Stony Brook Pizza
Pizza · Stony Brook
About Stony Brook Pizza
Located in Stony Brook, Stony Brook Pizza is a local favorite, serving up delicious pizza and more. We're proud to have earned a 4.2-star rating from over 200 reviews, a testament to our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. We're open seven days a week, from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday thr...
Located in Stony Brook, Stony Brook Pizza is a local favorite, serving up delicious pizza and more. We're proud to have earned a 4.2-star rating from over 200 reviews, a testament to our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. We're open seven days a week, from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and extending our hours to 11 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays. Stop by and experience the taste of Stony Brook Pizza!
What Customers Say About Stony Brook Pizza
Stony Brook Pizza is praised for its delicious and consistent pizza, friendly staff (especially Jack and Jeff), and fast service. Many reviewers consider it the best pizza in the area. Negative reviews mention issues with freshness and quality of ingredients.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: The staff is kind and helpful with choosing slices. Prices are affordable compared to other local places.
Frequently asked questions about Stony Brook Pizza
Stony Brook Pizza Stony Brook Reviews
My favorite pizza place! Workers are friendly, pizza is delicious, and never gets old! Perfect crust, sauce and cheese, definitely the best pizza near stony brook university! Love coming here.
Great place with friendly staff. Have lived in area many years and finally visited. Very affordable prices compared to other local Italian/pizza places. Had a regular slice, salad and pasta fagioli soup, all were great. Will definitely be returning, and sorry I did not try this local place out sooner. Tons of menu items and good, easy location!
Best pizza I've had in a while. I couldn't wait to take a picture & that's why 2 slices are missing. I would highly recommend the sausage and broccoli rabe pizza.
AWESOME place!!! I highly recommend it 5 STARS 😍 The slices are big and LOADED!!! My two favorites are the Buffalo chicken slice and the Veggie slice. The staff is Great👌😁
Best pizza in town hands down !!! It’s so delicious and Everybody is friendly so worth it ! Keep up the good work SBP♥️
Great place with friendly staff. Have lived in area many years and finally visited. Very affordable prices compared to other local Italian/pizza places. Had a regular slice, salad and pasta fagioli soup, all were great. Will definitely be returning, and sorry I did not try this local place out sooner. Tons of menu items and good, easy location!
Love Jack and the pizza is always consistent. I would highly recommend coming here as it’s the best pizza place in town.
Hands down the best pizza I have had in a while. I ordered 5 specialty pizzas for a birthday party. From the guy who took my order over the phone to the one who delivered at exactly the right time on the dot my experience was great. The prices were just as good as the service. Everyone loved the food and each pizza was really delicious. I would recommend them 110% to anyone,anytime! Love love love your pizza!
Best chicken francés I've had. The lemon sauce was on point! Great job Tony. Best Chef ever!
Fast service and good pizza. Did individual slices for us and the staff was so kind to us helping us choose what to get.
The pizza is great. The crust is nice. Ad I'm sitting here I'm watching Jeff the work interact with a woman about a party. Jeff is patient and thoroughly explaining all the options and he was so accommodating with the needs of the lady. Keep up the great customer service😊
I love coming here after my lectures. The staff is always really nice! I got two plain slices, a Coke, and a cheesy bread for a little over $6. Every person I introduce to this pizza place ends up loving it. Would highly recommend!
I've been coming here for years I do not see a different face every time I come in food is always delicious if I order something that is not made Jay will always make it fresh does not make a difference if I'm ordering there or home delivery I've never had a bad experience there Plus delivery is always very fast.I LOVE S B pizza!!!
Excellent pizza and service. Great pizzaria, would definitely recommend.
Best pizza in stonybrook area hands down! Can not recommend enough. Owner and staff are always a pleasure woth fast service.
Fast service and good pizza. Did individual slices for us and the staff was so kind to us helping us choose what to get.
Best chicken francés I've had. The lemon sauce was on point! Great job Tony. Best Chef ever!
Excellent pizza and service. Great pizzaria, would definitely recommend.
Best pizza around. Kids and I love grabbing a slice and hanging out.
Love Jack and the pizza is always consistent. I would highly recommend coming here as it’s the best pizza place in town.
I've been coming here for years I do not see a different face every time I come in food is always delicious if I order something that is not made Jay will always make it fresh does not make a difference if I'm ordering there or home delivery I've never had a bad experience there Plus delivery is always very fast.I LOVE S B pizza!!!
Best pizza in stonybrook area hands down! Can not recommend enough. Owner and staff are always a pleasure woth fast service.
The pizza is great. The crust is nice. Ad I'm sitting here I'm watching Jeff the work interact with a woman about a party. Jeff is patient and thoroughly explaining all the options and he was so accommodating with the needs of the lady. Keep up the great customer service😊
I love coming here after my lectures. The staff is always really nice! I got two plain slices, a Coke, and a cheesy bread for a little over $6. Every person I introduce to this pizza place ends up loving it. Would highly recommend!
Every weekend I try a new pizza place on L.I. So far this place is on the bottom. The slice was too thick, no taste, the sauce was like tomato juice and there was too much rubbery cheese. One bite and it all slid down to the tip. I would not return for the pizza. Just my opinion.
I had a crispy chicken salad the tomatoes had black spots on it The same for the Kalamata olives . The chicken was extremely dried as if it was reheated. Certainly not fresh. Pizza ok Little bit too greasy No napkins or utensils .
I had a crispy chicken salad the tomatoes had black spots on it The same for the Kalamata olives . The chicken was extremely dried as if it was reheated. Certainly not fresh. Pizza ok Little bit too greasy No napkins or utensils .
I called to order pick up today, and told person on phone that I had a coupon for 2 cheese pies and 12 garlic knots for $24.59 + tax. The person on the phone told me that the wrong coupons were sent out, and that the price was wrong and it would cost $5 additional dollars. I stopped by the restaurant 5-10 minutes later to discuss this, and I was told the same thing despite showing the coupons (pictured below). I will say that the employees were very respectful the whole time in my interaction, but I do not agree with this restaurant not honoring coupons, sent out recently and with out an expiration date, due to an error made by them. I will not be going back to this restaurant ever again, and I encourage nobody else to use this restaurant because of the dishonesty and false advertising.
I stop by this establishment tonight and order two large pizzas one with extra cheese and I've been there before they had great pizza but today I was totally disappointed and I had to travel a nice distance to get this and where was the extra cheese well this will be the last time I will be going there they need to do better
Sadest excuse of a calzone I have every seen either raw or not enough dough mostly all cheese even though I asked for meat in it cost me $15 to learn never to eat here again thanks
I stop by this establishment tonight and order two large pizzas one with extra cheese and I've been there before they had great pizza but today I was totally disappointed and I had to travel a nice distance to get this and where was the extra cheese well this will be the last time I will be going there they need to do better
I called to order pick up today, and told person on phone that I had a coupon for 2 cheese pies and 12 garlic knots for $24.59 + tax. The person on the phone told me that the wrong coupons were sent out, and that the price was wrong and it would cost $5 additional dollars. I stopped by the restaurant 5-10 minutes later to discuss this, and I was told the same thing despite showing the coupons (pictured below). I will say that the employees were very respectful the whole time in my interaction, but I do not agree with this restaurant not honoring coupons, sent out recently and with out an expiration date, due to an error made by them. I will not be going back to this restaurant ever again, and I encourage nobody else to use this restaurant because of the dishonesty and false advertising.
Save your money. They make chicken rolls and calzones and specialty slices days ahead and keep it in a refrigerator case. They use an "UNDER THE COUNTER MICROWAVE" to heat your food before putting it in the oven as though that makes it ok. Why are we paying top dollar?!?! For 3 day old chicken rolls?!?! Disgusting. This is a joke of a food establishment. Staff is extremely rude especially the creep behind the counter. I was in food service for over 20 years, make it fresh daily, and if you don't, its because you don't know how much to make or not make and lack the experience to keep food waste down, so you sell old food. How can you charge people for old food that you microwave because its been in a refrigerator case so long?! Best advice, steer clear. Extremely unfriendly. In this establishment the CUSTOMER IS ALWAYS WRONG.
Save your money. They make chicken rolls and calzones and specialty slices days ahead and keep it in a refrigerator case. They use an "UNDER THE COUNTER MICROWAVE" to heat your food before putting it in the oven as though that makes it ok. Why are we paying top dollar?!?! For 3 day old chicken rolls?!?! Disgusting. This is a joke of a food establishment. Staff is extremely rude especially the creep behind the counter. I was in food service for over 20 years, make it fresh daily, and if you don't, its because you don't know how much to make or not make and lack the experience to keep food waste down, so you sell old food. How can you charge people for old food that you microwave because its been in a refrigerator case so long?! Best advice, steer clear. Extremely unfriendly. In this establishment the CUSTOMER IS ALWAYS WRONG.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
East Side Dining / Chávez Hall
Chilli's Take Out
Parsnip
Burgerology
SAC Food Court
Panera Bread
Station Pizza
The Bench
Umberto's
Mezze
17 Photos
Explore Stony Brook Pizza's photos
About Stony Brook Pizza
How to get there
2460 Nesconset Hwy #10, Stony Brook, NY 11790
Highlights
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
2460 Nesconset Hwy #10, Stony Brook, NY 11790
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Stony Brook Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at Stony Brook Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Stony Brook Pizza
🏆 Rewards at Stony Brook Pizza
10% Discount
At Stony Brook Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu