The food is good and the service is amazing. The new drink menu is nice and I really like the honey Cajun chicken wings!

great Thursday night burger deal, awesome burgers.

Highly recommend going to this place ordered a Burger& Fries the burger done the way I like. Service was excellent my server was Morgan she always made sure everything was to my liking. I will likely come back to this place next time I am in East Aurora.

Great food great prices. Will definitely return in the future

Amazing! Dinner was incredible! The appetizer, main course and desert! Drunken clams💋 filets and lobster tail! 🤩! Peanut butter pie😍! And a bottle of champagne… $100?!? !! Valentines special! Service was fantastic! Bartender on point! So glad to have Riley Street Station back “☺️(and the owner working as hard as the staff!)

Great place. Eating area is quaint, good is great! Nice happy hour. Fire place, ambiance. Waitress was very nice, quick and attentive.

There were 6 of us dining before a Concert. The service was wonderful. The girls serving were delightful !

Went here last week with a few friends, we were immediately welcomed in from the host & didn’t even have to wait to get seated! Dining room looks amazing! Food came out fast & was hot & fresh! 10/10 will be coming back again soon!

I love the ribeye steak here. It is perfectly cooked and seasoned. The bartenders are very personable, welcoming, and friendly.

We held a baby shower here. The service and atmosphere was great. Brunch was predictable but good.

Excellent food wings were perfectly cooked, and the fries were very good. The French onion soup was also very good. The bar service was quick and friendly with good selection. We went on 75 cent wing night and will be returning. Got a side of their house blended wing and finger sauce it tasted strongly of artificial butter. I wasn't a fan of it, but this is due to a preference to real butter. Overall, it was a great experience

Delicious food. Great service. A standard in East Aurora! A must! The chili is piping hot and delicious. Takes away the blues in our cold weather. Gandy room open Fridays and Saturdays. It's a warm environment with great service.

I had my rehearsal dinner here and not only was the communication from start to finish incredible, but so is the staff. I have to give a special shout out to John who not only dealt with my bridezilla moment (due to unforseen parking issues) he also tried to make my day easier because of my worries over parking. I told them I loved fries but we didn't choose it for our menu. They remembered and made a special plate just for me. The atmosphere is incredible. The food is awesome. What really sold me though was the incredible staff from start to finish. Everyone who works there is incredible and they all deserve a raise especially Shelley and John. Thank you all for making our rehearsal dinner perfect.

Wonderful lunch/dinner. Our waitress was superb!! Thank you so much

We had a great lunch, we sat on the patio and had wings and fries. The queso was delicious as were the wings. I loved the honey Cajun sauce. Cassie was our server and she was great, she was busy but super attentive.

First time here and they didn't disappoint. An esthetically beautiful restaurant tucked away along the train tracks. Nicely priced menu and the food was great. Our waitress was very friendly. We would definitely return.

Riley station has upped their game since I was last there! Full compliment of local beer and nice portions of beautifully presented and we'll prepared food. Burger was huge and prepared as ordered, Medium rare. The curly fries were interesting shape and cooked crisp and served hot. Fish tacos for my friend and they were delicious too. Small fingers of crispy battered fish topped with crunchy Sriracha slaw and double taco and flour tortillas shell. We dined out back in the glassed in enclosure overlooking evergreens and green space. It will be lovely in the summer. Nice to have more classy options to dine.

Ate here with my fiance last night. The portobello sandwich was great and the sweet potato fries were perfect. My fiance was in love with the "honey cajun BBQ" chicken wings. Destiny was the real highlight though, she was outstanding, fun and kind and really made our night. We will be coming back soon!

This was our first stop on the Delicious East Aurora food tour. Excellent food and we even hot to meet the chef! The restaurant is very nice!

Food was very good ,first time having Rachele ,almost like a a Reuben only with turkey

The best Mahi fish tacos,with a chocolate martini and pecan cheesecake, this birthday girls meal was complete and amazing

Excellent patio restaurant for summer, able to make reservations for large group, food was great, service was spot on! Beef on week - 2 thumbs up!

Great food! Ambiance and service also excellent!

Great place to eat and bring the family to. Definitely will be back again from the Southern tier

After walking East Aurora, we decided to come here for lunch. Their French Onion soup is always delicious. So were the rest of our meals. We always tend to stop here to eat when we come to town.

Food was great; server was friendly and attentive. Very pleasant atmosphere.

The owner served our table, and the experience was great! They probably have the best options for happy hour apps in the area, and the prices are great. Looking forward to stopping by again real soon

Change your stuffed pepper recipe- the chorizo is way too greasy.

We stopped for a quick lunch while visiting for the day. The food was great, and our server was attentive and friendly. It was a great find as a last minute decision, and I would recommend it.

Nicely perserved but refurbished train station! Fireplace, ambience, setting offered a casual-to-fine dining experience. Our waitress Amber, absolutely friendly, accurate, courteous, efficient, just perfect!! There's outdoor patios as well. Also has bar. But this was NOT a sports/bar grill when dining. The dining areas completely separate from the bar area! Portions out weighed the cost for sure. Fair dining prices. Can't wait to go back!!

+1

I've been dying to try this place for awhile, so me, my boyfriend, and son went last weekend. The food was delicious, we especially enjoyed the creamy spinach and artichoke appetizer. The service was fabulous, even with the busy atmosphere, which, too or surprise, there was even a band playing! Great music, great food, and great staff, all for a great price! Definitely will be back.

We had a fast, friendly and great waiter named Aaron. He explained what Daily specials were and the soups available we were a senior group of ten. He went above and beyond to make sure we were all taken care of separate checks can be a pain. Loved the food and the decor will definitely be going back

Had a full service party of 20 last night. Everyone and Everything was EXCELLENT and I mean Everything. From the Hospitality from Anthony to the service from Tessa and crew. Thanks guys, see you again!

+2

Didn’t catch our servers name last night but she and the food were great! It was extremely busy so the little wait was understandable

Riley Street station is back and better than ever! Anthony and the team at Riley’s have done an amazing job with reopening such a historic restaurant in the heart of East Aurora. The service was fast, friendly and extremely attentive. The food was the real highlight though. With a newly revamped menu we struggled to decide what to eat. After some guidance we went with the spinach and artichoke dip, the chicken finger pizza, the fish tacos and apple bourbon bbq burger, Everything was delicious but the fish tacos and burger and sweet potato fries were the winners for us. Can’t wait to go back and try the rest of that stellar menu!

Great food, fantastic service. We were seated in the back near the windows by the tracks. It was interesting learning about the history of the building and it was fun to watch a train go by.

This place is outstanding! I have lived in area my whole life and Riley’s street has always had new owners but the one that owns Riley’s now knows what they are doing! Awesome food, great service and the prices are not that bad I decently recommend the mahi tacos!!

Jeffrey Chlebowy

We went for half price burgers on Thursday night. Big burger and hand cut fries for $8? You can't beat that deal anywhere.

Merced Leiker

The Black and Blue burger was fantastic! The bacon and bleu cheese crumbles really made the burger. I ordered it medium rare and it was cooked PERFECTLY. Our waitress was wonderful - friendly and interactive. And highly attentive! I can't remember her name but we were there Wed Jan 7 2026 at 5PM. And the place was nicely decorated for Christmas still. Just beautiful inside.

Mike Bowman

My wife and I ate at Riley Street Station on the recommendation of an employee at the motel where we stayed. I'm glad we went there! I had the best fish tacos I have ever had, and my wife enjoyed her meal, also! We were treated well by the staff there, and we were served in a timely fashion. We enjoyed eating outside the evening we ate there. If you are ever in East Aurora, NY, you definitely must eat at Riley Street Station!

Kevin T Jordan

this is the second time my wife and I have eaten here. we had the beef on weck, and the wings..hot of course. both times we were not disappointed. the food is excellent as well as the service. we will definitely be back. thank you for the delicious food.

+1

Robert James, Jr.

09/09/2025: Haven't been here in a while. Just a random Tuesday afternoon today. The chicken wings and onion pedals were fantastic. ~Love the food here. 08/11/21: Good burgers, fries, and dessert. Service was quick and efficient. We were there on DJ Trivia Wednesday. It was a good time.

Teresa Richie

My husband and I went on a Saturday and we both ordered burgers. My husband had the apple bacon burger and I had the goat cheese burger and both were delicious!!! Our waitress was awesome. Very knowledgeable and helpful. We will definitely be back.

