Marsyita Mohtar

Cute cookie bakery serving delicious novelty cookies and brownies in the heart of Castro. I had both the Sticky Nicky and a PB cookie. Both were delicious! Would return to get more novelty brownies.

Emilee Bargoma

This spot is a vibe. The music is good, the colors are lively, and my cookie choices were delicious. Definitely won't be frequenting regularly because, potbelly. But it's a definite goto for a quick fix every once in a while🤤.

Diana Nunes

You have to make this one of your stops while in San Francisco. As soon as you walk in the environment is warm and welcoming. The cookies smell amazing. The staff here is very kind and will go over all the cookies with you só know you exactly which one you’re craving. They also roll the cookie dough near you so you can actually see these artists at work. Super super cool. Cookies are delicious!

Maricha MartinezSosa

A taxi driver told me: if you go to Castro, you MUST stop by Hot Cookie and boy was he right! Their products are DELICIOUS! I as with a group so we got a variety to try and they all had a few common denominators: perfect balance between moist and crumbling texture, warm and you could feel they were fresh. I would back the taxi driver's advice: when in Castro, stop there and grab a few, they're still yummy the next morning!

+2

Sisi Chen

Seriously so tasty! Crunchy on the outside and chewy on the inside. We've tried their coco mac daddy, toffee milk chocolate and their peanut butter. They are all delicous. If you only want to try one, get the coco mac daddy! The ultimate pairing is to walk down to Castro Tarts and get their iced Vietnamese coffee.

Leslie Meyer

What a unique shop! My friends took me here while visiting San Francisco and I was absolutely delighted. It features tasty treats as well an entire wall covered with half naked pictures of people wearing the famed "Hot Cookie Undies". I bought the fruity pebbles Rice Krispy treat and was amazed by the size (freaking giant) and the tasty (surprisingly good). I will definitely come back here when I come back to SF.

Patrick Diaz Miholic

Hot Cookie is a must stop shop on any visit to SF. Their combination of tasty carbolicious sugar filled treats, fabulous staff and camp atmosphere put a smile on my face every time I visit. My personal favorites are the ginger snaps and macaroons! YUM! But if you're looking for something more adventurous try one of their famous phallic shaped bickies! This place really epitomises the saying "sugar, spice and everything nice"!!

Rachelle Lehan

Hot Cookie is always a must go spot if you are busy the Castro or playing tourist for a day. Who doesn't want a delicious cookie in the shape of naughty bits. In addition to the cookies they are known for they have a wide selection of other flavors. I got the cranberry and white chocolate cookie. The texture was wonderful but was a little too sweet for my preference. The person working the counter was friendly and helpful.

Mitchell Hanson

Small cookie shop in the heart of the Castro district. Got the cookies n crème, chocolate frosted brownie, and dirty krisp. The cookie was the best part with a soft center. Brownie had soft frosting but overall flavor was very generic and sweet. The Krispy rice treat was slightly dense, not as fluffy as I was hoping but decent flavor. Small shop inside just good for standing. Service was kind though!!!

Heidi Imbus

Stopped in to purchase a gift box of cookies today and the lady working grudgingly and minus any cheer, decided after I made my purchase of 8 cookies to brush me to the side and make me wait for her to take care of the next 10 people that came.after me. Is packing 8 cookies really that much of a challenge? When I explained I couldn't wait for her to take all of the cutomers after me (I had an appointment,) she snapped back saying "I"m the only one working " and stomped off to get a box (that I paid $1 for,) in the back. When she returned in an even more pissy mood then when I walked in, she basically started throwing the cookies in the gift box and then crammed the seperate bagged cookie that was for me in the box and half ass closed it. I took the bag out and nicely asked if I could have a sticker to seal the box. She barked back that there was a closure on the box, as she took a sticker and slapped it crookedly onto the box ruining the appearance of a nice gift box. I had tipped her a $1 and honestly, really wished I hadn't given her a penny. Seriously off off putting and a complete brat. Oh, and she mumbles so you can barely hear her. Will not go back. Really disappointed beyond.

E

I renamed this place to the “burnt cookie”. I ordered bunch overpriced $7 burnt cookie off Uber eats tried eating them but the hard burnt dry cookies were terrible. I brought them to the store showed them and the girl told me no. She will not exchange even one burnt cookie for a not so burnt cookie. The overcook their cookies so you have to trust me to save your money and do not waste it like I did mine for some worst cookies over ever had.