iPizzaNY

The best pizza I've had in my life. New York pizza at its best quality. Very authentic and made right in front of you hot fresh and tasty!! Stand at the counter and dive into pizza heaven! Real old school and just how pizza is supposed to be!

Really, really good classic NYC pizza served by the nicest people. Love it!

Served just right in terms of temperature and freshness. Just wished it was a bit more flavorful. I got a cheese slice

Rebecca Stanton

In my opinion, one of the best places pizzas in the city. The service is usually pretty fast. Only has a few counter seats. It is far from my house, but I love the pizza so much I order it at home if I want pizza and pay a really good tip.

John Sanchez

Just randomly decided to stop here for a pizza and I tell you I’m so glad I did.. I got the onions peppers sausage pepperoni slice for 5$ and it was delicious. Just a perfect slice everything about it was on point it’s a must try imo. Also tried their fried chicken and that was really good as well full of flavor. 5 stars

Travis B

My first real slice of NYC pizza today. Crust was perfect crunchy and chewy all at once. Buffalo style wasn't too bad. Not spicy enough for my taste.

Daniel Draughon

Really, really good classic NYC pizza served by the nicest people. Love it!

Bori WaHi

I visited iPizzaNY when they first opened up. Convenient location (very visible) and accessible by train and buses. The employees are well-mannered, efficient and friendly. The 🍕 is delish, and my favorite is the Barbeque Chicken. So if you're in the mood for some good quality pizza, iPizzaNY is a great option.

Kim Santiago

Served just right in terms of temperature and freshness. Just wished it was a bit more flavorful. I got a cheese slice

Lisa Williams

I love this restaurant I usually will grab a slice after work. I have no complaints at all. The chicken is really good 😋and try a honey butter biscuit if you get some chicken. Yum! The service is good and you can sit down at the counter and eat there or you can take it to go. Totally recommend 👌 this pizza shop.

Sayeda Mehajabin

The best pizza I've had in my life. New York pizza at its best quality. Very authentic and made right in front of you hot fresh and tasty!! Stand at the counter and dive into pizza heaven! Real old school and just how pizza is supposed to be!

PeggynJJ

I found this place accidentally. My car overheated and while I was waiting for it to cool down I decided to get a bite. I-Pizza was the closest to me. This pizza was hands down the best pizza I have had in years. I kind of gave up on looking for a traditional NY slice. Every place I try is either sweet or overloaded with herbs or just doesn't taste good. I dont live in Washington heights I'm in Westchester and I have been back here 3 times since. You won't be disappointed fair prices and good pizza. Just left them right now!

Pizza was great. Service was as expected at a pizza joint. Great atmosphere in Washington Heights

Pizza is great but they are only playing TikTok music like why are you playing dance monkey bro that kills the vibe

Tha Biggest

Pizza was great. Service was as expected at a pizza joint. Great atmosphere in Washington Heights

Yafreily Jimenez

Pizza is great but they are only playing TikTok music like why are you playing dance monkey bro that kills the vibe

Service was good but my pizza was slightly undercooked on the bottom. First time getting pizza there cause it smelled good from the outside but not sure I'll go back again.

Vladislava Petrova

Service was good but my pizza was slightly undercooked on the bottom. First time getting pizza there cause it smelled good from the outside but not sure I'll go back again.

I'm convinced that the 5star reviews are falsified... I'll go right out and say that the pizza is NOT worth 22 bucks for a pie. Domino's is better by a long shot and that doesn't say much. If you're looking for that genuine NYC pizza, it's not here. Pizza was burnt on the bottom and the crust was hard as a rock... I think a valid comparison would be elementary school cafeteria pizza. Seriously. After spending almost 40$ on the garbage with a side order of stiff mozzarella sticks, I felt instant regret when I opened the pizza box. Again, pay close attention to the 1 star reviews. They were not B.S'ing.... (I saw one where they literally said their pizza was green...) Tangent over*

Tonight I had one of the worst pizza experience in my life and unfortunately it’s with iPizzaNY right on 158 St and Bway. I ordered 3 plain pizza slices and one of the dudes, (he looks young compare to the other 2 staffers) gave me back incorrect change. The price was $7.50. I gave the cashier $13.00, he gave me back .50 as my change. I politely told the cashier that he gave me back the wrong change, my correct change is $5.50. The cashier wanted to give me a hard time as if I didn’t know how to count or as if I didn’t know how much money I gave him. He kept telling me I gave him 8 dollars. I saw that when I gave him the money, he didn’t even look at it!! He automatically assumed that I gave him $8.00. He kept me waiting for a while until he realized I wasn’t leaving for nothing on the planet if he didn’t give me my correct change. The cashier was looking at me like I was a demon, like I was in the wrong… I was looking at him like he doesn’t know how to multi task because he was handling pizza and money and got lost in the sauce. He was all over the place. The shift supervisor pulled up and started to ask me why did I pay 13.00 when it’s 7.50. I replied “As a customer I can pay however I want, as long as it’s being paid for. Some people don’t want singles.” Eventually after going back and forth he gave me my correct change but it’s unfortunate that certain staff members don’t know how to count money. That staff member in particular has to go back to school and learn how to count. He’s not ready for the pizza business. Good luck buying from these dudes and hopefully they’ll look at the money when you give it to them and hopefully they’ll give you back the correct change. ✌🏽

Ordered this on doordash listed a lot of items they do NOT sell we called and they really didn’t care. So now we’re stuck with stuff we don’t want and they never called to ask us what we wanted. THEY NEVER CALLED FOR SUBSTITUTIONS. They put what THEY wanted and literally never called or sent a message.. allergies exist!!!

The pizza was all black and burnt. They sent me the wrong order.

The way to place an order to be delivered here is best done by morse code. The person answering the phone does not comprehend English. Pizza was burnt and too 40 mins to be delivered... and I live around the corner!! And never as for a chicken parm because tou will get melted cheese and sauce and no chicken!

The pizza tastes artifical and the sauce is way too much and the crust is wayyy too thin it looks reheated not fresh

Fabian Palaguachi

The pizza was all black and burnt. They sent me the wrong order.

Jordan Andrews

Ordered this on doordash listed a lot of items they do NOT sell we called and they really didn’t care. So now we’re stuck with stuff we don’t want and they never called to ask us what we wanted. THEY NEVER CALLED FOR SUBSTITUTIONS. They put what THEY wanted and literally never called or sent a message.. allergies exist!!!

Samuel Martinez

The pizza tastes artifical and the sauce is way too much and the crust is wayyy too thin it looks reheated not fresh

Nicholas Sierra

I'm convinced that the 5star reviews are falsified... I'll go right out and say that the pizza is NOT worth 22 bucks for a pie. Domino's is better by a long shot and that doesn't say much. If you're looking for that genuine NYC pizza, it's not here. Pizza was burnt on the bottom and the crust was hard as a rock... I think a valid comparison would be elementary school cafeteria pizza. Seriously. After spending almost 40$ on the garbage with a side order of stiff mozzarella sticks, I felt instant regret when I opened the pizza box. Again, pay close attention to the 1 star reviews. They were not B.S'ing.... (I saw one where they literally said their pizza was green...) Tangent over*

Romello Reese

The way to place an order to be delivered here is best done by morse code. The person answering the phone does not comprehend English. Pizza was burnt and too 40 mins to be delivered... and I live around the corner!! And never as for a chicken parm because tou will get melted cheese and sauce and no chicken!

J H

Tonight I had one of the worst pizza experience in my life and unfortunately it’s with iPizzaNY right on 158 St and Bway. I ordered 3 plain pizza slices and one of the dudes, (he looks young compare to the other 2 staffers) gave me back incorrect change. The price was $7.50. I gave the cashier $13.00, he gave me back .50 as my change. I politely told the cashier that he gave me back the wrong change, my correct change is $5.50. The cashier wanted to give me a hard time as if I didn’t know how to count or as if I didn’t know how much money I gave him. He kept telling me I gave him 8 dollars. I saw that when I gave him the money, he didn’t even look at it!! He automatically assumed that I gave him $8.00. He kept me waiting for a while until he realized I wasn’t leaving for nothing on the planet if he didn’t give me my correct change. The cashier was looking at me like I was a demon, like I was in the wrong… I was looking at him like he doesn’t know how to multi task because he was handling pizza and money and got lost in the sauce. He was all over the place. The shift supervisor pulled up and started to ask me why did I pay 13.00 when it’s 7.50. I replied “As a customer I can pay however I want, as long as it’s being paid for. Some people don’t want singles.” Eventually after going back and forth he gave me my correct change but it’s unfortunate that certain staff members don’t know how to count money. That staff member in particular has to go back to school and learn how to count. He’s not ready for the pizza business. Good luck buying from these dudes and hopefully they’ll look at the money when you give it to them and hopefully they’ll give you back the correct change. ✌🏽