Supreme Burger

GLENN WATERS

🍔Supreme Burger Company: Burger Perfection in Staten Island! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 As a burger connoisseur, I can confidently say Supreme Burger Company serves the most incredible smashed double cheeseburger in Staten Island! Their signature burger is an absolute masterpiece - crispy edged patties nestled on a perfectly buttery, toasted bun that elevates the entire experience. Each bite delivers a perfect balance of juicy, well-seasoned beef with that classic smash burger crunch. The patties are grilled to perfection, creating those irresistible caramelized edges that burger lovers dream about. The house-made sauce and fresh toppings complete this flavor explosion. The atmosphere is welcoming, the staff is friendly, and the prices are reasonable. For burger enthusiasts seeking the ultimate gourmet experience, Supreme Burger Company is an absolute must-visit destination. Five stars, without a doubt! 🍔👌

Ahmed A

Glad I stumbled on this hidden Gem! Could possibly be the best burger on staten island! Fresh and Juicy! The freshest fry you will ever have! I could actually taste the potatoes. Will be back soon!

CAMI FILMS

Came here because I was craving a burger. Was pleasantly surprised! The burgers were very juicy and blasting with flavor. The nachos and cheese were also very good. Too bad I was too full to finish them lol. If I’m ever in Staten Island again I will be visiting here once more.

Vickie

First trip here. We ordered to go. We were greeted by an very friendly counter person, which was nice 🙂 We ordered two burghers, one was a double loaded the other plain, fries and a shake. Burghers were smashed with onions in the meat. Everything tasted extremely fresh. Inside is small but they do have 4 tables for sitting. There were people sitting and eating. There were board games provided if you wanted to eat and play games. There was also a free arcade machine with tons of games on it. Total was $40, which seems to be a little pricey but definitely in line with today's economy. The food was very good so worth the $, we will def go back. If you have time, read the about me on their website. Very well written and makes you want to try their food!

Aaliyah Jackson

My first time eating and the burger’s just awesome!! The service was excellent and the staff are friendly and attentive, they make sure you are served well. Their food is made fresh and cooked perfectly. The portions are generous and the pricing is affordable and you get good quality food. Definitely worth it!!!!

Ericca Jane Rios Stylist

Supreme Burger in Staten Island is a visual masterpiece. The flawless design elevates the restaurant to a level beyond your typical burger joint. The interior surpasses the aesthetics of many personal spaces lol. As for the dining experience, it was undeniably gluttonous, but every bite made it unforgettable. The menu boasts an array of decadent burgers and milkshakes that not only satisfy your cravings but leave a lasting impression! This Supreme Burger is more than just a place to eat; it’s a tasteful indulgence that sets a new standard for burger establishments. Don’t forget to get the churros!

Maria

The best burger in SI really fresh ingredients, the sauce they use on their burger is amazingggg im pretty sure it’s homemade and the fries are out of this world, perfectly crispy (not a greasy mess) I’ve had them multiple time and it’s always consistent quality definitely suggest eating in!

Giselle Pastuizaca

Amazing Food! Amazing Staff! And overall GREATTT VIBESSS ✨🙏🏼 My family and I had the Miami Burger, Waffle Fries, Teriyaki Wings, Vanilla Shake, and single mash burger and LET ME TELL YOU , The FOOD did NOT DISAPPOINT 😍 So flavorful! Our food was running late but they got right on it once they noticed how late it was. Very kind and attentive servers. 100% Recommend 👏🏼

Ronald Ortiz

Absolutely the best Staten Island burger spot … meat is fresh , ingredients are fresh simply amazing. Would definitely be coming back . I didn’t take a picture before I ate it because it looked so good and Iam glad I ate it because it taste even better 👍

Yudy Diaz

The supreme burger and supreme sauce were delicious, the best fried Oreos I ever had and an amazing service, the guys very attentive and friendly! Family friendly environment.I highly recommend it!10 out of 10.

The staff was professional and friendly, place was cool had a free arcade game , inside and outside seating... the fried pickles, and few smash burgers i ordered were fresh, hot and delicious . My new smash burger spot for sure

Shikha Baishya

I have come here several times and the food is always consistent and so good! They have great options for vegetarians as well. The owner also has exceptional customer service, everyone I’ve interacted with there is so pleasant!

First I just want to say I thought the food was very good. I received the food very quick. The sides were a little soggy but I don’t live super close so I expect that. But what I can’t get over was spending $14 dollars for a burger that size and you don’t even get a side with it. I got the build your own slider double patty with bacon added and when I received it I could not believe how small it was, I added a photo for reference. Besides that I thought everything else was good. I do not know if I will be ordering from there again but overall if you want a very good burger it’s a solid choice but be prepared to spend a lot for not a lot of burger. Ironically enough I though the side portions were ok for the price.

Michael Flaherty

First I just want to say I thought the food was very good. I received the food very quick. The sides were a little soggy but I don’t live super close so I expect that. But what I can’t get over was spending $14 dollars for a burger that size and you don’t even get a side with it. I got the build your own slider double patty with bacon added and when I received it I could not believe how small it was, I added a photo for reference. Besides that I thought everything else was good. I do not know if I will be ordering from there again but overall if you want a very good burger it’s a solid choice but be prepared to spend a lot for not a lot of burger. Ironically enough I though the side portions were ok for the price.

