Gourmet Pizza
Pizza · Rocky Point
About Gourmet Pizza
Gourmet Pizza, located in Rocky Point, is a local favorite serving up delicious pizzas with fast and friendly service. We offer a variety of options to suit your needs, including delivery, convenient takeout, and comfortable dine-in seating. Enjoy lunch or dinner with us any day except Monday. We're...
Gourmet Pizza, located in Rocky Point, is a local favorite serving up delicious pizzas with fast and friendly service. We offer a variety of options to suit your needs, including delivery, convenient takeout, and comfortable dine-in seating. Enjoy lunch or dinner with us any day except Monday. We're proud to serve local specialties and cater to all our guests, providing a fully wheelchair accessible environment with accessible entrances, parking, and restrooms. With a rating of 4.7 stars from 164 reviews, we're committed to providing a satisfying experience for every customer.
What Customers Say About Gourmet Pizza
Gourmet Pizza is a popular spot known for its delicious pizza and Italian dishes like lasagna and penne vodka. Customers rave about the friendly staff, welcoming atmosphere, and party room. Some customers have complained about soggy garlic knots and long wait times.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Try the grandma or Brooklyn pizza. They also offer early bird and nightly specials.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Gourmet Pizza
Gourmet Pizza Rocky Point Reviews
This place is absolutely amazing! The owners are incredibly sweet and welcoming, making you feel right at home. The outdoor patio is beautiful, and the eggplant parmigiana and calamari were outstanding—truly delicious. If you haven’t visited this hidden gem yet, you’re missing out. Beautiful for a date night. The location may be tucked away, but the food shines just as brightly! Also stop into their sister location Del Fiore for some delicious deli treats.
Drove 20 minutes because I read they had a great gluten free pizza. I got the Detroit gluten free personal pie, it’s like 4 Sicilian slices. This has to be the best gluten free pizza I have ever had, you wouldn’t even know it was gluten free. Hands down this is my new pizza spot!
Alfie's Pizza is an absolute gem that deserves all the praise! From the moment we stepped in, the owners made us feel incredibly welcome and treated us like royalty throughout our dining experience. Our journey began with a delectable selection of fried calamari, wings, and mozzarella sticks that were simply out of this world - each bite bursting with flavor and perfectly cooked. For our main course, we savored the Penne allá vodka with grilled chicken and the classic chicken parmigiana. Both dishes were cooked to perfection, with flavors that danced on our taste buds and left us craving more. I must say, I am forever grateful to my friend Camille for introducing us to this culinary haven. Not to mention the amazing drinks that perfectly complemented our meal and added an extra layer of enjoyment to our evening. The overall experience at Alfie's Pizza was nothing short of wonderful, and to top it all off, we were surprised with a Delicious Tartufo on the house - a sweet ending to a perfect meal. We left Alfie's Pizza with full and content hearts, already planning our next visit with family and friends. The team at Alfie's truly goes above and beyond to create a warm and inviting atmosphere, and their dedication to providing exceptional food and service shines through in every aspect. Thank you, Alfie's Pizza, for a memorable dining experience - we are thrilled to have discovered this culinary treasure!
What a great find!! We wanted some pizza delivered but couldn’t agree on a place. We were both tired of our usual places so we decided to give Alfies a try. When our order said delivered but nothing had arrived I called up - I figured it was a computer glitch. The manager told us it was waiting for pick up and apologized profusely for the wait. I offered to come pick it up but she insisted on bringing it herself. 10 min later one of the chefs was at my door also apologizing again and again while he was handing over a hot pie. In a day an age where all we see are negative reviews and Karen’s - it’s refreshing to see real customer service! The food … The pizza was great! We got half white which was very tasty - not bland like some places. This had flavor! The other half their classic plain - so good! The sauce is wonderful! We also loved the garlic knot crust. They even threw in something to apologize for the delay. It’s hard nowadays to find a place that has great food and great customer service. This place has both! We’ll definitely be ordering again!
If you are looking for a great place with great food to host a party, definitely use Alfie's! We hosted a baby shower in their party room with 36 guests, with room for more. The food was delicious and the space was beautiful! Everyone who works there is so kind and helpful. Book your next birthday, shower, or any kind of celebration at Alfie's, you won't be disappointed!
