Menu
Pueblo Real
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Pueblo Real
Photos

Pueblo Real

Mexican · Mayville

4.8 · 125 reviews Google
pueblorealmayville.com

About Pueblo Real

At Pueblo Real in Mayville, United States, we offer an authentic dining experience that embodies the warmth and vibrancy of Mexican culture. Our restaurant's bright interior and welcoming ambiance make it the perfect spot for families, friends, and solo diners alike. With a focus on using only the f...

At Pueblo Real in Mayville, United States, we offer an authentic dining experience that embodies the warmth and vibrancy of Mexican culture. Our restaurant's bright interior and welcoming ambiance make it the perfect spot for families, friends, and solo diners alike. With a focus on using only the freshest ingredients, our menu features signature dishes such as the Grande Molcajete, which has been praised for its rich flavors and generous portions. Our team is dedicated to providing exceptional service, with friendly and attentive wait staff who are eager to ensure every guest feels at home. From the complimentary chips and salsa to our extensive selection of cocktails, we strive to make every visit a memorable one. Whether you're in the mood for lunch or dinner, Pueblo Real is the ideal destination for anyone looking to indulge in delicious new Mexican cuisine.

What Customers Say About Pueblo Real

Pueblo Real is a highly-rated Mexican restaurant known for its delicious food, friendly staff, and inviting atmosphere. Customers rave about the fresh ingredients, generous portions, and tasty margaritas. Be prepared for potential wait times during peak hours.

Popular Dishes

enchiladas supreme veggie fajita queso dip Grande Molcajete Vallarta Special chicken fajitas seafood burrito burrito diabla

Best For

Families Groups Locals

Tip: Consider visiting during off-peak hours to avoid waiting for a table. The restaurant can get packed, especially on weekends.

Features

🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 👥 Groups

Frequently asked questions about Pueblo Real

Pueblo Real is located at 43 S Erie St, Mayville, NY 14757, Mayville.
Pueblo Real offers mexican cuisine.
Pueblo Real has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.
Pueblo Real offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.
The most recommended dishes at Pueblo Real based on customer reviews are: enchiladas supreme, veggie fajita, queso dip, Grande Molcajete, Vallarta Special.
Pueblo Real is ideal for families, groups, locals.
Pueblo Real is a highly-rated Mexican restaurant known for its delicious food, friendly staff, and inviting atmosphere. Customers rave about the fresh ingredients, generous portions, and tasty margaritas. Be prepared for potential wait times during peak hours.
Consider visiting during off-peak hours to avoid waiting for a table. The restaurant can get packed, especially on weekends.
125
Reviews

Pueblo Real Mayville Reviews

4.8
125
5★
92%
4★
2%
3★
2%
2★
2%
1★
2%
Reviews (40)
M
Mark Tevis

It was my first time at Pueblo Real in Mayville, NY and it won't be my last. The food was delicious, the house sangria was tasty, and the service was excellent. If you haven't been there yet, check it out. Highly recommended! 😋🥗🍷🇲🇽

M
Marcus LNU

Excellent quality. Great service. Decent price. Had chorizo pollo. Salsa was loaded with fresh quality ingredients

J
Jeffrey Currier

I love this place. Love the staff as well. And the food, fresh and delicious. Since this first time I have been three more times, and always terrific. I love everything about this restaurant, and I hope it continues through the long cold winter. It certainly will bring a bit of heat and joy! My last trip I got ordered Shrimp quesadilla, and one chili relenos, S appetizer. Perfect with fresh shrimp and chilis. Did I mention the chips and salsa are some of the best I ever had? 😋. Yummy!

E
Erin Saxton-Filkins

Great service and excellent food. I had a fajita bowl with Shrimp. The kids taco was a fantastic size and my daughter loved it. We also had the blackberry Margarita and it was full of fresh fruit and absolutely delicious! We will definitely be going back.

R
Regan Sims

My girlies and I love this place! Great frozen margaritas, great food, excellent service. We got to sing happy birthday to someone that was then given a sombrero to wear. And now we’re about to enjoy some dessert!! And my mom says the waiters are really cute.

D
Daria Barashkina

We had lunch at Pueblo Real — and it was simply amazing! 🇲🇽 We came all the way from New York, so we definitely have something to compare it to — and this place truly impressed us! The food was incredibly delicious: juicy meat dishes, fresh vegetables, and aromatic spices — everything was served hot and hearty, just the way we like it. We especially enjoyed the traditional sides — rice, beans, guacamole, and fresh salsa. The portions are generous, the presentation is beautiful, and the taste is authentically Mexican! 🌮🌯 The restaurant’s atmosphere is cozy and friendly, and the staff is welcoming and attentive. If you’re looking for truly delicious Mexican cuisine — this is the place! 🌶❤️

A
Ally

I don’t have a single negative thing to say about this place. The food is phenomenal at a reasonable price. I love that some of their menu items have meat with a smoky flavor.

