Smith Street Pizza

Love this spot! Not your average slice joint, this is real deal authentic pizza, don’t forget arancini, pastas and the rest. Clean, cute vibe, great guys behind the counter. A new go to!

Best best pizza I’ve had in a long time! Cheese is just right not too watery or anything it’s just right! Thin crust slices and their options are plenty. Rolls Chicken or Sausage are the bomb! Nice lil yard in the back menu above the wall is clear and very good. The owner classic ITALIAN from Brooklyn Downtown and he’s all business but really cool. Hires Latinos and treats them well - speaks to them in Spanish like a cool boss should!

Grandma slices are very tasty! Sauce is flavorful!! Nice crunch. Folks who work there are really nice and down to earth. Love this place!

Best pizza in New York! Ate here every day of our holidays! Thank you Caesar for making our pizza nights so much fun!! Vodka pizza was our family favourite :)

Jimmy Liang

Happened upon this pizza joint just because we were in the area this past summer and payed another visit this week. Just as good as I remembered—crust was crispy, cheese was gooey, toppings were generous and delicious! I personally love their mushroom slice, but the jalapeño chicken slice is 🔥too (in both sense of the word)! Before this place becomes too popular to sit for a slice at 5pm on a Friday, this spot is going up there for the best slices in BK awards. Try it, you’ll know what I mean!

dan73nyc Alvarado

The cleanest Pizzaria that I've ever been! Quality of the dough is superb! My son and I don't understand why there's no line!!! It blows L"Industria Pizza away to the Moon!

Alex

Simplicity can sometimes be perfection. Been to all the pizza joints in the area, and SSP blows them all away with their quality and pricing. Slices are fresh, and you can tell the pies are made with passion. I’d go as far as saying they’re making some of the best NYC style pizza in the city.

Andrew Dabydeen

Delicious pizza, fair prices, and quality ingredients - what else can you ask for? Came here after hearing some great things and was pleasantly surprised! There’s tons of options to choose from but everything looked great. Would highly recommend if you’re looking for a slice in the area.

Corey Dugan

Perfect by the slice place, bottom is nicely charred and the sauce has a ton of delicious sweet flavor. I got a slice of pepperoni but there were lots of choices. Can’t wait to go back and try the Sicilian. New fav spot in the neighborhood!

Brian Kennedy

I’ve been twice. First time was a Sunday around 1230pm and the slices were fresh, decent amount of people there. (UPDATE: NOW CLOSED ON SUNDAYS). Second time was 2pm on a Tuesday and the slices were just as fresh. Buffalo chicken is my favorite (crown jewel) . I’ve also gotten the marg slice with burrata which is delicious. Garlic knots come in orders of 3 for $2. They’re not small and come with a marinara to dip, so I plan to get an order each time I go. Buff chicken, marg slice with burrata (pic attached) and garlic knots with marinara to dip - $13 Delicious, not too thin but not overly fluffy crust/dough. Might be time for me to try something other than the pizza, but the pizza won’t disappoint. Update: still fire. Typically people post updates if something has changed - this update is to tell you that nothing has changed. If anything, Smith Street Pizza has gotten stronger. Since my initial review, I also added the vodka slice to my rotation. If you are lucky enough to pop in when that’s available, buy it. From my latest pic, it appears they’ve adjusted the Buffalo chicken slice by adding scallions. No complaints.

E Beck

The pizza and wings were really really good. FYI male sure you get the Mike's hot honey on the pizza. Game changer. The owner was amazing too.

Bill Konves

Great pie. 👍 the place is very clean. The selection of by the slice is amazing. Recommended for a slice of pizza so I bet the other things on the menu are excellent.

Michael Fuller

Great pizza spot right on Smith. Been waiting for this place to open for months and it was worth the wait. Everything was fresh and the staff was great. I live pretty close by so this will be my go to spot. Pizza Adventures: Destination #156

Julian Cuapio

I passed by with my son on Friday before taking him to watch “Five nights at Freddy”. My son wanted to get a small pizza to fit his “Freddy Fazbear” box he got from NYCC. The pizza guy Victor made it happen. The pizza looked great and was delicious. Thank you victor so much for making my son’s day. Will definitely come back again.

Anna Ciccarello

Love this spot! Not your average slice joint, this is real deal authentic pizza, don’t forget arancini, pastas and the rest. Clean, cute vibe, great guys behind the counter. A new go to!

Joe Ruiz

Best best pizza I’ve had in a long time! Cheese is just right not too watery or anything it’s just right! Thin crust slices and their options are plenty. Rolls Chicken or Sausage are the bomb! Nice lil yard in the back menu above the wall is clear and very good. The owner classic ITALIAN from Brooklyn Downtown and he’s all business but really cool. Hires Latinos and treats them well - speaks to them in Spanish like a cool boss should!

George Anthony

Extremely great underrated pizza in New York City. This place deserves to be on the list with the best.

Ariel

Grandma slices are very tasty! Sauce is flavorful!! Nice crunch. Folks who work there are really nice and down to earth. Love this place!

Delicious! We've tried a lot of pizza, and this one hits top five! Perfect crunchy bottom, good sauce and cheese! It is what we love! Go!

Renee Frye

Delicious! We've tried a lot of pizza, and this one hits top five! Perfect crunchy bottom, good sauce and cheese! It is what we love! Go!

Kimberly Campbell-Taylor

Great pizza, heros and service. Stopped by and really needed a slice of authentic pizza before my ride to Orange County and this place did not disappoint. Pepperoni slice was delicious and ordered a few parmigiana hero’s to take home to the family. Everyone enjoyed them. Will definitely return.

As I continue my unofficial Pizza Tour of NYC, I came upon Smith Street Pizza in Cobble Hill. There are some other main stays in the neighborhood but I wanted to give this spot a go. I usually opt for a Pepperoni slice as a barometer, but I also was craving a specialty slice with more substance. I decided to go with the Buffalo Chicken slice. Must say it was one of the better ones I have had. Plentiful amount of chicken. Great balance between Buffalo sauce and blue cheese sauce. The chicken was juicy and the crust itself was crispy with a bit of chew. A well executed slice! Would definitely try again when I'm back in Cobble Hill

Nice little pizza joint with an upscale feel. They have good aracini and thin slice (soft chewy crust) with a generous amount of cheese, 8-10 options for by slice and tons of options for salad, pasta, appetizers, aracini etc. Prices are normal ($3-$6 per slice) but you may need to get 2 slices as the slices are slightly smaller. They have a good amount of indoor seating and restrooms.

Tony Del Pino

As I continue my unofficial Pizza Tour of NYC, I came upon Smith Street Pizza in Cobble Hill. There are some other main stays in the neighborhood but I wanted to give this spot a go. I usually opt for a Pepperoni slice as a barometer, but I also was craving a specialty slice with more substance. I decided to go with the Buffalo Chicken slice. Must say it was one of the better ones I have had. Plentiful amount of chicken. Great balance between Buffalo sauce and blue cheese sauce. The chicken was juicy and the crust itself was crispy with a bit of chew. A well executed slice! Would definitely try again when I'm back in Cobble Hill

Alan Varghese

Nice little pizza joint with an upscale feel. They have good aracini and thin slice (soft chewy crust) with a generous amount of cheese, 8-10 options for by slice and tons of options for salad, pasta, appetizers, aracini etc. Prices are normal ($3-$6 per slice) but you may need to get 2 slices as the slices are slightly smaller. They have a good amount of indoor seating and restrooms.

Pizza is fine. Not good, not bad. Also, not cheap! Why people think it's great is a mystery to me.

Pizza was fine! But do not order delivery from here. They will leave your food in the floor of the entryway to your building. Photo the delivery driver sent me. Leaving it in an unsanitary place is unacceptable. Photo from the delivery person. I also called the restaurant several times last night to try and get an ETA for our order and no one ever picked up the phone.

James Brochhausen

Pizza was fine! But do not order delivery from here. They will leave your food in the floor of the entryway to your building. Photo the delivery driver sent me. Leaving it in an unsanitary place is unacceptable. Photo from the delivery person. I also called the restaurant several times last night to try and get an ETA for our order and no one ever picked up the phone.

was a regular here but the customer service has been absolutely terrible recently : i asked for a box for 2 slices of pizza since i also got fries and a soda which i was going to have to carry back to my job but the worker just kept telling me “no” after i witnessed him hand a small box to the customer before me he kept telling me the box is too big and i said you just handed a small box to the customer before me and he insisted on saying no. if he had told me i don’t have anymore small boxes i would have understood but it felt like he was just didn’t want to repackage the slices into a box. For 6 dollars a slice you could give a box . Extremely rude guy this isn’t the first time he gives attitude

Salma Hassan

was a regular here but the customer service has been absolutely terrible recently : i asked for a box for 2 slices of pizza since i also got fries and a soda which i was going to have to carry back to my job but the worker just kept telling me “no” after i witnessed him hand a small box to the customer before me he kept telling me the box is too big and i said you just handed a small box to the customer before me and he insisted on saying no. if he had told me i don’t have anymore small boxes i would have understood but it felt like he was just didn’t want to repackage the slices into a box. For 6 dollars a slice you could give a box . Extremely rude guy this isn’t the first time he gives attitude