps for everyone!!

Joshua Denman

Fantastic pie. Dough is tasty, well cooked, ingredients are fresh and full of flavor. The star of the show is the sauce, it's killer, top 3 I've ever had. Must have if you're in the area

Nathan Bell

Came to visit my brother in NY to help him move his family's sold estate. We got Marlo's for late/lunch. We got bacon pizza brócoli pizza plain pizza 2 dozen wings mind and honey bbq and garlic knots. Everything was delicious and boy do I miss NY pizza since moving away 3 years ago

Alicia

Literally can not get better food in Marlboro! Marlo is 100/10 Absolutely amazing food and service. Delivery is beyond fast and everyone who works there is incredibly nice and accommodating. We order here atleast 2xs a week!

Jocelyn Harbeck

Ordered a buffalo chicken wrap, with lettuce tomato added cheese and ranch on the side. If I could give 10 stars I would! Perfect amount of crispness to the chicken, just enough sauce, great costumer service on the phone and a super quick delivery! Thank you 😎

Evan

This place the bomb!!! The food there is exquisite, I believe every pizza is made with awesomeness. The workers I know are homedawgs so that’s what’s up and all the other ones are so nice and friendly. The atmosphere is breathtaking hot take incoming but my favorite part of the atmosphere is this painting that says cheese and the tv playing sports 🇦🇱. The place is so clean I think they have a cleaner that kills 100% of bacteria this review getting long so in conclusion This place is THE BOMB and overall good so go here 👍

Bryan Takeuchi

It's hard to find pizza spots that have a typical NY style slice up this way, but this spot is perfect 👌 I always get my haircut next door, but this time we decided to stop in for a slice and some pasta for the kids. The slices were HUGE yet nice and crispy, cheesy, and thin! Staff were very accommodating, they made a kid sized portion of pasta with butter and parmesan for the kids and they ate it up. Definitely coming back here more often!

Finn Wakley

Marlo's Pizzeria is a hidden gem in the heart of the city! From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with the aroma of freshly baked dough and savory toppings. The pizzas are out of this world—perfectly crispy crusts topped with the finest ingredients. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional. Whether you're a traditionalist or an adventurous eater, Marlo's has something for everyone. Don't miss out on the opportunity to indulge in a slice of pizza perfection!

Erica Leo

Great spot in Marlboro for takeout and delivery. Their dinners are delicious and come with pasta, salad, and bread. Great for catering as well. Big fan of their Buffalo chicken wrap that they press and their pizza by the slice.

Diane Taylor

It's a pretty standard looking pizza joint, with delicious thin pizza, tasty not-too-salty soup and sub with nice meats and fresh veggies. I wasn't thrilled with the sub, but I'm too full to describe my ideal sub roll. But it's more crusty on the outside. And tender on the inside.

Survey Purveyor

Whenever I stop through it's always nice to see the giant slices. Variety is also great too!!

Jim Elliott (RapidEye)

First time I've been disappointed with a New York pizzeria. Crust was pretty bland and the Margherita pizza had sauce instead of the plum tomatoes the menu stated and the cheese and basil were added after the pizza was cooked. Yeah cold cheese on top of a hot crust. It kind of softened a little after a few minutes so it was cool unmelted cheese on a luke warm pizza. Pretty bad when a pizza tastes better after it's been microwaved than it did when served out of the oven.

Chris

Very dirty bathroom. Dirty floors. Chairs old and falling apart. Pizza not made as described. Cheese was cold and not melted. Crust was bland. Do not recommend.