Joe Nelsen

hands down , best crust i have ever had ! top notch customer service and the pizza slices were more than delicious, heaven i would say

Julie Doucette

Absolutely the best Pizza in the Buffalo area hands down! The staff is equally amazing, especially the man making the pizza. This pizza is so mouthwatering delicious, you can’t stop at one or two slices. The pizza was thin crust and crispy, a ton of mozzarella cheese and yummy pepperoni, and the pizza sauce was so frigen good. We ordered a small 16” pepperoni pizza 8 slices and demolished it (I could only eat 3 slices but hubby didn’t hesitate to finish the rest😃 we stopped in for late dinner from our shopping in the US from Toronto and it was a fantastic choice! Also close to the outlets and other great stores. Enjoy all, we will definitely be coming back to Broadway Pizza 🥰

+1

Terence

Staff is very friendly and has a great sense of humor. Food is absolutely fantastic!!!! Calamari is a must!! Crispy on the outside and cooked to perfection. We had the Meat Lover Pie, Calamari and the chicken wings was absolutely delicious. Will definitely stop by again on our next visit!

FMG Productions

Great place for New York style pizza. The owners are very interactive and friendly. If you are looking for straight up New York city style pizza I’m talking then foldable slices in Broadway Pizza and Niagara Falls is the place to go. They also have a wide variety of other items that I have yet to try but based off the quality of the pizza I ordered I am sure they are good. There’s also ample room to sit down and eat if you’d like or take it to go do yourself a favor and try Broadway Pizza Niagara Falls.

+1

NotxarbYT

First time trying NY style pizza, wasn't disappointed. Cheap food (fed a family of 4 with leftovers and soda for $20), and was very tasty. Largest selection of menu items I have ever seen, and the workers were friendly and to the point. Would recommend!

Elder Martinez

Excellent NYC style pizza . I was recommended here and being the foodie I am I had to check it out. I had the pepperoni , cheese & garlic knots. Talking to the sweet lady at the register I learned that this is a family establishment and you can tell they take pride in what they cook because the pizza was amazing and delicious . I’m from Brooklyn and it brought me back so much nostalgia. The taste of everything is on point. Highly recommend! Will be back for more ! YUM.

Eric Massey

Pizza was amazing, Staff was super friendly I really don't know what could make this place better. Prices were good for the size of the pizza. Wings were excellent, nice and crisp, not burnt not all soft or frlmsy skin but cooked perfectly. If you're in town, new to town, or a local whose been unsure about giving them a try. Go in there and get your self a slice just to try it. I guarantee you'll be back buying whole pies..

Rob Holman

While traveling to Niagara Falls (the falls) we stopped in Niagara Falls (the city) at Broadway Pizza. We were looking for NY Style pizza and White Pizza, in particular, and wow! it was so good. I have had NY Style Pizza in several places in upstate NY as well as various places in Manhattan and Queens and this place stacks up with the best of them with a nice thin crust and good topping choices. We liked that they have pizza by-the-slice so we could get a bunch to try (shown in one of the pictures) and all were yummy. The Philly Cheesesteak was surprisingly good, even with some American Cheese interspersed. (My son was super happy about this) and the Buffalo Chicken was not too saucy. They even had a decent Jamaican Beef Patty, which I couldn't resist trying. The folks that run it were very friendly and it was a great lunch experience for a little over $30 for four of us.

The crust and cheese are the star of the show here they are excellent the sauce and pepperoni not so much sauce lacked personality was very flat in flavor pepperoni ok but not very flavorful cool spot with great staff though

Stu W.

Well what can I say it definitely not New York style pizza for anybody that's been to New York City as many times as I have trust me when I say that this is the farthest thing from New York style pizza as I've ever seen hard dry flavorless crust the next day you could literally break this pizza in half. Don't be fooled by toppings if you're looking for New York style pizza place this is not the place! Real pizza connoisseurs will tell you that!

Ryan Amatuzio

I went there for lunch today and ordered a stinger sub ( hero ) and there was literally one steak-um and one chicken finger chopped up on it with massive amounts of lettuce to make the sub look bigger. I wouldn’t eat there ever again. Shorty behind the counter was nice and she didn’t make the food so nothing wrong with service but whoever made this sub should be jailed for robbery.