Oscar Rivera

The lady's that work there are awesome. They always come check how you're doing and service was pretty fast the day I went to dine in. Pizza taste great, it reminded me of Shakey's pizza. Thick, fluffy, cheesy 🍕. I also got the cheeseburger calzon and it taste similar to in and out because of the 1000 island sauce.

Hugo

Really love going here. The pizza is phenomenal, really thick pizza. The best part of it is the cheese that they put on it. I've been here almost every time the family is craving pizza. As well as the wings, they have such a variety of flavors.

+2

Kbizzle_143

Wow talk about great pizza 🍕🍕. Was so delicious 😋,cool location with a classic rustic feel. They do more than pizza 🍕 just so you know. Burgers 🍔 sandwich 🥪 calzone pasta 🍝 and they have a salad 🥗 bar. I will definitely be going back to this spot. 🤜🏽🤛🏽💥💯

+19

David McCall

First time ordering from Nick's Pizzeria. Can't say it tasted bad, but it did not meet my expectations after reading other reviews. For me, it fell flat at the sauce. Although it had flavor, I couldn't discern a garlic or Italian flavor, which is something I come to expect. The cheese was abundant, and the pepperoni was tasty and crispy. We also had an Alfredo pizza, which also fell flat on flavor. Chicken was OK, and the crust crispy. Overall, next time, if there is a next time, I would try a sandwich, not the pizza.

TheBlak CircleGirl

Hubby has been going here since the first location was open. This was my first time. We had the calzone and (medium)cheese sticks. So so good! Like enough for 2 meals each! My one complaint was the bathroom. It's like all the good pizza smells went in there to die! Oy. Also the decor is very outdated but reminds me of other chain pizza places when I was a kid.

Tracy Anne Payne

We ordered Nick's pizza, Roundup is our favorite the service was great the pizza was good lots and lots of cheese on it and lots of good toppings but the crust is weird it's like it's wheat with ground seeds or something like that I didn't like it at all. Why did they change it???

Mike Meyers

If you order a pizza I would suggest you ask for light cheese. My kids couldn’t even hold the pizza up without the weight of the cheese flopping it all over their plates. Pizza tasted great otherwise. Servers seemed overwhelmed when they only had 6 booths or tables to tend towards. Atmosphere needs a little help especially the kids area.

Josue Corral

I rarely write reviews, but I need to document this. As someone who loves to cook, I hate going out and paying a premium for food that I could make better at home. Unfortunately, Nick’s Pizza just confirmed why I usually prefer my own kitchen. We started with the "Nick’s Sticks" because of the hype, but they were a letdown. While the crust itself was good, the topping just tasted like "cheese fat" on butter. There was no real flavor profile or identity—just grease. The "Nick's Special" pizza was the biggest disappointment. To me, a pizza needs sauce—enough that you can actually see it when you lift the cheese. That wasn't the case here; it was extremely dry. Stranger still, they put raw bell peppers on top of the cooked toppings, so when I picked up a slice, the peppers and mushrooms just tumbled off. The crust had a nice stiffness, but the meats were bland. The pepperoni had zero spice, and the other meats lacked flavor entirely. We also tried the meatball grinder, which was completely flavorless. I don't need to say more than that. The only saving grace was the wings—crispy with the sauce baked on perfectly. But honestly? I hate to say it, but for the price and flavor, Little Caesars beats this. I regret spending the money here.

Ed Callahan

Our pizza had next to no sauce. We let our server know and she said that's how they come. What? Sadly we won't be coming back here.

I used to like this place. I called to order pizza for pickup. A lady answered and put me on hold for a bit. When she was taking my order she didnt know that nicks had a nicks white pizza. 3 times I had to tell her she did. Then I started naming the ingredients off my head of what it was and she said I know what it is now. I told her importantly about sauce. This is key to the story. I picked up the pizza and they told me to look. It looked ok but the white pizza seemed off however its not the pizza I usually get for myself. It was for family back at home. When i got home, everyone did have a slice of the white pizza because the cheese looked off. It was slathered with cheese. Immediately upon bitting it, it was gross. No sauce what so ever. The next pizza barely any sauce, and it tasted meh. Barely any flavor. I called and talked to Manager Patty. I told her of the problem and was told the lady talking on the phone was new. I told the lady she got my order wrong because I wanted sauce and specifically mentioned it. One pizza had none and the other very little. As the conversation kept going on about how it was my fault, I said i wanted a refund. She told me no repeadtly. She gave me no other options like we can remake it for you. She protected the mistake of the new hire and made me the customer feel like crap. The manager made a big deal that I looked at the pizza when I was there. So PSA Take a BITE of your pizza and fully inspect it. Also pizza was lukewarm at best. Ill never go here again. My days of this pizza are over. Im going elsewhere. I did not name the new worker as its a mistake but Patty is not nice.

Raynell Yarbough

My family dinner tonight from this restaurant was absolutely horrible and extremely disappointing. Let’s start with the crust as you can see is burned, dry and extremely hard. Very little cheese and in some spots none at all. The sauce was cooked down in the crust. These 3 pizzas have a very thin layer of cheese, burned, over cooked and dry dough. Only half of each slice was partially ok. I ordered 3 large pizzas that costed me $76.00 what a waste This is a picture of 1 of the 3 large pizzas I called to complain and that too was a complete waste of time. This restaurant lost my family business

Sammy Hagan

Ordered a well done Alfredo pizza with artichokes added . Also asked for it to be well done but the pizza cant even be eaten due to all the toppings just sliding off onto the plate as soon as you pick it up . For the price this pizza should be perfect and made in a way that can be actually eaten. They couldnt even bother to slice the onions correctly. I have literally slabs of onion . WORST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD!! Ordering from Dominos would have been a better choice!!

Gladys Ortiz

If I could rate this 0 stars I would. I tried to give the place a chance the buffet was cold pizza is so soggy paid $30 for nothing. Came back ordered a custom large pizza and wings.. I got there early made me wait 5-10 minutes I got home and the pizza was soggy and cold had to reward it up. Started to eat the wings and they were not even warm. I called and they could do was 10% off my next order. $2.50 off my next order? I would not recommend at all. $50 down the drain.