We’ve ordered before the burgers are decent, but definitely not mind blowing. Yesterday I was late home for work so my boyfriend ordered food from here for delivery and asked what I wanted. I ordered the chicken sandwich and boy was that a mistake. Instead of a chicken patty, it was a bunch of burned pieces of chicken? It tasted like a sandwich of burned fried breading. I ate one bite and then threw it away. Don’t waste your money. Photo of said sandwich attached.

Meh. This place needs to change their frying oil, black chicken fingers and soggy. They premixed salad dressing in a salad before delivering, it’s going to be soggy by the time it’s delivered. The chips and nachos had the cheese already on it, again soggy by the time its delivered.

Where to begin? The menu describes the waffle fries as “crispy” and “seasoned”, they definitely hit the mark being crispy, however they lacked in the flavor area. The second picture shows what they believe to be a lettuce wrap.. not too sure how a couple stiff leaves tossed on top of a burger equates to a wrap… The milkshake was probably the biggest disappointment here. What’s typically the highlight where your sweet tooth is fulfilled left much to be desired. The milkshake lacked no milk, with its watery texture and boring flavor. To make matters worse, I had ordered another burger that they failed to properly make. With Staten Island staples like Duffys two doors down supreme burger company definitely needs to step their game up! $40 down the drain on lackluster food, definitely won’t be patronizing them again.

ALWAYS BEEN GOOD until tonight they completely burned the smash burgers all the way through and cost my parents and I 50 dollars for 3 doubles, onion rings, AND a tip completely unacceptable. This is after i told my parents it was a good idea for food as well so it kinda made me look stupid.

Ashley B

We’ve ordered before the burgers are decent, but definitely not mind blowing. Yesterday I was late home for work so my boyfriend ordered food from here for delivery and asked what I wanted. I ordered the chicken sandwich and boy was that a mistake. Instead of a chicken patty, it was a bunch of burned pieces of chicken? It tasted like a sandwich of burned fried breading. I ate one bite and then threw it away. Don’t waste your money. Photo of said sandwich attached.

Jonathan Curtis

Meh. This place needs to change their frying oil, black chicken fingers and soggy. They premixed salad dressing in a salad before delivering, it’s going to be soggy by the time it’s delivered. The chips and nachos had the cheese already on it, again soggy by the time its delivered.

James T

ALWAYS BEEN GOOD until tonight they completely burned the smash burgers all the way through and cost my parents and I 50 dollars for 3 doubles, onion rings, AND a tip completely unacceptable. This is after i told my parents it was a good idea for food as well so it kinda made me look stupid.

Brandon McClellan

Where to begin? The menu describes the waffle fries as “crispy” and “seasoned”, they definitely hit the mark being crispy, however they lacked in the flavor area. The second picture shows what they believe to be a lettuce wrap.. not too sure how a couple stiff leaves tossed on top of a burger equates to a wrap… The milkshake was probably the biggest disappointment here. What’s typically the highlight where your sweet tooth is fulfilled left much to be desired. The milkshake lacked no milk, with its watery texture and boring flavor. To make matters worse, I had ordered another burger that they failed to properly make. With Staten Island staples like Duffys two doors down supreme burger company definitely needs to step their game up! $40 down the drain on lackluster food, definitely won’t be patronizing them again.

The wings looked nothing like what was posted online, they weren’t even tossed in the sauce. The “cheese fries” had one squirt of nacho cheese, so sad for the price and such a waste of money. The wings were gray and had no flavor. The chicken sandwiches were good, so at least that’s something.

Don’t believe the pictures in the menu. Their burgers don’t worth 15$. Pickles were cold and not tasty at all. Stuff fries doesn’t look like on the pictures. Overall, for the price I paid, I expected much better. I won’t be coming back.

Burnt to the crisp. I wouldn’t have felt comfortable to hand this to someone but to each their own. Disappointing when you spend almost $30 on your meal and have to throw away these almost $10 onion rings!

Alecia Clark

The wings looked nothing like what was posted online, they weren’t even tossed in the sauce. The “cheese fries” had one squirt of nacho cheese, so sad for the price and such a waste of money. The wings were gray and had no flavor. The chicken sandwiches were good, so at least that’s something.

Julia Lapina

Don’t believe the pictures in the menu. Their burgers don’t worth 15$. Pickles were cold and not tasty at all. Stuff fries doesn’t look like on the pictures. Overall, for the price I paid, I expected much better. I won’t be coming back.

Mariama Annan

Burnt to the crisp. I wouldn’t have felt comfortable to hand this to someone but to each their own. Disappointing when you spend almost $30 on your meal and have to throw away these almost $10 onion rings!

What a lack of respect! I ordered two hamburgers, two orders of fries, and a milkshake, and the milkshake never arrived. They stole almost $20 from me, and I called and called, but no one answered. I ordered a double hamburger, and I only received a single one. These people don't treat their customers well. What a lack of respect! I'm never buying anything from them again. My name is Lamont Brown. Terrible service.

liz johns

We ordered a single smash burger with no cheese and a single Impossible smash burger with two orders of fries. We got two burgers wrapped the same with no marking. One burger had cheese - presumably the Impossible - but no sauce, no onions. I don't know if it's meat or not so I can't eat it. The other burger also had no sauce or onions. The fries were pale, unseasoned and tasteless. Not ordering from here again.