Best Mexican Restaurants in Staten Island — Page 2

4.2 avg. rating 36 restaurants 10,594 reviews
Looking for the best Mexican restaurants in Staten Island? Browse our curated list of 36 top-rated Mexican spots. The average rating is 4.2/5 based on 10,594 real Google reviews. From casual eateries to fine dining, find the perfect Mexican restaurant for any occasion.

What people say

Lou-Anne Barbaro

Very cozy! Wonderful service! Delicious food! We had the Mexican street corn, tacos and fajitas! Great Margaritas! Mexican coffee was the best!

About Cantina Mexicana

wthomas415

Cantina Mexicana is one of those places you end up craving after your first visit. The owners, Maria and Alphonso, clearly care about every detail—from the food to the atmosphere—and it shows. The chicken chipotle is unreal. It’s my go-to order and I honestly get it all the time because nothing els...

About Cantina Mexicana

Yoyou

We ordered the steak and blackened chicken fajitas. The sangria was well made. The staff, owners were very accommodating, gracious and friendly. This was our 1st visit and it won't be our last. We can't wait to dine there again!

About Cantina Mexicana

David Wallman

Delicious local Mexican food! Sometimes when I visit my fiancé’s family in SI we will come here for lunch and it never disappoints! Today we went with guac to start and then tacos. They refilled our chips multiple times for no charge! The Pina el pastor and el ranchero tacos were delicious and we’d...

About Cantina Mexicana

Albert Aydin

Service and food here were excellent. The guacamole was fantastic and tasted fresh. The tacos didn't fall apart and they had wonderful combinations of flavors for each taco option. This is definitely my new go-to spot on Staten Island.

About Cantina Mexicana