Mark Cruz

Our San Diego friends invited us to meet at Mayahuel and we had such a good time. Our waiter was just great. We all had multiple margaritas with tequila and mezcal. They were delicious. Most of us had yummy tacos and I ate the wonderful chicken mole. Great atmosphere.

Ali P

SOME OF THE BEST MEXICAN FOOD & tequila! I’ve come here numerous times and always come back because I can’t get enough of their yummy food and drinks. They started with a small hole in the wall spot and have expanded to a covered patio bar as well for more room (which means more space to eat, drink, and be merry!) Now I’m not big on tequila but if you are this is your spot! They have a huge array of different types of tequila and the bartenders are very knowledgeable about them to help you pick the one you’ll like. I almost always order carnitas tacos with rice and beans (can’t get enough of it!) except for when I make it in for the seafood stew. The seafood stew is a MUST try, one of my favorite things I’ve probably ever tasted (and I eat a lot). The seafood is fresh the broth is both refreshing and spicy, so so good! You obviously can’t come here and not have some margaritas to wash down your food! They also have a happy hour! I’ll always continue to come here!

Danielle M

I really love the mezcal margarita, so good! The mahi ceviche was tasty, I'd definitely suggest trying that. I also had a shrimp and a steak taco. I think the steak was the more flavorful of the two. They have some super super hot sauce if you're very brave!

Amjad Kinhnarath

Great find and recommendation from some local friends. There is indoor and outdoor seating. Its was a little chilly so we sat at the inside bar and did not regret it. The tequila selection was great and the bartenders we're very knowledgeable. Definitely try the house made tequila. The food was unexpectedly great. Looking at the menu was just the normal mexican fair but the tacos were outstanding.

+1

Jamie Zelek

Stopped here for lunch on a Saturday and I was very impressed! Our waiter was very knowledgeable about the tequilas on the menu and made us the best margaritas we’ve ever had. So fresh with smooth, perfect tequila, and at $9.50 each you can’t beat it! The food was also amazing (get carnitas and the chicken tacos!) everything tasted so good I couldn’t decide what my favorite was! Something unique they have there is the Yucatan seafood stew every Saturday, which I feel so lucky that I got to eat! It was such a cozy dish, with very unique flavors (pineapple, cumin, etc), and the seafood was so fresh. Overall this is a place with great food, an extensive collection of tequila, and unbeatable prices. You have to check it out!

Volodymyr Korsun

Great place with a unique vibe that serves outstanding margaritas!! Smoky mezcal margarita with Jamaica juice is amazing 😍 also good quality guacamole with chips and pico de gallo. However, the quality of the tacos was sub par, not even decent. The fish was super dry and tasteless. Carne asada was on the drier side as well. If they were to improve on the quality of their tacos this place could be bomb!

+9

Lily BW

The nopales with chips were delicious! I had the shrimp platter, my daughter the chicken platter and my hubby had the mahi mahi platter. The food should have been hot when reaching the table. Aside from that, it was good. The staff was great and the atmosphere was fun.

Melissa Martinez

The atmosphere was great, covered outdoor seating. It was very comfortable. The tequila and mezcal selection was amazing, however, they should be enjoyed by themselves as their cocktails are bland. The food was average at best, portions were small for the guys in our group. Some of them ate again afterwards. We ordered chips and guacamole, the portion was small, even on the chips. No salsa per se, they serve pica de gallo, not spicy. They also have a habanero water salsa in a plastic bottle they pass around. I ordered the steak plate, the steak was tender and I enjoyed the meal, but it was very basic. Salsa would have been nice. Service was mediocre. I’m glad we checked it out, but I won’t return.

Nivedita Paul

Stopped by on a week day. Was excited to try the mezcal margaritas. Ordered both flavors they have to offer - the original & Jamaica. Super duper disappointed :,( Decided to give the mezcal flight a try. That was a good choice. Should’ve done that instead of ordering the cocktails. Oh well! My favorite out of the 3 was hands down “Sierra Negra”.

regis kwong

Located in the vibrant University Heights area of San Diego, Cantina Mayahuel offers a taste of Mexico with its charming ambiance and lively bar. Let’s dive into the details: Atmosphere and Charm: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ The restaurant exudes a cozy, rustic vibe, complete with colorful tiles and wooden accents. It’s the kind of place where you can kick back, enjoy a drink, and soak in the Mexican spirit. Bar Delights: 🍻🥃 The bar at Cantina Mayahuel is a highlight. With an impressive selection of tequilas and a variety of beers, it’s a great spot for unwinding after a long day. Whether you’re sipping a margarita or opting for a cold cerveza, the bar won’t disappoint. The Food: 🌮🦐 Ceviche: Not bad at all! The tangy, citrus-marinated seafood is refreshing, especially on a warm San Diego day. The balance of flavors is commendable. Beef Tacos: Unfortunately, these didn’t hit the mark. The beef was lackluster, and the overall flavor fell short. San Diego sets high standards for Mexican cuisine, and Cantina Mayahuel didn’t quite meet them. Final Verdict: While Cantina Mayahuel has its moments of charm and decent offerings, it falls short in terms of food quality. If you’re seeking an authentic Mexican culinary experience, you might want to explore other options in San Diego. Remember, taste is subjective, and what one person finds mediocre, another might adore. So, if you’re in the mood for a laid-back evening with good drinks and a dash of Mexican flair, Cantina Mayahuel could still be worth a visit. 🌮🍹

+2

It does seem like my experience isn't the norm here but my experience was shockingly poor. Our group of 6 left a pop up show to grab a bite here. We showed up at 9:20, but they are open to 10 and we even asked if the kitchen was cool with it. We ordered right away though since they said they do last call at 930. All of us ordered right away. When the server delivered the food only 2 out of 6 meals came out and she acted like that was it. When we re ordered they kind of made a stink, and then forgot 2 meals again!! And refused to finish the order. Not really apologetic, eventually comped 1 meal, and was just unacceptable service. Food that came was good though. Weirdest thing, the manager Jorge at the end was very defensive about the situation. We were patient with the first mess up, doing it twice and not caring is annoying. The manager said a few times "the food you did get was good though." Unhinged response. Probably won't be back, which is a shame as the food was good, because of the management and service.

Ville Blackstone

I've been here once. And won't go back. The latino bartender is a jerk. Dude thinks he's gods gift to bartending or sumn. Relax bro, it's just a bar, you ain't famous. The food is average at best. Fun ambiance except for the short Latino guy in his mid 40s.

Angelo Sotira

Looked online to find a quick taco place with street tacos to bring back to the office. I found this place and decided to give it a try. The owner wouldn’t let me order them to go. Happy hour only, dine in only. It was 1pm on a Tuesday. No logic. No customer service. Ridiculous. Avoid this place like the plague.