Bagels Bread & Butter
Bagel · Staten Island
About Bagels Bread & Butter
Bagels Bread & Butter is a Bagel shop restaurant in Staten Island, NY. Rated 4.2 out of 5 by guests. Discover the menu, photos, and reviews.
What Customers Say About Bagels Bread & Butter
Bagels Bread & Butter is a popular spot known for its fresh bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and coffee. Customers consistently praise the friendly and efficient staff, especially Harris, Alex, and Abl. Some negative reviews mention order inaccuracies and inconsistent service.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Go in the morning or early afternoon for the best experience and consistent quality.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Bagels Bread & Butter
Bagels Bread & Butter is located in Staten Island, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- Calvary Presbyterian Church (A 668m) — church building in New York, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
Religious Buildings
- Sacred Heart Church (A 682m) — church building in New York, United States of America
Parks & Gardens
- Prall Playground (A 394m) — park in the United States of America
- Barrett Park (A 504m) — park in the United States of America
- Public School 45 Playground (A 518m) — park in the United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Bagels Bread & Butter
Bagels Bread & Butter Staten Island Reviews
Great food and service.. Highly recommended!
Great people, great service, great food!
Very nice people! Quick service and the sandwiches and bagels are AMAZING!! Love this place!!
I come in here weekly for their bagels since they are the best I could find on this island and I've visited almost every bagel place out here :) The bagels are big & fluffy and oh so good. The girls that work the register are always nice and the guys behind the grill are always on it and will go above & beyond! I hope they never stop making bagels! I could use some more minis sometimes tho :)
Best bec spot. Bagel cc they give you a good amount. Not like other expensive places. Variety of foods. The coffe taste amazing. Good friendly staff. Really fast paced. But really quick on getting your order.
Beautiful people work in this establishment. I seldom eat here. But when I do their food is fresh. I mostly just go to play the lottery games. Very convenient, clean, and good service. 👍
I’d like to wish everyone at 3 B’s a wonderful holiday . I start my morning with their amazing HOT coffee everyday. The bagels and flagaels are spot on with my favorite scallion cream cheese as well as so many other varieties to choose from. The store is clean and well stocked with groceries as well as always decorated for all of the holidays making it a very inviting atmosphere. I especially look forward to the latest door painting for each holiday/season . The owner takes great pride in his establishment. The staff knows most customers by name and their usual orders . Always a pleasant chit chat with the owner and the young ladies at the register . If anyone is looking for great bagels, breakfast , coffee and catering , look no further than 3 B’s. The owner keeps his store immaculately clean which is a priority for me as well as being there all the time dedicating himself to his customers and his business. Brick and mortar businesses are key within our neighborhood! Thank you to everyone at 3’s for their consistency and great food ! Happy Holidays!
This has become my go-to place for Bagels. The staff is awesome. Coffee is good. Bagels are made on the premises (true NY style). Lots of convenience store options. I've only gone here in the morning or early afternoon so that's my experience. They're very consistent. I really appreciate them
Outstanding! Absolutely outstanding. This place is truly worthy of the 5-Stars. Magnificent food. Sandwiches are phenomenal. Shout out to Harris, Alex, Abl and the rest of the staff. The special bagels they make, like the Galaxy, Bacon Cheddar, and Oreo are all amazing. Cragels are another serious awesome creation. You guys all do a wonderful job in upkeeping the place as well. Keep up the great work. You guys are truly deserving of the 5-Stars. Highly recommend this place. Their catering menu is also a great thing to check out.
Four stars because I just wish this lot would get rid of all this money beggars. They hang out in front and come in the store. The. You lose one and you gain another. They harass the customers to no end. Where is the landlord of this property??
This place is good but this place has alot of the time messed up my orders from not toasting it when i ask it toasted or completely forgetting lettuce or even mayo and u can explain it to them twice what i have before and they have still messed up but i still would recommend this place just be sure to speak clearly of what u want
I usually go for the penne parmesan pasta , it is absolutely delicious. Friendly lovely girls in the front. Their muffins are good too—there was a long strand of hair in mine and I haven’t went back since. They are usually clean and I know things happens but I need to heal first before I can go back.
The guy working the deli at night is DISGUSTINGLY disrespectful, arrogant, and rude. THREE times i went to this place and he always tries to make comments about customers to make his little cashier friend laugh but tonight was the last try for sure. Whoever owns this place really needs to teach their whole night time staff how to treat the customers.
I ordered my sandwich and I was changing my mind mind about the role and the deli person told me no I cannot change my mind. He already cut the role all I asked for egg and sausage on a roll that he versus the egg never even asked me if I wanted an egg cracked. he explained that’s how it is you take what I give you poor customer service it is ridiculous. It’s not the first time that happened to happen many times before.
Foods great, the service is disgusting, prices are outrageous for people that don’t pay attention to your order. You ask them what you want they give you whatever they feel like. I don’t know how many times they’ve got my order wrong
I've given this place plenty of chances. I used to go here for the selection of flavored coffee, but no matter what time I go in they are always out or low. I order simple sandwiches like a bacon or sausage, egg and cheese on a roll or a bagel and they ALWAYS get it wrong. On top of that they either barely pay attention to you or give you an attitude like you are bothering them. The two young ladies at the register are always on their phone and act like you don't exist unless you directly engage them, no matter how busy it is. Once they do help you they are pretty polite, but still. There is no communication between them and the cooks so they have to open up sandwiches just to see what they are. Don't go here, unless you are fine with an overpriced order that is wrong and comes free with a side of attitude or a blatant apathy to paying customers.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
La Rosa Chicken & Grill
Doc Hennigan's Tavern
Gyro King
Forest BBQ
China Bell
New Island Garden
G's Cheesesteaks
Beans & Leaves
Wonder
Forest Bagels
11 Photos
Explore Bagels Bread & Butter's photos
About Bagels Bread & Butter
How to get there
732 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
732 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Upcoming Events
Staten Island FerryHawks vs. Lancaster Stormers
19 May 2026, 10:30
SIUH Community Park
Staten Island FerryHawks vs. Lancaster Stormers
20 May 2026, 18:30
SIUH Community Park
The Art of Circus
21 May 2026, 13:00
St. George Theatre
Staten Island FerryHawks vs. Lancaster Stormers
21 May 2026, 18:30
SIUH Community Park
park in the United States of America
park in the United States of America
park in the United States of America
church building in New York, United States of America
church building in New York, United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Bagels Bread & Butter and other restaurants
Earn Points at Bagels Bread & Butter!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Bagels Bread & Butter
🏆 Rewards at Bagels Bread & Butter
10% Discount
At Bagels Bread & Butter
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu