Shelley's

Name: Shelley's
Address: 59 NY-59, Monsey, NY 10952, Monsey, NY, 10952, US
Telephone: +18454253311
Price range: €€
Rating: 4.5

Pizza · Monsey

4.5 · 910 reviews Google

Shelley's

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

www.shelispizza.com

About Shelley's

Shelley's is a Monsey favorite, known for its delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. Our diverse menu offers something for everyone, from top-quality sushi to flavorful pizzas crafted in our new brick oven. Customers rave about our gnocchi, pasta dishes, and crispy, seasoned fries. We're committed to providing excellent service, with a friendly staff dedicated to ensuring every guest has a satisfying experience. Whether you're dining in our newly renovated, wheelchair-accessible space, taking advantage of our convenient takeout or delivery options, or enjoying a solo meal, we strive to make every visit memorable. We also offer local specialty items and are open for lunch and dinner.

What Customers Say About Shelley's

Shelley's Pizza in Monsey is known for its delicious pizza, generous portions, and great service, especially from Emily at the cashier. The newly renovated space is comfortable, though some find it cramped. Some customers complain about high prices and language barriers.

Popular Dishes

pizza (9) shakes sushi spicy fries venilla milkshake gnocchi pasta cauliflower bites

Best For

Families Groups Casual Quick Bite

Tip: Shelley's has a diverse menu with something for everyone, including sushi. The pizza is made in a new brick oven.

Features

🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery ♿ Accessible 🌅 Breakfast 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner 🥗 Vegetarian ☕ Coffee

🎯 Casual ✨ Trendy 👥 Groups

What to see nearby

A 713m

Monsey Church

iglesia

View details

Data from Wikidata

Frequently asked questions about Shelley's

Shelley's is located at 59 NY-59, Monsey, NY 10952, Monsey.

Shelley's offers pizza cuisine.

Shelley's has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.

Shelley's offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.

The most recommended dishes at Shelley's based on customer reviews are: pizza, shakes, sushi, spicy fries, venilla milkshake.

Shelley's is ideal for families, groups, casual dining, quick bites.

Shelley's has a diverse menu with something for everyone, including sushi. The pizza is made in a new brick oven.

910

Reviews

Shelley's Monsey Reviews

4.5

910

5★

74%

4★

12%

3★

2★

1★

Reviews (20)

Idy Gottesman

Food is delicious! Very generous! Nice place newly renovated!

Mesikos Center

We had such a nice experience with our group. The price was perfect and the food was plenty. I would recomend them for everyone in every event.

David Leftywitz

Very nice place. Good pizza. My food was cold when I got it but the staff was very helpful and gave me a new one.

Jacob Wiesenfeld

Wow, wow wow this place was amazing. Everything was delicious from food to the drink drinks and great customer service. The pizza was good and fluffy Fries was crispy and salty The pasta was out of this world And don’t get started about those cauliflower bites every lick was heaven

Avraham Fleisher

This is the best pizza store in all of rockland county! They have a new brick pizza oven which makes the pizza come out so good! They also have really good gnocchi and pasta! Restaurant is newly renovated, and the couches and chairs are super comfy! This is by far the best shop around.

Rebecca Zlato

Great food and service, very clean environment! My kids and I love the shakes!

Moishy Kudan

I live in Albany NY and whenever I go to monsey, and stop at Shelli's pizza, and get something to eat, the service and food is outstanding! Everyone is really nice and recommend Shellis pizza!

Motche

Pizza, spicy fries and venilla milkshake was great. But they forgot to tell me that my food is ready..

Dovid B

Good food. Great customer service. I had an issue, Emily at the cashier. Made sure I am satisfied. She contacted the owner. together, they make sure that I am getting Top Notch service. It is a comfortable environment to sit in to eat. Dedicated business owner

Aviva Koff

Great food and fast service They remodeled and it’s really nice

Green pepper

Very good pizza and very good service and also kid friendly and no wait time

A Goldminer

Great place, big verity of tasty food with generous portions.

A. S.

Monsey's top pizza shop. Their food is delicious. Tasty and flavorful, with a diverse menu that has something for everyone. Their sushi is top of the line too. They have a huge variety with the ability to customize according to your liking. The ambiance is amazing, spacious comfortable seating with enough room for everyone. Their customer service is their biggest plus though. Always patient, helpful, with a bright smile for every single customer!

Brock Zurdog

Good pizza, but dude, how do you expect your customers to leave happy when your workers can’t even talk to the customers because they don’t understand a word of English. And that’s besides the fact our order number was 97 and they started announcing numbers like 100, 101, and 102 and we we like “did you forget our order because we were 97” and we waited another 15 minutes and the worker pulled out our pizza from some random spot and said “97” it was cold and I’m not sure how the heck that happens. Get some workers who people can talk to and that might help. The food was decent though. I might be back considering the food was good.

B F

It's a great store Very convenient Good food Ever since they renovated its literally impossible to stand by registering and not be bumped in from ppl all sides So narrow the space and annoying Can barely walk through with food to the table which is set up like a maze Pushed tightly together Wish they do something abt it Otherwise service it great.

Sruli Feig

They hiked up their prices! Very expensive. After seeing the owners the reply I’d like to add an example 4 garlic nuts for $5 dollars is crazy and yes the prices have been changed since I used to shop there and bought it for way cheaper. One more note as a customer if renovating your store will hike up the prices there is no need for renovation.!