Whiskey Wagon Saloon
Bar · Theresa
About Whiskey Wagon Saloon
Whiskey Wagon Saloon in Theresa offers a quintessential American bar experience where friendly locals gather for live music, bar games, and great company. Guests praise the attentive staff who make every visit feel special, from Scotty's heart-signing cocktails to quick service during football seaso...
Whiskey Wagon Saloon in Theresa offers a quintessential American bar experience where friendly locals gather for live music, bar games, and great company. Guests praise the attentive staff who make every visit feel special, from Scotty's heart-signing cocktails to quick service during football season. The menu features standout burgers, crispy wings, and delicious sandwiches, complemented by an excellent selection of beers and craft cocktails. Whether dining in, ordering takeout, or stopping for a solo drink, the warm atmosphere and relaxed vibe make it a favorite annual destination for travelers returning from Black Lake. With extended late-night hours on weekends, this spot perfectly blends fast service, outstanding food, and a welcoming environment for any occasion.
What Customers Say About Whiskey Wagon Saloon
Whiskey Wagon Saloon is a popular local bar known for its friendly atmosphere, great wings and burgers, and decent prices. Service can be slow and the kitchen is small. Some reviewers mention inconsistent food quality.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Bring cash or a debit card, as they don't take credit cards. Ask for Scotty at the bar!
Features
Frequently asked questions about Whiskey Wagon Saloon
Whiskey Wagon Saloon Theresa Reviews
This has become our annual stopping point after leaving black lake, the food is always AMAZING! The servers are attentive and friendly, if we were local I'd be a regular for sure! I tried something different this time and was in awe of the grilled ham and cheese sandwich, literally the best one I've ever had!! The bacon ranch fries are a staple snack also, so delicious and loaded with bacon.
This has become our annual stopping point after leaving black lake, the food is always AMAZING! The servers are attentive and friendly, if we were local I'd be a regular for sure! I tried something different this time and was in awe of the grilled ham and cheese sandwich, literally the best one I've ever had!! The bacon ranch fries are a staple snack also, so delicious and loaded with bacon.
Great place to grab a drink and some food. Met some great people
Great burgers and wings. The great prices makes this place even better. Will definitely be returning but make sure you bring cash or debit card for atm.
The wings are fabulous. The service is very attentive and cares about your experience. Recommend for a relaxed spot to get a drink and chill.
Great food with only trying takeout so far. The fried food options and chicken wings are worth reordering
A real local bar with a pool table, decent drink and food prices, and awesome wings!
My favorite wing place. Takes a while to get food but totally worth it.
Scott makes a excellent burger. Cooked to order and a great group of people having great conversations.
Only negative is their ATM, they don't take credit cards, and small kitchen.
Love this bar! Locals are a blast, and food is just what you need when suckin down some beers while catching some football or just swingin by. Wings are bomb, along with burgers! Live music always kicks it up a notch. - Glorrrrrrrrria! (By SonSet)
When you get here ask for Scotty best bartender in town. Very lovable and a nice teddy bear. The drinks taste way better when he gives you a heart hand-sign(you know what I mean) ;) ❤️
Excellent food, prompt friendly service. The fried onion rings and fried mushrooms are outstanding - very crispy outside, soft and delicious inside. Everyone's sandwich was delicious and had a lot of meat.
Quintessential American bar, friendly service, good company. However BEWARE of the food. The current cook (4/24) is slovenly, inexperienced, and way out of her depth - unsanitary and just bad.
When you get here ask for Scotty best bartender in town. Very lovable and a nice teddy bear. The drinks taste way better when he gives you a heart hand-sign(you know what I mean) ;) ❤️
Love this bar! Locals are a blast, and food is just what you need when suckin down some beers while catching some football or just swingin by. Wings are bomb, along with burgers! Live music always kicks it up a notch. - Glorrrrrrrrria! (By SonSet)
Great place to grab a drink and some food. Met some great people
Only negative is their ATM, they don't take credit cards, and small kitchen.
