amy guttmann

The only place to celebrate every milestone and every day moments! From the food to the incredible service, the Bay Cafe is a hidden gem. Louis, our server, has been an incredible part of our experience for years. So grateful for his suggestions and ability to accommodate our every need. Looking forward to our next visit for years to come!

RoseofMidwood Brooklyn

Larisa and her staff are 5 stars. The food and service amazing. We brought cousins who were here visiting from Argentina. The Margherita pizza was delicious, the Pao de Queijo is gluten free and was so flavorful and soft. Must order kachapuri....they would never find this in their home country and were impressed by the bread , the consistency of the cheese and the runny egg. ( fyi bring lactaid pills for this dish if lactose intolerant, it swims with butter). The Caesar salad with its giant homemade croutons, finely shredded parmesan was refreshing, as was the strawberry hibiscus Boba tea.

Moshe Aziz

If you’re looking for a hidden gem with an unbeatable combination of excellent service, delicious food, and great prices, look no further than Bay Café by. This spot truly excels in offering high-quality kosher dishes. The service is top-notch, with attentive and friendly staff making every visit enjoyable. Whether you’re in the mood for a savory pizza loaded with fresh toppings, perfectly crispy fried bites, or house-made pasta that tastes like a piece of Italy, Bay Café has got you covered. Highly recommended for anyone looking to enjoy a fantastic meal. Definitely a must-visit!

+3

Avraham Grant

What can I say, Daniel is an amazing chef. his food is delicious and unique. From the corn croquettes to the Chilean sea bass and we can't forget the cauliflower soup nor the roasted portabello mushroom, everything was balanced and delicious and made me want more. Finally we can't forget our waiter, Ali who was courteous, patient and personable, wanting our visit to be memorable. Go and be amazed!

+1

Esfira Shakh

Had a date night with hubby and this truly is a perfect place for a romantic and just a pleasant place to enjoy each others company. The staff was meticulous with their service and attentive to our needs. We ordered a quinoa beet salad, BBQ cauliflower, fish tacos as appetizers and each dish was not just beautiful in presentation but delicious with rich flavors. For mains we had the spinach/cheese Ravioli and a Mediterranean Bronzino which I personally could not have asked for more. The Bronzino was so perfectly seasoned, cooked to perfection and the flavors could be tasted in the meat of the fish not just the crispy skin. A def must have when you come here. My new go to location for the perfect date.

+1

Rivka A

Incredible food and service. Everything was delivered quickly. It was fresh, delicious, and the ambiance and paintings were on point. Would 10000% be coming back!!

+4

Lika Star

Heard a lot of rave reviews about this kosher dairy place and after ordering food from them twice, have to agree that all of these reviews were on point. Both orders were delivery but everything we ordered was cooked fast, packed extremely carefully and all dishes arrived piping hot and tasting incredibly fresh and delicious. Portions are big enough to share, food is full of flavor, seasoned superbly and obviously made from premium quality ingredients. Mushroom & Cheese stuffed baked potato is definitely 1 of the ultimate comfort foods for many and The Bay Cafe’s version was a true perfection with lots of yummy melted cheese, great tasting mushrooms mixed in with scooped potatoes insides. 10 out of 10 for sure! Beets & Quinoa salad was an excellent combo of different fresh veggies, nuts, fruits and feta cheese, resulting in a fabulous mix of sweet and savory plus adding a raspberry vinaigrette as a dressing brought it all to a very satisfying explosion of flavor. Definitely a Must Get Salad! Another 10 out of 10. Lastly we got Maryland style Crab Cakes, made with imitation crab meat but it didn’t diminish the taste at all. This dish comes with 2 large pieces of Crab Cakes, served on a bed of fresh arugula and lots of cherry tomatoes with a side of delectable homemade tartar sauce. Crab Cakes were crunchy outside, juicy and tender inside, had a unique taste and was truly amazing. All in all-very satisfying experience, would love to try more dishes from their vast menu and dine there in person.

+1

Nachi B

Delicious dinner with the family at the bay cafe. The Serivce is excellent and the food is amazing. We had fish tacos and chili and chips for appetisers that were super fresh and tasty. Mains were excellent and the desert was to die for. We had bananas foster which they made table side and churos with chocolate and caramel dipping sauces.

+3

Isy Bochner

The ambiance is very pleasant. The food is excellent and nicely presented. The staff from the front door on in was warm, caring and attentive. They seemed genuinely concerned that everything was perfect. All in all a great experience. Can't wait to go back for more.

Milton Klein

There really is only one word to describe our experience at the Bay Cafe and it is Awesome. From the moment we entered to the moment we left everything was perfect. We were there with friends and we ordered various dishes and everything was delicious and fresh. The food in the restaurant is important but so is the service and the staff was fabulous coming around often checking if everything is okay making sure our glasses were full. We got excellent value for our money so put the Bay Cafe on your list.

+5

Kosher Food World

I heard a lot of hype about this place so I went to check it out for myself. Here’s a breakdown of what we ordered: Mushroom gnocchi - it was absolutely delicious! Seriously so fresh and tasty, and I can honestly say it was one of the best gnocchi I ever had! Halloumi salad - it was basic, nothing special. Lasagna Frittas: this was different and yummy. It came with an Alfredo dipping sauce which elevated it even further and made it heavenly. Fish tacos - they were ok, the fish had a good crunch but otherwise it was dry. I dipped it into the Alfredo sauce from the frittas and it tasted good like that. The interior is a bit outdated but overall it’s a nice ambience and they have good service. For more kosher reviews on Instagram @kosherfoodworld

+4

Yossi I Berkowitz

The servers were excellent making it a really nice dining experience, the food on the other hand needs some help, I ordered the eggplant pizza and the marinara sauce is missing zest and salt, my wife ordered stuffed pasta in a Pink sauce which was also lacking taste, It wasn't bursting with flavor as you would expect in a nice restaurant.