Benny’s pizza

badwith names

Wow man. Was just visiting Port Jervis and was insanely surprised how good this pizza was. One of the best I ever had.

charley walker

The best service and food I’ve had in my stay in America

One of the best pizzas I've eaten in years and the service is so friendly!

Awesome pizza and wings. Plus it was still hot when it go to me. Some of the best food ever. Very friendly staff too. Give it a try, you won't regret it.

Ordered our first veggie pizza and garlic knots, delicious! Nice crust and generous toppings. Will definitely order again.

What an awesome addition to Huguenot. We ordered a regular pie and a chicken ranch pie...both were amazing! We also got a Bennie's special wrap which was a hit with my Vegetarian. Bbq wings were a bit chewy for my liking. Chix parm sandwich was very good. The delivery person had to make a trip back as some of our order was missing, but the owner was more than lovely and sent the food back out to us within 20 mins. The driver was very nice. Believe the hype, it's well deserved!

Got our 1st pizza tonite. It was so good. Definitely will go again and try some other stuff too!! Very friendly staff.

I was on my way to work and I thought I would order pizza from Benny's. I was not ready to have it so I told her I would need a delayed delivery. She took my name number and the time I wanted it delivered. While I was at work I was wondering if they would forget but no they did not. Excellent Pizza. I ordered a large pepperoni and green pepper pie. The Taste is awesome really good. I have been so tired of ordering from the same old places all the time. I'm really happy that Benny's is there and I'll be ordering from them frequently. Awesome job Benny's.

I ordered Bennys Special Wrap. One of the best wraps I have ever had. The price was very reasonable. The food was ready very fast and the owner was very nice.

Great pizza!! Way better than any I’ve had around here. Nice job! I’m originally from Italy, so I know a good pizza when I taste one. This was my second time getting it, and it’s just as good as the first. This is officially my new go-to pizza spot. Totally deserves the praise. Prices are also the lowest I’ve seen in a long time.

The pizza is one of the best available in this area, with a good crust/cheese/sauce ratio, and not being undercooked like so many places around here do. Service is attentive and fast, and they should do well in an area with little competition. The only downside is the ugly, empty interior, but hopefully this will be taken care of as time goes on, since they just opened recently.

We absolutely love Benny's pizza! We happened to catch him on opening day. He was not prepared for a sudden opening. But was super excited to get started. Our pizza was amazing! And we've been back every week. Although we are tired of pizza. Our kids are not! His subs are amazing, too! I guarantee they are fresher than anyone in the area! We have tried then all!

If you’re on the hunt for the perfect slice, look no further than Benny’s — a true gem that checks every box and then some! From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted like family. The service is beyond exceptional — warm, friendly, and attentive without being overbearing. You can tell the team here genuinely cares about their customers, and it makes every visit feel special. Now let’s talk about the food — wow. Every bite of Benny’s pizza is a masterpiece. The crust is that perfect balance of crispy and chewy, the sauce bursts with rich, savory flavor, and the toppings are always fresh and generously layered. Whether you’re a classic pepperoni lover or into creative combos, Benny’s never disappoints. Don’t skip the garlic knots or the house-made marinara — they’re addictive. But what truly sets Benny’s apart is the atmosphere. It’s cozy yet vibrant, with just the right mix of laid-back charm and lively energy. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice on your lunch break or settling in for a relaxed dinner with friends, it’s the kind of place that makes you want to stay awhile. In a world full of average pizza joints, Benny’s stands out as something truly special. Amazing food, amazing service, and a vibe that keeps you coming back — this place is a total win. 🍕✨ 10/10 — Highly recommend!

Damon was friendly and professional!! He read back my order which resulted in my order being perfect!! It was truly a pleasure talking with him. He also went out of his way to deliver our order personally. And oh yeah the food was delicious.

Completely fake Stephanie never ordered or called before that is not true. There was a man smoking at the same time you posted the review he was there ordering a sandwich and he did not eat it at all and ask for his money back then he ask for 2 plain slices and the place was closed and we had to give him the money back and u asked him why Rae you waisting both of our time you made the food and didn’t even try it and gave it back to me

This was my second time picking up food from here. Their sandwiches are delicious! All their food is amazing and the prices are great. Great service too! And its so clean! My go to for food in the area.

katherin storms

Best pizza in town . Benny is also the sweetest owner I know !

Brooke Ann

This was my second time picking up food from here. Their sandwiches are delicious! All their food is amazing and the prices are great. Great service too! And its so clean! My go to for food in the area.

ap234 productions

Completely fake Stephanie never ordered or called before that is not true. There was a man smoking at the same time you posted the review he was there ordering a sandwich and he did not eat it at all and ask for his money back then he ask for 2 plain slices and the place was closed and we had to give him the money back and u asked him why Rae you waisting both of our time you made the food and didn’t even try it and gave it back to me

Kim Que

I was on my way to work and I thought I would order pizza from Benny's. I was not ready to have it so I told her I would need a delayed delivery. She took my name number and the time I wanted it delivered. While I was at work I was wondering if they would forget but no they did not. Excellent Pizza. I ordered a large pepperoni and green pepper pie. The Taste is awesome really good. I have been so tired of ordering from the same old places all the time. I'm really happy that Benny's is there and I'll be ordering from them frequently. Awesome job Benny's.

Shaun Good

I ordered Bennys Special Wrap. One of the best wraps I have ever had. The price was very reasonable. The food was ready very fast and the owner was very nice.

Harold Howlett

Got our 1st pizza tonite. It was so good. Definitely will go again and try some other stuff too!! Very friendly staff.

Chrissy duryea

Awesome pizza and wings. Plus it was still hot when it go to me. Some of the best food ever. Very friendly staff too. Give it a try, you won't regret it.

Mel Gannon

What an awesome addition to Huguenot. We ordered a regular pie and a chicken ranch pie...both were amazing! We also got a Bennie's special wrap which was a hit with my Vegetarian. Bbq wings were a bit chewy for my liking. Chix parm sandwich was very good. The delivery person had to make a trip back as some of our order was missing, but the owner was more than lovely and sent the food back out to us within 20 mins. The driver was very nice. Believe the hype, it's well deserved!

Julie

Best pizza I've had in the area in a really long time.Great customer service and friendly as well I live in cuddebackville and they deliver to definitely a plus although I would drive just to get their pizza anyways because it's delicious 😋.Highly recommend you give Benny's pizza a try!!! 😀

Carol Starr

Ordered our first veggie pizza and garlic knots, delicious! Nice crust and generous toppings. Will definitely order again.

Donna Davenport

We absolutely love Benny's pizza! We happened to catch him on opening day. He was not prepared for a sudden opening. But was super excited to get started. Our pizza was amazing! And we've been back every week. Although we are tired of pizza. Our kids are not! His subs are amazing, too! I guarantee they are fresher than anyone in the area! We have tried then all!

Fabio Emma

Great pizza!! Way better than any I’ve had around here. Nice job! I’m originally from Italy, so I know a good pizza when I taste one. This was my second time getting it, and it’s just as good as the first. This is officially my new go-to pizza spot. Totally deserves the praise. Prices are also the lowest I’ve seen in a long time.

Antonio Figueroa

The pizza is one of the best available in this area, with a good crust/cheese/sauce ratio, and not being undercooked like so many places around here do. Service is attentive and fast, and they should do well in an area with little competition. The only downside is the ugly, empty interior, but hopefully this will be taken care of as time goes on, since they just opened recently.

Damon Lakin

If you’re on the hunt for the perfect slice, look no further than Benny’s — a true gem that checks every box and then some! From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted like family. The service is beyond exceptional — warm, friendly, and attentive without being overbearing. You can tell the team here genuinely cares about their customers, and it makes every visit feel special. Now let’s talk about the food — wow. Every bite of Benny’s pizza is a masterpiece. The crust is that perfect balance of crispy and chewy, the sauce bursts with rich, savory flavor, and the toppings are always fresh and generously layered. Whether you’re a classic pepperoni lover or into creative combos, Benny’s never disappoints. Don’t skip the garlic knots or the house-made marinara — they’re addictive. But what truly sets Benny’s apart is the atmosphere. It’s cozy yet vibrant, with just the right mix of laid-back charm and lively energy. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice on your lunch break or settling in for a relaxed dinner with friends, it’s the kind of place that makes you want to stay awhile. In a world full of average pizza joints, Benny’s stands out as something truly special. Amazing food, amazing service, and a vibe that keeps you coming back — this place is a total win. 🍕✨ 10/10 — Highly recommend!