Yummy Gyro
Greek · Williston Park
About Yummy Gyro
Located in Williston Park, Yummy Gyro offers a delicious and convenient dining experience. We're proud to have earned a 4.0-star rating from 207 reviews, reflecting our commitment to quality and service. Enjoy our gyros and other tasty options with features like outdoor seating, delivery, takeout, a...
Located in Williston Park, Yummy Gyro offers a delicious and convenient dining experience. We're proud to have earned a 4.0-star rating from 207 reviews, reflecting our commitment to quality and service. Enjoy our gyros and other tasty options with features like outdoor seating, delivery, takeout, and dine-in. We offer fast service for both lunch and dinner, and cater to solo diners. We're committed to accessibility, providing a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, and restroom. You can also enjoy alcohol with your meal. We're open seven days a week, from 11 AM to 9 PM.
What Customers Say About Yummy Gyro
Yummy Gyro is a popular spot for Greek cuisine, especially gyros and platters. Customers praise the fresh, flavorful food and generous portions. Some reviewers mention issues with online orders, billing discrepancies, and occasional slow service.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: The food is great for take-out. Double-check your bill for extra charges.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Yummy Gyro
Yummy Gyro is located in Williston Park, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Parks & Gardens
- Albertson Park (A 559m) — park in the United States of America
- Kelleher Field (A 705m) — park in the United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Yummy Gyro
Yummy Gyro Williston Park Reviews
Catered from Yummy Gyro for a party of 40 people and everyone loved it. Nesi made it super easy to place the catering order. We had tzatziki dips, spanakopita, zucchini fritters, two types of salads (villager was a hit) chicken skewers, beef and lamb shawarma, broccoli rice and pitas. The food arrived piping hot as well so easy to keep warm in warming trays before people dove in. Will definitely be ordering from again.
I stopped in for lunch and ordered a Greek wrap. The Greek wrap took 5 minutes or so, but that's only because the guy made it right there on the spot, no complaints. I was handed the plate with a napkin, smile and a metal fork and knife. I proceeded to eat my lunch outside at the table like a gentleman. I recommend yummy gyro and will be back.
Wow after I tried yummy gyro at Port Washington I wanted to see if there is any difference between this one but let me tell you that there is no difference at all absolutely amazed by the food and service very delicious highly recommended
Cute spot. I thought it was waiter service but it’s not. It’s self service…. It’s a nice spot for a quick bite.
Wow after I tried yummy gyro at Port Washington I wanted to see if there is any difference between this one but let me tell you that there is no difference at all absolutely amazed by the food and service very delicious highly recommended
Cute spot. I thought it was waiter service but it’s not. It’s self service…. It’s a nice spot for a quick bite.
Catered from Yummy Gyro for a party of 40 people and everyone loved it. Nesi made it super easy to place the catering order. We had tzatziki dips, spanakopita, zucchini fritters, two types of salads (villager was a hit) chicken skewers, beef and lamb shawarma, broccoli rice and pitas. The food arrived piping hot as well so easy to keep warm in warming trays before people dove in. Will definitely be ordering from again.
I stopped in for lunch and ordered a Greek wrap. The Greek wrap took 5 minutes or so, but that's only because the guy made it right there on the spot, no complaints. I was handed the plate with a napkin, smile and a metal fork and knife. I proceeded to eat my lunch outside at the table like a gentleman. I recommend yummy gyro and will be back.
Best cheeseburgers and fries around. So tasty.... and the gyros are quite yummy as well. One of my favorite local places. Owner is very nice as well Can't wait for yummy taco 🌮to open Oh don't forget the baklava on the way out. Yum!
Food was really solid, great portions and quality. Service could use some help, definitely need to be kinder towards customers.
Amazing Food and Service chicken gyro great w fries
Amazing Food and Service chicken gyro great w fries
Food was really solid, great portions and quality. Service could use some help, definitely need to be kinder towards customers.
Stopped by after work and got a lamb/beef gyro. It was truly delicious. Will be stopping by again. Best pricing for fresh food made right in front of you.
Best cheeseburgers and fries around. So tasty.... and the gyros are quite yummy as well. One of my favorite local places. Owner is very nice as well Can't wait for yummy taco 🌮to open Oh don't forget the baklava on the way out. Yum!
Very good spot for Mediterranean bites and I always get their juicy Souvlakis. Nice neighborhood with ample private lot.
Good family of two deal. $40 for rice, lamb/chicken/pork meat, two pitas, a green salad, and lemon potatoes.
Great food nice people reasonable priced nice platters I had gyro platter lemon potatoes salad pita bread tzatziki sauce nice size platter for 14 dollars home made ice tea only 2 tables and widiw counter fresh food plenty Of delivery and take out orders
Very good spot for Mediterranean bites and I always get their juicy Souvlakis. Nice neighborhood with ample private lot.
Good family of two deal. $40 for rice, lamb/chicken/pork meat, two pitas, a green salad, and lemon potatoes.
Great food nice people reasonable priced nice platters I had gyro platter lemon potatoes salad pita bread tzatziki sauce nice size platter for 14 dollars home made ice tea only 2 tables and widiw counter fresh food plenty Of delivery and take out orders
The food is great. Delicious and reasonably priced. Not really a sit and eat kind of place. Order your food to go.
My most favorite meal is the "Family Style Whole Rotisserie Chicken Special". Meal includes a whole chicken, salad, rice and grilled vegetables which are good for 4 people. Price is very good too, $24. Chicken is full of flavor and juicy. Sweet potato fries is also my choice. I did try the individual wrap but it had too much meat for my taste. The delivery usually took too long to come but recently it has been improved.
The food is great. Delicious and reasonably priced. Not really a sit and eat kind of place. Order your food to go.
My most favorite meal is the "Family Style Whole Rotisserie Chicken Special". Meal includes a whole chicken, salad, rice and grilled vegetables which are good for 4 people. Price is very good too, $24. Chicken is full of flavor and juicy. Sweet potato fries is also my choice. I did try the individual wrap but it had too much meat for my taste. The delivery usually took too long to come but recently it has been improved.
Their food is great, but they need to be better at checking their online orders. On multiple occasions I’ve placed my order online and paid for it, wait the time I’m told to pick up my foot, only to get there 30 plus minutes and my order has not even been entered to be made. It’s then rushed, things are missing or undercooked, and it’s unfortunate because I really do enjoy their food. If online ordering is too difficult to keep up with, then maybe do away with it.
Their food is great, but they need to be better at checking their online orders. On multiple occasions I’ve placed my order online and paid for it, wait the time I’m told to pick up my foot, only to get there 30 plus minutes and my order has not even been entered to be made. It’s then rushed, things are missing or undercooked, and it’s unfortunate because I really do enjoy their food. If online ordering is too difficult to keep up with, then maybe do away with it.
I ordered a chicken platter for $20. The platter was advertised coming with a side of pita and salad. I received a pile of dry chicken and potatoes with nothing else. The zucchini pancakes tasted bad. Potatoes were good. The baklava said “serves 10” and we received 3 small pieces. They were subpar. Overall very unhappy with my meal. Will not go back.
Small mainly take out place. Outside sitting available if weather permits so you can eat there. Good food but a busy kitchen and understaffed. They need more help. We waited 40 minutes for our food as there appeared to be only two people helping all those waiting for take out as well as eat in.
I ordered a chicken platter for $20. The platter was advertised coming with a side of pita and salad. I received a pile of dry chicken and potatoes with nothing else. The zucchini pancakes tasted bad. Potatoes were good. The baklava said “serves 10” and we received 3 small pieces. They were subpar. Overall very unhappy with my meal. Will not go back.
Small mainly take out place. Outside sitting available if weather permits so you can eat there. Good food but a busy kitchen and understaffed. They need more help. We waited 40 minutes for our food as there appeared to be only two people helping all those waiting for take out as well as eat in.
Don't order the soup unless you enjoy chicken skin, plastic and bones in it. We have ordered from here for years and the last few times have been underwhelming. Tonight was upsetting.
Don't order the soup unless you enjoy chicken skin, plastic and bones in it. We have ordered from here for years and the last few times have been underwhelming. Tonight was upsetting.
The food at Yummy Gyro tastes fine — the gyros and platters are generally fresh and flavorful, and the portions are decent. However, there’s a major caution: I’ve noticed extra charges on the bill. While the food itself is enjoyable, the billing process can be tricky. It’s important to double-check your receipt before paying, line by line, to make sure you’re not being charged for items you didn’t order. If you keep an eye on the bill, your visit should be fine, but it’s a bit frustrating to have to be so careful. Bottom line: Tasty food, but be vigilant when paying.
Food has always been decent but they’ve cut back on portions. My super gyro had literally only slice of avocado lol. But what earned this 1 star was watching the woman chef on 3/2 using the same gloves as she’s cooking with.. go up to the register and touch her dirty phone cable and charge her phone. That’s a health code violation. Imagine what we don’t see
I've been ordering food here for a couple of years. Today, my brother received a 10% coupon and tried to use it in person. The owner did not accept the coupon despite it clearly meeting the terms of our order. On top of that, he started to yell and say that "he needs to pay rent somehow." Certainly, not respecting your customer base is not going to help pay rent. Upon speaking with some friends, many of us have had similar experiences with the owner. This isn't an isolated incident at all, and their coupon policy is pretty much all fake. Should probably check it out with the BBB or something. I highly recommend checking out jimmys gyro in carle place, or opa grille. The food is better quality, cheaper, and the staff is respectful.
Save your money and don’t go here. Ordered a gyro sandwich. Was told it wasn’t ready, waited 15 min and then asked again if my order was ready.. I was given a gyro that was sitting there the entire time. When I confront them about it, I got an attitude by the bald guy. The entire bald guy was talking to the cashier and clearly not paying attention to his duty. While waiting, another customer had ordered a gyro sandwich and was given a platter instead. He had to wait an extra 10 minutes to fix the order. Finally got my one gyro after 25 min of waiting and got an attitude as I was leaving. Again. Highly recommend not going here. Try grill mark instead
I've been ordering food here for a couple of years. Today, my brother received a 10% coupon and tried to use it in person. The owner did not accept the coupon despite it clearly meeting the terms of our order. On top of that, he started to yell and say that "he needs to pay rent somehow." Certainly, not respecting your customer base is not going to help pay rent. Upon speaking with some friends, many of us have had similar experiences with the owner. This isn't an isolated incident at all, and their coupon policy is pretty much all fake. Should probably check it out with the BBB or something. I highly recommend checking out jimmys gyro in carle place, or opa grille. The food is better quality, cheaper, and the staff is respectful.
Save your money and don’t go here. Ordered a gyro sandwich. Was told it wasn’t ready, waited 15 min and then asked again if my order was ready.. I was given a gyro that was sitting there the entire time. When I confront them about it, I got an attitude by the bald guy. The entire bald guy was talking to the cashier and clearly not paying attention to his duty. While waiting, another customer had ordered a gyro sandwich and was given a platter instead. He had to wait an extra 10 minutes to fix the order. Finally got my one gyro after 25 min of waiting and got an attitude as I was leaving. Again. Highly recommend not going here. Try grill mark instead
The food at Yummy Gyro tastes fine — the gyros and platters are generally fresh and flavorful, and the portions are decent. However, there’s a major caution: I’ve noticed extra charges on the bill. While the food itself is enjoyable, the billing process can be tricky. It’s important to double-check your receipt before paying, line by line, to make sure you’re not being charged for items you didn’t order. If you keep an eye on the bill, your visit should be fine, but it’s a bit frustrating to have to be so careful. Bottom line: Tasty food, but be vigilant when paying.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Cornerstone Pub & Restaurant
Food Court Korea
Starbucks
Wendy's
Luigi's Pizzeria
Brendos
Yummy Tacos
Jonathan’s Restaurant
Sushi Republic
Miraj Healthy Grill
Gallery
No photos available
Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places
About Yummy Gyro
How to get there
579 Willis Ave, Williston Park, NY 11596
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
579 Willis Ave, Williston Park, NY 11596
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
park in the United States of America
park in the United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Yummy Gyro and other restaurants
Earn Points at Yummy Gyro!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Yummy Gyro
🏆 Rewards at Yummy Gyro
10% Discount
At Yummy Gyro
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu