Rosey's Italian Cafe

Name: Rosey's Italian Cafe
Address: 2133 Five Mile Line Rd, Penfield, NY 14526, Penfield, NY, 14526, US
Telephone: +15853855600
Price range: €€
Rating: 4.5

Italian · Penfield

4.5 · 601 reviews Google

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

www.roseysitaliancafe.com

About Rosey's Italian Cafe

At Rosey's Italian Cafe, we're a family-run eatery serving up delicious sandwiches and homestyle mains that'll make you feel like you're dining with nonna herself. Located in heart of Penfield, our cozy atmosphere is the perfect spot to catch up with friends or enjoy a quiet night out. Our beer and wine selection is also top-notch, complementing our homemade pasta dishes perfectly. We've been told by our customers that our service is always warm and attentive, making you feel right at home. Come taste the difference for yourself - we can't wait to serve you!

What Customers Say About Rosey's Italian Cafe

Rosey's Italian Cafe is a local favorite known for its delicious Italian food, large portions, and friendly service. Many reviewers specifically praise the chicken French, eggplant parm, and homemade sauces. The cozy atmosphere makes it great for date night.

Popular Dishes

chicken French (4) eggplant parm (3) meatballs lasagna Chicken and Artichoke French Fried Calamari gnocchi

Best For

Couples Families Groups Business Locals Celebrations Casual

Tip: Rosey's is great for takeout and catering. Order ahead, especially on weekends, and be prepared for generous portions.

Features

🌳 Outdoor 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery ♿ Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner ☕ Coffee

🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Frequently asked questions about Rosey's Italian Cafe

Rosey's Italian Cafe is located at 2133 Five Mile Line Rd, Penfield, NY 14526, Penfield.

Rosey's Italian Cafe offers italian cuisine.

Rosey's Italian Cafe has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.

Rosey's Italian Cafe offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.

The most recommended dishes at Rosey's Italian Cafe based on customer reviews are: chicken French, eggplant parm, meatballs, lasagna, Chicken and Artichoke French.

Rosey's Italian Cafe is ideal for couples, families, groups, business dining, locals, celebrations, casual dining.

Rosey's is great for takeout and catering. Order ahead, especially on weekends, and be prepared for generous portions.

601

Reviews

Rosey's Italian Cafe Penfield Reviews

4.5

601

5★

71%

4★

17%

3★

2★

1★

Reviews (22)

Tim S.

Rosey’s catered my daughter’s birthday party. The food was absolutely delicious and prepared meticulously for the event.

James Alaimo

I have ordered food from Rosey's 5 times in the last 2 months. I could eat this every night of the week. Absolutely fantastic traditional Italian food that is consistent. I absolutely love it. Having it tonight!

nicholas rogers

No one does Italian better than the staff at Rosie’s. Amazing staff and even better chicken French

MEGAR

I ordered two dinners for my Dad the day before Christmas Eve. I live out of town and I’m sick and can’t be with him . A friend picked it up and brought it to him. He called me and absolutely raved of how good the food is. I ordered him both the eggplant and lasagna dinners with sides of meatballs and sausage Thanks to Rosey’s I know my Dad will have plenty to eat for Christmas Eve as well as Christmas.

Sarah Pastecki

The food was amazing, the servers were really nice and we would definitely go back! - Brecken (age 9) who loved the chicken French so much. If he could give 100000000 out of 5 he would have! Everett (age 9) - the spaghetti was delicious, the chicken parm was really moist and soft and delicious and the portions were great. Would also give it 100000000 if he could!

Griffon O'Cuirc

Got take out from them and it was utterly delicious. Best eggplant Parmesan I've ever had and all the ingredients were cooked perfectly. The sauce was divine. Chicken cutlets sandwich was huge and the bread was so soft. Highly recommend. Will be getting again

Mary Ann Uhrenholdt

We tried Rosey’s because a friend recommended it. Four of us dined together and each really enjoyed our meal. The service was great! We will return and recommend to others.

Gail Snyder

Our food was really good. Big portions. The services was great. Will definitely be coming back. Great job.

Brenda Bermudez

Rosey's Cafe has excellent service! I had a staff lunch that they accommodated for our office within 30 min notice. Thank you so much for such a quick turnaround!

