Not sure what to expect but blown away by the food and people. The pizza was delicious and my calzone was the best I've had. Cost was less than some of the "best pizza" places in NY. This is totally up there.

Delicious pizza thank you 🍕

I totally love the pizza here and the service is always fantastic. They have a few great options and the pizza is always served fresh straight from the oven.

Great pizza! Will give most shops a run for their money. I wish it was a bit cheaper but you can't skimp out on quality 👍🏾

Pizza so good I had no time to take a picture of it just this grape soda can.

Tasty and fresh. Top of the line service. In addition ample space to spread out to dine in. Not crowded which I appreciated immensely. A wide range of choices depending on your mood and preference.

Had Sicilian special, great deal, great food. I love pizza!

Great food. I know this is a pizza place but I would highly recommend trying their Caesar Salad, the dressing is a hidden gem. Thank me later.

The pizza was great and the service was fantastic. Nick was so friendly.

The pizza here is great ! The staff is courteous and the place clean. I enjoy coming every week.

The place is not too bad, is Good for quick bite...

Great slices and specials 🤑! Service is fast and super friendly. This a go-to spot when i'm working in the area.

Very very decent. Pizza, not very expensive, good selection of toppings. Nothing to blow your mind, but good to grab a slice

Excellent NY classic pizza. Delivered piping hot to our hotel in a timely manner. Would recommend to others.

Amazing pizza. Large space. Reasonably priced. Friendly. Clean dining room (and restroom!).

Great pizza with a lot of seating, for something quick (headed to work or just strolling by) it was really really good. Would definitely recommend this place

Great food, no-frills and quick service, and atmospheric 1960s era music and decor. Pizza is relatively cheap at $3.25 a slice. Everything feels very authentic and truly Italian. I'll definitely be visiting this establishment again during my time in New York.

best pizza i have had in nyc. and the staff was very kind.

One of the best casual pizzerias in the neighborhood. Really good NY cheese slice and staff are nice.

Pizza is absolutely delicious, the people who work there are so nice. Every time I call to order it's like they are personally excited to make a pizza for me. Delivery is incredibly fast and the pizza always shows up hot. Can't say enough good stuff abut them.

Great location. Plenty of seating. Lunch specials are priced right. Nice variety on menu. Calzone was hot and delicious. Lots of pizza choices by the slice or whole pie too.

We were visiting from Ireland and asked a doorman on park av where the best new york slice was, he put us in a cab to cassianos and wow was he right! My 9 year old is still talking about how good it was. 10/10

I am absolutely in love with this pizza. The slices are bigger than my face and taste great. I basically live for the Chicago style pizzas and I have tried every version that they have made. Will definitely recommend this place. Up next I need to try the pasta and paninis. Fyi: the paninis are huge as well, looks more like a sandwich rather than a panini.

The pizza tasted really nice with good quality cheese despite it looking dry, as soon as it was heated, it was back to its glory. Staff were super friendly too.

We were beat after a long day of site seeing. Later in the night we finally got hungry and just wanted pizza that would deliver. This place was EXTREMELY timely and delicious to boot. Ordered at 9:26 p.m., food at our door within 25 minutes. (2 personal 9" pies and an order of meatballs.)

I ❤️ different types of pizzas. And, they're ready-made, very fresh.

Great and extremely friendly staff , great place so sit down and enjoy quality pizza

Great place to get a slice. Had a loaded meat piece and a cheese. Both were very good-but the cheese was the star

I was stuck in traffic for over 5 hrs on 11/16/18 due to the unexpected snow. I was across the street from Cassiano's for over an hour, 8 months pregnant with gestational diabetes, alone and hungry. I called for a delivery and I explained my predicament. The gentleman that answered was sympathetic and took my number in case I moved by the time my order was done. When he called me back ... I was still in the same spot and was able to accept delivery of a delicious crispy chicken caesar wrap and a much needed bottle of water. Thank you guys for helping. It's greatly appreciated by both of us!👍🏾👶🏾🤗

Friendly staff and efficuent service. Clean and well maintained environment. Tasty delicious pizza. Overly pricey $3.50 for one slice plain cheese pizza.

People answering phones were a lil New York (Attitude) but hey Texas boy can overlook that ... the pizza was great and for my sixth time here I have had pizza all over NYC from midtown to Brooklyn to the Bronx.... it’s goood

This joint’s pizza is outstanding—a generous, evenly baked pie with delicious dough and a killer veggie medley on top. Totally authentic Italian vibes.

Lots of variety, plenty of seating. The pizza is actually very good. Tasty, with crunchy crusts, with generous portions and very well priced given the area.

Ordered the day before for 150 construction workers, they all really liked it! Ordering on the phone was easy and delivery went well. Great value as people said it was far better than the cheep pizza they usually get! They mad sure they gave us everything we needed including ice which people were so grateful for. Definitely recommended for any big pizza parties.

GO HERE!!!!!! 5 stars across the board! I had the best slice and roll I have ever had in many years as a NYC resident. It's a family owned operation, shout-outs to Nick for making me feel like I am a part of the family. Prices for midtown are really competitive, you can beat them for quality/price.

wrote this review before finishing this lasagna pizza... freaking incredible. would order again, same day even.

Has delicious pizza. Sauce has a good flavor! Cheese they use is very good.They will add more sauce & cheese if U wish(My husband's favorite) on the pizza or anything U want! Delivery people are good & friendly. All the items they have on the menu are tasty! Staff is friendly and get the orders correct!

Always a pleasure to come here whenever we're in Yonkers. Cassiano's pizza is the real deal, they make some damn good pizza. The staff is prompt and always out front to field any inquiries. We haven't found a good spot in Clifton, NJ yet that compares to Cassiano and we're not sure we will. If you're in Yonkers stop by. They also have an Italian restaurant attached to it next door.

GREAT PIZZA!! Our office is nearby and we ordered 10 pies and 3 salads at 11:00am on their website.. Everything showed up at 12 noon still very hot and Delicious. Best Pizza in Midtown, hands down. We will definitely be ordering Cassiano's again!!

Cassiano’s is the ultimate pizza of New York. The two cheese deal for 6.50, includes a drink. The cheese here is always fresh and I always see the workers making pizza. They aren’t normally busy, which is perfect for me since my pizza comes out quick and hot! The owners are friendly, the workers treat you with a smile, and an authentic New York attitude is apparent at the door. I recommend this place to anyone coming to the area.

I don’t right reviews often, but casianos has some of the best pizza around nyc. The specialty slices r delicious and the plain can compete with some of the best like lindustrie and Mama Toyo’s. But I think the highlight was the super respectful high energy manager Nicholas. I can’t say enough about how he runs casianos, he is second to none.

Best pizza in the City hands down. Food was hot and came out quickly. Owner was super friendly. Overall great experience would highly recommend checking out Cassianos.

Cool vibe and lots of seating. Pizza slices around $3.5-4.5. Family oriented/friendly.

On a cold Superbowl Sunday, Cassianos came in clutch!! So happy they decided to open today they absolutely saved me from cooking for 25 people I was hosting for a superbowl party. Try everything they have to offer here from the great NY style pizza to penne vodka, wings, chicken tenders and mozzarella sticks all were delicious and prepared expertly in catering trays with setup included. A1 Cassianos catering experience!

The best pizza in NYC ever. Its family owned and delicious pizza. As an Italian American, its hands down the best. Well... outside of Italy of course. Used to live around the corner from it. Also, lived in Rome for some time, and as far as US pizza is concerned, this place is amazing. It's not cheap, but not expensive. Do you want pizza! this is the place. Order out or pickup.

Danny R

The best penne pasta I have ever have. This place also have a really good pizza slice. Staff is great. Especially Nick.

Elena Ashurova

Very tasty pizza, polite staff, definitely worth a visit!

Saint

Not all NY slices are made equal. This right here is a great NY slice of pizza. Cheese to sauce ratio is always right (so far when I order), bread is toasty not over done.

Wendy C

Tasty hot pizza! Very affordable too, the drunk nonna slice slaps

Max Avery

Great pizza, great price - served hot and fresh - awesome music playlist too

William Sean

Phenomenal pizza shop. The service is absolutely tremendous. One of the young owners helped me and he could not have been more of a gentleman.

Stacey & Nick Martin

Great pizza! We had the Buffalo chicken, pepperoni and a cheese slice. Would definitely eat there again.

semajh bludson

Ive been going to cassiano's lately and now feel good enough to post this review today i tried the shrimp caesar wrap and it was so good the shrimp was nicely grilled lettuce nice and crisp and the wrap was not dripping in dressing! the fries are amazing as well fresh and crisp and the doughnut light airy and fluffy, my grandma / nonna slice was so good i forgot to snap it before i ate it so just imagine a perfectly crisp perfectly sauced fresh slice and you're there! lastly the customer service here is very good too! they're efficient , and the piece de resistance , and they have the 12 oz tall boy diet cokes! dont come running in here and buying them all up now please! Great job Cassiano's

A V

I’ve been coming here for years. I work close by and the food is always great and it’s a great value for your money. I’m a pizza lover and it’s the best pizza in the area BY FAR. Always fresh. Amazing customer service is the cherry on top that keeps bringing me back in.

Bruno Storchi Bergmann

I had a very good calzone here. I tried one with sausage, onions and tomato sauce. It was light on the dough, very meaty and tasty on the filling. Left me craving for more.. Went a second time, to be sure Cassiano's is the real deal: got a large piece of spinach and artichoke pizza, which amounted to 8 bucks with a bottle of Sprite included. The pizza was crunchy, and the toppings were tasty. For the price point, I don't think you'll find any better pizza in mid town Manhattan! I'll be trying the deep dish pizza next time.

Dawnydoo

Best pizza ever had in NYC! Friendly staff, fresh pizza, amazing range, reasonably priced .. definitely 10/10

Paola C

Deliciousssss. Nice place to get a slice of pizza. Great customer service. Bilingual (English -Spanish)

+1

Lancine Keita

I really love the deep dish Buffalo pizza, it's not for everyone but I'm addicted.

One of my favorite lunch places. All kinds of ready made pies w awesome toppings. Th in house menu is very tasty.

Pizza's really good (I'm 100% italian, living in Italy, pretty trustable) maybe some white paint around could help! But trust me... the pizza was great!

Omg this Pizza in the NYC was good. 😊 We got it delivered thru Grub hub. I wanted a Thick crust pizza. This was so good and very big. #Cassianos #Pizza #Vacationmode

I was in town for a Yankees game, after, we went downtown to catch a cab to Newark. I wanted some New York style pizza and it was around 4 oclock pm. We walked in, no one was in there but it was a Saturday afternoon, so I passed it off. I got a slice of cheese pizza, it was really good. Definitely what I wanted, a nice walk up to the counter, get a slice, dive-y kinda place. It really capped off my great trip to NYC.

Pretty darn good pizza, with a nice saltiness from its mixed cheese blend, and had a (though almost slightly bland once to the end) crisp crust. My veg slice was fresh (this place is busy) and loaded with chopped veg and extra sautéed mushrooms. Straightforward, classic, friendly.

When I’m in Manhattan, I don’t look to Google or Yelp to find pizza. I simply wait until I pass a pizza joint that gives me a good feeling. Got that feeling about Cassiano’s. The pizza was good, but not the best. The service was on point.

Really good selection of pizza .. the pasta isn't all that bad either but not the reason to go here. The actual restaurant itself is why I'm not giving it five stars.... it's a dump and not all that clean. However prices are good and the pizza itself is yummy ... A great slice place

The school kids are hanging out ,even though they're not buying food there, they take up the seats of buying customers. Beggers are constantly interrupting customers while they are eating. The food is great , and the prices are good.

Their pizza looks good, nice staff too, I don't know how it tastes though. Getting it as a thank you for some nice people in the block. I hope they like it.

Was it the best pizza of my life... maybe not. Was it yummy and perfect and cheap and fast? Yes. Yes it was.

Daniel Pino

Cassiano’s Pizza Layout/atmosphere *Two rooms of tables; TV; menu on video boards above display cases Service *Energetic cashier Food/drink *Regular slice - solid; no flop; decent crisp; little on the oily/greasy side (cheese tends to fall off the deeper you bite into the slice)

Joseph Vormittag

The service was excellent, and the location was convenient. The young man at the cash register was very friendly. I ordered 2 scicillian slices.

We had the three slices of pizza and two drinks and the pizza was really good and the crust was crunchy

The pizza is excellent. Everything else (caprese salad, chicken parmesan, pasta) tasted like Walmart great value products. I would order again but only pizza.

Great pizza, but poor pizza value. Medium thickness New York pizza crust with just the right amount of sauce. Try the calzone or delicious platters instead for a better value.

Solid slice but won't blow anyone's mind. Had two slices and a soda for $11. Lots of seating which is great!

$18 + for 4 slices. not the cleanest place. the pizza man was very friendly! Owner/Register guy on the phone while checking us out... less then personable...decent pie though.

Chicago slices were tasty. Loses a star for not having WiFi

Sam

Decent pizza but terrible service. New Yorker and used to handing the pizza manually but on the iPhone, not caring customers waiting, disregard for others around (speaking vulgar Spanish assuming others don’t understand). Dirty space and Bad service - don’t go here unless it’s 3 am.

Horrible customer service. The servers always have attitudes here. I really dont expect wonderful tasting pizza in this area, but judging from this well known midtown neighborhood you would think people would have excellent customer service and not act like your a bother when asking simple questions.

Very bad food very bad service very bad guys working in the pizza store they cursing costomers very bad manners never go to this pizza store new yorkers never go to this places with this kind of bad environment rude attitude with tourists

The staff in this place is SO RUDE. What I ordered was not what I expected, so when I called to ask for something different, they yelled at me, refused to do anything and were plain nasty. Ill never order from here and quite frankly, neither should you. Also, the pizza was falling apart, and soggy by the time I got it.

The young guy working there is very rude and has terrible communication and customer service. Made me never want to return again

This place just lost my business. The first time I ordered from here I got the pepperoni calzone and it was amazing. This time however, it was soggy and cold and unbelievably underwhelming. The mozzarella sticks were terrible too. One of the sticks didn't even have cheese in it! And then the delivery time was 20 minutes AFTER the delivery window. Just awful all around. I'm upset that my money was literally wasted, because this food isn't edible.

I had a very experience tonight the guys was actually I would never go back!!!!

My family had a terrible experience. The counter staff was beyond rude. One of our chicken heroes was under cooked and all three sandwiches were mostly just bread and sauce with very little meat. Horrendous. I regret that we did not walk out after being treated so viciously. But with hungry kids in tow... I regrettably stayed.

A negative 10 stars!!!!!!! $50 for two slices of regular and a bottle of corona, is this some kind of joke here? Pizza tasted like it’s from two days ago, you should shoot yourselves

First and for most I had to choose 1 star in order to leave a review if not they would have gotten -5. I have given this establishment several opportunities only because there aren't many options in my neighborhood for pizzerias that are open late. I usually don't post reviews but, when it comes to this place every time I visit this place I've had a bad experience. I went in this evening to order a chicken parm hero for my son and I noticed as I placed my order to the cook and requested for the cheese to be well done he seemed rather annoyed right off the back. Didn't make no eye contact with me and didn't even acknowledge my request. I sat down with my 9 yr old son and waited for my order and after 15 min I noticed that there was an order just sitting on the counter. I asked the older gentleman at the counter who took my payment "If my order was ready". Once again I once greeted with no verbal communication and was just given a hand gesture pointing to the counter where the bag was sitting. Not sure what's wrong with this establishment but, it seems as if no one there is happy or wants to do their job. By the way the food is below average. I won't be visiting this place again and I WON'T RECOMMEND THIS PLACE TO ANYONE. EVERYONE BEWARE!!!!

J.U Martinez

The so called owner on this restaurant is EXTREAMLY RUDE!! Started cursing when i went to order and pick my order even threatened to go outside to fight.. why kind of place is this that treats its customer and I can imagine its employees like this! DO NOT support this type of place!

张冠宇

An elderly person working in the kitchen, in charge of the takeout section, was very fierce, very impolite, and very unfriendly. They even chased me away when I went in to pick up my takeout order.

MaryLuz Dominguez

Pizza was ok but unfortunately we had to watch as this arrogant owner was shouting and insulting a Door dash worker. So disrespectful for the clients to be there and watch this racism scene I would qualify 0 stars just because of this.

Amrita Patnaik

I ordered an entire Drunk Nonna Pizza. The pizza mentions it comes with vodka sauce, mozzarella, and fresh basil. However, it ALSO comes with prosciutto. The meat is NOT mentioned anywhere. I called the restaurant and he insisted that vodka sauce anywhere always by default has meat in it and that I should have specifically requested it to be without meat. This is not true, vodka sauce doesn't have meat by default, and again it was mentioned nowhere on the menu. I'll have to throw this $30 pizza in the garbage since I'm a vegetarian.