Wow, wow, wow!!! I came here a few times And ordered my usual, a large pie , meatball parm and some garlic knots. The food was delicious, pizza was soft with the right texture of crispyness on the crust, the meatball parm was so tasty in that signature tomato sauce and the garlic knots were so aift and garlicky, so good . Listen, if you live in rocky point or neighborhood towns and have not tried this place , your missing out !!! They have a dine in area as well as togo counter to sit or carryout . This is a new place and Iam a big time pizza enthusiast, most nee places let me down , this one blew my taste buds away, friendly staff, clean and organized etc. Im just a paying customer , and trust me , try this place and be sure and ready to leave ur usual spot . This is the situation I’m in now , Its crazy. Please message me if you think this review is so on point..
Excellent crust. Ordered two vegan pies (the Sicilian was delish) and we feel utterly blessed to have local options. Staff friendly and helpful. Can't wait to see what other vegan options they offer in the future.
This place is absolutely amazing! The owners are incredibly sweet and welcoming, making you feel right at home. The outdoor patio is beautiful, and the eggplant parmigiana and calamari were outstanding—truly delicious. If you haven’t visited this hidden gem yet, you’re missing out. Beautiful for a date night. The location may be tucked away, but the food shines just as brightly! Also stop into their sister location Del Fiore for some delicious deli treats.
Drove 20 minutes because I read they had a great gluten free pizza. I got the Detroit gluten free personal pie, it’s like 4 Sicilian slices. This has to be the best gluten free pizza I have ever had, you wouldn’t even know it was gluten free. Hands down this is my new pizza spot!
Alfie's Pizza is an absolute gem that deserves all the praise! From the moment we stepped in, the owners made us feel incredibly welcome and treated us like royalty throughout our dining experience. Our journey began with a delectable selection of fried calamari, wings, and mozzarella sticks that were simply out of this world - each bite bursting with flavor and perfectly cooked. For our main course, we savored the Penne allá vodka with grilled chicken and the classic chicken parmigiana. Both dishes were cooked to perfection, with flavors that danced on our taste buds and left us craving more. I must say, I am forever grateful to my friend Camille for introducing us to this culinary haven. Not to mention the amazing drinks that perfectly complemented our meal and added an extra layer of enjoyment to our evening. The overall experience at Alfie's Pizza was nothing short of wonderful, and to top it all off, we were surprised with a Delicious Tartufo on the house - a sweet ending to a perfect meal. We left Alfie's Pizza with full and content hearts, already planning our next visit with family and friends. The team at Alfie's truly goes above and beyond to create a warm and inviting atmosphere, and their dedication to providing exceptional food and service shines through in every aspect. Thank you, Alfie's Pizza, for a memorable dining experience - we are thrilled to have discovered this culinary treasure!
What a great find!! We wanted some pizza delivered but couldn’t agree on a place. We were both tired of our usual places so we decided to give Alfies a try. When our order said delivered but nothing had arrived I called up - I figured it was a computer glitch. The manager told us it was waiting for pick up and apologized profusely for the wait. I offered to come pick it up but she insisted on bringing it herself. 10 min later one of the chefs was at my door also apologizing again and again while he was handing over a hot pie. In a day an age where all we see are negative reviews and Karen’s - it’s refreshing to see real customer service! The food … The pizza was great! We got half white which was very tasty - not bland like some places. This had flavor! The other half their classic plain - so good! The sauce is wonderful! We also loved the garlic knot crust. They even threw in something to apologize for the delay. It’s hard nowadays to find a place that has great food and great customer service. This place has both! We’ll definitely be ordering again!
If you are looking for a great place with great food to host a party, definitely use Alfie's! We hosted a baby shower in their party room with 36 guests, with room for more. The food was delicious and the space was beautiful! Everyone who works there is so kind and helpful. Book your next birthday, shower, or any kind of celebration at Alfie's, you won't be disappointed!
Wow, wow, wow!!! I came here a few times And ordered my usual, a large pie , meatball parm and some garlic knots. The food was delicious, pizza was soft with the right texture of crispyness on the crust, the meatball parm was so tasty in that signature tomato sauce and the garlic knots were so aift and garlicky, so good . Listen, if you live in rocky point or neighborhood towns and have not tried this place , your missing out !!! They have a dine in area as well as togo counter to sit or carryout . This is a new place and Iam a big time pizza enthusiast, most nee places let me down , this one blew my taste buds away, friendly staff, clean and organized etc. Im just a paying customer , and trust me , try this place and be sure and ready to leave ur usual spot . This is the situation I’m in now , Its crazy. Please message me if you think this review is so on point..
Not just your local pizzeria. While the pizza IS consistently delicious, the restaurant also serves up classic Italian food in a tastefully designed, cozy dining room. Their nightly specials are 'gram worthy while their early bird specials are filling and affordable! Run, don't walk, to this wildly fantastic family owned and operated establishment.
Had a birthday party for my husband today had about 40 people. They made everything perfect! Food was wonderful service could not have been better. I would definitely use Alfies again for a party.
Stopped in for a quick bite. Great spot, pizza was delicious! We had grandma slice and plain slice with garlic knot crust. The server was friendly and professional. Like everywhere else, prices have gone up but it was worth the cost.
Amazing food and great service!! Camille is a great owner and so so fair. Chicken parm is delicious!! The decor is so cute and very festive for every season. Absolutely love this restaurant and love the staff!!
The pizza is excellent and all their entrees are as well. The staff is so nice and friendly. I would recommend it to all my friends and family.
Food is amazing! The staff is so helpful and bubbly. We felt right at home. Can’t wait to go back.
I would gladly pass our 2 other pizza spots to come here. I really enjoyed the pizza they have a large variety
They have the best pizza! Def try it if you haven't yet! The grandma and Brooklyn is my favorite!
Wonderful place. Down home Italian cooking. The atmosphere is heart warming. The owners right to the cashiers are happy, grateful for the business that comes into the restaurant. The atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting they have a fun area for the kids when they come in from town. Alford makes this town home for me Ridge- Shoreham- Rocky Point- Best of the North East on Long Island.
Today we had a wonderful Happy Bee 🐝 day birthday party! With family and friends! First time here and certainly not the last! The food was amazing and the restaurant is absolutely beautiful. Leah our waitress was great !! I want to thank Camille the owner for being so professional kind and welcoming! Thank you again guys!!
Had a birthday party for my husband today had about 40 people. They made everything perfect! Food was wonderful service could not have been better. I would definitely use Alfies again for a party.
The pizza is excellent and all their entrees are as well. The staff is so nice and friendly. I would recommend it to all my friends and family.
Amazing food and great service!! Camille is a great owner and so so fair. Chicken parm is delicious!! The decor is so cute and very festive for every season. Absolutely love this restaurant and love the staff!!
Food is amazing! The staff is so helpful and bubbly. We felt right at home. Can’t wait to go back.
Not just your local pizzeria. While the pizza IS consistently delicious, the restaurant also serves up classic Italian food in a tastefully designed, cozy dining room. Their nightly specials are 'gram worthy while their early bird specials are filling and affordable! Run, don't walk, to this wildly fantastic family owned and operated establishment.
I would gladly pass our 2 other pizza spots to come here. I really enjoyed the pizza they have a large variety
They have the best pizza! Def try it if you haven't yet! The grandma and Brooklyn is my favorite!
Stopped in for a quick bite. Great spot, pizza was delicious! We had grandma slice and plain slice with garlic knot crust. The server was friendly and professional. Like everywhere else, prices have gone up but it was worth the cost.
We drove here from Wading River. Totally worth it. Great Italian food. Has lasagna, penne vodka and Sicilian pizza. All were excellent
Today we had a wonderful Happy Bee 🐝 day birthday party! With family and friends! First time here and certainly not the last! The food was amazing and the restaurant is absolutely beautiful. Leah our waitress was great !! I want to thank Camille the owner for being so professional kind and welcoming! Thank you again guys!!
Wonderful place. Down home Italian cooking. The atmosphere is heart warming. The owners right to the cashiers are happy, grateful for the business that comes into the restaurant. The atmosphere of the restaurant is inviting they have a fun area for the kids when they come in from town. Alford makes this town home for me Ridge- Shoreham- Rocky Point- Best of the North East on Long Island.
