Lorenzo's Pizza

Lorenzo Pizzeria is truly an absolute gem of Staten Island. My son was craving pizza late at night around 9pm, and even though they were closing at 9:30, I went in hoping to grab a couple of slices. Instead of handing me older slices, the gentleman insisted on making a fresh pie — and then only charged me for two slices. He was so kind, gentle, and thoughtful with my child, and even brought the fresh pizza out to my car. This kind of love, compassion, and dedication to quality is rare these days. Everything here is made in-house, fresh, and the place is spotless. It’s businesses like this that truly deserve our support. Staten Island is lucky to have them. If you want amazing pizza with a side of genuine kindness, Lorenzo Pizzeria is the place to go. Support small businesses like this — they really make a difference.

Been ordering from them for at least a year now. Their plain pie is solid but if you wanna have a great flavorful experience, do yourself a favor and get the Grandma Pie. It is amazing.

The owner his fiancé and the sweet girl treat me and my son like friends more than customers only place me and my son will get pizza on the island and the pizza best on the island always fresh and they have 11 dollar deals for a large pie Monday to wed which is unbeatable thank you for always treating us good I will go here forever

Have to rate this place again! The food is phenomenal and the staff goes above and beyond. Without a doubt, the best pizza on Staten Island. Thanks again for the free garlic knots on my birthday, you guys rock!

Best wings ever. They give you twelve usually (this time I got 16!) and the hot&honey sauce is to die for. I asked for extra sauce on the side for my fries and they gave me a whole pint of it. 10/10.

Couldn’t make a combination of everything that makes a Staten Island Pizzeria. The moment I stepped into Lorenzo’s I felt like family. It’s so nice to come to get a slice and being able to see a friendly face. Beautiful food and beautiful atmosphere

choppy84

Been ordering from them for at least a year now. Their plain pie is solid but if you wanna have a great flavorful experience, do yourself a favor and get the Grandma Pie. It is amazing.

Victor Difinizio

Had the best Calzone since I’ve lived on Staten Island, the pizza was very good as well. First time ordering from this place and can’t wait to try the others on the menu. I found my new Pizziera.

Mike Cerillo

Love this place, everything is really delicious. Owner is super friendly.

Ivana DiBenedetto

Have to rate this place again! The food is phenomenal and the staff goes above and beyond. Without a doubt, the best pizza on Staten Island. Thanks again for the free garlic knots on my birthday, you guys rock!

johnny chang

Very good tasting and not too salty or oily. The quintessential of a NYC 🍕 😋😉

R rahman

Lorenzo Pizzeria is truly an absolute gem of Staten Island. My son was craving pizza late at night around 9pm, and even though they were closing at 9:30, I went in hoping to grab a couple of slices. Instead of handing me older slices, the gentleman insisted on making a fresh pie — and then only charged me for two slices. He was so kind, gentle, and thoughtful with my child, and even brought the fresh pizza out to my car. This kind of love, compassion, and dedication to quality is rare these days. Everything here is made in-house, fresh, and the place is spotless. It’s businesses like this that truly deserve our support. Staten Island is lucky to have them. If you want amazing pizza with a side of genuine kindness, Lorenzo Pizzeria is the place to go. Support small businesses like this — they really make a difference.

Emma Jackman

Best wings ever. They give you twelve usually (this time I got 16!) and the hot&honey sauce is to die for. I asked for extra sauce on the side for my fries and they gave me a whole pint of it. 10/10.

James Drew

Couldn’t make a combination of everything that makes a Staten Island Pizzeria. The moment I stepped into Lorenzo’s I felt like family. It’s so nice to come to get a slice and being able to see a friendly face. Beautiful food and beautiful atmosphere

Arjeta D

The counter girl was very sweet. I got a regular pie and a personal square pie. It was delicious. I wish I took a photo before I inhaled it. lol

Robert Kramer

All I have to say is that they have great food and pizza, but on Super Bowl night they screwed up my online pizza order, (happens), so I called up and said you got my order wrong and the manager said, don’t worry I’ll just send you another Pizza and keep the one you got. That’s what I expect, great service, from a great place that has great pizza.

samantha calabro

From the moment you step inside, it creates a warm and inviting atmosphere to have the best dining experience. Lorenzo's pizza isn't just a pizzeria, they cater to diverse dietary preferences as well and their menu goes beyond pizza! Their gluten free pizza is just as amazing as a normal slice, and If you love the square pie, I would for sure give it a try here! The staff are friendly, welcoming and attentive ensuring that you have the best dining experience! If you are a pizza lover, this is the place for you. Whether you're a local or just passing through, a visit to Lorenzo's Pizzeria is sure to leave you with a satisfied palate and a smile on your face!