M
Matt Jones

Relatively new restaurant in Mayville. Went on a whim with the wife and we loved it! It was packed for a Thursday night, but the staff had us at a table immediately. With 5 minutes, we had drinks ordered and some chips with salsa. The salsa was quite nice, too. I got a burrito diabla and my wife got a fajita bowl. I doubt we waited more than 10 minutes before the food was served. Both of us really liked our meals and packed some away for lunch the next day. Something important to know is that they are still waiting for their liquor license, so no cocktails or beer...yet. Also, parking is available. If they are busy, you may have to walk a few minutes to get to the restaurant. Finally, the service was awesome. We were helped by no less than 5 staff, which made the whole experience that much better. All in all, definitely come give Pueblo Real a try!

S
Soblessed 76

Super friendly people, quite welcoming on the way in and the service was great. Salsa was awesome, great flavor and not overly watery. I had the seafood burrito which has tilapia, shrimp, and crab. Flavor was spot on and the portion was very filling. Rice was also a great side.

N
Not a Bot

Went in for lunch with the family. I ordered the chicken fajitas, they were delicious. Our server was very friendly and made sure our needs were met. We will definitely be back for more!

T
T C

Very delicious. Highly recommend. The food is plentiful, well presented and reasonably priced. I really loved the pineapple filled with shrimp, chicken and steak- Vallarta Special.

K
Kristen Sukalac

Outstanding food. The Grande Molcajete was delicious (in the iron pot in my picture). Portions are huge (see the size of the fried ice cream compared to my hand). The team running it are super friendly and helpful. You have to wait for a table at peak meal times, so consider going another time. (At 4pm, it was still quite busy but there was no wait.)

E
Elijah B.

If you’re looking to stuff yourself with delicious Mexican food, this is definitely the place. We were on vacation in the area and ended up coming back here a few times. Everything was super tasty and had a great vibe. They’ve only recently opened, so unfortunately no alcohol yet, but other than that it’s spot on.

D
Darlene B

Food was great! We have enchiladas supreme and veggie fajita. Lots of delicious food. Love the wall paintings, place is cozy. Large bar with 3 TV screens. Service was great all around. Will definitely return!

Jeffrey Currier
Jeffrey Currier

I love this place. Love the staff as well. And the food, fresh and delicious. Since this first time I have been three more times, and always terrific. I love everything about this restaurant, and I hope it continues through the long cold winter. It certainly will bring a bit of heat and joy! My last trip I got ordered Shrimp quesadilla, and one chili relenos, S appetizer. Perfect with fresh shrimp and chilis. Did I mention the chips and salsa are some of the best I ever had? 😋. Yummy!

Erin Saxton-Filkins
Erin Saxton-Filkins

Great service and excellent food. I had a fajita bowl with Shrimp. The kids taco was a fantastic size and my daughter loved it. We also had the blackberry Margarita and it was full of fresh fruit and absolutely delicious! We will definitely be going back.

Daria Barashkina
Daria Barashkina

We had lunch at Pueblo Real — and it was simply amazing! 🇲🇽 We came all the way from New York, so we definitely have something to compare it to — and this place truly impressed us! The food was incredibly delicious: juicy meat dishes, fresh vegetables, and aromatic spices — everything was served hot and hearty, just the way we like it. We especially enjoyed the traditional sides — rice, beans, guacamole, and fresh salsa. The portions are generous, the presentation is beautiful, and the taste is authentically Mexican! 🌮🌯 The restaurant’s atmosphere is cozy and friendly, and the staff is welcoming and attentive. If you’re looking for truly delicious Mexican cuisine — this is the place! 🌶❤️

Ally
Ally

I don’t have a single negative thing to say about this place. The food is phenomenal at a reasonable price. I love that some of their menu items have meat with a smoky flavor.

Regan Sims
Regan Sims

My girlies and I love this place! Great frozen margaritas, great food, excellent service. We got to sing happy birthday to someone that was then given a sombrero to wear. And now we’re about to enjoy some dessert!! And my mom says the waiters are really cute.

Matt Jones
Matt Jones

Relatively new restaurant in Mayville. Went on a whim with the wife and we loved it! It was packed for a Thursday night, but the staff had us at a table immediately. With 5 minutes, we had drinks ordered and some chips with salsa. The salsa was quite nice, too. I got a burrito diabla and my wife got a fajita bowl. I doubt we waited more than 10 minutes before the food was served. Both of us really liked our meals and packed some away for lunch the next day. Something important to know is that they are still waiting for their liquor license, so no cocktails or beer...yet. Also, parking is available. If they are busy, you may have to walk a few minutes to get to the restaurant. Finally, the service was awesome. We were helped by no less than 5 staff, which made the whole experience that much better. All in all, definitely come give Pueblo Real a try!

Soblessed 76
Soblessed 76

Super friendly people, quite welcoming on the way in and the service was great. Salsa was awesome, great flavor and not overly watery. I had the seafood burrito which has tilapia, shrimp, and crab. Flavor was spot on and the portion was very filling. Rice was also a great side.

Not a Bot
Not a Bot

Went in for lunch with the family. I ordered the chicken fajitas, they were delicious. Our server was very friendly and made sure our needs were met. We will definitely be back for more!

T C
T C

Very delicious. Highly recommend. The food is plentiful, well presented and reasonably priced. I really loved the pineapple filled with shrimp, chicken and steak- Vallarta Special.

Kristen Sukalac
Kristen Sukalac

Outstanding food. The Grande Molcajete was delicious (in the iron pot in my picture). Portions are huge (see the size of the fried ice cream compared to my hand). The team running it are super friendly and helpful. You have to wait for a table at peak meal times, so consider going another time. (At 4pm, it was still quite busy but there was no wait.)

Elijah B.
Elijah B.

If you’re looking to stuff yourself with delicious Mexican food, this is definitely the place. We were on vacation in the area and ended up coming back here a few times. Everything was super tasty and had a great vibe. They’ve only recently opened, so unfortunately no alcohol yet, but other than that it’s spot on.

Darlene B
Darlene B

Food was great! We have enchiladas supreme and veggie fajita. Lots of delicious food. Love the wall paintings, place is cozy. Large bar with 3 TV screens. Service was great all around. Will definitely return!

Ariel Cartwright
Ariel Cartwright

Pueblo Real is great! The food was delicious, the wait time was short, the prices were reasonable and the staff were friendly. Highly recommend.

K G (Khandio)
K G (Khandio)

Very comfortable and accommodating for a party of 6 without a reservation. Chips and Salsa refilled throughout the dinner 🍽️ Prices are reasonable and the food is Great 👍

J
Josh Koch

Buy fire one of the best Mexican restaurants we have around. Great salsa and chips come to your table 1st like always. Food was amazing and fresh also fast. Our waiter was one of the best services we ever had from a waiter very kindly appearance, feel good. The decor and atmosphere and there is top-tier great work on a nice new restaurant in our area. Hope it stays this way.

f
francine P

My daughter and I dined here today. The interior is bright. My daughter and I lived in Denver for more than 20 years. I was not sure what to expect. The restaurant was clean and decorated for the holidays. Our waiter was conscientious and helpful. I found everything in our experience very pleasing. Our waiter was attentive. I was very surprised that the food was so delicious!! The Mexican food in Denver is very good, in part because there are Many Hispanic people. I was so pleasantly surprised to find our meal today so terrific and enjoyable. I beleive there is an authenticity that I did not anticipate. I recommend this restaurant without reservation! No doubt we will become regulars!! Francine

J
Joel Keefer

If I could give this place 6 or 7 stars, I would. We had heard so many great reviews and we were not disappointed. Our waiter was genuinely friendly and energetic. Plenty of chips and some tasty salsa when we sat down. Ordered some queso dip (one with chorizo, the other without). Both delicious, and I'm not normally a big queso fan. Some of the drinks came with flaming sugar cubes which was a nice touch. Ordered a lot of food and it came out fast. And, it was amazing. A friend recommended I get the carnitas and it was amazing (I ate every bite). We will definitely be coming back and recommend everyone reading this to go if you haven't!

a
ann14701

A Gloomy rainy day was made bright and cheerful by the wonderful lunch I enjoyed today. The restaurant was very nicely decorated clean and inviting. The staff was welcoming and friendly. I joined a friend for lunch and we both had great food. Menu was extensive, Margaritas were flowing. We will be back for sure.

O
Olivia Barnes

So so good! My new favorite local spot for sure. The chips and salsa are complimentary & delicious, and all of the meals we have tried have been fantastic. The atmosphere and staff are great! It was packed on a Saturday night when we went, and people were even waiting outside in the freezing cold, so clearly all the locals agree it's worth it!

