I was skeptical to try West Point Pizza, as I'd heard from others that their pizza was okay but not the greatest. That was completely false. Parking may be a little difficult at times, and you'll walk into West Point Pizza to find that it's a very small storefront, with seating for maybe 10-15 total, a small drinks selection cooler, and a small showcase. I ordered Plain, Chicken Bacon Ranch, and Buffalo. The plain was decent. Decently sauced & cheese'd. Cooked well, not burnt out over done, but not super doughy either. The chicken bacon ranch was outstanding, perfect blend between the 3. Added a little ranch on top for a little extra. Was done well, again, not over cooked or burnt, not super doughy either. The same applies to the Buffalo slice. Amazing. It's not too spicy, not too bland, perfect radio. Again, I added some ranch to the top for that little extra flavor. While I was not a fan of the plain slice, I absolutely enjoyed the specialty slices that I got, and I have to say, in my opinion, way better than the competitors in town. I've been back multiple times, and it's been the same consistently.

Matvey Vikhrov

Ordered 10+ times for delivery and pickup. Never any issues. Pizza is good

Rick Nocella

Brought our grandson back to West Point and this is the third time we’ve been there. We’re from Long Island and I have to say his pizza is some of the best I’ve ever tasted. It’s a small place I think 3 of 4 tables but the pizza is worth it.

Laura Kelly

We take a pizza out weekly . Hidden secret and we share this with all our friends we always order a bunch of small pizza because the crust always tastes the best for us! We love having own little pizza it’s so perfect !

Jill Quigg

We just moved to the area and have tried several pizza joints. This is the best one we've had! The crust is thin, but not floppy. It has just the right amount to crispness. It also wasnt too salty. We bought stromboli as well and it was delicious. We will visit again!

Joe Thomas

New England style pizza (I think they call it that so as not to offend neighboring states). Thin crust but still chewy. Fast service, even for those who just walked in.

+4

Guadalupe Solano

You gotta give this place credit. I have been coming here for quiet some time and they seem to always be open late for a late night meal, and I’ve also noticed that they are dedicated to staying open during extreme weather (snow/flooding). they make deliveries super convenient! I appreciate the counter staff as they’re always pleasant, but have also utilized their online ordering system (easy to navigate) their pizza has a nice crust and they don’t skimp out on the toppings, & my personal favorite is their thick Sicilian slice, perfect breading! so glad this place is around.

Ask Miss Patience

Growing up in Brooklyn and living abroad accept Imma pizza snob. This said, finding places around the country or even NY isn’t always easy. Often must accept unique cheese pies and for sure this place makes them. Been ordering here for decades when visiting family. It’s delicious. In my view. Perfect for not being my favorite from Brooklyn. Only odd thing, even though near West Point Military Academy do not offer a veteran discount. It’s so affordable no complaints. Just found this odd considering this is a military town

LDH

Enjoyed lunch after my son completed west point SLE. We sat in the extra dining area, which turned out to be much cooler. Allowed us to spend more time with each other. The Salad was beautiful and so fresh. Have never had avocado chicken pizza- delicious. And the garlic parmesian wings-OMG!! Wish we lived here just so we could eat here more often.

Marc Maynard

We stopped here for a quick bite on our way out of town. It was Sunday afternoon and the area was very quiet. We only ordered two slices of pizza to go. The pizza is delicious!! I could taste the hint of basil on it and it was rocking. When I paid, I made an error. I intended to tip 20% and inadvertantly added 120%. I was not spending a lot either way. The man behind the counter noticed my mistake, brought it to my attention, and offered to make it right. That is the kind of place I want to do business with. Show these people some love and go buy pizza at West Point Pizza! I will definitely be back again.

+1