The Philly cheese steak was alright, a bit dry, but I had much better garlic rolls, as they were too soggy and oily.

Thin crispy crust. No discernible style of flavoring. Basically tastes like a grilled cheese. Mediocre; grade this one at 69.

Mark

The Philly cheese steak was alright, a bit dry, but I had much better garlic rolls, as they were too soggy and oily.

Gary Wilson

Thin crispy crust. No discernible style of flavoring. Basically tastes like a grilled cheese. Mediocre; grade this one at 69.

Damn…..disrespectfully burnt my hero 🫣🤦🏼‍♀️ Got 1 chicken parmigiana (that one was delish and not burnt) and one eggplant parmigiana (pictured) but wow lol for the price no thanks ✌️👋

Cynthia Santiago

Damn…..disrespectfully burnt my hero 🫣🤦🏼‍♀️ Got 1 chicken parmigiana (that one was delish and not burnt) and one eggplant parmigiana (pictured) but wow lol for the price no thanks ✌️👋

Have been here three times in the past few months and they have progressively gotten worse. They reheated my slices on dirty aluminum trays the last visit and from that point I will not give them another chance. Place used to be better, not sure if they have new owners or management but it’s terrible now. Go to Round Pie across the street or Prime Pizza a few blocks down, much better pizza.

Unfortunately not what we expected for a “Upside Down” style pizza or even the garlic knots. The pizza looked like it was an old pie & just warmed up and sent out. The garlic knots were BEYOND oily. 8 garlic knots to an order should not be drenched in a bottle of oil before being sent out. Terrible experience. Will not be ordering again. Please do not waste your time on the upside down pizza assuming you’re getting an L&B pie. The prior reviews must be fake because the pie can not compare to anything like L&B. And please deff DO NOT waste your money on the Garlic Knots unless you love dough drenched in oil. Waste of money!

Placed an order on August 30th to be delivered. I never received the order and have to take the lost! But here is a review to let others know. My ordered was never delivered. They stated to SLICE that they delivered it to a lobby. Which lobby we don’t know! I was waiting outside in front for 30 minutes prior to delivery and nobody ever called me!

Tony

Placed an order on August 30th to be delivered. I never received the order and have to take the lost! But here is a review to let others know. My ordered was never delivered. They stated to SLICE that they delivered it to a lobby. Which lobby we don’t know! I was waiting outside in front for 30 minutes prior to delivery and nobody ever called me!

NYS F1NEST

Unfortunately not what we expected for a “Upside Down” style pizza or even the garlic knots. The pizza looked like it was an old pie & just warmed up and sent out. The garlic knots were BEYOND oily. 8 garlic knots to an order should not be drenched in a bottle of oil before being sent out. Terrible experience. Will not be ordering again. Please do not waste your time on the upside down pizza assuming you’re getting an L&B pie. The prior reviews must be fake because the pie can not compare to anything like L&B. And please deff DO NOT waste your money on the Garlic Knots unless you love dough drenched in oil. Waste of money!

Tony C

Ordered online for a well done cooked pie for a certain time pick-up. Got there on time and he is just putting in my pizza. Another customer comes in after me and gets his pie before me. Finally get home to find an undercooked terrible tasting pizza. First and last time for me.

Chris

Have been here three times in the past few months and they have progressively gotten worse. They reheated my slices on dirty aluminum trays the last visit and from that point I will not give them another chance. Place used to be better, not sure if they have new owners or management but it’s terrible now. Go to Round Pie across the street or Prime Pizza a few blocks down, much better pizza.