Olivia Barnes
Olivia Barnes

So so good! My new favorite local spot for sure. The chips and salsa are complimentary & delicious, and all of the meals we have tried have been fantastic. The atmosphere and staff are great! It was packed on a Saturday night when we went, and people were even waiting outside in the freezing cold, so clearly all the locals agree it's worth it!

francine P
francine P

My daughter and I dined here today. The interior is bright. My daughter and I lived in Denver for more than 20 years. I was not sure what to expect. The restaurant was clean and decorated for the holidays. Our waiter was conscientious and helpful. I found everything in our experience very pleasing. Our waiter was attentive. I was very surprised that the food was so delicious!! The Mexican food in Denver is very good, in part because there are Many Hispanic people. I was so pleasantly surprised to find our meal today so terrific and enjoyable. I beleive there is an authenticity that I did not anticipate. I recommend this restaurant without reservation! No doubt we will become regulars!! Francine

Joel Keefer
Joel Keefer

If I could give this place 6 or 7 stars, I would. We had heard so many great reviews and we were not disappointed. Our waiter was genuinely friendly and energetic. Plenty of chips and some tasty salsa when we sat down. Ordered some queso dip (one with chorizo, the other without). Both delicious, and I'm not normally a big queso fan. Some of the drinks came with flaming sugar cubes which was a nice touch. Ordered a lot of food and it came out fast. And, it was amazing. A friend recommended I get the carnitas and it was amazing (I ate every bite). We will definitely be coming back and recommend everyone reading this to go if you haven't!

Lew Meckley
Lew Meckley

Excellent new Mexican with very tasty food and drinks. Service was quick and attentive. Margaritas were available both frozen and on the rocks with fresh fruit muddled in. Lots of variety, but fairly expensive as drinks go. Dinner varieties were all good and as appropriate with fresh ingredients. Servings are good size, but make sure you leave room for some of the best fried ice cream I've ever had! Note that they don't take reservations, so arrive early if you don't want to wait. Also noticed lots of meals going as take-out.

ann14701
ann14701

A Gloomy rainy day was made bright and cheerful by the wonderful lunch I enjoyed today. The restaurant was very nicely decorated clean and inviting. The staff was welcoming and friendly. I joined a friend for lunch and we both had great food. Menu was extensive, Margaritas were flowing. We will be back for sure.

A
Amy Figueroa

Was unaware of the difference in price from lunch to dinner. Didn't even notice the different menu for dinner so we were shocked when we saw the bill.. also was very disappointed in the fact that we were given a tiny serving of guacamole and was charged $5.75 for it! It tasted amazing but would never have thought it was almost 6 dollars for that little amount. They did fix the bill and removed the guacamole to make us happy but still talked with the owner and told him some ideas. Also, music was quite loud and it wasn't easy to hear the waiter fever easily.

Amy Figueroa
Amy Figueroa

Was unaware of the difference in price from lunch to dinner. Didn't even notice the different menu for dinner so we were shocked when we saw the bill.. also was very disappointed in the fact that we were given a tiny serving of guacamole and was charged $5.75 for it! It tasted amazing but would never have thought it was almost 6 dollars for that little amount. They did fix the bill and removed the guacamole to make us happy but still talked with the owner and told him some ideas. Also, music was quite loud and it wasn't easy to hear the waiter fever easily.

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in Mayville →
📸

2 Photos

Explore Pueblo Real's photos

Pueblo Real
Pueblo Real
📍

About Pueblo Real

How to get there

43 S Erie St, Mayville, NY 14757

Loading map...
Pueblo Real
Tap for directions

Highlights

Highly Rated
4.8/5 stars
💬
Many Reviews
125 reviews
👨‍🍳
mexican
Cuisine type

Services

🍽️ Lunch
🍾 Dinner
Coffee
🍰 Desserts
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery
🍴 Dine-in

Dining Options

🍽️ Dine In
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery

Restaurant Info

Status
Verified by owner
🕐 Hours Today
11AM-10PM
Rating
4.8/5
💬 Reviews
125
⏱️ Typical Visit
People typically spend 45 min to 1 hr here
📞 Phone
+1 716-224-1040
🌐 Website
www.pueblorealmayville.com
📋 Menu
View Menu

Amenities

🅿️ Parking
Wheelchair Accessible
🚻 Restroom
💳 Credit Cards
🏘️

The Neighborhood

Location

43 S Erie St, Mayville, NY 14757

📍 Explore the Neighborhood

Weather
22°
Weather updated hourly · Jobs and events refreshed daily
🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Pueblo Real and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Pueblo Real!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Pueblo Real

🏆 Rewards at Pueblo Real

💰

10% Discount

At Pueblo Real

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
Leave a Review on Google
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it