Scott Roc

This weekend we dined at Rosey's for my Mother's birthday dinner. The food was like always fantastic. The appetizers of clams casino and party potatoes were a great start. The staff is always very friendly. We started going to Rosey's during the pandemic. We used to purchase to go food on Thursday nights to support our local restaurants. Rosey's had a nice family to go specials during that time. Even there to go food is fantastic. I say this because sometimes to go foods loose some of there flavor due to packaging and transfer etc. No fault of the restaurant, but not the case with Rosey's. Their sauce is the best I have ever tasted. My Mom purchased three large containers of their sauce to bring home. We are very happy that a restaurant like Rosey's exists in our time.

David & Mary VerLee

We used Rosey’s catering this past week as we have dined there quite a few times and have always enjoyed our dinners. The meatballs in their wonderful homemade sauce won rave reviews! Rosey also got us 80 mini cannolis which were a big hit!

Bob P

I’ve ordered delivery from Rosey’s multiple times this year. I’ve tried the chicken and veal parm combo, the chicken parm, and a few others. Dishes were all delicious and got to me piping hot. Always a treat from this restaurant.

Jacob M

I called Rosey’s on a Saturday at 1:45 to place an order for takeout. When I showed up, I realized they weren’t even open until 3pm, I had no idea! Still, they went out of their way to make my order an hour and fifteen minutes before opening. It was hot, fresh, and ready for me in 10 minutes. They truly didn’t have to do that, but the customer service and kindness blew me away, especially as a brand-new Penfield resident. Rosey’s just earned themselves a loyal customer!

Hai Nguyen

Our party of 11 had an amazing Friday evening dinner. Fantastic food, attentive service and fun atmosphere. A hidden gem in Penfield!

Jenn Streber

My husband brought me here for the first time a few weeks ago and I loved it. I love that it isn’t very big inside which gives it a charming, cozy feeling. The food is amazing and the servers are fast and very friendly! It’s the perfect place for a date night!

Suzanna Prong

I've dined at Rosey's many many times but was not feeling well so ordered from GrubHub. Man was it just what the doctor ordered. Giant homemade cheese ravioli, a big meatball, eggplant parm and cheesy garlic bread. It was enough for three full meals. Thanks, Rosey's!

Julie

Chefs kiss! The sauce was perfect. Bread dipped in sauce, amazing! The gnocchi so soft and pillowy! I enjoyed the flavor! Atmosphere was gorgeous and service was welcoming and kind. Thank you!

Megan Prescott

I order for pick up, it was ready within 10-15 minutes. Their food is delicious, first time ordering from them. The customer service is excellent. I ordered the Chicken and Artichoke French meal with linguine and an appetizer is Fried Calamari. Highly recommend when you have that Italian craving.

BJean Gammi

10 Sept '25 Rosey's food was very good. For once there was actually plenty of sauce on my pasta. The waitress who served us was not only very attentive plus she was friendly and polite. It definitely made our lunch really pleasant. The atmosphere was cutely done kinda on the lines of a café On the down side I feel the prices were a little high fir what you get. I'm thankful for a neighbor who got us a gift certificate so we could afford a one time visit to Rosey's.

Dolores Green

I am so sorry to write a VERY negative review for my dinner, not the others in my party. I have known, loved & enjoyed Rosey's fish fries for yrs in Downtown Roch & Penfield. The last 2 Fish Fries, within the last 6 months, have been BEYOND a disappointment. I have always recommended these to everyone. Plus, tonite, our server did not deserve the tip I gave her. The only reason I ordered the Fish Fry was to see if the other one was a one time disappointment. This IS NOT a beer battered Fish Fry. It is disgusting. Not any flakey fish, just horrid ..some kinda coating.🤪 You have lost me.🥲

Ellen Young

Very disappointed in our visit last night. Brought a couple of out-of-town visitors and the food and service was not good. All of our meals were lukewarm. I sent my lasagna back and it did not come back any hotter. The waitress brought 5 slices of bread for 7 people. She did not check in and did not ask if people wanted drinks refilled. Poor experience all around. Have been there before and the everything was great. Not sure what has changed.

Sheri Kausch

The half portion of chicken and artichoke French wasn’t even a full chicken breast. Frankly, it was repulsive and looked like someone’s half eaten leftovers. Complete waste of money. This photo is exactly how the dish was served to us (2 artichokes and a partial piece of chicken breast). This should not be considered a "French" sauce..