Brother's Pizza
Pizza · San Juan
About Brother's Pizza
Brother's Pizza in San Juan is a local favorite, serving up delicious pizza with fast and friendly service. We're proud to have earned a 4.5-star rating from over 1200 reviews, reflecting our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Enjoy our pizza your way with options for dine-in, takeout,...
Brother's Pizza in San Juan is a local favorite, serving up delicious pizza with fast and friendly service. We're proud to have earned a 4.5-star rating from over 1200 reviews, reflecting our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Enjoy our pizza your way with options for dine-in, takeout, delivery, curbside pickup, and even no-contact delivery. We also offer outdoor seating and a wheelchair accessible entrance. Open daily from 11 AM to 9 PM, we're ready to welcome you for lunch, dinner, or a solo treat.
What Customers Say About Brother's Pizza
Brother's Pizza in San Juan is a local favorite known for its delicious pizza and friendly service. Customers rave about the quality toppings and well-cooked crust. While some find the prices a bit high and crust sometimes not crispy enough, the overall experience is highly positive.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Use the app for convenient ordering and to save your favorite orders for easy reordering.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Brother's Pizza
Brother's Pizza San Juan Reviews
Great pizza! Quality toppings. I wanted to try a local place. The pizza was hot and fresh. The crust was crispy on the bottom, but not dried out. While all of the toppings were good, the sausage stood out especially. It was awesome!
This is our go place for pizza and Subs, wraps, dinners, salads and much more. Located in Publix shopping center. Always greeted cheerfully upon entering the place, booths on one side and several tables on the other side of restaurant. They do a tremendous carry out business, always busy. The star of the menu is their pizza, it is just delicious with ample fresh toppings and loads of cheese. We always order ours well done and we are always pleased. They are big pizzas and a medium size is big enough for 2 people and some for breakfast the next day. We love their Caesar salad and order a small size, big enough for 2 people to share and it’s a big plate of it. The dressing is darn good. Prices are very reasonable in my opinion, you get your money’s worth. The help working are always very polite and sweet. You get in and out in a timely fashion. Try this place, it’s loved by all the locals, I’d call that a cult following, that includes me!! Debbie 🍕
I want to leave a fair and kind review, and I do recommend visiting this restaurant. Overall we had a great dinning experience. We were waited on promptly, our server was friendly and attentive and our orders were served timely. We absolutely loved the garlic Parmesan chicken wings, the best I’ve had at a pizza place, they were perfectly seasoned and cooked. I also ordered the calzone, it also was delicious and baked to perfection. What were we disappointed with? It was the cheese pizza, it was over cooked. The cheese was actually burnt. Reading previous reviews, it seems that this is a valid complaint. If you are a pizza restaurant, you should be able to cook a delicious perfect cheese pizza. Not sure what the issue is, not enough cheese, so the thin layer of cheese is cooking too quickly before the crust has time to cook, or the oven needs calibrating. It’s a shame, because it is a nice neighborhood restaurant. The inside is cute but could use some modern updating (a-lot of nick-nacks dates the restaurant). We will defiantly dine in again and try some other food items on menu.
We visited Brother's Pizza for the first time and had lunch. I had the veggie pizza. It had a delicious white sauce. My husband had the meat pizza. We really enjoyed their pizza. Great flavor and the crust was cooked perfectly! The service was great too. We will definitely visit again.
I got the Farmer’s Market pizza and it’s deliciously packed with toppings! I like the texture of the pizza! Eating on other pizzas feels like I’m tugging on carpet when this is so easy to chew. Restaurant was also very clean. Will be back for sure. A+
Great pizza! Quality toppings. I wanted to try a local place. The pizza was hot and fresh. The crust was crispy on the bottom, but not dried out. While all of the toppings were good, the sausage stood out especially. It was awesome!
This is our go place for pizza and Subs, wraps, dinners, salads and much more. Located in Publix shopping center. Always greeted cheerfully upon entering the place, booths on one side and several tables on the other side of restaurant. They do a tremendous carry out business, always busy. The star of the menu is their pizza, it is just delicious with ample fresh toppings and loads of cheese. We always order ours well done and we are always pleased. They are big pizzas and a medium size is big enough for 2 people and some for breakfast the next day. We love their Caesar salad and order a small size, big enough for 2 people to share and it’s a big plate of it. The dressing is darn good. Prices are very reasonable in my opinion, you get your money’s worth. The help working are always very polite and sweet. You get in and out in a timely fashion. Try this place, it’s loved by all the locals, I’d call that a cult following, that includes me!! Debbie 🍕
I want to leave a fair and kind review, and I do recommend visiting this restaurant. Overall we had a great dinning experience. We were waited on promptly, our server was friendly and attentive and our orders were served timely. We absolutely loved the garlic Parmesan chicken wings, the best I’ve had at a pizza place, they were perfectly seasoned and cooked. I also ordered the calzone, it also was delicious and baked to perfection. What were we disappointed with? It was the cheese pizza, it was over cooked. The cheese was actually burnt. Reading previous reviews, it seems that this is a valid complaint. If you are a pizza restaurant, you should be able to cook a delicious perfect cheese pizza. Not sure what the issue is, not enough cheese, so the thin layer of cheese is cooking too quickly before the crust has time to cook, or the oven needs calibrating. It’s a shame, because it is a nice neighborhood restaurant. The inside is cute but could use some modern updating (a-lot of nick-nacks dates the restaurant). We will defiantly dine in again and try some other food items on menu.
