Pop's Bakery and Deli

Great food, huge subs packed with meat. Nice bread selection and baked goods. Try it!

Wonder family- owned bakery with delicious breads, baked goods, salads and subs. Very reasonable prices as well

Very glad I decided to stop by for a steak sub here. It was so full I couldn't even close it to take a bite. Very happy with the portions.

The food was delicious and fresh. It is cash only but they do have an ATM inside. Staff was friendly and had excellent recommendations on what to try.

Super duper friendly staff Really good food More than honest portions Would definitely go back for sure --- Yahoo wants an update- So... everything is the same as above :) still a great lil food shop

Their fresh bread and subs are fantastic. I always leave with some cinnamon rolls and cookies too!

Large Turkey sandwich today. was as awsome as the last 5 I have bought from here. Enough to feed a family with this thing.

Loved the soup I purchased!!! Everything looked so good! Will definitely be back to try more!! ❤️❤️

Incredible, flavorful food and very generous serving sizes!

Local bakery that has some great baked goods and breads. Recommend for anyone coming through the town of Honeoye!

Huge portions of great food

We had lunch here today and everything was so good! The Tiramisu was the best I’ve even had!

Pasta dishes are great value. The Chicken French is DELICIOUS!

Love the fresh bread and the subs are awesome! 10/10

Very friendly staff and delicious food. Just remember to bring cash, as the don't take cards.

Best steak sub, hands down. Fresh made bread seals the deal.

Delicious food, excellent service. You will not be disappointed.

Nice little place to grab a bite. Sizes are pretty big lol

Subs are gigantic, and tastes amazing!! Highly recommend going here!!

Amazing very full subs. Homemade sub sun rools are spectacular!

Great for, good portions

Huge roast beef sub!

Super sweet lady in the front! Huge portions and delicious baked good for a good price

Freshly prepared. Ginormous! The sub roll is so flavourful. Bought some loaves of Italian bread, the best! So friendly and welcoming.

Absolutely love everything I've ever ordered from here. Cheesecake and steaks sub are the best around. Great pricing, timely, friendly, and quality food.

Very pleasant .Looking at a beautiful array of desserts she put on a beautiful meal of your choice off the menu. Prices are good and you have more than enough to take home

Very cute little restaurant!!! We stopped in passing through the area the locals were very friendly and told us that everything on the menu was good and they weren't lying!!!

Can’t wait to go back!

I got chicken parmasan over angel hair, which had an authentic rich flavor of Basil and Garlic. It would serve 3-4 people easily! ☆☆☆☆☆

The subs were amazing. Loaded with toppings and weighing a whole lot! Definitely recommend stopping here and trying it out.

Awesome subs. So much meat you can make 2 subs.

Great little hidden, small town bakery. Best fresh brownies and sweets in town. Try the pasta dinners. You will get your money's worth and more.

Was in town for the Honeoye 30K race. We stopped in to get food to take to the Air BNB Friday night. I got the chicken parm and my wife also got a pasta dish. Both excellent. Of course we got a cookie and sweet roll for dessert and they too were amazing. Very friendly staff also. Highly recommended if in town!

Great food with big portion. The cold subs have so much meat on them!! Also tons of bakery selections.

Best subs in Honeyoe! First hot sub I had tonight there. It wasn't on the menu so I asked if they could make me a Chicken Cordon Bleu sub and they made it for me. it turned out amazing! The chicken tenders were nice and crispy with a good amount of ham and swiss cheese! Delicious 😋 thank you!

I can eat three meals off of one large sub. I would rather spend my money here than any other place around.

We stopped for lunch on our drive from Finger Lakes to Niagara Falls and it was amazing little Deli. They make their own Bread. The Reuben Sandwich was delicious and the Buffalo Chicken Chowder as well. Definitely recommend.

Great portions, great prices, delicious food and pastries!!!!!! Portions are huge!!!!!peanut butter cookies, chicken broccoli alfredo and meatloaf dinner!!!!!!

