Scotty's Pizzeria and Restaurant

First time there, was very impressed! We got the Buffalo chicken pizza, awesome crust! The calamari was great even had tentacles which are our favorite and the penne ala vodka was delicious, perfectly cooked! We will be back for sure!

Delicious pizza, I’d recommend the white pizza!

The best Calamari we've had in a long time! Pizza rocks at this place as well!!

It makes me so happy to see so many local teens working here and doing such an amazing job. Christine and Scott are both great, they help support the community and their food is out of this world. Can I just say chicken tenders???? THE BEST AROUND! Yummy yummy pizza too.

Ordered from here for the very first time, and it is delicious! Got large half cheese, half sausage pizza to go. Only had to wait about 15 minutes. When I opened the box it already looked pretty good. When I took my first bite, that confirmed it! Definitely was worth the drive!

I love it there. The food is always delicious & the people are great....so much so that they will run my pickup order out to me when they have time and see me pull up. My local favorite!!

ValhallaVal

I love it there. The food is always delicious & the people are great....so much so that they will run my pickup order out to me when they have time and see me pull up. My local favorite!!

ZakkuTakku

Ordered from here for the very first time, and it is delicious! Got large half cheese, half sausage pizza to go. Only had to wait about 15 minutes. When I opened the box it already looked pretty good. When I took my first bite, that confirmed it! Definitely was worth the drive!

Valera Davis

Delicious pizza, I’d recommend the white pizza!

George Knarich

The best Calamari we've had in a long time! Pizza rocks at this place as well!!

chuck mccoy

Every time I go I always ask for the owner. He is a very hard worker with a great selection of subs, pizza, etc. Will return.

Ryan Lietaer

We ordered take-away dinner for 13 people including children, teenagers, parents and grandparents. We had 5 pizzas, salads, garlic knots and a chicken parm. My father and I went to pick up the food which wasn’t quite ready and so we enjoyed a nice cold beer while we waited. Everyone working at Scotty’s was so incredibly nice, we really enjoyed our short wait. Upon arriving home we all sat down to enjoy dinner and couldn’t believe how good each and every dish was; all of the food was incredible. My 15 yr old son maintains that it was the best pizza he’s ever had and no one disagreed. I strongly recommend visiting Scotty’s if you have the chance.

Janet Preston

Stopped by on Thursday night and there special was lasagna had you're choice of cheese or meat, salad and bread. It was delicious.Even had enough to take home. We have also tried the Calazones and Pizza and both were very good.

Mike Jacobsen

While up from DC, my family visited Scotty's after going to the fairground light show. The food was excellent and the staff and owner were very friendly. They made my son steamed broccoli upon request, an item not on the regular menu. The atmosphere was family-friendly and inviting. We will definitely come back.

NYFLDON

Good pizza and and garlic knots! My cousin and I had just finished work, hours later than expected, we happened to arrived just before they closed for the evening, and was hesitant to place an order that late. The staff happily took our order of pizza by the slice(s), and garlic knots. Maybe it was an easy order, but the staff showed no signs of frustration given the late order. Food was great, staff was great, not to mention the atmosphere...I had never been before and noticed a nice little bar, wishing I was out of work sooner so as to enjoy a beer. Thank you Scotty's staff!

Matthew Merritt

Really friendly staff and extremely great pizza. Their white pizza is one of the best I've ever had, because it has some of the best ricotta I've ever had. Have them add sausage and fresh basil to it - pizza heaven.

Gina Buttignol

First time there, was very impressed! We got the Buffalo chicken pizza, awesome crust! The calamari was great even had tentacles which are our favorite and the penne ala vodka was delicious, perfectly cooked! We will be back for sure!

Stacy Romaine

Great pizza - we all enjoyed it! Stayed at Gilbert Lake State Park recently and normally have ordered from a different local shop just because we always have. But they were closed this time, so we went with Scotty's, and are happy we did. One thing but not a complaint, none of the places around here seem to have sheet pizzas, I'm told that's maybe a regional thing more to my area near Rochester - would be a great addition when serving a crowd. We had to order 5 larges, which adds up a lot quick than 2 or 3 sheets, which are also cut in a more manageable size, usually. But I digress - the pizza was great and I daresay we may make this our new "usual" when we're at the park! :)

Lisa LaLonde

It makes me so happy to see so many local teens working here and doing such an amazing job. Christine and Scott are both great, they help support the community and their food is out of this world. Can I just say chicken tenders???? THE BEST AROUND! Yummy yummy pizza too.

Iduhonouduhowestcoast

Awesome pizza!!! Dough was on point light and thin great flavor had a slice of buff chicken perfect flavors! My buddy got pepperoni roll and loved it as well!! Definitely recommend!!

Good pizza and my co workers loved their antipastos but very cold in dining area

Everything about the pizza is good, the food isn’t the best but, don’t expect that in rural area. Edit for the owner: My family and I ordered wings, knots, and pizza the best part of the restaurant is the walk from my relatives house up near high street and west street. I’m not sure what you guys can improve on.

The food was very good. Authentic Italian. Our waitress was extremely nice and very friendly. Her second day on the job. We definitely will go back

Joseph “Joey” Pare

Good pizza and my co workers loved their antipastos but very cold in dining area

Michael McSain

The food was very good. Authentic Italian. Our waitress was extremely nice and very friendly. Her second day on the job. We definitely will go back

James Byler

Everything about the pizza is good, the food isn’t the best but, don’t expect that in rural area. Edit for the owner: My family and I ordered wings, knots, and pizza the best part of the restaurant is the walk from my relatives house up near high street and west street. I’m not sure what you guys can improve on.

if i could give this no stars i would.. Food is absolutely disgusting here not worth the 20$ meal at all. taste like water down bland runny food very disappointed…

Kim Potter

if i could give this no stars i would.. Food is absolutely disgusting here not worth the 20$ meal at all. taste like water down bland runny food very disappointed…

I've been here a few times, tried to give it a couple second chances, however I don't think I'll return again. The first time I went, I was very uncomfortable with how the owner (or manager?) speaks to his employees. Another time, there were kids running around with no shoes on. I'm not entirely sure of the restaurant's rules, but I'm almost positive you need shoes to enter and dine in. I wouldn't waste your time here, there is better pizza in the area!

Kate Lauren Mooney

I've been here a few times, tried to give it a couple second chances, however I don't think I'll return again. The first time I went, I was very uncomfortable with how the owner (or manager?) speaks to his employees. Another time, there were kids running around with no shoes on. I'm not entirely sure of the restaurant's rules, but I'm almost positive you need shoes to enter and dine in. I wouldn't waste your time here, there is better pizza in the area!