We visited Brother's Pizza for the first time and had lunch. I had the veggie pizza. It had a delicious white sauce. My husband had the meat pizza. We really enjoyed their pizza. Great flavor and the crust was cooked perfectly! The service was great too. We will definitely visit again.
As always, I have found my Italian place to eat. Loved the pizza tonight but still partial with the spaghetti and meatballs. Will go back soon for another fix
Stopped for dinner. Ordered mozzarella sticks and a pepperoni stromboli. Mozz. sticks were the nice big round sticks. Cooked just right! No over or under cooking. Now, the stromboli. By far the best stromboli I've had in years. The dough was flavorful and crispy. The balance of cheese and pepperoni!! On point!!
While an inconvenience for this business, brought order out to me in vehicle as walking w/two canes make for a difficult time to carry a FABULOUS pizza it's appreciated very much. Great extra help for a great product makes the entire transaction pleasant! See you again.
Really good, local pizza. All the toppings are always delicious with a great crust as well. The crust is a little floppy but still good. Every appetizer we've tried has been excellent as well.
Hands down New England , CT, NY style pizza ! Super fresh taste , crispy airy crust I can’t say enough good things about the pizza , garlic knots and fried mushrooms! Everything is delicious!!!
If you are looking for excellent pizza this is the place to go. The pizza here is delicious, fresh and you can tell they use quality ingredients. This is as close to NY pizza that I have found in this area. And they have pizza by the slice as well. Highly recommend!
Literally one of the best places in the area to eat...all the food I have tried there is exceptional. On top of that the service is top notch as well.
Stopped for dinner. Ordered mozzarella sticks and a pepperoni stromboli. Mozz. sticks were the nice big round sticks. Cooked just right! No over or under cooking. Now, the stromboli. By far the best stromboli I've had in years. The dough was flavorful and crispy. The balance of cheese and pepperoni!! On point!!
While an inconvenience for this business, brought order out to me in vehicle as walking w/two canes make for a difficult time to carry a FABULOUS pizza it's appreciated very much. Great extra help for a great product makes the entire transaction pleasant! See you again.
As always, I have found my Italian place to eat. Loved the pizza tonight but still partial with the spaghetti and meatballs. Will go back soon for another fix
Literally the best pizza I've had in a long long time. The cheese was completely melted and if I could eat it over and over again for the next week I would lol. Thank you! Seriously made with love!
Really good, local pizza. All the toppings are always delicious with a great crust as well. The crust is a little floppy but still good. Every appetizer we've tried has been excellent as well.
I got there to pick up my two pizzas and they had missed the second one on the order. So only one was ready. But they put the other one right in the oven and it was done in just under10 minutes. They were both delicious! Thank you
Can't say enough about our order last night. Large means large lol. I ordered well ahead. I was texted when it was ready right on time and a great atmosphere inside. Lived here ten years and this was the first time I used you 🤦♀️ It won't be the last time! I operate short term rental and will be recommending to all guests for sure. Thanks we will be back to have a sit down meal soon.
It's the best pizza in town, my favorite is their farmer's market specialty pizza. But I'm not a fan of black olives so I always omit those and add garlic. I can certainly vouch for their calzones as well. The app makes ordering really convenient and saves what I order so I can just open it and reorder.
Brother’s Pizza is our “go to” spot for pizza in Citrus County. Today’s order was good, but just a little “off” versus all our other orders…we ordered “well done” and it’s usually more crispy than today was. Quality of food was still great & it won’t stop us from going back
Stopped in for lunch. Started with knots, side salad the had the large house special pizza. Food was good, suggest salads be served in a bowl. Also pizza was missing garlic, if it had included this item the pizza would be top shelf.
The food and service here are GREAT, but, the temperature inside is NOT very warm when it is cold outside! Sometimes when it is warm outside it is still VERY cold inside. The employees cannot adjust the temperature as it is controlled by an app thru the owner. Even the employees are freezing!! The owner needs to address this problem as it is a contiually ongoing thing. We go there weekly and can't enjoy our meals when it is this extreme.
Really liked the Pizza. Crust crispy got extra cheese not sure i needed it but it was favorable. Probably one of the best ive had here. 1 thing is the price its a bit high at almost $35 for a large meat lovers. Also it is very good i just wish the bottom crust was a bit more crispy but thats me. But over all it waa very good. Will go back.
Really liked the Pizza. Crust crispy got extra cheese not sure i needed it but it was favorable. Probably one of the best ive had here. 1 thing is the price its a bit high at almost $35 for a large meat lovers. Also it is very good i just wish the bottom crust was a bit more crispy but thats me. But over all it waa very good. Will go back.