My favorite wing place. Takes a while to get food but totally worth it.
A real local bar with a pool table, decent drink and food prices, and awesome wings!
Excellent food, prompt friendly service. The fried onion rings and fried mushrooms are outstanding - very crispy outside, soft and delicious inside. Everyone's sandwich was delicious and had a lot of meat.
Quintessential American bar, friendly service, good company. However BEWARE of the food. The current cook (4/24) is slovenly, inexperienced, and way out of her depth - unsanitary and just bad.
Great food with only trying takeout so far. The fried food options and chicken wings are worth reordering
The wings are fabulous. The service is very attentive and cares about your experience. Recommend for a relaxed spot to get a drink and chill.
Scott makes a excellent burger. Cooked to order and a great group of people having great conversations.
Great burgers and wings. The great prices makes this place even better. Will definitely be returning but make sure you bring cash or debit card for atm.
Food has been very good every time we have been there.
Great small town bar. Service and food was excellent. Highly recommend to anyone in the area or passing by.
Nice little tavern, great place to grab a drink and bite to eat
Great small town bar. Service and food was excellent. Highly recommend to anyone in the area or passing by.
Nice little tavern, great place to grab a drink and bite to eat
Food has been very good every time we have been there.
There aren't many dinner options within 30 miles of here. We were all hungry and the first choice was closed. This is the type of local spot where the juke box stops playing and everyone stares at you when you walk in. Everyone else obviously knows one another in this close knit part of New York. Our server was friendly but she was the only one in the entire place serving a dozen or so tables. She was also the only one bussing tables. The food wasn't very good. There's no sugar coating it. My Philly cheese steak had few peppers or onions and had no spice. The Buffalo chicken sandwich was basically a chiybreast with Frank's Red Hot. The bourbon barbecue sandwich was similarly constructed. It wasn't terrible but it was just OK.
Definitely a local's spot and mostly a bar that has food. The meals were merely okay and it took forever but the waitress was very kind and it was a cheerful mostly welcoming atmosphere.
Is a good place to eat. Little difficult to get an order in. Place seems a little understaffed and needs a dedicated waiter/waitress/bartender especially during busy times. Would benefit from a place at the bar to come up and order drinks that doesn't have a barstool (ie: either middle of the bar or at the right corner just before the ATM.)
There aren't many dinner options within 30 miles of here. We were all hungry and the first choice was closed. This is the type of local spot where the juke box stops playing and everyone stares at you when you walk in. Everyone else obviously knows one another in this close knit part of New York. Our server was friendly but she was the only one in the entire place serving a dozen or so tables. She was also the only one bussing tables. The food wasn't very good. There's no sugar coating it. My Philly cheese steak had few peppers or onions and had no spice. The Buffalo chicken sandwich was basically a chiybreast with Frank's Red Hot. The bourbon barbecue sandwich was similarly constructed. It wasn't terrible but it was just OK.
Definitely a local's spot and mostly a bar that has food. The meals were merely okay and it took forever but the waitress was very kind and it was a cheerful mostly welcoming atmosphere.
Is a good place to eat. Little difficult to get an order in. Place seems a little understaffed and needs a dedicated waiter/waitress/bartender especially during busy times. Would benefit from a place at the bar to come up and order drinks that doesn't have a barstool (ie: either middle of the bar or at the right corner just before the ATM.)
Attempted to order food tonight and we were hung up on Last time we were at this location we were not served alcohol by the bartender and were told to go to the other bartender. Terrible service.
Attempted to order food tonight and we were hung up on Last time we were at this location we were not served alcohol by the bartender and were told to go to the other bartender. Terrible service.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
Gallery
No photos available
Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places
About Whiskey Wagon Saloon
How to get there
43523 NY-37, Redwood, NY 13679
Theresa, NY 13679
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Whiskey Wagon Saloon and other restaurants
Earn Points at Whiskey Wagon Saloon!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Whiskey Wagon Saloon
🏆 Rewards at Whiskey Wagon Saloon
10% Discount
At Whiskey Wagon Saloon
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu