American Pie

What a gem! Probably the best greens in Rome! The vodka riggies were awesome!

My daughter and I absolutely love this place! If we get pizza this is where we get it from! Their boneless wings are AMAZING!!! The food there is absolutely great and so is the staff! Seriously would give 6 stars if I could!

Food is excellent. We have been there twice and we were pleased both times. I have already recommended it to friends. Please keep the food good, quality and reasonably priced. We will be returning.

Great food at good prices. Delivery was smooth. Thank you for the great product. Looking forward to more deliveries.

Food is beyond the best food I have ever had for a pizza shop. I’ve had the fried meatballs, the Reggies, the greens, tenders, fried mushrooms, subs, pizza, wings. Best everything wings around! I have yet to have one bad meal, everything is just amazing!!!

I was looking for some fried cauliflower, not something common in Rome NY. And a proper calzone! They didn’t let me down!!! 5 stars out of 5 ! Highly recommend! Thank you very much for bringing Rome NY some good food!

The food was amazing the greens are beyond great deff going to go there from now on for lunch

Melissa Piersall

Food is beyond the best food I have ever had for a pizza shop. I’ve had the fried meatballs, the Reggies, the greens, tenders, fried mushrooms, subs, pizza, wings. Best everything wings around! I have yet to have one bad meal, everything is just amazing!!!

Key Reverend

I was looking for some fried cauliflower, not something common in Rome NY. And a proper calzone! They didn’t let me down!!! 5 stars out of 5 ! Highly recommend! Thank you very much for bringing Rome NY some good food!

Camryn Lundrigan

The food was amazing the greens are beyond great deff going to go there from now on for lunch

16 women held our book club meeting here!! Everything was delicious from pizzas, sandwiches and entire meals!! Super dining room and dedicated staff!! We will be back!!

Good pizza, good people. I was early to picking up. Sat for about 8 minutes. Everyone that walked in the door got greeted pleasantly. Was treated well at the register. Thanked when they left. Nice people work here.

I ordered catering for my daughters birthday party. Everything was FANTASTIC! They followed directions perfectly for all my food allergy guests. The service and was so pleasant and delivery was on time! Everything was fresh and the french fry tray were so crispy!!! We will be doing catering again from here!

I ordered a meatball and sausage calzone and extra crispy wings. Everything was hot and delicious. Did not disappoint! The sauce was spot on, wings were crispy but not overcooked and the calzone was overstuffed with meat. We will definitely placing future orders. The price was good too!

Our riggies and pizza were delicious! We will definitely be back.

We had a birthday party on a Sunday (usually don't open until noon) but they were so accommodating having 6 pizzas ready for pick at noon. Thanks so much American Pie of Rome! The pizza was delicious and everyone at the party was raving about it.

SMOKED Wings are awesome! These days many places have wings on the smaller side...theirs are nice and big - and I don't know if anyone doing smoked wings... Their pizza is also really good. Some complain about party cuts, but for those that say you should never party cut unless asked for is simply wrong. I grew up eating Tony's in new Harford, and they always cut them that way. Many others do the same. Wife had a chicken finger sub recently, and that was also good. Overall, I think American Pie is going to be the one to last in that location. I hope so...

First time here and ordered wings to go! Gentleman on the phone was courteous and knowledgeable.Cooked just as I requested and price was reasonable! By far the best option in Rome! I will be back!!!

Jerome Plano

First time here and ordered wings to go! Gentleman on the phone was courteous and knowledgeable.Cooked just as I requested and price was reasonable! By far the best option in Rome! I will be back!!!

Annette M

16 women held our book club meeting here!! Everything was delicious from pizzas, sandwiches and entire meals!! Super dining room and dedicated staff!! We will be back!!

Charis Carr

Our riggies and pizza were delicious! We will definitely be back.

Todd Schutt

What a gem! Probably the best greens in Rome! The vodka riggies were awesome!

Adam Keller

Good pizza, good people. I was early to picking up. Sat for about 8 minutes. Everyone that walked in the door got greeted pleasantly. Was treated well at the register. Thanked when they left. Nice people work here.

Tiffany Apel

I ordered catering for my daughters birthday party. Everything was FANTASTIC! They followed directions perfectly for all my food allergy guests. The service and was so pleasant and delivery was on time! Everything was fresh and the french fry tray were so crispy!!! We will be doing catering again from here!

Chelsea Johnson

We had a birthday party on a Sunday (usually don't open until noon) but they were so accommodating having 6 pizzas ready for pick at noon. Thanks so much American Pie of Rome! The pizza was delicious and everyone at the party was raving about it.

valerie lints

I ordered a meatball and sausage calzone and extra crispy wings. Everything was hot and delicious. Did not disappoint! The sauce was spot on, wings were crispy but not overcooked and the calzone was overstuffed with meat. We will definitely placing future orders. The price was good too!

Jeff O

SMOKED Wings are awesome! These days many places have wings on the smaller side...theirs are nice and big - and I don't know if anyone doing smoked wings... Their pizza is also really good. Some complain about party cuts, but for those that say you should never party cut unless asked for is simply wrong. I grew up eating Tony's in new Harford, and they always cut them that way. Many others do the same. Wife had a chicken finger sub recently, and that was also good. Overall, I think American Pie is going to be the one to last in that location. I hope so...

Food was good. Only criticism I can give is spruce up and clean the bathroom. One waitress/worker was pretty loud behind counter and swore a few times. Customers don’t really care to hear all that.

Stopped in for a quick lunch, deciding what we wanted took longer than it took the team to get us our 2 slices. Pizza was great! Fast, cheap, tasty: simple as that. Will stop by again when in the area.

Ordered twice from this establishment and the food is incredible. Fast take out and delivery was still hot. Would of rated 5 stars but felt dinners should include rolls or bread.

The Pizza is delicious, nice and seasoned. The Wings need work though.. When Someone asks for Everything Wings we are expecting Wings with extra delicious Flavors added... Stop being afraid to use the Bleu cheese.

3 slices for 8 bucks not a bad deal. Tonys thicker crust style. Decent flavor on the sauce. My slices were a little bit over sauced and the crust was a bit undercooked

Joe L

3 slices for 8 bucks not a bad deal. Tonys thicker crust style. Decent flavor on the sauce. My slices were a little bit over sauced and the crust was a bit undercooked

I’ve only ever stopped here for a quick slice. It’s a decent pizza place, but nothing special. I would rate the value as excellent, the service is really good, too. The pizza is good, in my opinion, not great. There’s not a ton of seating, but if you want a quick slice - it’s a great love to stop. I think it’s one of the only places where you can still get 2 slices and a soda for $5, which I consider a super value with prices of everything in the rise.

I would not say the pizza is way salty, it was just fine and even so I wouldn't mind a little added given I had a veggie packed pizza. The shaker parm helps. Overall it was very good, the only thing I wasn't a fan of was the bell peppers were a little bitter. There was lots of cheese, onions were tasty and fragrant, and THANK YOU because I can tell that FRESH real mushrooms are used. Nothing more sad than a canned mushroom. It was cold on the wintry night we ate in and the bell peppers weren't great that's only reason -1☆ otherwise good food and friendly staff.

Patrick DeBono

I’ve only ever stopped here for a quick slice. It’s a decent pizza place, but nothing special. I would rate the value as excellent, the service is really good, too. The pizza is good, in my opinion, not great. There’s not a ton of seating, but if you want a quick slice - it’s a great love to stop. I think it’s one of the only places where you can still get 2 slices and a soda for $5, which I consider a super value with prices of everything in the rise.

Wings were good, cheese pizza needed more sauce, same with the one with fixins. Riggies were not the best, since there was more oil than sauce. It was hotter than medium, but that's a crapshoot since each person is different. It's about the sauce.

Person at the counter was nice. I got 2 slices, a cheese and garlic. The dough is like what you would buy at the store and make pizza at home with the kids. The sauce and dough are very salty. I like New York style pizza and this is not even close. Would not go back.

Stephanie Warren

Person at the counter was nice. I got 2 slices, a cheese and garlic. The dough is like what you would buy at the store and make pizza at home with the kids. The sauce and dough are very salty. I like New York style pizza and this is not even close. Would not go back.

Wait time is quite long. They are friendly but we are not too comfortable with the ambiance of the place plus the pizza is average for us :)

Had ordered here recently with family and very impressed with calzone so ordered from here tonight. Ordered two calzones and went in expecting to pay $10 each plus tax according to the menu prices with 3 additional toppings each (listed on menu as $8.50 each plus $.50 per topping). Total before tax came to $28.75 and when asked why price was so high was just told prices increased but not reflected on menu. Happy with the food but disappointed with the almost 50% increase in price without explanation or an updated menu.

I bought a fish fry that was burnt and one side the breading underneath was uncooked. They gave me a half a cup of coleslaw. I was extremely disappointed and won’t go back!!!

Slices were old and dried out!! Nasty! I arrived at 7:20, and I only saw one worker! He chose to ignore me for about 7-8 minutes, before he got me my dried out old slices! Oh well...maybe I'll try DiCastro's next time!

Ordered a calzone with pepperoni and mushrooms. Not much pepperoni and mushrooms. It was mostly cheese and very greasy.

This was our third choice after nearby pizza places were closed due to storm damage. They had two dried old pizzas to pick from for pizza by the slice. Opted to do a small one for three people. 25 minute wait for the pizza. It was ok. For being New York and in a city baring the name Rome, this is a miss.

Paul W

This was our third choice after nearby pizza places were closed due to storm damage. They had two dried old pizzas to pick from for pizza by the slice. Opted to do a small one for three people. 25 minute wait for the pizza. It was ok. For being New York and in a city baring the name Rome, this is a miss.

Not impressed in any fashion. I'm guessing the place has changed at some point, because I remember years ago it was a really good place for grub.

First time at this eatery and I was not in impressed with the pizza. There's no reason to have bad pizza in Rome, NY! The sauce had zero flavor and there was a ton of it. Not enough cheese and very little pepperoni. It was priced nicely at $6.00 for two slices and a soda and the service was friendly. There may be good items in the menu, so I have heard, but the pizza is not it. Bonus points for being opened on mother's day when all the other pizzerias were closed.

Ron Chamberlin

Not impressed in any fashion. I'm guessing the place has changed at some point, because I remember years ago it was a really good place for grub.

Dimas Dominguez

Ordered a calzone with pepperoni and mushrooms. Not much pepperoni and mushrooms. It was mostly cheese and very greasy.

Calzones were good. However absolutely no COVID safety whatsoever. Staff not wearing masks in food prep area, and not wearing masks at the cash register when taking orders. Guy vacuuming the dining area, no mask. Won't go back.

Ordered a bunch of appetizers. Fried raviolis, fried calamari, fried mushrooms, mozzarella sticks. The fried raviolis were so spicy that I couldn't even eat them. They tasted like they were breaded with jalapeno peppers. I have never had spicy fried raviolis before so that was very strange, and a heads up would have been nice. Also the marinara sauce with them was actually cocktail sauce. The fried calamari was mixed with pieces of chicken fingers. The fried mushrooms turned out to actually be fried cauliflower. I spent 40 dollars on this food and was EXTREMELY disappointed. I will never eat here again.

Unless asked for you never cut a puzza into party slices. Flavor is very weak. Wings are under cooked. And they cost more than the favorable competitor's in the area. So they need to serious step up their game or be like other 5 pizza joints that have been in that location

Ordered a small two item pizza with 2# wings. The pizza was scrawny, flimsy and hardly had any toppings. The wings were good size (13pcs.) but only a sprinkling of hot sauce....they were dry so we added are own. I also purchased 3 celery/bc @ $2 a piece....$28 total...feel ripped off. My kids laughed at the pizza. Just another failing business there at that location.

I ordered a pizza last night and when it got here it was cold and hard so I called them back to have a pizza remade but in the middle of that they were closing so I told them I would call the next day. So I called the next day and I told the lady what was wrong with the pizza and she told me that of course it would be cold cuz it's been delivered and sitting all night and that it would be hard because it's been sitting all night and told me that she couldn't do nothing about it and hung up on me so the food the service and the atmosphere was very terrible

Grease so bad it went through the box. Problem the delivery also. We will NEVER order from them again.

Outrageous to get home to enjoy dinner on a friday night to 7 wings. You charged me $11 for SEVEN wings. Pizza looks like cardboard, dry as hell. I have never had this issue here as we order quiet often, but I'll never go back.

I ordered from here after working a long week, and I didn't feel like cooking dinner. Unfortunately, upon delivery and after opening my pizza I discovered that they dropped or somehow managed to destroy the pizza I had ordered.i tasted it anyway, and it was very sour and cold. Disgusting. I used to hear good things from here. It's sad to see this happen.

Donald Saunders

I ordered from here after working a long week, and I didn't feel like cooking dinner. Unfortunately, upon delivery and after opening my pizza I discovered that they dropped or somehow managed to destroy the pizza I had ordered.i tasted it anyway, and it was very sour and cold. Disgusting. I used to hear good things from here. It's sad to see this happen.

Cassandra Goad

Outrageous to get home to enjoy dinner on a friday night to 7 wings. You charged me $11 for SEVEN wings. Pizza looks like cardboard, dry as hell. I have never had this issue here as we order quiet often, but I'll never go back.