Alfie's Pizzeria and Restaurant is the perfect example of a garbage restaurant that found their way into a hidden gem location. We sat down for our meal (with only two people) and ordered. One of us ordered Eggplant Parmigiana, and one ordered Chicken Parmigiana. After waiting for 1 hour and 15 minutes for our order (which mind you was literally just chicken, eggplant, pasta, and sauce), the food was beyond mediocre. Chicken Parm came out without even looking like chicken parm. It was absolutely swimming in way more sauce than necessary. After excavating through the mountain of sauce on my plate and parting the figurative red sea, lo and behold, chicken appears! Two almost paper-thin pieces of fried chicken cutlets that were soggier than boiled noodles, and tough at the same time. Not sure how that's possible but I guess it was. Pasta side was nothing special whatsoever. Penne with marinara sauce (which was expected), but with the absolute dismal presentation of the chicken parm when it was first placed upon the table, expectations were already low. Now, for the taste. Chicken parm was tough, and nothing special. Any seasoning that MAY have been on there was washed away within the veritable flood of sauce that was dumped onto my plate and quite literally seeping off of the sides every single time I tried to cut into the chicken. Chicken slid all over because of the bottomless pit of marinara it was floating atop, leading to sauce getting all over the table no matter how it was cut, at any angle. Given they were quite literally 3 sheets of paper thick, the chicken itself was bland and rather disappointing as it had the same flavor as if I had just taken a bite into a cardboard box sprinkled with salt and pepper, and a dash of tomatoes. Even if someone could look past all of this, the two of us came out to a total price of $100 for the meal after tip. I forgot I was ordering from a 3 star Michelin restaurant I suppose. Get your act together, and fix the service, the cooks in the back, and know how to operate when under pressure and during busy hours, or don't even bother opening your doors at all.
Alfie's Pizzeria and Restaurant is the perfect example of a garbage restaurant that found their way into a hidden gem location. We sat down for our meal (with only two people) and ordered. One of us ordered Eggplant Parmigiana, and one ordered Chicken Parmigiana. After waiting for 1 hour and 15 minutes for our order (which mind you was literally just chicken, eggplant, pasta, and sauce), the food was beyond mediocre. Chicken Parm came out without even looking like chicken parm. It was absolutely swimming in way more sauce than necessary. After excavating through the mountain of sauce on my plate and parting the figurative red sea, lo and behold, chicken appears! Two almost paper-thin pieces of fried chicken cutlets that were soggier than boiled noodles, and tough at the same time. Not sure how that's possible but I guess it was. Pasta side was nothing special whatsoever. Penne with marinara sauce (which was expected), but with the absolute dismal presentation of the chicken parm when it was first placed upon the table, expectations were already low. Now, for the taste. Chicken parm was tough, and nothing special. Any seasoning that MAY have been on there was washed away within the veritable flood of sauce that was dumped onto my plate and quite literally seeping off of the sides every single time I tried to cut into the chicken. Chicken slid all over because of the bottomless pit of marinara it was floating atop, leading to sauce getting all over the table no matter how it was cut, at any angle. Given they were quite literally 3 sheets of paper thick, the chicken itself was bland and rather disappointing as it had the same flavor as if I had just taken a bite into a cardboard box sprinkled with salt and pepper, and a dash of tomatoes. Even if someone could look past all of this, the two of us came out to a total price of $100 for the meal after tip. I forgot I was ordering from a 3 star Michelin restaurant I suppose. Get your act together, and fix the service, the cooks in the back, and know how to operate when under pressure and during busy hours, or don't even bother opening your doors at all.
I figured based on the reviews that it would be a great place to check out. However, their garlic knots were really soggy and their pizza was not that good. Definitely disappointed.
Found them on Instagram but it’s nearly impossible to find their location on their BUSINESS ACCOUNT. Why on earth in 2025 would you have an Instagram account for your business but make it nearly impossible for customers to see YOUR ADDRESS? It’s a BRICK AND MORTAR establishment. Just dumb.
I figured based on the reviews that it would be a great place to check out. However, their garlic knots were really soggy and their pizza was not that good. Definitely disappointed.
Found them on Instagram but it’s nearly impossible to find their location on their BUSINESS ACCOUNT. Why on earth in 2025 would you have an Instagram account for your business but make it nearly impossible for customers to see YOUR ADDRESS? It’s a BRICK AND MORTAR establishment. Just dumb.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
Billie's 1890 Saloon
Hana
McDonald's
Midori Sushi & Steakhouse
Dunkin'
Domino's
Wild Feast
RUVO
Inferno's Grill
JR's Steakhouse (Historical)
Gallery
No photos available
Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places
About Gourmet Pizza
How to get there
41 Broadway, Rocky Point, NY 11778
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
41 Broadway, Rocky Point, NY 11778
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Gourmet Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at Gourmet Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Gourmet Pizza
🏆 Rewards at Gourmet Pizza
10% Discount
At Gourmet Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu