Best American Restaurants in Staten Island — Page 2

4.3 avg. rating 25 restaurants 22,858 reviews
Looking for the best American restaurants in Staten Island? Browse our curated list of 25 top-rated American spots. The average rating is 4.3/5 based on 22,858 real Google reviews. From casual eateries to fine dining, find the perfect American restaurant for any occasion.

What people say

Giovanni

Ever since I moved to New York, I’ve been recommended to try this place. For my birthday, we decided to go there, and it was an absolutely fantastic experience. Of course, you need to make reservations, so plan accordingly. Prices are obviously New York-style, so be prepared for a bit of a splurge....

About Blue

Maryna Sulyma

Very nice restaurant with a pretty good choice of dishes. We ordered fresh oysters, some appetizers and side dishes, plus drinks. Though we ordered half a dozen of oysters, the platters of one dozen came, which was not so bad. The only disappointment was the plate with two super small octopus tentac...

About Blue

Nate D

WOW. AMAZING. My partner and I are visiting from Ohio for Mother’s Day weekend and we decided to go to Blue to celebrate. This was our first experience and oh my gosh.. I’m so impressed!! The food, service, views, ambiance were ALL on point. I absolutely cannot wait to return! Thank you so much for...

About Blue

Lauren Rosenfeld

We went last week to celebrate our anniversary and was not disappointed! The food was delicious and the service was great. The weekday/night prix fixe menu was a fabulous bargain- portions were generous! Beautiful sunset views! We will most definitely be back!

About Blue

Shawn G

Came here for birthday celebration and ordered the surf and turf for 2. Absolutely delicious. Also got the lamb chops for appetizers done medium and it was extremely flavorful. Frozen martini was also delicious. Would definitely come back again.

About Blue