American Pie Pizza

Name: American Pie Pizza
Address: 927 Maple St, Carrollton, GA 30117, Water Mill, NY, 30117, US
Telephone: +17708323000
Price range: €€
Rating: 4.4

Pizza · Water Mill

4.4 · 929 reviews Google

American Pie Pizza

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

www.facebook.com

Yelp 3.5 (44) TripAdvisor 4.3 (46) Yellowpages 4.8 (4)

About American Pie Pizza

En American Pie Pizza, somos una familia apasionada por la buena comida y por hacerte sentir como en casa. Nuestra especialidad son las pizzas artesanales, elaboradas con ingredientes frescos y de la mejor calidad, pero también te ofrecemos deliciosos subs calientes, ensaladas, alitas y calzones gen...

What Customers Say About American Pie Pizza

American Pie Pizza in Water Mill is highly praised for its delicious pizza, with many calling it the best in the area. Customers consistently compliment the fresh ingredients, perfect crust, and great customer service. It's a kid-friendly place that can get rowdy during parties.

Popular Dishes

pizza (18) buffalo chicken pizza cinnamon ball dessert butter balls BBQ Chicken pizza Baked Potato pizza birthday cake dessert pizza

Best For

Families Groups Casual Locals

Tip: The pizza is best when fresh, so get it as soon as it's ready. Expect large parties in the evenings and weekends.

Features

🅿️ Parking ♿ Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner 🥗 Vegetarian 🌱 Vegan

🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy ✨ Trendy 👥 Groups

Frequently asked questions about American Pie Pizza

American Pie Pizza is located at 927 Maple St, Carrollton, GA 30117, Water Mill.

American Pie Pizza offers pizza cuisine.

American Pie Pizza has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.

American Pie Pizza offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway.

The most recommended dishes at American Pie Pizza based on customer reviews are: pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, cinnamon ball dessert, butter balls, BBQ Chicken pizza.

American Pie Pizza is ideal for families, groups, casual dining, locals.

The pizza is best when fresh, so get it as soon as it's ready. Expect large parties in the evenings and weekends.

929

Reviews

American Pie Pizza Water Mill Reviews

4.4

929

5★

65%

4★

22%

3★

2★

1★

Reviews (21)

Scott Schlueter

A staple in the area, good for take out or dine in. Bring cash for discount.

Trayvon Kemp

Honestly some of the best pizza I have had around Carrollton! I also want to mention the customer service was great and the manager will take care of your order if the pizza isn’t perfect! This place is a 10/10

Jessica

A slice of Americana. The best locally owned pizza place in town. They are a well oiled machine. I have picked up an order every Friday for 3 months and I noticed employee turnover is low meaning they can keep people and that’s a good sign. Order always perfectly on time, the pizza is best when fresh, the place is clean. It’s a great example of how location doesn’t matter if you provide a really great service, atmosphere, and product. It’s also one of the few places with a special event room.

Jai Hicks

The buffalo chicken pizza is delicious.🔥🔥🔥🤤 I order it every time. I also tried the cinnamon ball dessert they had. It's really sweet, but I like it. Heads up, they're gooey, you'll want to use a fork.

James Cole

Some of the best pizza in Carrollton! Come here all the time very consistent quality

jauspitz1

If you get it as soon as it's ready, it is the best pizza in town.

Brian Halstead

Great tasting pizza, from the sauce to the amount of cheese and the crust was perfect. The sides are amazing as well and the portions are more than enough.

Meredith Booker

Our 1st visit, and we will be back! The pizza was delicious!

Tiffany Anderson

We had the party room for a small baby shower. Private no distractions. We ordered 2 party pizzas and butter balls. Food was delicious! Delivered to the table we had set up hot and fresh! We did have to ask for plates and utensils.

Zay Andrés

This is hands down the best pizza place ever in Carrollton GA 🙌 I like how the employees take time to make sure their food is fresh and well made for customers like me. The tables are clean, the room is very huge and the atmosphere is very warm out here. It just suits this place well! I enjoy eating here & my main favorites of this establishment is the pizza and their wings! They were pretty tasty & tasted VERY FRESH! Bathrooms are very clean as well. No issues while using it. I ordered mild original wings and of course it comes with their BBQ sauce! The pizza itself was very cheesy and hot. I will continue with patronizing this establishment. I will definitely return. This is a must have if you're over here looking for fresh pizza, or if you're looking for delicious wings.

Zandra Johnson

This is the best pizza I've had in the West Georgia area. I will definitely come back.

Coach Clark

Hydro for about 45 minutes to experience this my friends invited me. Might I say well worth the pizza was off the chain... delicious

Weslyn Wiley

Good prices! They have a small, personal pizza (8" with choice of 2 meats and 4 veggies) for under about $6.50! Really enjoyed the pizza and looking forward to trying the $7 lunch buffet.

Derek Sutton

I got my pizza to go but overall it was a good experience! Not really nothing to exciting to state other than it is more of a kid like atmosphere!

Donald Beckworth

Stopped by today after riding the Carrollton Beltway on our bikes. The wife went for a custom personal and I went for a medium Baked Potato pizza with bacon. Yummy. Service was prompt. Pizza was good. Can't ask for much better. Expect large parties in the evenings and weekends. Looks like the kind of place all the sportsball teams come after scoring all the goal units 👍🤓

Calvin Palmer

I rediscovered this place after years and years, and the pizza did not disappoint. The pizza here is really good, crust is normally on thin side. I have only ordered pepperoni and sausage and the Alfedo pizza add chicken. I was just there last week: it took over 30 minutes for three pizzas, dine in, but two were Xtra large which may have contributed to the delay. This factor would have been better received if communicated. Their customer service skills are not the best and could use some improvements.

christyn aliffi

The pizza (for this area) was great in my opinion. The buffalo butter bites were just, meh. Honestly if they had homemade ranch on them it would make them a million times better. The garlic butter on the crust was great, but compared to the pics our pizza came out with very little crust. Large area with plenty of seating and super casual.

Vicki Johnson

We had a good 1st visit. We will be back. The sauce is a canned sauce. However, it is one of the better ones we have had. Once they get the first customer in for the buffet at opening, they keep the pizzas coming. Their birthday cake dessert pizza is amazing!!! The restaurant was very clean. Bathrooms were both very clean.

Blake Collis

The food was absolutely amazing. We got a large BBQ Chicken pizza, and it was enough to feed 3 adults. My only complaint: It’s very kid-friendly, with an arcade-like feel to it. It can get pretty rowdy in there when there is a party of some sort happening. There is a seating outdoors, which I thought was nice. The dining room is also really open and features large windows for a good view. It is easily accessible to shopping and other activities, and only about 2 miles from anywhere worth visiting in Carrollton. We loved the food. We eventually got annoyed by the screaming children everywhere.