Brother's Pizza
Pizza · Staten Island
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About Brother's Pizza
En Brother's Pizza, traemos un pedacito de Sicilia a Staten Island con nuestras irresistibles pizzas cuadradas, famosas entre los locales. Además de nuestras especialidades sicilianas, también preparamos deliciosas pizzas de masa fina para todos los gustos. Con una valoración de 4.4/5, te invitamos...
En Brother's Pizza, traemos un pedacito de Sicilia a Staten Island con nuestras irresistibles pizzas cuadradas, famosas entre los locales. Además de nuestras especialidades sicilianas, también preparamos deliciosas pizzas de masa fina para todos los gustos. Con una valoración de 4.4/5, te invitamos a descubrir por qué somos un clásico de la pizza.
What Customers Say About Brother's Pizza
Brother's Pizza is a Staten Island favorite, known for its fresh, high-quality pizza and friendly service. The Sicilian and Margherita pizzas are highly praised. The ambiance evokes a Little Italy feel, making it a great spot for locals and visitors alike.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: The Sicilian and Margherita slices are highly recommended. Be aware that the pizza can sometimes be oily.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Brother's Pizza
Brother's Pizza is located in Staten Island, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Religious Buildings
- St. Roch's Church (A 357m) — church building in New York, United States of America
- St. Adalbert's Church (A 563m) — church building in New York, United States of America
Parks & Gardens
- Egbert Triangle (A 119m) — park in the United States of America
- Markham Playground (A 274m) — park in the United States of America
- Northerleigh Park (A 867m) — park in Richmond County, New York, United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Brother's Pizza
Brother's Pizza Staten Island Reviews
I confess. I can't tell if I'm more addicted to the pizza, or to Riley! No, really. I didn't care for squares. However, I'd promised myself I'd try all the pizza places on SI that people tout. And, I'd tried the rest...And, I liked or loved the rest... But, the first night I tried Brothers, it begat two more nights in the same weekend. It's become my naughty go-to, and the place I often grab pizzas to bring with me to friends, afar. I really try to restrain myself and it doesn't often work. I'm so in love that when I go in, I just get whatever's still warm. I love it all: plain sicilian, upside down, gramma, or even a plain slice! The staff is RIDICULOUS! They are not only crazy friendly, they're ON IT. I have a huge soft spot for my three guys--Riley, Will and VG--but you cannot go wrong with staff here. They put general hospitality to shame! It's such a shame that they're close enough that I might start walking there if it ever stops snowing.
Classic spot for pizza cash only but they have an atm on premises. Same family owned buisness. Its all great if ya know ya know...Pan slice is a fav.
Walk in for a fresh square pie well done. This place is the Best! From a great slice, sauce to owners and staff friendly happy helpful . Thank you
Some of the best pizza we’ve ever had. The restaurant was clean and service was fast! Would highly recommend!
I love their pizza, but today 12/20 my pie was a little burnt
Great pizza. So-so ravioli. Service was great and friendly. Place has the right atmosphere, restaurant and bar area. No nonsense pizza pub/tavern. I'd your travels bring you near the Verrazano, stop by for a treat.
my daughter goes to Wagner College so we stopped over and had some brothers pizza a white pizza with ricotta and a regular plain absolutely fantastic. The people were great. The food was unbelievable hot fresh. They brought it right to the table. Keep doing a great job. do you deliver to Staten Island to Wagner College? If so, let me know and I'll tell my daughter and I'm sure a lot of friends will order. Thanks again. Keep up the
Iv never been to NY so I wanted the pizza for sure. A friend local to the area brought me here and i was not dissapointed
OK Tough Guy – Stop claiming to be from New York City. Everyone knows you’re from Milford, Pennsylvania or Fishkill, New York – Please spare us the lies and stolen valor. Bronx born, Long Island raised, Toured the Means Streets of Every Borough in this City – Battling the Demons in countless Emergency Rooms across the great city of New York – And, yes – I lived in Queens throughout my tenure which traumatized me. No Psychiatrist could calm be down; The only thing I could find to relax me is a good slice and an ice cold Mexican Coca Cola; - I’ve had them all, across Queens, Manhattan, Brooklyn, the Bronx and in the current decade – G-d has brought me to Staten Island. If you are still reading this, I guess you have figured it out, sizzle chest, this Fat Hebrew boy knows what he’s talking about. Brother’s Pizza in Staten Island quite possible may be the best and finest Pizza on the planet. Take a Prozac New Haven – yeah, you guys are amazing – But, you haven’t tried the Sicilian slices at Brother’s Pizza in the enchanted and forgotten world of Staten Italy, I mean Staten Island. Confession, please don’t have me wacked for saying this, the regular Napolitano slice is off the chart too. Why is Brother’s Pizza so incredible? Does this Pizzeria sit upon ground containing magical water, pumped from the sacred ground making the most incredible and delicious pizza dough? Is it the “Love” and “Skill” of Filippo Giove and his Colorful and Friendly band of Loyal Meshugganahs Pizza Boys who pull each and every one of their culinary masterpieces out of the oven. Let’s cut to the chase, Pizza is exceptional and made from the finest ingredients. Every visit to Brother’s Pizza, you will get service with a smile and perfection. Don’t be a putz, make the shlep to Staten Island – Yes, they have Parking. I suspect you may find some of the best pizza, particularly the Sicilian, on the planet earth. Don’t forget to show Love and Respect to the G-dfather, Filippo – He’s just a regular, run of the mill Mensch. L’Chayim / Salute
Service was friendly and quick. While I utilized pick up, the restaurant was clean and well maintained. Patrons looked happy as they enjoyed their meals Food was excellent. One of my all time favorites!
Delicious! The pepperoni pinwheels were the best thing I’ve ever eaten! The staff were also super friendly and we loved everything we ate! Best pizza place in the city! (Do be mindful, it is cash only!)
Oily pizza but tbh it's so good that I didn't care because I was hungry. I added the usual grated cheese and it was perfect, very cheesy in itself and piping hot!
Great NY pizza parlors NEVER provide atmosphere. The pizza was 5 stars all the way. The crust has a delicious flavor. I ordered extra cheese & got EXTRA. That is not the norm in a lot of pizzeria take out places. The staff was very attentive, did their best not to keep anyone waiting, and they were busy. I highly recommend the pie, and I'm anxious to order other menu items. READ, PLEASE? Do not listen to poor reviews for Brother's Pizzeria. Any business fortunate enough to be supported for 4+ decades is doing it the right way. Good ingredients, caring staff, that is a recipe for success. Every pizzeria has an "off" night. The orders come in quicker than a computer can spit them out. How can anyone produce HAND MADE FOOD, perfectly & timely every time? Don't expect "fast food" at a great pizza joint, folks. Great pizza takes time & listen up! Humans DO make mistakes. Maybe even YOU!! 😉😉
I used to work in Staten Island 20 years ago (I'm 40). Brothers was the best pizza I had then and still the best. I live in Jersey and we have some good pizza. This place is still top 3 for me.
Miss this place! Such a Wonderful Family owned business. The Pizza Margherita & Calzones were so delicious & Reasonably priced. Hubby & I got to meet Filippo Giove Jr & He was very polite & super chi…
Miss this place! Such a Wonderful Family owned business. The pizza Margherita & Calzones were so delicious & Reasonably priced. Hubby & I got to meet Filippo Giove Jr & He was very polite & super c…
Miss this place! Such a Wonderful Family owned business. The Pizza Margherita & Calzones were so delicious & Reasonably priced. Hubby & I got to meet Filippo Giove Jr & He was very polite & super c…
Miss this place! Such a Wonderful Family owned business. The Pizza margherita & Calzones were so delicious & Reasonably priced. Hubby & I got to meet Filippo Giove Jr & He was very polite & super c…
One of my favorite pizzerias in Staten Island. The food is always fresh and delicious, the pizza is consistently great, and the service is friendly. Whether it's a quick pickup or delivery, it never …
One of my favorite pizzerias in Staten Island. The food is always fresh and delicious, the pizza is consistently great, and the service is friendly. Whether it's a quick pickup or delivery, it ne…
One of my favorite pizzerias in Staten Island. The food is always fresh and delicious, the pizza is consistently great, and the service is friendly. Whether it's a quick pickup or delivery, it neve…
One of my favorite pizzerias in Staten Island. The food is always fresh and delicious, the pizza is consistently great, and the service is friendly. Whether it's a quick pickup or delivery, it neve…
I been going to Brothers pizzeria for years. Its quality pizza made fresh. And if you want to eat in the ambiance is like little Italy. But that's just one person's opinion.
I been going to Brothers pizzeria for years. Its quality pizza made fresh. And if you want to eat in the ambiance is like little Italy. But that's just one person's opinion.
I been going to Brothers pizzeria for years. Its quality pizza made fresh. And if you want to eat in the ambiance is like little Italy. But that's just one person's opinion.
Brothers pizza has the best food also the service is good.. they all have good service to the customers
I have been going to Brothers pizza for decades it's my goto spot for QUALITY authentic old school slices . The Sicilian is their most popular for good reason but the vodka slice and margarita ar…
I Love Brother's I haven't been there in a while but It was great the food,the drinks,and the service !
This is my favorite Pizza spot on the island. The pizza is always nice and fresh, the service is fast and friendly and the ambiance is cool and laid back.
Too expensive but good pizza. We enjoy their pizza. We love the cheese pizza and the vegetable pizza.
OK Touch Guy – Stop claiming to be from New York City. Everyone knows you’re from Milford, Pennsylvania or Fishkill, New York – Please spare us the lies and stolen valor. Bronx born, Long Island rais…
My friend and I both had 2 slices of Margherita Sicilian pizza. It totally blew me away how terrific it was. The sauce was incredible and the mozzarella cheese very tasty. I haven’t had this reaction…
My friend and I both had 2 slices of Margherita Sicilian pizza. It totally blew me away how terrific it was. The sauce was incredible and the mozzarella cheese very tasty. I haven’t had this reac…
My friend and I both had 2 slices of margherita Sicilian pizza. It totally blew me away how terrific it was. The sauce was incredible and the mozzarella cheese very tasty. I haven’t had this reacti…
My friend and I both had 2 slices of Margherita Sicilian pizza. It totally blew me away how terrific it was. The sauce was incredible and the mozzarella cheese very tasty. I haven’t had this reacti…
will I have to say is I can't believe people still don't know how long to keep a sicilian square in the oven for until it's nice hot and crispy and nice cheese that's bubbling. when it was served it was soft lukewarm not nice it could have been a 10 but it was like a 6 the freeway that got the temperature right I told him I wanted it hot it was not hot that's supposed to be brothers pizza man come on the monster had an amateur working on something when I used to go to years ago he had everything on point little slacking now
Walked in here one late weekday to get a grandma slice, and got a slice of thin crust thrown on top free of charge. Not world-shaking quality, but still a simple, great, well-executed pie. I can definitely see this being a place you would love to go on a weekend or to celebrate a birthday. Maybe not worth a trip to Staten Island, but if you’re already there, definitely worth stopping by.
Pizza was OK. I've had better service was wonderful though they get you as soon as you walk in the door ambience is just like any other pizza shop tacky looking.
Pizza was OK. I've had better service was wonderful though they get you as soon as you walk in the door ambience is just like any other pizza shop tacky looking.
I ordered the same thing every time I go and the employees are charging me different prices. This is not the first time this has happened.
Leaving Staten Island, I was still searching for good pizza and ready to find it. We cruised around a while looking for an open place with parking and there was Brother's. It was very tasty. Every…
Leaving Staten Island, I was still searching for good pizza and ready to find it. We cruised around a while looking for an open place with parking and there was Brother's. It was very tasty. Eve…
Leaving Staten Island, I was still searching for good pizza and ready to find it. We cruised around a while looking for an open place with parking and there was Brother's. It was very tasty. Eve…
Pizza was great as always but the garlic knots tasted stale like they were leftover from the day before. The only problem I had was when you claim to be a cash only establishment you should have change in the draw to make change when someone tries to buy food.
Im sorry but i dont like when businesses take advantage of their clients with insane hikes in prices and blame it on the “economy” i just ordered a regular slice and a drink and it came out to $7.50 , rising prices through out the years is understandable but when you’re adding $1 - $1.50 to the hike that’s just abuse , anyone who understands math knows that you don’t raise your price by dollars when prices for supplies go up , 10¢ - 15¢ is understandable but anything more than that ever 8 months is wacky . This goes for every business not just this one . Highly upset while I eat my $8 slice and drink that once was $4.50 , I’ll add that the pizza was the shortest pizza I’ve seen in New York
I ordered a large 1/2 meat lovers and 1/2 pepperoni pizza for carry out. Price went up from last year. No thrill or frills. Service was ok. Place was packed for a Wednesday evening.
Brother’s Pizzeria Est. 1975 Layout/atmosphere *Dining room with tables and a TV (faux villa look, paintings of Italy); cash only; parking lot Food/drink *Sicilian slice - solid; liked the sauce, wasn’t a fan of the crust *White slice - solid; flop; parts of crust overcooked
Had the regular round pie. It's decent. Definitely on the oily side. A little floppy. Taste was good though. Service was excellent. The go to items I'm told are the Sicilian pie and the chicken roll.
I think it just might be me. This place was crowded (with what seemed like a lot of regular customers), and it was too busy to answer phone, and there’s a bunch of testimonials that swear by the pizza here. For me, meh. I ordered two grandma squares and nothing about them was memorable. I did detect the freshness of the tomato sauce, but I have no other praise to offer other than that. Price of $7 was fair. Very spacious dining area. I sat at a table underneath a photo of The Sopranos cast. I didn’t dislike my pizza, but it didn’t impress me either. I wouldn’t go out of my way to come here again, but I do encourage anyone who’s never been here to give it a try and judge for themselves. Because it could just be me.
Ike this place but this time they did me wrong I used to like when they made my pepperoni pi de fresh and with the pepperoni melted thru the cheese but this time they just reheated a regular pie and add it the pepperoni I notice because I ordered it on my way there and thought to buy a feel slices while I weight but.it took me 7 mine to get there and when I got there my pie was weighting for me all ready..they must have a new magic oven or something
The pizza has the cheese sliding off the I’d expect this from a mediocre place but not brothers and I can’t even pull a slice off without the cheese sliding off the pizza because the pizza isn’t pre cut at all incredibly disappointing from a Staten Island pizza lover who goes all over the us for pizza! Not to mention the puddle of oil clearly visible in the photo the pizza is glistening with it 🤮
I don’t know what happened to this pizzeria but I hate cold pizza, service is horrible is as if they just want to hurry up and they are not fulfilling their customers orders with empathy, Brothers you need to pick it up or you will loose it, not coming back.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
Yum Yum Chinese Food
Jersey Mike's Subs
Michaelangelos Pizzeria
Metro Pizzeria & Restaurant
No. 1 Chinese Kitchen
Recuardos Restaurante Mexicanos
O'Neill's Restaurant & Bar
Gino's Pizza
Gyro King
Mandarin House
32 Photos
Explore Brother's Pizza's photos
About Brother's Pizza
How to get there
750 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
750 Port Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10302
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Upcoming Events
Staten Island FerryHawks vs. Southern Maryland Blue Crabs
21 Jul. 2026, 18:30
SIUH Community Park
Staten Island FerryHawks vs. Southern Maryland Blue Crabs
22 Jul. 2026, 10:30
SIUH Community Park
Staten Island FerryHawks vs. Southern Maryland Blue Crabs
23 Jul. 2026, 18:30
SIUH Community Park
Staten Island FerryHawks vs. Southern Maryland Blue Crabs
24 Jul. 2026, 19:00
SIUH Community Park
park in the United States of America
park in the United States of America
church building in New York, United States of America
church building in New York, United States of America
park in Richmond County, New York, United States of America
What people say about Brother's Pizza
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Brother's Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at Brother's Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Brother's Pizza
🏆 Rewards at Brother's Pizza
10% Discount
At Brother's Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu