Katie Merrick

Crust has a rich, almost buttery flavor. So delicious! The burrata slice was my favorite! Very sweet, nostalgic ambience in the shop, with charming tables. Worth the rating!

A.L. Harris

Stopped in here tonight for a couple of slices. Solid choice. Pizza was good. Crispy thin crust with a nice sauce and cheese. The Sicilian slices looked good too and I’ll be back to try a few of those. Service was friendly and fast. Could have sat inside but chose to take it to go. Definitely one of the better pizza places on the UWS.

Tamika Hunt

The food, service and atmosphere were excellent. A fantastic representative of the upper west side and NY style pizza. The pizza, both tradish and Roman are available by the slice. There are also wings. My family and I enjoyed a slice of grandma Style chicken bacon ranch and Bianca Pepe, which is their white pizza. We also had the wings along with a slice of plain NY style and margarita pizza. The crust was the right ratio of thin and crispy. The service was fantastic and the price very reasonable and affordable. Great pizza!!!

+1

Key Williams

I was warmly welcomed and quickly taken care of by a friendly staff member. The attentive staff provided excellent customer service. I appreciated being addressed as 'sir,' which added a personal touch to the experience. The pizza slices were generously sized and perfectly cooked with a satisfyingly crispy crust. I'm a big fan of thin-crust pizza, and this one hit the spot. The balance of flavors was spot on, with just the right amount of sauce and toppings to let the crust shine.

Chanaka Hettige

Absolutely loved the pizza. I was not able to hunt down a NY Style Pizza and finally made it here. The service is great and they reheat the pizza before serving and it still stands out. The location is not fancy but popular with locals. You'd have great food and good experience here. Give it a shot.

DReager1

Mimi's is an excellent new spot on the UWS! I recall trying their location on the east side and this one maintains their high standards. While they are known for the square slices, no corners are cut on the traditional either. Each slice clearly has a lot of effort into it and their selection is quite varied. Just as important as the food, the service here is excellent. The staff was attentive and polite, the store is kept very well clean and it has a good atmosphere. I'm definitely going to be trying more and more flavors on each visit and I highly recommend stopping by when you are on the lookout for a great slice!

Matt B

A decent pizzeria on the Upper West Side. They’ve got very large slices for a reasonable cost, but they lacked that wow factor hence the 4star review.

+13

Julien Garros

This is a solid neighborhood pizza spot. You can eat in, sit outside, or just grab take-out. They’ve got square pizza, slices, or full pies and it’s all really good. Great New York-style pizza at a fair price. Service was friendly and quick. Definitely worth checking out if you’re nearby!

Erik Webb

Good spot — I tried the gluten free crust with buffalo chicken ranch toppings. It took 30 minutes to bake, since it was made incorrectly with breaded chicken the first time, but ultimately worth the wait.

Abigail R.

The staff was kind, and there’s a good amount of indoor seating. The crust was the perfect thin slice, but the cheese on the pizza tasted like rubber. I ended up just eating the bread and sauce. The garlic knots also had no flavor.