Jersey Mike's Subs
Sandwich · Suffern
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike's Subs in Suffern brings the taste of the Jersey Shore to you! We're a counter-serve sandwich chain known for our generously sized subs piled high with fresh cold cuts and delicious toppings. Enjoy a satisfying lunch or dinner with us, choosing from dine-in, takeout, or convenient delive...
Jersey Mike's Subs in Suffern brings the taste of the Jersey Shore to you! We're a counter-serve sandwich chain known for our generously sized subs piled high with fresh cold cuts and delicious toppings. Enjoy a satisfying lunch or dinner with us, choosing from dine-in, takeout, or convenient delivery options, including curbside and no-contact services. We're open daily from 10AM to 9PM. With a 4.4-star rating from 121 reviews, we pride ourselves on quality and customer satisfaction. Our location is wheelchair accessible, ensuring a comfortable experience for everyone.
What Customers Say About Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike's Subs in Suffern receives generally positive reviews, with customers frequently praising the food quality and friendly service. Some customers have noted issues with order accuracy and occasional rudeness from staff. The restaurant is often compared to Chipotle.
Best For
Tip: Give it a try, the food is absolutely amazing.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike's Subs Suffern Reviews
Affordable and delicious stret tacos. We went with two steak/two chicken tacos and an order of birria tacos. Both orders were tasty. A good portion of meat, wasn't over cooked or blan.
Excellent! Small quaint local business serving value priced great tasting food! Very interesting decor with a very relaxed feel. Very down to earth owners who cater to their customers. Excellent for carryout or dine in. A good selection of soft drinks, deserts, and sparkling water. Awesome sound system with a nice variety of music! Plenty of parking with other places to shop within walking distance. Please leave a tip for the staff because the food is well worth it!
I was visiting the area for a youth sports event. Looked up close options for food. This place was fantastic. Cute window drawings and the inside is beautiful with amazing paintings. Clean! And the food... Fresh salsa, guac and chips were delicious and everything was spot on. When I come back to the area I will be back to try something new
Just what you want from a legit local burrito and tacos spot. Legit. Get the jalapeño and mushroom mix in your burrito. And don’t forget to add a Mexican Coke. Good guacamole too, as the name would suggest. And the chips are fresh.
Better than Chipotle. My first time and I was happy I choose this place to eat lunch, I'm a taxi driver and always saw this place coming around it and was sketchy since I always try mexican restaurants and always left with disappointment. The guy that was doing my burrito was really friendly, he insisted on trying las calavazas and I was effi about but I'm glad he convinced me, they are full of flavor as well as the pico de gallo, y regret not getting the hotter source but the mild space also has a good taste. I also put the fajita peppers and onions. Definitely a different taste... will come here if I have trips around this restaurant.
Affordable and delicious stret tacos. We went with two steak/two chicken tacos and an order of birria tacos. Both orders were tasty. A good portion of meat, wasn't over cooked or blan.
Excellent! Small quaint local business serving value priced great tasting food! Very interesting decor with a very relaxed feel. Very down to earth owners who cater to their customers. Excellent for carryout or dine in. A good selection of soft drinks, deserts, and sparkling water. Awesome sound system with a nice variety of music! Plenty of parking with other places to shop within walking distance. Please leave a tip for the staff because the food is well worth it!
I was visiting the area for a youth sports event. Looked up close options for food. This place was fantastic. Cute window drawings and the inside is beautiful with amazing paintings. Clean! And the food... Fresh salsa, guac and chips were delicious and everything was spot on. When I come back to the area I will be back to try something new
Just what you want from a legit local burrito and tacos spot. Legit. Get the jalapeño and mushroom mix in your burrito. And don’t forget to add a Mexican Coke. Good guacamole too, as the name would suggest. And the chips are fresh.
Better than Chipotle. My first time and I was happy I choose this place to eat lunch, I'm a taxi driver and always saw this place coming around it and was sketchy since I always try mexican restaurants and always left with disappointment. The guy that was doing my burrito was really friendly, he insisted on trying las calavazas and I was effi about but I'm glad he convinced me, they are full of flavor as well as the pico de gallo, y regret not getting the hotter source but the mild space also has a good taste. I also put the fajita peppers and onions. Definitely a different taste... will come here if I have trips around this restaurant.
Cute restaurant! Tasty food! The decor of the restaurant is the best thing!
Really great food. Nice small place to eat peacefully. Wish people working there could understand what I want and be little flexible.
This is my go to for a great burrito. Everything is always fresh and the place is nice and clean. Guys are always smiling and happy to serve you. Love the spicy sauce! Never have eaten in always take mine to go. Easily could share a burrito!
Really great food. Nice small place to eat peacefully. Wish people working there could understand what I want and be little flexible.
Randomly went in here, was suppose to eat somewhere else, but it was closed. The food here is absolutely amazing. Give it try.
This is my go to for a great burrito. Everything is always fresh and the place is nice and clean. Guys are always smiling and happy to serve you. Love the spicy sauce! Never have eaten in always take mine to go. Easily could share a burrito!
Very good food.a little spicy. $15 for a big quesadilla (2 people can eat). Person was very nice. However, there is an extra charge for using a credit card.
Good food, bit pricey for regular plate but good taste.
Very good food.a little spicy. $15 for a big quesadilla (2 people can eat). Person was very nice. However, there is an extra charge for using a credit card.
Good food, bit pricey for regular plate but good taste.
If you are after authentic Latin cuisine, this ain't it. This is food in the belly 1 stoplight off the interstate. Food isn't being prepped fresh, just rewarmed from the metal chaffing dish. That all being said, they had a clean interior with lunch counter style seating. Friendly staff and the food was ready fast. Prices felt high for what it was.
It has a very inviting fun looking facade but that about as far as it goes. The food prep is a takeoff of Chipotle with smaller serving, but the same pricing. I ordered a carnitas bowl and the first thing he did was add 4 scoops of rice and a sprinkle of black beans. Bad start. A little carnitas, even smaller amount of guacamole ( I added 2 extra sides of it and it was still not a full spoonful) a sprinkle of cheese, pico de gallo salsa, hot sauce and it was done. Home I broke out my favorite tortilla and made a mean burrito…. Unfortunately it was all very blah. $13 for blah? Uh, no.
If you are after authentic Latin cuisine, this ain't it. This is food in the belly 1 stoplight off the interstate. Food isn't being prepped fresh, just rewarmed from the metal chaffing dish. That all being said, they had a clean interior with lunch counter style seating. Friendly staff and the food was ready fast. Prices felt high for what it was.
It has a very inviting fun looking facade but that about as far as it goes. The food prep is a takeoff of Chipotle with smaller serving, but the same pricing. I ordered a carnitas bowl and the first thing he did was add 4 scoops of rice and a sprinkle of black beans. Bad start. A little carnitas, even smaller amount of guacamole ( I added 2 extra sides of it and it was still not a full spoonful) a sprinkle of cheese, pico de gallo salsa, hot sauce and it was done. Home I broke out my favorite tortilla and made a mean burrito…. Unfortunately it was all very blah. $13 for blah? Uh, no.
It was chipotle. Meat was dry and bland. No fresh Ingredients. Atmosphere was ok. Music way too loud. Food was just “okay” .. the worker was beyond creepy
It was chipotle. Meat was dry and bland. No fresh Ingredients. Atmosphere was ok. Music way too loud. Food was just “okay” .. the worker was beyond creepy
We were looking for a local alternative to Chipotle, but unfortunately very disappointed with the meal. Portions for the burrito, chips, and queso were considerably smaller and blander than anticipated. There also seemed to be an issue with the cashier trying to upcharge on Guac when we did not request any, multiple times. Will not be back.
Not sure if it was the Salsa or the Guacamole, but something was extremely salt, which messed up the entire meal. I have only been the re once and plan on stopping by again to see if it was just a mistake.
Ordered through Door Dash. Got the wrong item. DD refunded my money but I don't like what came instead so it's going to waste. I only ordered a burrito bowl and a soda (which did get delivered.) This shouldn't happen with such a small order. Don't know if this was their error or the dasher error, so I'll give them another try another time.
We were looking for a local alternative to Chipotle, but unfortunately very disappointed with the meal. Portions for the burrito, chips, and queso were considerably smaller and blander than anticipated. There also seemed to be an issue with the cashier trying to upcharge on Guac when we did not request any, multiple times. Will not be back.
Ordered through Door Dash. Got the wrong item. DD refunded my money but I don't like what came instead so it's going to waste. I only ordered a burrito bowl and a soda (which did get delivered.) This shouldn't happen with such a small order. Don't know if this was their error or the dasher error, so I'll give them another try another time.
I AM EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED! I have been a guacamole regular since they have opened. Within the last 2 years service has completely plummeted! Sadly the owner is the sweetest man you’ll ever meet but the 2 regular employees are HORRIBLE! This is the 3rd time I’ve received a raw protein and for it to be fish and chicken will kill someone! I may never go back.
THEY DO NOT FOLLOW DIRECTIONS. When I called I specifically told him what I wanted and none of the stuff that I ordered came right. I told the guy on the phone to give me a lot of chips and I would pay for it. This is what I got 😨 I called the restaurant again and the guy hung up on me. Never going back again
THEY DO NOT FOLLOW DIRECTIONS. When I called I specifically told him what I wanted and none of the stuff that I ordered came right. I told the guy on the phone to give me a lot of chips and I would pay for it. This is what I got 😨 I called the restaurant again and the guy hung up on me. Never going back again
Workers are very rude. They make a person feel like never coming back. I think they need better customer service for sure. I was very disappointed. I have been there a couple of times and its always the same horrible customer service. The rice was also cold.
4/27/25 5:15pm Walked in, placed an order to go, guy was super rude. Ordered $67.00 in food, guy forgot to put my kids cheese quesadilla in the bag, the question then becomes do I drive back? Nope. Food was made Chipotle style, no issues with that, but everything we ate was luke warm at best. I'm not normally one to post a negative review, maybe it was just the perfect storm. Guy was rude, food was cold, and they forgot to put my kids cheese quesadilla in the bag. Overall food was OK, take that with a grain of salt, again, I'm not happy with the overall experience and am maybe judging the food to harshly. My end all be all question with any dining experience is would I go back? In this instance, the answer is no. Jason H. Norment
Food was delicious. Service was absolutely absurd. Employee was annoyed when asked what was in the quesadilla. Asked because the order was placed online, where you can choose what you want inside (no corn due to allergy) he already added corn and pointed to the receipt as if the mistake was on us. He was annoyed having to make a new one and when asked to add guacamole he responded it was more money. Obviously guac is always more $. Food was delicious, just don’t be so rude when it comes to customer facing situations. Sucks because the place is cute and such a vibe.
Workers are very rude. They make a person feel like never coming back. I think they need better customer service for sure. I was very disappointed. I have been there a couple of times and its always the same horrible customer service. The rice was also cold.
4/27/25 5:15pm Walked in, placed an order to go, guy was super rude. Ordered $67.00 in food, guy forgot to put my kids cheese quesadilla in the bag, the question then becomes do I drive back? Nope. Food was made Chipotle style, no issues with that, but everything we ate was luke warm at best. I'm not normally one to post a negative review, maybe it was just the perfect storm. Guy was rude, food was cold, and they forgot to put my kids cheese quesadilla in the bag. Overall food was OK, take that with a grain of salt, again, I'm not happy with the overall experience and am maybe judging the food to harshly. My end all be all question with any dining experience is would I go back? In this instance, the answer is no. Jason H. Norment
Food was delicious. Service was absolutely absurd. Employee was annoyed when asked what was in the quesadilla. Asked because the order was placed online, where you can choose what you want inside (no corn due to allergy) he already added corn and pointed to the receipt as if the mistake was on us. He was annoyed having to make a new one and when asked to add guacamole he responded it was more money. Obviously guac is always more $. Food was delicious, just don’t be so rude when it comes to customer facing situations. Sucks because the place is cute and such a vibe.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
Buffalo Wild Wings
Da Nina Italian Restaurant
Jumbo Asian
Popeyes
IHOP
Wendy's
Pita Land
Taqueria America
White Castle
Starbucks
2 Photos
Explore Jersey Mike's Subs's photos
About Jersey Mike's Subs
How to get there
218 NY-59, Suffern, NY 10901
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
218 NY-59, Suffern, NY 10901
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Jersey Mike's Subs and other restaurants
Earn Points at Jersey Mike's Subs!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Jersey Mike's Subs
🏆 Rewards at Jersey Mike's Subs
10% Discount
At Jersey Mike's Subs
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu