Cellar 58

Name: Cellar 58
Address: 58 2nd Avenue, New York, NY, 10003, US
Rating: 3.7

Italian · New York

3.7 · 194 reviews Google

Cellar 58

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

www.cellar58.com

About Cellar 58

Cellar 58 is a Italian restaurant in New York. Rated 3.7/5 based on 194 reviews on OpenTable. Casual Dining.

Frequently asked questions about Cellar 58

Cellar 58 is located at 58 2nd Avenue, New York.

Cellar 58 offers Italian cuisine.

194

Reviews

Cellar 58 New York Reviews

Reviews (11)

Hansley GONZALEZ

NOW THAT WHAT I CALL 58 Hours QUEENS N.Y. Times.

Francesca Nadel

Fresh pasta cooked 'al dente', extensive wine list, home-made desserts. The service was friendly and genuine. The music, soft. The ambiance, romantic. Only suggestion, avoid the veggie-burger and the passito. I would return with my Italian mother, and I wouldn't miss the cheese/meat entrée.

Scott Dillin

Felt right at home as soon as we walked, the staff were very friendly and accommodating. The food was outstanding and on Thursday nights they have a piano player.

Paolino Bindi

Best wine bar in the area.... Maria is a fantastic host, Enrico the chef has a real passion for quality and making delicious pastas!

Bradley Schwartz

Great food & wine!

Nate Buck

The Corcoran Group

Cute and cozy wine bar with a great selection of wines and small plates and entrees. Our personal favorites: the gnocchi, the Prosciutto Di Parma sandwich, and the Cutting Board.

Ian Schwartz

great place for casual dates. good food and wine

Kevin Wu

Pretty decent food. Lasagna was good but no Max's, Spaghetti carbonara was my favorite and pretty good, Gnocci made from spinach dish was weird and frankly even between a group of 8 we could not help the friend finish the 8 pieces of it b/c it was so rich and odd (not your typical gnocci). Wow, they messed up gnocci, haha! Wine was good, place affordable, nice back area for a large 8 or even larger who knows group seating. Charcuterie good.

Michael Morgenstern

Gross food. Reservation @9 - we were seated @10. Owner said he would provide us 'free drinks' with because of the wait and charged us for the 'free drinks', Don't waste your time.

Betty Woods

This place... very rarely do I feel uncomfortable going anywhere in the city. This place I was uncomfortable from the moment I saw it. To set the scene, I was coming to an event here and when I arrived, there was hardly anyone else except for my friend and what I am guessing to be the owner and a few workers. I understood some curiosity since I am sure they were expecting a certain type of attendees for the event and that wasn't me. However I swiftly came to the conclusion that it wouldn't of mattered what event I was there for as the looks kept coming from the owner, workers and the people who showed up. Either way, you have no idea why I'm attending and for all they know I could have been writing for a reputable site. I got the impression that based on how they looked they had already come to some judgment which I suppose is their prerogative. Based on the other reviews I've seen for this place and my experience I would never come back here and wouldn't recommend anyone else coming here either.