J Ell

Went in toward the end of the evening and had a ribeye that was cooked to perfection. The whole dish was outstanding and my bartender (sat at the bar) was very attentive and friendly. Patrons were all easy-going and nice to talk with

Best Domains in America

Great dinner at Rileys this weekend with family while enjoying their amazing outside patio. I had the turkey club wrap with sweet potato waffle fries with honey, it was outstanding. Son had Buffalo Wings which were Carolina Gold and grilled, he loved them and daughter had a chicken quesadilla with tortilla chips. Everyone was very happy and is excited to go back. Band on the patio started at 7. Highly recommend, great outdoor seating and will be back soon.

David Niedbala

We enjoyed the cowboy burgers for lunch and I opted for the sweet potato fries. The food was delicious! I have had sweet potato fries at many places and these were really good! 5/5 on the sauce! Portion size for the burger was perfect too!

Joe Massey

Our hockey team ate here after a hockey game at the classic rink. Great wings and good atmosphere. Pretty neat this was an old train station

+1

M. Klein

Stopped in for dinner and it was packed. We ended up just eating at the bar, as the wait was an hour. It worked out fine. Riley Street Station was decorated up nicely for the holidays. The Mediterranean wrap was good. Their fresh cut fries were great. The hand cut fingers were delicious. The scampi was reported to be good as well. The prices seemed reasonable. Service was good except for clearing the dirty plates, but overall a nice experience. We will be going back.

+4

Linda Mann

The burgers are absolutely delicious! I had the Black & Blue burger and hubby had the Stuffed Banana Pepper Burger. Oh... and the onion petals... YUM!!! Relaxing atmosphere and family friendly. Will definitely go back when I'm in the area.

Dave Lush

Fantastic food! I got the scallops special, Caesar salad, clams casino and they were amazing! The scallops didn’t taste like sand and fish. They were cooked to perfect! Great job to the chefs!

Visited after a long day travelling. Had a nice beer and some chicken wings.

Good food and great service. Daily specials make for economic choices.

Even though they had a big party of 30 it moved along fairly well. Service was very good and kept apologizing for the delay. Food also very well received. Would recommend to check it out.

Great bar to drink at and good location. Food and service is starting to go downhill. Bartender himself was nice and apologetic but it feels like he's wearing too many hats and is overtasked.

Unique venue. Good menu selections. Try the beef on wick - awesome. Our server today was excellent, courteous and friendly.

Went for dinner July 17th with my Daughter and Grandson. Food was Excellent, our Waitress was Excellent. I was little disappointed in my Strawberry Margarita, basically watered down. Usually 1 good Margarita and I'm good for a drink, didn't really get that from this drink. Also we sat outside in front, tables and chairs need to be wiped down before service. They were incredibly dusty from the driveway work being done.

Always have good food, no matter what I try to order. Great local place with new ownership that seems to want to make sure everyone is happy.

We like Riley's Street. Always have. Very kind staff, even when I forgot to call for reservations a day earlier they accommodated us. Little disappointed in the food this time around as the calamari was over cooked as well as the wings(ordered extra saucy and they came out with little sauce and way too crispy) . We are chalking it up to a bad day which happens. We will be back to try again

We had a really nice lunch. The place us really cute. The food is unique. I got a goat cheese burger with balsamic glaze and my husband got a burger with apples and bacon jam. The sweet potato fries had a really good maple glaze on them. We would go again.

Went here with a friend on a weeknight and it was a good experience. Prices for food weren’t too unreasonable. Caesar salad had about twice as much dressing as it should have. Completely drenched. My pasta was also swimming in sauce. Clams casino was made well. Service was good, overall a good experience.

I had a birthday dinner not too long ago and the service and food was great. I was a bit busy but the everything came out great and timely. I had a great birthday dinner.

Good service, decent food. Though when they advertise handcut fries and you get little bits and pieces of potato fried in dirty oil, I expected more!

Busy night for them, some food items had run out, somewhat small portions. We had to wait for our reserved table. Good service, very friendly and nice when the owner checks on you! Beautiful tree out front!!

Waitress did not provide specials while others did for other patrons. Sandwich was missing an ingredient listed on the menu. No mention that the sweet potato fries had additional ingredient added (brown sugar) Otherwise the burger and sandwich we got were good.

Jennifer

Pretty neat place as far as looks. The food was okay. The online menu is not the same as the restaurant menu ( prob just not updated) so make sure if you are going there for something specific they have it first.

Mary Krencik

Food was excellent. The chicken fingers were huge, just service was a tad slow and I Sat facing the sink/service area.... Appreciate the fact the owner or manager came around asking how our dinner was. P.S. the Cajun BBQ sauce is amazing!

Francis Cavalier

Great little pub in East Aurora, redesigned from past layout, the bar is spacious with several TVs . The back room is very open with lots of windows and a great view of the train bed . The food was awesome , I had the Ruben and the portion was huge . The surprise of the meal were the sweet potato fries . Wafgle fries covered in honey and brown sugar . Beer selection was OK , they had a few local drafts . Definitely recommend stopping in Updated visit: we had to go back for another family dinner this time , I got the wings this time and they didn't disappoint. In an area of world class wing places , Rikeys it in the top echelon with all the other greats . Definitely try the wings

This was my first visit since the reopening. I've been here many times prior. The food was a hit or miss. The appetizers were mediocre while the burgers and chicken parm were good. The wine selection needs improvement - a small wine list with a few vineyards per type seems to better fit the food menu. The staff was nice but somewhat disorganized. It was a busy night, and a band was playing in the bar area. I plan to return and hope some of the above are just growing pains.

The tree was the best part. The food was just okay. Not one of our meals was hot, the soups and salads came just after the entrees were served. It's loud and the seating is crowded. Our waitress made incredibly brief stops at our table and basically dropped off rolls and barely looked at us. We were looking forward to this dinner and we were all disappointed.

We went as a table of 4 adults and 3 toddlers, we had 4 orders of wings for wing night and 2 children’s meals, waited over an hour for our food. Restaurant was not busy at all, maybe 4 or 5 other tables. Seemed like a long time for a simple order. No explanation from our waitress.

If I hadn’t eaten there before I would never go back. We got the fajitas and it was like boiled meat with no flavor and they didn’t have all the fixings. Luckily we’ve eaten there before with other meals and it is normally really good.

Got a burger and French onion soup. Soup was bland for onion soup. Hamburger well it just a burger.

I only gave the service 2 stars because it took about an hour for a Reuben and an appetizer. Our server was good.

We had to wait a long time for a table. The burgers that we ordered came really close to being raw inside, the burger that my wife got had a plastic bread closure in her burger and it was raw inside. No one from the kitchen ever came out to apologize just the waitress and the hostess and it was not there fault. I am pretty sure there were several health violations that day. Will not be returning. To many other good restaurants in EA.

Came at 4:30 on a football Sunday. Wasn't very full, but was told 10-15 min wait. After 30 minutes we left. They were clearly under staffed and having trouble.

First time in years I have been here. Service was okay, dirty dishes left on table. Fish was brown and well overcooked. Pesto linguini with shrimp had NO flavor and over priced. Out of a party of 6 not one of us finished our food.One dish was perfect,the chicken wings! $175 bill. Not worth it at all. Unfortunately we will not be back.

Great location, service and ambience, sub par food. Night life looks strong. I really wanted to find goodness here. Sadly, our meal had little to speak kindly of. The grease is old. Burgers were dry, and something is up with the pizza crust. I assume they use a thin frozen crust on the kids menu A silverfish dropped from the ceiling onto our plate, and that was the end of our meal.

Atmosphere was wonderful and our server was wonderful but sadly the food was not good. Had the pasta Primavera and it had NO Flavor or seasoning. Very dry and not even a handful of vegetables in it. Definitely not worth the $18. Also red wine selection needs improvement.

Came for a visit on two separate occasions and sat in the dining room area. Only one of us liked the food either time. The service was extremely slow. The second time we came, one of our guest's meal was forgotten and they didn't get it until the rest of us were all done; they ended up taking it to go. And after a switch of the bartenders, the second one didn't know how to make one of the drink specials. We did get comped for said meal and drink. It is a nice looking dining area, however there are too many good restaurants in East Aurora to make it worth trying to dine here again. Hopefully the bar area is better.

First time trying the new Riley's and it will definitely be the last. The wings tasted only of old fryer grease. No flavor at all. The pizza was a round flavorless chunk of bread. To say it was disappointing is an understatement. It filled the garbage instead of being eaten. Will not be returning.

Service was extremely slow, food was extremely slow to come out, took the waitress 30 mins to refill a drink. Definitely won't be back

So I went for a fishfry last Friday ... I was told I couldn't have a table, but I had to eat at the bar cause it was only me and didn't have another person so I ordered a blueberry beer and it was so funky like they've never cleaned the taps before just sour nasty terrible and I asked if I could order a fishfry and they just said yeah it's this much money no menu no nothing and I said OK. The fish came smelled like ammonia the batter which is supposed to be deep-fried was either steamed or microwaved. It was soggy like gum and just tasted horrific like it was bleached out with some kind of ammonia. I don't know kill any bacteria, but I find myself sitting in the bar by myself with a horrible fish, fry, horrible beer, and the funny thing about it is the fish fry was $20. He told me which is insanely expensive. No other restaurant charges $20 and it's the worst food worst beer worst experience I've ever had in my life never ever ever ever never again.

Just decided to stop in for pizza and wings ....let's say please take the pizza off the menu....frozen dough, bland sauce spiced up with oregano and cheap pepperoni....to RSS's credit they did offer to take off bill and replace...but we said no, but they still removed pizza off bill...of course we left the other half....maybe try a sandwhich next...fyi our male waiter was fantastic and understanding..he gets 5 stars...

The food was burnt and couldn't eat it. I'm not sure how a chef could send it out. I thought the stuffed mushroom cap was a bit laughable as you only get 1 tiny thing for the price. The food tasted cheap and it was anything but.

We had a reservation for 1:30 for 9 people ! Seated on time but waited over an hour for food !!! Food was average. No explanation from waitress. Did note she was the only one working the dining room. Need acoustic tile in ceiling. If management was there I would have complained personally

The meal should have been at least 20 percent off, with a 20 percent coupon for next time. But due to the owners GREED he hid like a coward hoping the The problem would resolve itself! They should’ve informed the customers when they came in that they were running way behind instead they hid that from the customers! Waited 10 minutes for a table, which is understandable, them were at the table for approximately 20 minutes before someone even came over then we were told I’m sorry they didn’t tell me I had this table. Poor Management again. Then we waited approximately 50 minutes for a double order of wings and a pizza! IF THEY EXPECT TO LAST IN EAST AURORA THEY HAD BETTER GET THERE HEAD SCREWED ON STRAIGHT!!! The customer should not have to chase the owner down! I own my own business and I don’t operate like that ! This is called getting involved with the customer! They also should come around and ask how things are tonight and not leaving it all up to the waitress! GET WITH THE PROGRAM OR GET OUT OF BUSINESS!🤔

We went in on a Sunday my son and my husband, not many people there. We waited almost an hour for a small cheese pizza, 10 wings and a soup… the pizza was hard and very burnt at the bottom with pounds of cheese and pounds of sauce. Very unfortunate since we have come here in the past and it has been great. The service was very poor as well..

Joel Hayden

As a few others describe in their reviews, we too encountered a surly waitress and very substandard service. After waiting over 30 minutes for our food, we left. Meanwhule, others seated nearby after we arrived received their orders and were finished eating. It is an easy decision not to give this place another try.

Anne

Went on Sunday, only seating at bar tables which was fine. Bartender totally ignored when we went up to order food and drinks. She was too busy with her friends at the other end of the bar to care that we needed anything. She was telling other people she didn't want to work, but nobody would take her shift. Some guy at bar took empty plates away (not sure if he was her bf). Other patrons were ready to leave. Hostess was absent when additional people were coming in.

Sara Wolfie

Tldr: No service during the unreasonably long waits for food, with way too much noise and a surly waitress. ** I do not recommend the glass patio if you have any kind of hearing problem or hearing related sensory issues. ** I went for lunch with a small group of around 10 people. The waitress got our drinks to the table and took our food orders fairly quickly. She then disappeared until our food was dropped off **over an hour later**. At that point, she offered drink refills and disappeared again until it was time to pay and leave. She also had an attitude - not a good one. I had the burger with apples on it. The apples were diced into tiny pieces and mixed with the BBQ sauce. I only know they were actually there because I could see the tiny lumps in the sauce. They added nothing to the taste or texture and didn't live up to the hype in the menu. The burger itself was properly cooked the way I asked for and tasted good. We sat in the glass patio. The scenery was a pretty view of the side of a hill. There's nothing to keep the sound from bounching around and echoing, so it was very loud with people talking and the overhead music. It was a small room with few people in it, but it sounded like the middle of a large crowd.

Dauble Music

I really enjoyed my chicken water! Just hope to see more water next time though. Gross food, $14 for one piece of mushroom that was also swimming in water. Service wasn’t great either. Atmosphere and decoration is the only thing thats good and you regret everything quickly after. They only have 4-5 things on the main menu and they shouldn’t be this bad. Never going again.