We didn’t not know about this hidden gem. I 100 percent recommend this place. So we have only had the Italian sausage sub and chicken parm sub. Bothe of them were huge. Sausage was piled high with onions and peppers and I dare to say a lb of mozzarella, chicken parm was fire the sauce was delicious and chicken was actual chicken breast and breaded and also tons of cheese.

Great place the subs are amazing! Awesome baked goods and awesome customer service!

I’ve been getting food here since they opened and it has stayed consistently great, with huge portions!

We've thoroughly enjoyed the Open Face Prime Rib Sandwich, Ziti with meatballs, Chicken French and just recently the Yankee Pot Roast. All delicious, home made meals taste and very large portions. Looking forward to the next special.

Just in town visiting for the weekend, stopped in for a bite to eat. Definitely worth every bite. The deserts were amazing as well. We got few things to eat snd got a few things to go. I’ll def will refer the place to anyone Definitely will be back sometime soon I’m 💯 positive. Thank you for the great food and friendly service with a smile.

The food is amazing...some are a bit spicy for me but love the steak sub. However, the reason we go there at least once a week is to buy their authentic, delicious italian bread, tiramisue and cinnamon rolls.

We stopped during hunting season for lunch. OMG!!! These subs are the biggest I’ve ever seen. I can eat a large Wegmans sub, but Pop’s subs are ridiculously huge. When they put meat on, the do not go skimpy. The sub is so thick, you have to squeeze the bread down just so you can bite it. With as much meat they put on, I do not understand how they make any money off from it. I live in Greece Rochester, and it still would almost be worth the trip to Pop’s for subs. My friend told me he had other plates of food there, and they were awesome. Definitely worth the trip even from Rochester, especially if the family goes. You will not regret it.

Me and my husband decided to get a sub on Saturday for dinner so we thought we would try Pop's..thank God we did ..the subs were amazing. Had alot of meat on them like back in the day and rolls were soft ..and the cinnamon rolls are HUGE and delicious..highly recommend this place ...we will definitely go back again ..

Another great find for homemade food! Everything a small town bakery/deli should be..friendly people quality home cooked food and quick service. Chicken Parmesan sub was delicious!

Tasty local food! I had a hot lunch and a sweet treat after my snowy hike at Harriett Hollister state rec area. There are a few tables to sit at and eat there. Saw lots of happy customers. Cash only, but ATM provided on premises.

I've been here many times for lunch.. their subs are second to none. The subs are piled with meats.

Chicken French with angle hair pasta was a delightful surprise of taste coming from a small bakery and dinner. Large portion size in the dinner plate. I'll get that again next trip. Only bad thing is there is no ramp or railing for those that have a hard time walking.

Favorite food stop in Honeoye! One of few places (and only) to have -pizzas these days, very good subs, and some products that I haven't seen anywhere else! Always enjoy talking with the main front lady there (I forget her name, sorry!) in my monthly Honeoye visits. This place is CASH-ONLY so keep that in mind!

We love the Chicken French ! Also tried other dinners to change it up once in a while and they were great also. The service is very friendly and they always acknowledge you when you come in, unlike a lot of other places. We recommend Pop’s all the time!

We went to Pop’s today ( Thursday, 6/01/23) for lunch and were completely blown away! My husband had a medium Italian assorted sub and I had the Cajun chicken and shrimp salad. Both meals were huge - we will each get another meal out of our selection. The sub roll was fresh baked and delicious. The filling was extremely generous. The salad had 4 huge shrimp and more chicken than I have ever seen on a salad - both were freshly cooked ( still warm) and seasoned to perfection. The croutons on the salad were so delicious. There were so many flavorful ingredients and seasonings, I didn’t need to use the salad dressing I had ordered on the side. We left with our left-overs and purchased 2 meatballs with sauce and a loaf of fresh Italian bread. I highly recommend this little gem!!!

Baked goods are absolutely amazing!!! Best Tiramisu I’ve ever had along with the pretzel looking pastries, both the chocolate and apple are mind blowing!!! Keep up the great work. Customer service was great the same .

We stop in most Sunday mornings for a loaf of fresh bread and some cookies. Both are most often still warm! Delicious. They also make great lunches and dinners. The specials are usually what I end up getting. Large portions, reasonably priced. We also love that they have a mini deli inside. It's great when we need some last minute fixings for work week lunches. The counter and what you can see of the kitchen always look clean and the staff is kind. Highly recommend.

I have never had subs with so much meat on them. And their prices are very reasonable to.

Huge subs! You definitely get your money's worth. I had a medium steak sub w mushrooms, peppers, onions, banana peppers, and provolone cheese. This thing was HUGE, I bet it easily weighed 3 lbs! They serve it with a fork...it's that big (I was still able to fold it and eat it like a sub). M husband had a medium Italian assorted. We both enjoyed pur subs, and I'll definitely be going back before heading home to TX. Their sub rolls are made fresh daily, in-house, and are definitely the pièce de résistance.

Very nice place to eat with large portions. 👌 😋

First time getting takeout here. Let me start by saying the smells are amazing from the bakery when you walk inside. I got a steak bomber and my wife got a dinner along with artichokes French and then my son got chicken fingers. All the food was amazing! Huge portions. The steak sub was so good and it started with their fresh bake roll they serve it on. I’m certain we will return. Side note they do have 3-4+ tables for sitting down to eat your order. They are cash only. A very nice addition to Honeoye. The Italian Assorted is huge!

The place is amazing and the cookies are delicious. Best prices around and amazing customer service. These were the only cookies left right now at work after I brought them in.

Ended up at this little bakery because we were passing through town and nothing else was open. Boy were we pleasantly surprised! Super friendly, HUGE portions and absolutely delicious!

Delicious food! What a gem! Everything we ordered was amazing! Can’t wait to come back!!!

OMG this is better than subway it's a little Italian place and it's amazing you name it they have it. But bring cash. Yes they have an ATM Machine there but believe me the prices are worth every penny. For what you receive. But don't believe me check it out for yourself. Pops is amazing and awesome place. And it's here in our little small country town. Thanks 🙏

Loved the baked goods and huge sub sandwich

Get to Pop's, it was absolutely amazing. I recently discovered this incredible deli and let me tell you from the cinnamon rolls (as big as my head) to the subs I could barely get my hands around! Skip the deli in the city and MAKE the trip to Honeoye! Totally worth it and you wont regret it.

Unbelievable subs! Stopped in last Friday. First time for my wife and I. Great service and seriously the best subs ever! Talk about meat in a sub? Wow! I couldn't eat it all. Glad we got mediums. Priced right. Next time Im going to get large so I can enjoy it all week. We'll couple of days. By the way the menu. Going to be trying a lot more! Thank you for the kind service. She is great!

Laura Laesser

Huge subs! You definitely get your money's worth. I had a medium steak sub w mushrooms, peppers, onions, banana peppers, and provolone cheese. This thing was HUGE, I bet it easily weighed 3 lbs! They serve it with a fork...it's that big (I was still able to fold it and eat it like a sub). M husband had a medium Italian assorted. We both enjoyed pur subs, and I'll definitely be going back before heading home to TX. Their sub rolls are made fresh daily, in-house, and are definitely the pièce de résistance.

David Mazerbo

Unbelievable subs! Stopped in last Friday. First time for my wife and I. Great service and seriously the best subs ever! Talk about meat in a sub? Wow! I couldn't eat it all. Glad we got mediums. Priced right. Next time Im going to get large so I can enjoy it all week. We'll couple of days. By the way the menu. Going to be trying a lot more! Thank you for the kind service. She is great!

Carrsondra May

Very nice place to eat with large portions. 👌 😋

John Law

First time getting takeout here. Let me start by saying the smells are amazing from the bakery when you walk inside. I got a steak bomber and my wife got a dinner along with artichokes French and then my son got chicken fingers. All the food was amazing! Huge portions. The steak sub was so good and it started with their fresh bake roll they serve it on. I’m certain we will return. Side note they do have 3-4+ tables for sitting down to eat your order. They are cash only. A very nice addition to Honeoye. The Italian Assorted is huge!

C Teed

The place is amazing and the cookies are delicious. Best prices around and amazing customer service. These were the only cookies left right now at work after I brought them in.

arketekchic

Ended up at this little bakery because we were passing through town and nothing else was open. Boy were we pleasantly surprised! Super friendly, HUGE portions and absolutely delicious!

Amanda Jamison

Loved the baked goods and huge sub sandwich

Emma Kubinski

Delicious food! What a gem! Everything we ordered was amazing! Can’t wait to come back!!!

Michelle Duemmel

OMG this is better than subway it's a little Italian place and it's amazing you name it they have it. But bring cash. Yes they have an ATM Machine there but believe me the prices are worth every penny. For what you receive. But don't believe me check it out for yourself. Pops is amazing and awesome place. And it's here in our little small country town. Thanks 🙏

Friendly staff and the food is outstanding! Subs are extremely generous portion of meat on delicious bread. I was recommended to try pop's from a friend of mine and I'm very glad I did. Definitely go try them out, you won't be disappointed.

My husband and I have gone there twice now and we will definitely be back! Got the chicken parm today and it was hands down the best red sauce I have ever had!

Best French fries ever. Even the ones I took home and reheated in the air fryer because I had too many to eat in one sitting came out awesome

Always the best meal! And great value.

We happened to be in the area and decided to get lunch from here. I ordered a sub for my husband. You definitely get what you pay for. There was a ton of meat in his sub. He said it was amazing. I ordered what they call a mini pizza and that was delicious and perfect size. We live about a 1/2 hour from this place but we will definitely be stopping by there again.

We stopped here on a whim before heading to a wedding nearby. We had just enough time to eat some of their mini pizzas and grab their huge cinnamon rolls. The dough they use is incredible! I’m hoping we are back in the area so we can try everything else. Chefs kiss!

Awesome food. Chicken parm and red sauce was fantastic. Huge portions for the price too.

Not sure why it took me so long to try this place! We eat here on the regular now. All the food is amazing and they give large portions for the price.

Excellent! Picked up subs today. 1 turkey and 1 meatball. Great price, excellent bread, loaded with meat, and Delicious. Not the closest but the best!

Buy far the best place for a sub, haven't tried anything else yet but I plan on it, I've never seen a sub with so much meat on it, they definitely blow every other sub place off planet earth, you will be extremely happy with this place biggest sub around

Keith Cummings

Excellent! Picked up subs today. 1 turkey and 1 meatball. Great price, excellent bread, loaded with meat, and Delicious. Not the closest but the best!

Misti Carbone

My husband and I have gone there twice now and we will definitely be back! Got the chicken parm today and it was hands down the best red sauce I have ever had!

Cym Mitch

Best French fries ever. Even the ones I took home and reheated in the air fryer because I had too many to eat in one sitting came out awesome

Ryan Swisher

Awesome food. Chicken parm and red sauce was fantastic. Huge portions for the price too.

Bryan Small

Friendly staff and the food is outstanding! Subs are extremely generous portion of meat on delicious bread. I was recommended to try pop's from a friend of mine and I'm very glad I did. Definitely go try them out, you won't be disappointed.

Michael “Mike” Brown

I have never had subs with so much meat on them. And their prices are very reasonable to.

Lydia LaDue

Not sure why it took me so long to try this place! We eat here on the regular now. All the food is amazing and they give large portions for the price.

Debbie Ackerman

We love the Chicken French ! Also tried other dinners to change it up once in a while and they were great also. The service is very friendly and they always acknowledge you when you come in, unlike a lot of other places. We recommend Pop’s all the time!

Pazza

We stopped here on a whim before heading to a wedding nearby. We had just enough time to eat some of their mini pizzas and grab their huge cinnamon rolls. The dough they use is incredible! I’m hoping we are back in the area so we can try everything else. Chefs kiss!

Jennifer Goodell

We happened to be in the area and decided to get lunch from here. I ordered a sub for my husband. You definitely get what you pay for. There was a ton of meat in his sub. He said it was amazing. I ordered what they call a mini pizza and that was delicious and perfect size. We live about a 1/2 hour from this place but we will definitely be stopping by there again.

Donna Marshall

We went to Pop’s today ( Thursday, 6/01/23) for lunch and were completely blown away! My husband had a medium Italian assorted sub and I had the Cajun chicken and shrimp salad. Both meals were huge - we will each get another meal out of our selection. The sub roll was fresh baked and delicious. The filling was extremely generous. The salad had 4 huge shrimp and more chicken than I have ever seen on a salad - both were freshly cooked ( still warm) and seasoned to perfection. The croutons on the salad were so delicious. There were so many flavorful ingredients and seasonings, I didn’t need to use the salad dressing I had ordered on the side. We left with our left-overs and purchased 2 meatballs with sauce and a loaf of fresh Italian bread. I highly recommend this little gem!!!

Great mom and pop shop. Delicious homemade bread!

Had a delivery in the area. The place i had to deliver to was closed for lunch. So, I stopped for lunch at this location. The food was great. The service was great. We'll come back if i am in the area again.

Honestly, got the garbage plate, it was inexpensive and surprisingly good. A little heavy on the onions but that's personal taste. Cheeseburgers are good. Saved some for the next day too. I will go again.

Sweets were amazing! Mini pizzas were a hit with the teenagers. Meatball sub was huge but strong seasoning that we were not a fan of.

Pop's bakery is a great addition to our town. They give excellent customer service, The owner Tom puts love into all the dishes that he creates.

Foods really good but there sauce is way too sweet. I don't know if they're putting sugar in it, but please don't.

I am a local, I want to like this place so bad. The bread and rolls are great but the tomato sauce is insanely sweet. Close your eyes and think 'tomato flavored cake frosting' level sweet. Maybe it's just preference, but I can't eat anything there with tomato sauce on it.

The lady was so nice and the atmosphere was nice but I do NOT RECOMMEND THE CHICKEN BUFFALO WRAP HOLY SMOKES THAT WAS DISGUSTING WIYH HALF A BOTTLE OF HOT SAUCE IN MY WRAP. Never again but I guess the subs are good. I just highly recommend not going is all. Good luck

My friend and myself ordered 4 steak salads last Friday night. When we got them home, we discovered there weren't any of the delicious huge croutons on any of the salads and none of them came with bread. None of us realized this until we were half way through our meals. We have never had a bad meal or poor service from Pop's but that night I was disappointed in how quickly we were rushed through and I called a half hour ahead to place the order. I was going to call to complain but I figured I'd mention it next time I go in.

Order two hotdogs and fry i waited for 30 minutes

Their "Chiken marsala" is just noodles and brown sauce. Not a single drop of marsala flavor. More like, noodles and mystery gravy.

We bought two subs yesterday. First subs we've had since before the pandemic started. We were so disappointed. They were flavorless.....roast beef I could not eat because it was so grizzly. Sub rolls were too heavy and no flavor at all. Too much oil added that appeared to be just plain oil that just made it oily...Overall it was a blahs tasting sub that I'm feeding to the chickens, dogs and crows!

Fish fry looked big with box,lot of fries,until I realize they are those reconstituted seasoned fries,first red flag,tried the Cole slaw,disgusting and seemed old,not a good start,some of the fish was mushy,greasy dark with old fryer grease,if the Cole slaw was uneatable,what's that say about a place,have heard the subs are good,will try for a third time before I write them off

We no longer eat at this place. When we did, the food was mediocre, I felt like it was always less than I hoped for, a bit bland (usually order sandwiches or baked goods, things looked and sounded good, but always just so-so). Ordered two cinnamon buns at one point and they were practically inedible-- so much cinnamon and not enough of whatever else should be in there. Ultimately we stopped eating there for two reasons - 1) the food was unimpressive enough that it didn't seem like a loss after considering whether or not #2 could be true: 2) after hearing of some questionable behaviors by the ownership towards employees we couldn't in good faith continue to support the business