Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar

Name: Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar
Address: 287 Windsor Hwy #100, New Windsor, NY, 12553, US
Telephone: +18454206004
Rating: 4.4

Regional · New Windsor

Savor Latin American flavors in the heart of New Windsor

4.4 · 344 reviews Google

Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar Opening Hours

Monday 12:00–23:00

Tuesday ● 12:00–23:00

Wednesday 12:00–23:00

Thursday 12:00–23:00

Friday 12:00–23:30

Saturday 12:00–23:30

Sunday 12:00–22:00

Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

About Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar

Contemporary kitchen offering upscale Latin American tapas & entrees, plus a full bar.

What Customers Say About Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar

Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar is highly praised for its authentic Puerto Rican and Dominican food, especially the mofongo, pernil, and tostones. Customers consistently highlight the flavorful food, friendly service (especially Lori and Danny), and reasonable prices. Some negative reviews mention inconsistent quality and issues with orders.

Popular Dishes

mofongo (5) tostones pernil Rice and Red beans Pastelillos Rabo Churrasco

Best For

Couples Families Casual Tourists Locals

Tip: Call or go in person to order, as they don't make everything on the menu every day. Also, try the mofongo!

Frequently asked questions about Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar

Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar is located at 287 Windsor Hwy #100, New Windsor.

Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar offers regional cuisine.

Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.

The most recommended dishes at Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar based on customer reviews are: mofongo, tostones, pernil, Rice and Red beans, Pastelillos.

Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar is ideal for couples, families, casual dining, tourists, locals.

Call or go in person to order, as they don't make everything on the menu every day. Also, try the mofongo!

344

Reviews

Nelly's Mofongo Restaurant and Bar New Windsor Reviews

4.4

5★

80%

4★

3★

2★

1★

10%

Reviews (22)

William Velazquez

Salsa night in the Hudaon valley felt like I was in San Juan. Great band, great crowd, great drinks, great sound. Truely a happy place! Only thing missing was the Coqui in the distance. The night was memorable! Cant wait for next Salsa night.

Soul Seeker

Everything on the menu is amazing, and they make the best Cubano in Orange County, hands down. Attentive, friendly staff, and an immersive atmosphere. Would give more stars if I could

Jenny

Great Spanish food and reasonable prices. The mofongo is yummy!

phantom nyc

I became a regular within 2mths and here to stay 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 🫶🏾🫶🏾My favorite dish is baked chicken🍗 (dark meat) with rice 🍚and peas,beans on top and plantains on the side 🍛🤤🤤🤤when I tell you their chicken is so tender and well seasoned 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 I mean TO THE BONE 🦴 🤤🤤 Food is great and prices are reasonable. I love yall and will see you TOMORROW 😭😭👏🏽👏🏽🫶🏾🫶🏾

Casey Ayala

Ordered catering for my housewarming, food is AMAZING - super smooth process, everyone is so nice!

Giovanni Ochoa

Best Spanish food in Orange County in my opinion. The people there are so friendly and the food is unbelievable.

Luis Alvarez

The Food here is really good. The Rice and Red beans with the chicken and peppers are the best I have tasted out in a minute.

HolySocom

full of flavor and good vibes. The mofongo was absolutely delicious perfectly seasoned and cooked just right. You can tell they take pride in their food. The portions were pretty good. Lori was friendly and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. Whether you’re a fan of Caribbean cuisine or trying mofongo for the first time, Nelly’s is definitely worth the visit. I’ll be coming back for more!

Keanu

All around amazing experience. Seasoned food, clean atmosphere and attentive service. If you can ask for Lori, she was awesome. Will return for more tostones!!! And Danny the manager was awesome too!

Jose Vazquez

Best mofongo I’ve ever had!! Everything was so good!! We will definitely be coming back here!

Robert Perez

Nice variety of Hot Food ready to go as well as menu items. Service was prompt and courteous. Food was fresh and delicious. Nice portions for the price.

B Wheeler

Nelly Latin Restaurant (formally named Cilantro) Amazing Latin (Puerto Rican / Dominican) food! Some of the best mofongo and pernil ever tasted outside of the islands. Pasteles are on point! Food is consistently flavorful and fresh and not too salty. The service could not be more perfect: always on time, with great quality food served by the kindest owners 😊 prices are super affordable (The combo specials are the best - 2 or 3 eat for $20) with very generous portions

A “SubZero XT” L

Moving to New Windsor and found this gem of a place. The Montaditos and Pastelillos were on point! The Rabo was tender and super tasty, just needed to be served hotter. The Mofongo was really good as well, nice flavor. The Churrasco was super tender and the sauce was yummy! Happy to have this within driving distance from home.

Teresa Ridgeway

This place has amazing Dominican food for an excellent value. The tostones are crisp and made to order. The pernil is perfection. Excellent empanadas. Quick service. I recommend calling or going in person to order. They do not make everything on the menu everyday. They are ready made in a case cafeteria style. The empanadas and tostones are made to order.

Megan Leigh Abernathy

Absolutely delicious! We ordered from the ready made food, slow roasted beef with the eggplant and a side of plantains! Very flavorful and great comfort food! John was a our server who was delightful.

Hadiya Fisher

The food Is awesome! And there is this one particular waitress I cant remember her name! But she said something like " I'll be your stalker tonight " I found that hilarious lol. If you're looking for authentic PR food this is the place.

Ed Loz

We were visiting Storm King art center and after a long hike were starving. This place was very close and had good reviews. Great choice of Puerto Rico food. Friendly personnel and fast service

Claricia Harley (Reese)

The food was delicious and the service was excellent. It's a beautiful place to dine at. We will be going back again for a date night night our without our babies.

Elena bearese

I was liking this place but my las purchase I got a rubber band in my beans Soooooo no hair nets????? Also they need to understand client request better. We ordered for 4 people and it came out to $127.

Brooke Gonsalves

I went in to give this place another chance as I didn’t have a good experience before. The mangu is better than last time, salami perfect. The cheese was only 1 piece and it was small but also just tasted like dirty oil/pan and the second egg has SHELLS ALL IN IT. I’m crunching down and just all hard pieces.

murd777

The chicken had a weird taste (cider) seems like was there for days. I didn’t eat it. First time and last time coming to that place. Horrible!

Gabriella WOWITSGOLDIE

Do not order from this place !!!! customer service is horrible… We paid $20 for a pork dinner and it didn’t even come with rice and beans !!! I am so disappointed, the last time we ordered it came with rice and beans .::this time your telling me when it says choose a side for a $20 dinner and you pick tostones that is suppose to be instead of rice and beans ?? Total rip off and very upset. Will not order again. Do not recommend.