The Pizza Pit
Pizza · Sloatsburg
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About The Pizza Pit
The Pizza Pit is a Pizza restaurant in Sloatsburg, NY. Rated 4.2 out of 5 by guests. Discover the menu, photos, and reviews.
What Customers Say About The Pizza Pit
The Pizza Pit is a popular spot known for its great pizza and friendly service. Customers rave about the cheese pizza, buffalo chicken sub, and fresh ingredients. Some note slightly higher prices and occasional inconsistencies in service speed.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: The location can be a little hard to find, so make sure you don’t miss it. Also, be sure to check out the cool photos on the wall while you wait.
Features
Frequently asked questions about The Pizza Pit
The Pizza Pit Sloatsburg Reviews
We stopped into the pizza pit to grab a couple of slices our way up to the park. The Best pizza In the surrounding area. Thin and crispy Made with quality products you can taste the difference. We enjoyed it so much that after our hike, we bought Whole pie to take home as we passed there again.
This is the best cheese pizza (I got some extra cheese added) in Rockland county!
I stopped by the Pizza Pit on Monday around 6, and the young man/teen working there was very nice and friendly. We had a great chat about Latin music while I waited for my order really made the visit enjoyable! Great service and good vibes.
The Pizza Pit in Sloatsburg, NY never disappoints. Their pizza is always amazing, fresh, tasty, and made just right every time. You can tell they care about quality, and the flavors really hit the spot. Whether I’m grabbing a quick slice or ordering a whole pie, it’s consistently great. Definitely one of the best pizza spots in the area. Friendly service and a solid local vibe make it even better!
Great pizza, and friendly workers, me N wifey ordered the cheese steak pizza, and cheese steak fries 👍👍 our second time here, food is always good, and yes prices have gone up slightly...but so has everything else in the country 🤷🤷 no biggy, it's worth it. This is our pizza place of choice when we come from the city to hike the nearby mountain trails.
It didn't look good when I ordered a large pie with sautéd onions, and they asked me 'what are sautéd onions?' Surprisingly though, the pizza was pretty good. The sauce has a nice 'sweet' taste to it, it's thin and not doughy, and they actually make it 'well-done' when you ask, unlike every other pizza place on earth. Do NOT get the wings though. They are $18 for a dozen, and they are the WORST wings I've ever had. They must broil them in the oven - they definitely were not fried. Very rubbery and NO bbq sauce whatsoever on them. Stay clear of those, trust me. But I actually liked the pizza, even though that's way too expensive for what it is too. It's a little pizza shop in Sloatsburg, not Manhattan!
Pizza was good. Nice crunch to the crust and a good cheese blend. Wings…well the initial $18 hit for a dozen is on the high end, but when they came out they were sizable so I guess inflation, right? However, salty is not even the word. I muscled through 5 wings and could not finish. It got to the point of inedible. (I am not an anti-salt guy either.) I was disappointed because they looked great. I asked the person at the counter if they are brining them, etc to explain to salt content, but the individual said no. I would go back for the pizza, but would be apprehensive about anything else due to seasoning. I thought by returning more than half of my order would result in more than a sorry, but….
I asked for a plain pizza with fresh garlic and fresh Basil. When a pizza is cooked with fresh garlic you smell the cooked garlic aroma in the air. Eventually it didn't have fresh garlic and no fresh Basil. They put pesto over it. Pizza was good but because there was no fresh garlic and basil. I give this place a two star.
It’s expensive but at least its not good. Plaij slice has absolutely no flavor. Avoid.
My pizzas came out 20 minutes apart from each other. They didn't even cook my 2 pizzas at the same time. I was the only person in there when I came in and placed the order. Their pre-made slices looked great. The two pizzas I ordered from them looked like they were told to skimp on toppings. Barely any cheese on their white pizza (which is literally white sauce and cheese). I felt mostly like I was eating dough. The sausage/ pepperoni pizza also barely had cheese on it. I'm disappointed in the price I paid ($50 for 2 large pizzas, one cheese and one 2 topping) for the amount of ingredients actually put on top of the dough. When I called after I got home, they didn't seem to care or offer a replacement. I won't be returning.
I saw the Kiss sign out front and thought it was the greatest thing I ever saw. I wasn't even all that hungry, but I pulled a u-turn and went back for a slice and a soda. I walked up to the counter and some old guy and a young woman were talking to each other in Spanish. I stood at the counter. They continued talking. I stood there. He pulled out a calculator and started punching in numbers and showing her the readout on the calculator. I stood there, waiting to order. They didn't look up. Three minutes passed. They showed absolutely no interest in serving me. I turned around and walked out. I will never support a business that disrespects its customers. You shouldn't either. Rank amateurs.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Dunkin'
Curleys Corner
Four Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria
Panera Bread
Doc's Pizza & Steak
Monsey BBQ
Domino's
Chick-fil-A
Taqueria America
Nonna's Pizza
22 Photos
Explore The Pizza Pit's photos
About The Pizza Pit
How to get there
57 Orange Turnpike, Sloatsburg, NY 10974
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
57 Orange Turnpike, Sloatsburg, NY 10974
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at The Pizza Pit and other restaurants
Earn Points at The Pizza Pit!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at The Pizza Pit
🏆 Rewards at The Pizza Pit
10% Discount
At The Pizza Pit
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu