Aman Chabra

Stopped in for lunch on our way home from the YMCA-Snow Mountain Ranch, and everything about this place was excellent! We came in with a BIG group of 3 families with quite a few little kids, and we were greeted, seated, and fully taken care of! We didn't order anything exotic...just some cheese sticks, and a few large cheese and pepperoni pizzas, and we drank waters. BUT... everything about our experience was AWESOME! The cheesy bread was fresh, perfectly cooked, and the marinara dipping sauce perfect, as well. Once the pizzas came out, they were also very well cooked, totally hit the spot for our big group! Right before we left, one staff member offered us a 4th of July special with complimentary small scoops of ice cream for the kids, which was the perfect way to end our experience! The place also has big screen TVs and was showing extreme sports on TV which was surprisingly an entertaining way for my youngest daughter to pass the time while we waiting for our food. The music selection was also very good as well! If you're in Winter Park and looking for a place with a cool vibe, friendly staff, and great food, make sure to stop by this place!

Keith

Wonderful takeout experience. Everything was really delicious. The margarita pizza is so good with the cherry tomatoes, balsamic glaze, and fresh basil. Such an amazing cheese pull from the jumbo cheese sticks, we couldn’t fit it all in the picture. The fettuccine alfredo also came with a complementary piece of bread.

Kristin M Scott

Absolutely phenomenal service and outstanding food. Legit the best pizza in Winter Park. Also, I highly recommend the wings, and meatballs!!! Vibe is super casual, decent beers on tap, hippy/old school ski vibe. Come check it out!!!

Colin Piaskowski (HTA Colin)

Cool place with good music. Got two pizzas for the price of one. Both were chicken specialty pizzas and were good. Live bluegrass music the night we were there. Very busy but still got our food quickly.

+1

Alex

Landed at this pizza bar after a long ski day and we were blown away by this hidden gem. Dustin gave us some food suggestions and great conversations, and the bar service was 10/10. The pizza was great, and the cheese sticks were even better. Will absolutely be returning!

David Zappa

You go out to eat for an experience. Alchemy will give you an experience that is exceptional, local, and won't kill your wallet. The food was delicious and noticeably homemade. You can taste the difference between frozen pre made and what I was served today. Obviously homemade, fresh to order and made with love (Go for the meatballs) . The ambiance is fun, welcoming , unique and authentic. The staff was extremely friendly, attentive and showed genuine care throughout the whole experience. Chris, Hippie and Hansen all had a hand in making my time here unforgettable. If you want the best of authentic local cuisine, amazing service ,all at a reasonable price this is your place.

The great things about this place are: Friendly and fantastic service! The atmosphere was energetic. It was comfortable and clean. The not-so-great thing is that two of four pizza slices were undercooked inside. Also, I understand the crust we ordered should be crispy and dark brown, but it was too charred for our taste. I could have told them, but I had already eaten the half that was cooked, and we were in a hurry. I’m hoping this isn’t usually how their pizza is cooked, so I’ll go again someday, order the same, and see what happens.

Bob Mitchell

Seems like a fun spot with very nice people. Ordered some pick up and thought the pizza was good not great. We did like the cheese head bread which is pictured.

JASON BURBACH

I visited Alchemy on an off night, and while the wings I ordered were fantastic, the pizza had some issues. The crust of the pizza was charred, and the bottom crust was undercooked. Since the BBQ restaurant owned by the same people is great, I suspect this was just a one-time mistake. I’ll be back soon.

Melissa

Ordered takeout excited to try a place new to us since last we were in town. Showed up when told pizza would be ready. After waiting 1/2 hour and asking, found out pizzas had been ready for unknown amount of time sitting under warmers and not alerted. So pizza not warm when we ate. Carnivore was good, duck very good…but the Detroit style was burned to the point we had to remove all crust and edge cheese. So a very mixed review on all fronts.

White Buffalo

Alright you know me I’m honest about my food so here’s my review of Alchemy pizza 🍕 in Frazier Colorado! The .5 mile I had to walk just to get to the place was kind of a let down as parking is minimal. The place is a decent vibe though nice tapestry and good wall art and the guy working the counter was freaking awesome! Now let’s get to the price of the pizza $22 for a 12 inch two topping pizza holy shit they are taxing not a big deal though right as long as the pizza is loaded and has good amount of topping especially for $3 a topping. That’s where the let down hits you literally get one little mushroom piece and one pepperoni on each piece like really $3 a topping and that’s what you give hmmm 🤔 won’t be back solely due to the price and how awful they top a pizza! Now to the actuall taste of the pizza it has a real good flavor overall about a 6.5-7 but with the walk and how expensive for how terrible of a put together pizza I’m gonna aim towards an overall 4 or 5/10 for this spot definitely try any other pizza joint if up here anything has to be better. But don’t let it take from the guy who was really kind at the front your still the man!