Mr. Sub

Name: Mr. Sub
Address: 109 Mill St, Watertown, NY 13601, Watertown, NY, 13601, US
Telephone: +13157821760
Price range: €€
Rating: 4.5

Sandwich · Watertown

4.5 · 282 reviews Google

Mr. Sub

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

About Mr. Sub

Mr. Sub is a Watertown staple, offering a comforting and satisfying menu of classic subs and pizza. Customers rave about the quality ingredients and generous portions, particularly the Super Italian sub piled high with toppings and the delicious pizza, considered a great value. The friendly and attentive service creates a welcoming atmosphere, and many appreciate the nostalgic, old-school charm of the dine-in experience. Perfect for a quick lunch, dinner, or solo meal, Mr. Sub provides both takeout and outdoor seating options. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, ensuring a comfortable visit for everyone.

What Customers Say About Mr. Sub

Mr. Sub is a beloved local sandwich shop known for its friendly, family-like atmosphere and delicious, affordable subs. The Super Italian sub and pepperoni pizza are highly praised. Some customers wish they had longer hours.

Popular Dishes

Super Italian Pepperoni Pizza BLT sub Tuna melt Italian Sub pizza (3)

Best For

Locals Solo Dining Quick Bite Casual

Tip: Visit for a quick and affordable lunch. Many recommend the Super Italian sub or the pepperoni pizza. Be aware that they close relatively early.

Features

🌳 Outdoor 🅿️ Parking ♿ Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner

🎯 Casual 🤫 Quiet

What to see nearby

Heritage

A 334m

Saint Paul's Episcopal Church

iglesia

View details

Trinity Episcopal Church and Parish House

Heritage

A 580m

Trinity Episcopal Church and Parish House

iglesia

View details

Data from Wikidata

Explore the area around Mr. Sub

Mr. Sub is located in Watertown, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.

Historical Heritage

Saint Paul's Episcopal Church (A 334m) — church building in New York, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
Trinity Episcopal Church and Parish House (A 580m) — church building in Watertown, New York, United States Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos

Data from Wikidata

Frequently asked questions about Mr. Sub

Mr. Sub is located at 109 Mill St, Watertown, NY 13601, Watertown.

Near Mr. Sub you can find points of interest such as Saint Paul's Episcopal Church, Trinity Episcopal Church and Parish House.

Mr. Sub offers sandwich cuisine.

Mr. Sub has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.

Mr. Sub offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway.

The most recommended dishes at Mr. Sub based on customer reviews are: Super Italian, Pepperoni Pizza, BLT sub, Tuna melt, Italian Sub.

Mr. Sub is ideal for locals, solo dining, quick bites, casual dining.

Visit for a quick and affordable lunch. Many recommend the Super Italian sub or the pepperoni pizza. Be aware that they close relatively early.

282

Reviews

Mr. Sub Watertown Reviews

4.5

282

5★

74%

4★

13%

3★

2★

1★

Reviews (21)

Matt Northrup

Great locally owned and operated eatery. Pizza is OK, subs are stellar - highly recommend the Reuben, hot pastrami, All-American and meatball subs! The chicken Caesar salad and homemade Mac salad are also a repeatable favorites…

Tyler Thatcher

If you’re looking for a fresh, delicious, and affordable sub, this is the spot. Everything tasted great, and the staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming

Reg Schweitzer

Best subs in Watertown and made with care by the same people for decades. Hidden Gem!

hippiety

it was my first time coming here and it was very good! we just only got a pizza but it was really tastey(:

Paul McCorry

I went in for a quick lunch, the shop is super cozy, the food is AMAZING and very inexpensive and the staff is incredibly friendly. 10/10 recommend and I will be going back.

Ryan O'Donnell

Great sandwich. Very affordable and high quality meats. Super friendly staff!

Andrew Drury

Family type atmosphere, welcoming to new customers and old. Fresh rolls made every day. Varieties of hot and cold subs to choose from, and salads. You will never go wrong, with a Mr. Sub!

David Stenberg

I have no idea how Cam's, which is on the same block, is still open. Mr. Sub is REAL pizza. I have driven past this place countless times and never stopped because it's tiny and hard to get to. Big mistake!!! Easily the best pizza in Watertown/Carthage/Adams area with absolutely no comparison. FYI: If you get a "medium", that's a large round pizza - if you get a "large" thats a large Sicilian.

Aaron Bates

Amazing place to stop and grab a delicious bite 😋. The family that owns this really treats you like family ❤️. I always love coming to Mr.Subs.

Ed Hufsmith

Awesome Italian Sub! I split it with my co-worker. We thought it was fantastic! The soft chewy bread & the shaved lettuce were delicious! Sitting in this shop was like steeping back in time, the price was very reasonable. The owner, Mrs. sub was there and told us the history of the shop, lovely lady. I will definitely stop back on my travels.

joey “Chico” Nier

The best damn sub shop in town! Simply put it's one of my favorites. The staff there is very respectable very aware of the customer and they take care of the customer all the time. My favorite is a BLT sub. Tuna melt delicious. Keep up the good work Mr Sub...

Matthew Janis

I have driven by this location for two years and never stopped in until today for a quick lunch. The customer service immediatly waslking in was awesome. I was able to get a very fulfilling half a cold sub and envied the hot choices they had. I can't wait to eat their again. Parking and seating was kind of tight but everyone made it work.

Jim Swem

Working in Watertown today and I wanted a local shop for lunch. Searched Google, and this was the first local choice !! Half of a Super Italian, Mac salad, soda !! Wonderful !! When I walked in there was a full house, but these women didn't take long to work through the crowd !! Very personal service, friendly too !! What a great find !! Sitting outside, the sun was excellent !! Nap time !

Sierra Walker

Best Subs in Upstate New York ❤️ skip Jrecks and Subway and make the trip you won't regret it.

Rudy Toth

I always eat here when other local restaurants are closed temporarily. I found over the years they have excellent subs and especially the Pepperoni Pizza which you can't go wrong with two slices and a can of soda for about $4.00. Try to get the same some where else... no chance! They are very friendly and nice and their place where you decide to sit and eat inside the establishment they are very clean for your consumption. I guess you can eat outside on their picnic tables when it's sunny and nice outside and under the umbrellas too. ☀️👍🏻😆👍🏻🏆

Damien Morrow

Man, the pizza for $10.95 is a STEAL. And I always love getting a can of DC and eating a couple slices on a busy day. I wish they were open more often, but I can respect keeping hours a little restricted so those who run it can live a good life outside of working there.

Joe blow

Best subs in town with a large selection. The Super Italian with everything is disgustingly good. It's the heartiest sub I've ever had, with tons of toppings. I'll get the pastrami and have them put some corned beef on it as well. Delicious. I only wish they had rye rolls for it, then it would be perfect.

Marcus Chauvette, Sr.

I love this place! Great, consistent food and friendly staff. Some of them have been there for as long as I can remember. My only complaint is that they close too early, and they're not open at times and days where they should be. We were home visiting and tried to catch them open. The all-too-familiar pizza sub was well worth the wait!

Samantha deManbey

A humble little sub shop with a big menu. Had the Greek salad which was great with the added pickles. Some interesting items that were also available were pickled eggs and fresh cookies. Good prices and very friendly staff. Great place for a quick and tasty meal.

Chrissy

What pizza place stops making anything hot after 530pm??? 530pm? That’s just crazy to me. Most people want pizza for dinner after they get out of work and is looking for an easy meal for their kids. This place should be open to atleast 8pm. Says open until 6 but don’t call at 5:33 because they don’t make anything hot past 530. I’ll never try and give them my business and money again.