Joe Higgins

I cannot say enough about this Amish run establishment. I can't figure out how they can price their breakfast so low. Service is exceptional as is the food. The place is spotless!

Nina TS

Whenever we visit Penn Yann and need to grab lunch, this is our go-to place for food. We do shop at the store, which is amazing with all their options. This time, we went in for a late lunch before running more errands. Between us, we tried an assortment, and everything was delicious! It's all made in their little Cafe. I tried the Southwest Salad, which was the special, my wife had the Oven Roasted Chicken Panini, and we grabbed a bowl of Potato & Ham Chowder soup to bring home. The Salad was delicious, with the dressing being just the right amount of spice. The sandwich was perfectly made. The soup was perfect for the chilly day we stopped in. I've tried multiple items on the menu and everything is delicious. They have wholesome and healthy options for anyone whose looking for specific dietary needs.

Kelly M. (creperum)

Friendly service and big portions for lunch. The tastiest oak milk latte's around! We make sure to come here whenever we're in the area.

Jennifer Conway

Highly recommend!!! Love the zucchini panini and we tried the zucchini chowder soup ☺️ plus my husband enjoyed his mocha java!

poisoned_record

Stopped in for breakfast while camping in Keuka State Park. Amazing fruit smoothies, the raspberry was delicious! Even stopped in again for breakfast the next day for an amazing blueberries and cream latte and French toast for breakfast, as well as a zucchini Panini to go for lunch later in the day. 10/10 Cafe! Great service and lovely atmosphere! Presentation of dishes is also very pretty, even when you order to-go!

Brittany Moore

This little store and cafe is always a delightful experience! It’s wildly popular for good reason, always clean and bright and busy! It’s located just a few miles outside of Penn Yan and if you’re going to the Windmill it’s right on your way. The food from the cafe is wonderful, I’m partial to the paninis!

Holly Pealo

I loved this place! The food and coffee were very good, the service was fast and the people friendly. After breakfast we shopped around in the grocery and gift area. A really fun stop on our overnight getaway.

Curtis Cressman

I ordered the July Special, Peach Panini. It was super good!! I was a little skeptic at first, but thought I’d give it a try since it is very popular. Well for good reason! It’s also a very nice atmosphere here with friendly people. (Customers and staff)

taylor franklin

Maybe one of my favourite spots to eat in the Finger Lakes area. If I could I would fly up every morning( home is Austin) to grab a freshly made Seneca Sunrise Sandwich. It was pure perfection between two perfectly toasted slices of bread. And while it might seem like an odd combo to some it paired perfectly with a side of the mac salad! The people working here were so lovely and helpful. I would give it 10 stars if I could.

Amish bulk food store, deli, and cafe. Amish servers are very kind, helpful, and efficient. The food is some of the best and freshest in the area. Accepts EBT/SNAP, Debit/Credit, Cash.

J L

Great breakfast spot with a unique grocery store next door. It got pretty busy during our visit so be prepared to wait. My Seneca breakfast sandwich was delicious. Also, try the Frye pies!

Tomas Ortiz-Potter

Disappointed today, we absolutely love oak hill and they have the freshest food. Ate at their cafe today and served really low quality meat, the chicken was comparable to the inside of a chicken nugget, definitely not the oven roasted chicken that was advertised. The roast beef was shiny and looked fake. All of the baked goods are amazing, very conflicted about the sandwiches today. Will not order the paninis again.