Wesley Chan

Great local pizzeria. Got a margarita and Buffalo chicken with blue cheese. Crust is thin but has a nice crisp. Margarita sauce was tangy and sweet. Appreciate that they take credit card.

Empress Cece

Chicken parm was good. I asked for penne pasta instead and that penne was in the vodka sauce I’m going to assume. Either way it was freaking delicious with out the chicken. The pasta comes in a separate pan from the chicken. The grilled chicken with pasta was delicious. The grilled chicken was slightly salty but the spinach was great, not soggy or oily. Cooked perfect. And I had a slice it was great and fresh!

Jay Neisen

Nice enough people and quick but the pizza is mediocre, the crust and sauce just don’t have much flavor and the toppings were also lacking. I’ve been twice with the same experience both times.

Renee Richter

We ordered take out. Pizza, chicken wings, and Caesar salad. My husband loved his buffalo chicken wings. I found the pizza to be lackluster. Not true New York style and for some reason they only put the toppings on one side. The Caesar salad was great, but there was not enough salad dressing.

Kevin Shen

It was okay. The cheese slices were good, but the one with spinach and ricotta cheese wasn’t. The latter was just bland with no flavours - it became a chore to eat after two bites.

Bobby Cho

Solid 2 star pizza with unrealistic price. Meatballs were old, dry, and overcooked. Pizza tasted sweet for some reason? Highly doubt they use fresh mozarella...

D C

It's okay. Very average tasting pizza. Also, they charge more for their two slice special than they do on Wall St. Pretty insane.

Wayne Jackson

Should of stick with gino's pizza shop and that what I get trying something different and wasting my money. A horrible looking fried calamari where you get this crap from ? even the supermarket calmaria looks better and that marinade who the hell made that crap???I wouldn't dare risk and try their pizza. Don't understand why they still in business. This pizza shop is not recommended at all 👎

J Bond

I would highly advise checking the expiration dates on the drinks , grabbed a drink from there and it was expired by a whole year 😡

Tristan Compton

Received a cheesesteak with leaking, moldy green peppers and twice fried fries. Grandma pizza made with stale 99 Cents Tomato paste. $50 for old rotten food and owner bold- facedly claims it's not his. Never eat here *Edit* The Rotten Smelling Food you so keenly mentioned was purchased from your establishment, with reciepts. That picture is of the Rotten bell peppers I gave safe passage into the trash. I returned to your business with your Rotten Food on my time, to offer you the opportunity to give me a refund as a courtesy, not because I need you to get one. Due to your response, you still lost that $50, in addition to everyone on Google now being aware you sell Rotten Food.

G

Horrible service! These people are new to the neighborhood and have the highest priced pizza trust me! Been here for 30+ years never had a bad experience with a pizza shop until these guys came around. Rude & impatient, and doesn’t have any care for the customers. A hour before closing time Gino’s down the block sells discounted slices especially if it’s been sitting there all day, but Prospect Pizza will sell you the stalest pizza and driest cheese full PRICED right before closing time. 1 star.

A Q

Ordered a large cheese pizza and a eggplant hero. The pizza was alright. It was a little sweet. The eggplant hero was terrible. There was a little bit of sauce which made it extremely dry, you couldn't even tell there was eggplant in it and there was no cheese. Save your money.