I ordered a meatball Parm sub. This is what I got. A meatball Parm hero as long as I can remember growing up in NYC was prepared as follows... Meatballs and sauce are placed on hero bread , generously covered with mozzarella cheese and placed in an oven to melt the cheese and toast the bread . Simple. Right?
I ordered a meatball Parm sub. This is what I got. A meatball Parm hero as long as I can remember growing up in NYC was prepared as follows... Meatballs and sauce are placed on hero bread , generously covered with mozzarella cheese and placed in an oven to melt the cheese and toast the bread . Simple. Right?
Not sure where all the 5 star reviews come from for the pizza. I found the cheese pizza terrible. I was VERY disappointed. If I’m spending my calories eating a pizza treat I would like it to both look AND taste good. If I’m spending money on a pizza or any food from a restaurant, I would like it to be worth what I paid for. There was so little cheese on my cheese pizza I could use a toothpick to lift it. The crust looked just like the ones you buy at the grocery store to heat up/bake at home.
Not sure where all the 5 star reviews come from for the pizza. I found the cheese pizza terrible. I was VERY disappointed. If I’m spending my calories eating a pizza treat I would like it to both look AND taste good. If I’m spending money on a pizza or any food from a restaurant, I would like it to be worth what I paid for. There was so little cheese on my cheese pizza I could use a toothpick to lift it. The crust looked just like the ones you buy at the grocery store to heat up/bake at home.
The prices keep going up. 6” Meatball sub should not be almost $10. When the bread is super dry , stale, almost like crouton bread. And the sauce was thicker than tomato paste with little black flakes that taste like char from the grill. Gone down hill over the last year.
Sadley not what they used to be! On 10/05 they only had one server, she was way over worked. So wait for order was longer and only one drink refills. Table that sat behind us could tell was regulars, came in after us had there order taken before ours, we were just sitting there, then to round it out, when I went to pay, I didn't catch that the server didn't charge us for a drink when she brought us the bill for our lunch, so after she got my card she thought it was ok to just add it, then run my card. Don't get me wrong, I am happy to pay what I owe, just surprised to get my card back with being charged a different amount then what I was asked to pay, she left bothe bills under my card so at least i could figure out what happend. All she had to do was alert me to the billing error when she came back with the card, but she just set it down and walked way for me to see. I keep both of the receipt, if I find them I'll post them later. Love there food, always been on point. Has been for over 10 years, not that I eat here often, but have a few times when I am in the area! But dont overlook how I get treated!
The prices keep going up. 6” Meatball sub should not be almost $10. When the bread is super dry , stale, almost like crouton bread. And the sauce was thicker than tomato paste with little black flakes that taste like char from the grill. Gone down hill over the last year.
Sadley not what they used to be! On 10/05 they only had one server, she was way over worked. So wait for order was longer and only one drink refills. Table that sat behind us could tell was regulars, came in after us had there order taken before ours, we were just sitting there, then to round it out, when I went to pay, I didn't catch that the server didn't charge us for a drink when she brought us the bill for our lunch, so after she got my card she thought it was ok to just add it, then run my card. Don't get me wrong, I am happy to pay what I owe, just surprised to get my card back with being charged a different amount then what I was asked to pay, she left bothe bills under my card so at least i could figure out what happend. All she had to do was alert me to the billing error when she came back with the card, but she just set it down and walked way for me to see. I keep both of the receipt, if I find them I'll post them later. Love there food, always been on point. Has been for over 10 years, not that I eat here often, but have a few times when I am in the area! But dont overlook how I get treated!
Update 1/23/2026: Haven't visited in 5 months, stopped in for a large pie with 3 toppings and house salad. Bill was $44 before tip. Insane... Great pizza still but they priced themselves out of customers. Friday nights they used to be packed with takeout orders constantly in and out. No more, 80% if the place was empty and only saw 2 takeout orders while we dined Older update: Something happened in the last few weeks, menu changed, portions smaller and taste different. Pizza still good though
I wanted to try this place since it seemed like the reviews were good. Very disappointed. The chicken wings were hard and dry like they had been sitting out all day. They definitely were not fresh. The fries were terrible. The pizza wasn't any better, greasy and the pepperoni was spicy! The only good thing was the salad. So definitely not worth the money we spent.
I wanted to try this place since it seemed like the reviews were good. Very disappointed. The chicken wings were hard and dry like they had been sitting out all day. They definitely were not fresh. The fries were terrible. The pizza wasn't any better, greasy and the pepperoni was spicy! The only good thing was the salad. So definitely not worth the money we spent.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
The Polo Pony
Kluck Chicken Restaurant
Domino's
Stirrups at World Equestrian Center
Wendy's
Whispering Oaks Winery
IHOP
Market Kitchen & Bar
Burger King
Zaxby's
2 Photos
Explore Brother's Pizza's photos
About Brother's Pizza
How to get there
6746 W Gulf to Lake Hwy, Crystal River, FL 34429
San Juan, FL 34429
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Brother's Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at Brother's Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Brother's Pizza
🏆 Rewards at Brother's Pizza
10% Discount
At Brother's Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu